Portrayal Of Native Americans In Film

4566 words - 18 pages

When Columbus first set foot in the New World, he believed that he had arrived in the islands just off the coast of Cipango, known today as China. Thinking this, he called the people that he met Indians, as they lived on the islands that he falsely believed were the Indies. The term Indian spread back to Europe, as did the term Indies, and to this day, Native Americans are known as Indians, and the Caribbean islands are referred to as the West Indies. The Indians populated a much greater area than Columbus could have imagined, covering the land of two Continents. The Native people of these lands, known already by a term in their languages that roughly meant "the people", were now thrown into one large group called Indians, which stretched nearly pole to pole.

The Indians were an invented people. The place they inhabited was not the Indies, and their culture varied from tribe to tribe. The Indian in film is also an invented population of people. No distinction between reality and the imagination are made in these movies. The portrayal of the Native American, and the Native American ways of life were displayed incorrectly in film, and warped the image of the Native American in the eyes of all Americans, especially their descendants.

The movies studied vary, from those dealing with Columbus' first encounter with these fascinating people, up through to the end of the 19th century. The films viewed include: 1492 (1992), Christopher Columbus (1985), Christopher Columbus: The Discovery (1992), The Last of The Mohicans (1992), Apache (1954), Dances With Wolves (1990), Crazy Horse (1996), A Man Called Horse (1970), A Man Called Horse III (1982), Soldier Blue (1970), Buffalo Bill and The Indians (1976), and Black Robe (1991).

Throughout this paper, a variety of criteria will be used to judge the films viewed. Movies will be judged on whether or not the Indians portrayed in the films are true Native Americans, white people with skin darkened by makeup, or neither. The movies will also be evaluated in how they portray the Native American culture, including clothing, housing, and language. The films 1492, Christopher Columbus and Christopher Columbus: The Discovery are unique in that they all cover the same time period, the same Native Americans and the same general story, which should be common to nearly everyone in North America. Due to this, it is easy to compare and contrast the Tainos, who have the dubious distinction of being the first to come in contact with the white man during the Age of Discovery. It would be quite easy to construct a paper simply contrasting the historical stories that are told within these three films. Not only do the stories vary, and the relationships between certain characters change, but the portrayal of the Native Americans also varies. The first meeting of the Spaniards and the Indians was shown differently in all three of the movies.

Christopher Columbus and Christopher Columbus: The Discovery were both...

Find Another Essay On Portrayal of Native Americans in Film

The Portrayal of Female Athletes in Film

812 words - 3 pages The Portrayal of Female Athletes in Film Portrayals and stories of women in sport and film are varied and unique to the woman, but some common threads can be found throughout these films. Understanding the culture of sport and how women are depicted as athletes in movies shows how society at large views women. The perseverance and strength of women athletes in unjust or unfair situations regarding their sport is a very important and all too

FAS IN NATIVE AMERICANS Essay

1035 words - 4 pages A Race at Risk: Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Native Americans have a higher rate of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome (FAS) than any other group in the United States. FAS is the direct result of a woman's drinking of alcohol during pregnancy. It should be no surprise that in the United States the group with the highest rate of alcoholism is the same group with the highest rate of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. Although there is no cure for FAS, it is completely

The History of African Americans in Film

2058 words - 8 pages Man.? Before 1970 African Americans were depicted as train porters, waitresses and shoe shine boys. This all changes when in 1971 Melvin Van Peebles came out with his groundbreaking film ? Sweetback?s Baadassss Song.? This was the first film in which the black man came out on top over the white establishment or ? The Man.? That same year Gordon Park came out with one of Blaxploitation?s best known films, Shaft. This was one of the first movies

Stripped of Personal Freedom: Native Americans in the West

1111 words - 4 pages people who were treated horribly or who faced mounting obstacles didn’t actually have it as bad as another group. But throughout all the years we’ve studied, one group that stood out to me who were dealt a horrible fate were Native Americans living in the west during the 19th century. When Americans began to expand westward, Indians unwillingly had their lives flipped upside down and changed drastically. After years of displacement, they were being

The History of Native Americans

894 words - 4 pages tell each tribe by looking at their clothes, headdresses and ornamentation. The Native Americans was very religious, and were inspired by nature. Most Native American tribes recognize that all things in the universe have a deeper meaning. Symbols were used to recognize these beliefs.For example Indian symbols include images of the sun, moon, animals, or ancestral tribe members. For example the sun symbolized the cardinal directions

The Worth of Native Americans

730 words - 3 pages mental health help, and you need it, and it’s taken away, you have to learn how to adapt to life without it. That couldn’t be very easy. When living in a world where you are told, and constantly reminded that you will not amount to anything but a Native American, it influences all of the choices that you make. Native Americans were expected to fail; not matter what they did. They weren’t thought to be as worthy or good enough as the “true

Early Education of Native Americans

1070 words - 5 pages Native Americans put up a good fight in defending their homelands against foreign invaders. Unfortunately, they suffered defeat and realized they would have to adapt to a new way of life. The battle for their lands was over, but the battle for their identities would just begin. However, it would not be the hardened warriors engaging in this conflict. Instead, the young Native American children would witness first-hand the American government’s

American Treatment of Native Americans

2049 words - 8 pages autonomy to rule their nations. In 1972, the U.S. Congress passed legislation that changed education standards for children, then passed the Indian Education Act in 1975, which gave Indian parents greater control over their children’s education (“Latinos and Native Americans Seek Equality” 772-773). Although the Indians have been re-establishing their original cultures, they remain limited to small patches of land allowed by the U.S

The History of Native Americans

1081 words - 4 pages Indian threat to the peaceful westward expansion, and try to destroy its cultures, spiritual, economic, and political traditions by assimilating Native American into American life. The signing of these treaties and the adoption of policies and laws gradually declined sovereignty of indigenous nations. In the 1830’s, Five Indians Nations lived in territories that many Americans thought it might be more profitable for breeding, however

Native Americans Of North Carolina

1021 words - 4 pages American Indians had been living in North Carolina for at least 9,500 years before European explorers first encountered them in the 1520's. For the past several decades an increasing number of Americans have been identifying as American Indians. For centuries before European contact, these native people lived in harmony with the natural environment, taking no more from the land than they needed to survive. Of all the states in the Union

The Genocide of Native Americans

1359 words - 5 pages famous memoirs have come from these genocides, and many have come from events that do not exactly classify as genocides. Many sites such as listverse.com, toptenz.net, and 8list.ph have created lists of the most horrific genocides in history, there are 8 that come up time and time again they are the Genocide of North Korean Prison Camps, the Genocide of Native Americans, the Bosnian Genocide, Stalin’s Genocides, The Chinese Cultural Revolution, the

Similar Essays

The Negative Portrayal Of Native Americans In Children’s Literature

2096 words - 8 pages The Negative Portrayal of Native Americans in Children’s Literature The American institution has raised countless generations with misconceptions and lies regarding various foreign cultures. During the 1950’s the educational system in America was given the responsibility of teaching children the horrors and injustices they would suffer if the "evil" communist took over the world. Schools taught students that communist wanted to take away

"Dances With Wolves" Analysis Illustrate How Native Americans & Native American Culture Is Represented In This Film Differently Than In Usual Media Presentations.

563 words - 2 pages The misguided portrayals of Native Americans in the media can be retraced back to outdated Western films. These films had the reoccurring theme of Cowboys versus Indians. Native Americans have been portrayed as thieving, violent, lazy, hostile, uncivilized savages. The White man thought the Natives were undeserving of the lands riches, when in fact their contributions to their environment changed and enriched our world. The White man is

Portrayal Of Asian Americans In The Media

3230 words - 13 pages the possible explanations for the stunning success of William Hung, racism takes precedence. Hung is carrying on the “stigmatic torch of the verbally-accented Chinese forever-foreigner” (Thoughts, 2004). Asian Americans have been in the United States since the 1800s, and yet their portrayal on film has continued to be presented as more foreign and less American. Certain movies during 1940’s to 1970’s had “scotch tape Asian characters” (Fong, 1998

The Disappearance Of Native Americans In California

1642 words - 7 pages in California, the world as Native Americans knew it was never the same again. The late 1700s initiated and marked the colonization of Spaniards in the “Golden State” which in turn provoked the massive persecution and extermination of Native American population as well as the disappearance of Native heritage and culture. As a result, the recurring despairs and adversities of the Indian population began. Professor Edward D. Castillo expresses