Power Struggles In Capitalist Democracies And The Fate Of American Labor Unions

3465 words - 14 pages

Power Struggles in Capitalist Democracies and the Fate of American Labor Unions

To some, "capitalistic democracy" conjures up the picture of a utopia where the free market is accompanied by individual liberty and social justice. To others, however, the term is more like a paradox—despite tremendous economic power, the advanced industrial nations are not immune from the evils of socio-political inequality as well as economical disparity. Amongst the capitalist democracies of the world, it is an established and well-known fact that when compared with the advanced industrial countries in Europe, the United States has the worst condition of economical-political inequality and social injustice. Its government is the least progressive, and its social inequalities the most deplorable. To explain the condition in the U.S. today, both the universality of capitalistic democracies and the peculiarities the American system employs—as well as this system's political and historical development—must be examined and explored.

As Joshua Cohen and Joel Rogers articulated in On Democracy, a capitalist democracy is one that "if [it] is not just capitalism, still less is it just democracy" (Cohen 50). Indeed, despite the apparent political equality in a system that nowadays guarantees universal suffrage, the dominate socio-political structure in the United States and most western European countries does not allow—neither by intention nor in practice—free and equal competition between the capital and labor. Cohen and Rogers theorize that at the heart of this disparity lies what they call "the demand constraint" and "the resource constraint". In summation, the demand constraint states that because of the fact that the entire capitalistic economy is intrinsically dependent on the investment and satisfaction of the capitalist class, the state and the labor class cannot and will not make all the necessary demands to the rich; and the resource constraint is that labor's collective actions suffers from lack of resource and a magnified free rider problem that oftentimes render them ineffective.

The demand constraints limits what the labor class and the state can demand from the capitalist class because it essentially controls the economy through capital investment. As a result, "the satisfaction of the interest of capitalists is a necessary condition for the satisfaction of all other interests within the system." (Cohen 298). There exists an inherent imbalance of power in a capitalist democracy because its stability and growth depends primarily on the economic well being of the capitalist class. This group holds the power of choosing what, where, and how to invest their resources. Moreover, "corporations control a host of decisions unless and until the government specifically intervenes". (Clowson et al, 161) The labor class is dependent on them for employment and income, and the state also relies on them both directly and indirectly—directly through income tax...

Find Another Essay On Power Struggles in Capitalist Democracies and the Fate of American Labor Unions

Fractured Unions- reasons for the decline in labor unions in United States and the future expectations.

4063 words - 16 pages for the American workforce, there has been a continued decline in union membership and influence over the past 30 years (Sherk). There are several reasons for this decline, which will be discussed, in the following pages.BodyThe Diminishing Importance of UnionsWhile labor unions were once crucial to the workforce of America, they no longer meet the workplace purpose that American laborers once looked to them for. At one point in time, labor unions

Labor Unions and Effects on the Lives of Factory Workers

783 words - 3 pages Organized labor, during the period from 1875-1900, had drastic effects on the lives of factory workers. Labor unions not only sought to improve working conditions; they wanted to have a large impact on society as a whole as well. These unions also altered feelings toward organized labor. The Industrial Revolution that took place after the Civil War made for a more economically sound country. American workers, however, were becoming more and

Historical Background of Labor Unions and Leaders

2426 words - 10 pages workers’ day to day concerns were not being addressed (Fossum, 2012). Realizing the shortcomings of these previous leaders, Samuel Gompers took a different approach as the first president of the American Federation of Labor. Gompers believed that small craft unions could become stronger as a coalition with the power to negotiate with employers in the short-term and significantly impact the daily lives of workers (Yellowitz, 1989). Although

Creation of Labor Unions in Bangladesh

1045 words - 5 pages and gender discrimination is a constant up rise. Unionists in Bangladesh are facing much scrutiny even till this day. There have been reports of torture, arrests and even deaths that went into the valiant effort to gain the basic working privileges they so rightfully deserve. Creation of labor unions in the Bangladeshi textile industries are necessary to bring about better working conditions and protection of equal employment opportunities for

"Do We Need Labor Unions in America?" and "What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Union Membership."

957 words - 4 pages A question that is often asked is whether labor unions are still necessary in America as we know it today. It is a very difficult question to answer and in order to do so we must first take a look at what it does, as well as what the advantages and disadvantages are. A labor union is an organization of many workers that has come together to negotiate and achieve certain conditions such as proper pay, work environment, hours, and rules and

Economics of Labor Unions

1042 words - 4 pages employer agree on a wage and employment levels that depend only on the opportunity wage of labor and labor's value of marginal product.Negotiation is common in many settings. A common feature of all negotiation is an understanding by the parties to the negotiation about the process that will be used to resolve a dispute in the event the parties fail to reach an agreement. Disputes between labor unions and employers can end in a strike or can be

Question: Analyze the impact of any TWO of the following on the American industrial worker between 1865 and 1900. Government actions Immigration Labor unions Technological changes

918 words - 4 pages Between 1865 and 1900, American industry workers experienced both good and hard times. Labor Unions were forming, and these new creations often produced better lives for the workers. However, waves of immigrants were also coming into America, which resulted in the threat of job stability. Labor Unions and Immigration both had momentous effects upon the industry worker, for better or for worse.After the Civil War, which killed much of the working

The Mediatization of Politics in Western Democracies

2393 words - 10 pages This growing influence of the mass media and changes in communication has led to the subordination of the power of other influential institutions in society. “This process is referred to as “mediatisation” and as a result of mediatisation institutions in society and society as a whole is shaped by and ultimately dependent on the mass media” (Mazzoleni and Schulz 1999: 247 – 261). This ultimately means a “media logic” has formed. In relation to

American Capitalist Society In The 19th Century

1463 words - 6 pages Herman Melville’s Utilization of Bartleby the Scrivener: the Story of Wall Street As a Means of Criticizing Capitalism and Its Crimes Against Humanity Herman Melville's "Bartleby, The Scrivener: A Story of Wall Street" scrutinizes the alienation of labor, the social ideologies and the dehumanizing consequences of the American capitalist society in the 19th century. Bartleby is the main character in the story. The other characters

Orderly Struggles of Power, Persona and Reality in Gilman’s The Yellow Wallpaper

1618 words - 6 pages ” was created. During the 19th century, the time of which the story was written, women were expected to play the role of a wife and mother and society did not tolerate anything otherwise (American Literature, 1998). “The Yellow Wallpaper” demonstrates the struggle for power, search for persona, and the escape from reality of a female manic. In order to understand the narrator’s terrors of the phobia, the events in the story are told in

The Power Struggles in Jury of Her Peers and Mama Come Home

1184 words - 5 pages The Power Struggles in Jury of Her Peers and Mama Come Home The issue of dominance and subordinance is addressed in the short stories “A Jury of her Peers” by Susan Glaspell and “Mama Come Home” by James Tiptree, Jr. In the stories the subordinates are harmed by the dominants, but the subordinates overcome the suppression to triumph in the end. The groups with the power control the laws and the positions of the weaker group. To

Similar Essays

Norma Rae: Labor Unions And The Power Struggle

3420 words - 14 pages Introduction Labor unions were established as a way for workers’ needs and grievances to be heard by management. According to Fossum (2012), “forming a union creates a collective voice to influence change at work” (p. 7). The collective voice of workers in a union holds much more power than any single employee’s voice. It can loudly draw attention to mistreatment or abuse of workers. The organized collective voice of workers demands to be

The History And Formation Of Labor Unions In The Unites States Of America

3197 words - 13 pages Labor formed in 1869. One of the most famous unions formed, however, is the American Federation of Labor (AFL), formed in 1886. One of the AFL’s founders was its famous first president, Samuel Gompers, who helped to change the social and political standing of the workers in America (AFL-CIO). The American Federation of Labor also helped create the Committee for Industrial Organization (CIO) in 1935, which became its own union in 1938. They

American Early Labor Unions Essay

1324 words - 5 pages destroyed by Jay Gould's Missouri Pacific Railroad.The American Federation of Labor (AFL) began in 1886 and it was a union that began to expand as the Knights of Labor began to diminish. It was a loose alliance of national craft unions, unions that were open only to skilled workers such as train conductors. The AFL did not allow women, blacks, and unskilled workers. The AFL worked to gain simple things such as less hours and higher wages. The

The Past, Present And Future Of Labor Unions

2270 words - 9 pages unions and the problems it faced during the era of modern industries. Looking up where unions actually originated can be traced back to the early history of America. Throughout time, unions did their best in acquiring the rights needed by their members and having a power in the workplace. The events that labor unions have participated and contributed a lot in the history of the United States. The first workers who fought for their rights