Pragmatic Justification Essay

1368 words - 5 pages

Bertrand Russell, one of the most influential philosophers of the modern age, argued extensively in his book, “The Problems of Philosophy”, that the belief in inductive reasoning is only rational on the grounds of its intrinsic evidence; it cannot be justified by an appeal to experience alone (Russell 1998). Inductive reasoning refers to a form of reasoning that constructs or assesses propositions that are generalizations of observations (Russell 1998). Inductive reasoning is thus, in simple terms, probabilistic. The premises of an inductive logical argument provide some degree of support for the conclusion, but that support is in no way definitive or conclusive (Browne, 2004). Yet even if one agrees with Russell and concludes that there are no rational justifications for the principle of induction in and of itself, one can still maintain that there is a pragmatic justification for maintaining a belief in the principle. Simply put, there are still perfectly sound reasons for behaving as if the principle of induction holds true, regardless of whether or not the principle itself is rationally justifiable (Browne, 2004). This type of justification can be used across many of the belief systems that we as human beings hold, even stretching to the playing field of religion. In this paper I will outline not only why it is pragmatically justifiable to believe in the principle of induction, but also why it is equally as justifiable to believe in an infinite God, regardless of whether or not deductive reasoning provides us with definitive support for such conclusions.
Let’s begin by examining the issue of universal order and the Problem of Induction. The problem with inductive reasoning is that it is based on the assumption that the future will resemble the past (Russell, 1998). It is upon this reasoning that we base our belief in gravity and other such universal “laws” (Russell, 1998). Russell has outlined that inductive reasoning does not provide definitive proof of the occurrence of future events, regardless of how many times they have occurred in the past. Thus, rationally speaking, we have no definitive or conclusive reason for the belief in universal order, since we cannot continue to believe that universal laws, such as the law of gravity, will hold true simply because they have up until this point (Russell, 1998). However, pragmatically speaking, one can assume that the universe will either be orderly, or it will not. Furthermore, we will either expect the universe to be orderly, or we will not. Thus, one of only four possibilities is rationally possible (Browne, 2004). The universe will continue to be orderly, and will we assume that it shall continue as such; the universe will continue to be orderly and we will expect that it will not continue as such; the universe will be disorderly and we will assume that is orderly; or the universe will be disorderly and we will assume that it is disorderly (Browne, 2004). Logically, if we...

Find Another Essay On Pragmatic Justification

Why is Islam perceived as a threat to the west? What justification is there in viewing Islam as a political threat to the west?

986 words - 4 pages countries throughout the war was clearly based on a pragmatic style of politics."The terrorist attacks on The U.S. in September 2002 further made the western public feel that the religion of Islam was a threat to the west. These attacks, carried out by a small extreme group of fundamentalists has succeeded in raising the awareness of Islamic fundamentalism in the west and raising sense of threat from the extreme version of the faith. The attacks

Film Analysis: Chuck Palahniuk’s Fight Club

704 words - 3 pages questioned both the random man’s and the veteran’s actions. Why did the random man come up the veteran and apologize? Why did the veteran look at him in disgust? But I then realized I must understand the fundamental question of empathy. The question is answered with a metamorphic cliché; you don’t know what you have until it’s gone. In analysis; you cannot experience empathy without a true pragmatic understanding of the victim’s experience

medical negligencee

2520 words - 11 pages for the justification. The law of causation has long been a problematic area that attracts clarification. Thus, in view of the inherent obscurity in causation problems, the court is bounded to employ a clearer principle in order to uphold consistency and coherence in this doctrine. Relationship between Bailey case and but for causation rule The basic rule of causation is the but-for test which requires the claimant to show that but for the

Death And The Maiden - Film Vs

1120 words - 4 pages throw the car over the cliff-edge. In doing this she is not only destroying a phallic symbol, and thus undermining Roberto’s sexuality and any claims he has on sexual dominance or superiority, she is destroying a perfect symbol of the male thirst for power and control, and the pragmatic logic to which her need for revenge has been sacrificed, into the infinite, chaotic abyss that defies all these principles, and unquestionably swallows it

Vampiric Embrace

1706 words - 7 pages reinforcement offered by the decrees of the Church and the State a man may fall prey to his own devices. If that were to happen then he may become an enemy of the state, and attempt to rebel. If this happened, then the Leviathan need simply bare his teeth for a moment and snuff out the problem. I think Hobbes saw the church as a tool, one to used for purely pragmatic purposes. Hobbes would rather have tyranny than chaos, and with so much war

Character Analysis for Raja Rao's Kanthapura

1102 words - 4 pages admonishing Gandhians against hatred and violence, he is sorrowful but calm, and submissive but steadfast, in his leadership of nonviolent actions. Although beaten severely and imprisoned frequently, Moorthy remains loyal to Gandhian principles, despite becoming a supporter of the more pragmatic Jawaharlal Nehru in the nationalist movement. Bhatta, the First Brahmin, or chief priest at ceremonial feasts, and primary landlord of Kanthapura. A clever

Differences Between Human Need and Human Want

1077 words - 4 pages prioritization to our thoughts. What is the dividing line between wanting and needing, and how dependent is our happiness and overall success in finding the answers to this question. Is “To each their own” a pragmatic justification in answering these questions? Or is there a set code or universal list that applies to all of us? Furthermore, if we were to break down our needs into emotional and physical categories, which would be most imperative to human

Moby-Dick as an Absurdist Text

1058 words - 4 pages ask this question misses the point of Ahab’s journey and Absurdism entirely. Ahab’s choice in pursing Moby Dick isn’t about being pragmatic, since pragmatism is by its own definition contrary to the absurd. Ahab has no need for meaning, per se. Certainly, he recognizes that he will always peruse meaning to some extent, such is the cross all Absurd heroes must bear. But just as Sisyphus did not push the boulder with the intent of being free from

Origins of the Cold War

1311 words - 5 pages affected much of the US historiography and academic life until the early 1980's. The new thinking reflected the findings of the opening of the American archives covering the 1940's. It also mirrored disillusionment with Johnson's justification of the Vietnam War which seemed rather similar to Truman's use of communist fear in his appeal for aid to Greece and Turkey.2The revisionist school analyzes the economic and domestic forces conditioning

knowledge and evidence

1624 words - 6 pages One definition of knowledge is true belief based on strong evidence. What makes evidence “strong” enough and how can this limit be established?      The making of knowledge is the process in which personal opinion is fortified by pragmatic evidence. It is to my belief that, evidence is a keystone in the justification of truth, because it is something solid and concrete. Significance of evidence is also magnified by

State Mass Killings in Indonesia 1965 to 1966

3552 words - 14 pages interests, justification for violence, formal organizations, and mobilization factors. Finally, I suggest future preventative policy measures. Introduction Violence marks much of human history. Within the sociopolitical sphere, violence has continually served as a tool used by various actors to influence and/or to control territory, people, institutions and other resources of society. The twentieth century witnessed an evolution of

Similar Essays

The Schelling Segregation Model Essay

2495 words - 10 pages aspects to show my conclusion: 1. Schelling’s model in the context of the DN theory of explanation 2. Schelling’s model in the context of the pragmatic theory of explanation 3. How to explain neighbourhood segregation… An emphasis will be placed on the first and second to allow more thorough justification. In this essay, neighbourhood will be defined in terms of “neighbourhood spaces” . Schelling’s Explanation Schelling’s explanation of

American Philosophy Essay

664 words - 3 pages also a philosophy that is deeply embedded in American culture. Pragmatism is a doctrine which tests truth by its practical consequences. William James was the most influential American-pragmatic philosopher. James used pragmatism to solve the problems that interfered with the individuals "feeling at home in the universe." James concluded that philosophy was only useful if one could use it to better his or her life. Americans today think the

Hamlet Essay

551 words - 2 pages Hamlet, the central character, has been analyzed and criticized for centuries. His complex character has given way to numerous variable interpretations and psycho profiles. He's open to different, yet possible explanations of his character. For example, one might view him as piacular and petulant, whereas another might see him as pragmatic and rash. However, there lies one clear consensus: Hamlet's character is by no means heroic through his

The Extent To Which Lenin's Nep Solved The Problems Caused By War Communism

801 words - 3 pages dislike for capitalism, but he produced little in way of legitimate economic structuring. Accordingly, the economic policies sustained succeeding to his empowerment were somewhat pragmatic. Russia’s involvement in World War I had brought Russia to an economic disintegration (Michael Lynch 123). As a resolution the Bolshevik party introduced “war communism”. All aspects of the economic, social and cultural normality had to be