Pragmatism Vs. Idealism (A Man Essay

2265 words - 9 pages

Morality is often overpowered by materialistic pursuits. In ?A Man for All Seasons?,Robert Bolt shows the corruption of those who put self interest above all other values. His use of such characters as Thomas Cromwell, Richard Rich, Chapuys and Wolsey help convey this corruption. There is yet another character who is a pragmatist that Bolt successfully represents. Thomas More is an idealist as well as a pragmatist, for he is prepared to give up everything for his beliefs and takes all precautions possible to make his case ?watertight?. It is through this pragmatism and idealism that Robert Bolt shows the corruption of the times.Thomas More believed in his ideals to such an extent that he was prepared to sacrifice his life for them, if the need arrived. He was a firm believer in the separation of Church and State. When the King tried to start the reformation of England and the Church by a simple Act of Parliament called the Act of Supremacy, Thomas refused to sign it. He believed that the indictment of the King was ?grounded in an Act of Parliament which is directly repugnant to law of God. The King in Parliament cannot bestow he Supremacy of the Church because it is a Spiritual Supremacy! And more to this the immunity of the Church is promised both in Magna Carta and the Kings own Coronation Oath!?(Bolt, p. 92) The marriage was yet another reason why More refused to sign the Act. He knew that if he signed it then he would accept the King as the Supreme Head of Church and thus give the King the power to ?dispense with the dispensation? which to him was against his morals and religion. Of course the marriage was associated with other things -attack on the abbeys, the whole Reformation policy-to which More was violently opposed. When told by Norfolk that his parish attire is a disrespect to the King and his office. More replies that ?the service of God is not a dishonor to any office?(Bolt, p.26) Even though he loves the King to death as proved by Mores loyalty towards him, he values his morality and religion more. For his conscience is a ?little area where I must rule myself?(Bolt,p.34). His position is perfectly described in his belief that ?when statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties... they lead their country by a short route to chaos.? His idealism is clearly shown in his refusal to take the oath for the oath to him was an invitation to God to act as a witness as well as a judge and the consequence of a perjury was damnation. He is a man who is ?anchored to his principles? (Bolt, p.36). The issue is not about what other people see his beliefs as but ?not that I believe it, but that I believe it...?(Bolt, p.53). He needs to be true to his conscience and cannot let other people interfere with these decisions, for when he faces his creator it is he alone who will answer Him. ?In matters of conscience, the loyal subject is more bounded to be loyal to his conscience than to any other thing?(Bolt, p.89)...

Find Another Essay On Pragmatism vs. idealism (a man

Old vs New South, paper based on Flannery O'Conner's book A Good Man is Hard to Find

1233 words - 5 pages Paper based on Flannery O'Conner's book A Good Man is Hard to Find -Old vs New SouthIn Flannery O'Connor's stories, 'A Good Man is Hard to Find' and 'Good Country People,' a change from the old south to the new south is quite evident. O'Connor uses these stories to show the differences between the old and new south and to voice her disapproval as to what the south was becoming. What upset O'Connor about the new south can be shown by carefully

Good Country People Vs A Good Man Is Hard To Find

978 words - 4 pages Mistrust, religion, dysfunctional families, and death are all topics that come up at one time or another during Fannery O'Connor's symbolic tales "Good Country People" and "A Good Man is Hard to Find". "Good Country People" is a story about a simple mother, her 30 year old daughter who likes being miserable, and the man that steals her leg and teachers her a lesson in life. "A Good Man is Hard to Find" is a story about a dysfunctional family who

Idealism and Its Struggles to Exist

2185 words - 9 pages depend on other natural qualities to determine them. Hegel called his philosophy absolute idealism. Hegel based his ideas doctrine more on Plato’s belief that self- determination through the exercise of reason achieves a higher kind of reality than physical objects (Mastin, 2008). Friedrich Schelling was a German philosopher. Schelling built on Kant, Hegel, and Berkeley’s work. Schelling was the man responsible for the creation of objective idealism

American Philosophy

664 words - 3 pages pursue their own feelings in a country that allowed it. Transcendentalism is another American philosophy that also deals heavily with the individual. Transcendentalists believed formalized society oppressed the individual. Thus, they strove to create a doctrine that stressed the importance of the individual. Ralph Waldo Emerson suggested this idea in his book Nature. Emerson maintains that man is one with Nature and Nature is one with

The Effects of Philosophy on Various Characters in "All the King’s Men"

1543 words - 7 pages Everyone chooses their own personal philosophies to live by. We often forget that these choices are very influential on the day to day existence of every life around us. Idealism and pragmatism influence man more than any other two philosophies and we as humans must decide on which of the two will define us, just like the characters in Robert Penn Warren’s “All the King’s Men”. The battle between idealism and pragmatism in this novel is fought

What is the Determining Factor in Success or Failure while Facing Adversity?

3285 words - 13 pages still from the film The Emperor’s New Groove. It’s a scene where Kronk is deliberating between two options. The second is an excerpt from an essay by Richard Stallman entitled “Copyleft: Pragmatic Idealism.” It’s more about the pragmatism of the GNU General Public License than an introspective look at humanity, expanding on reasons why people should be writing open-source software, but while technology seems about as far from human as one can get

A Marxist Philosophy of Life - Reading Mao’s Three Essays

879 words - 4 pages From Mao’s three essays, namely In Memory of Norman Bethune, Serve the People, and The Foolish Old Man Who Removed the Mountains, we can see that the two defining themes of Mao’s rendition of Marxist philosophy towards life are altruism and pragmatism, both of which are in line with Marxist theories. However, considering the historical context of the three essays, Mao’s philosophy of life as shown in the aforementioned essays can be seen as

"The Utopia" of Book Two is a clear expression of More's reaction to his own context. Explain with specific examples from the book

985 words - 4 pages Thomas More's context was 16th century England, which entailed the Humanist movement. Thomas More constantly shifted between the ideals of Humanist philosophy and service to his king and country. The period leading up to the writing of Utopia swelled a massive personal dilemma within More between philosophical idealism and worldly pragmatism. It can be witnessed in More's novel Utopia, that Book Two is a clear expression of Thomas More's own

Teaching Philosophy Statement

1318 words - 5 pages idealism that the everyday world of things and objects is merely a fleeting, shadowy copy of the true ideas which the soul carries which encourages students to seek a higher level of thinking (Hamm 1974, 212). Idealism also includes the cultural heritage and wisdom which each student should be encouraged to share by being knowledgeable about it, participating in sharing it and elaborating it through their own contributions in the classroom and in

"Politics has nothing to do with idealism; it is all about hard-headed decisions, money and power." Do you agree?

1197 words - 5 pages Politicians have not always been associated with diplomatic chicanery, amoral pragmatism and self-aggrandization, the way they tend to be now. There was a time when leaders like Abraham Lincoln sounded the clarion call for democracy, and pleaded as Woodrow Wilson did in his Fourteen Points for world peace and mutual respect. Since the twin horrors of World War I and World War II, as well as various crises like Vietnam, however, the masses have

My Education Philosophy

1787 words - 8 pages knowledge is imparted. Through schooling, students should also advance socially so that they are able to relate to anyone at any time. In essence, the interests, abilities, talents, and gifts of students should be identify and developed through schooling (Peterson, 2009). Conclusion Teachers must instil knowledge and inspire students. A thorough understanding of the philosophies, such as Idealism and Pragmatism, is essential for becoming an

Similar Essays

Muslim Vs. Rastafarians Islam Interprets The Relationship Between A Man

2293 words - 9 pages MUSLIM VS. RASTAFARIANS Islam interprets the relationship between a man and a woman as one, which should make many babies while living a peaceful existence. “...(God) has created men and women as company for one another, and so that they can reproduce and live in peace and serenity according to the commandments of Allah and the directions of his messenger.” On the other hand,“...(Rastafarians) view the position (of) women as a (weak

Muslim Vs. Rastafarians Islam Interprets The Relationship Between A Man

2288 words - 9 pages MUSLIM VS. RASTAFARIANS Islam interprets the relationship between a man and a woman as one, which should make many babies while living a peaceful existence. “...(God) has created men and women as company for one another, and so that they can reproduce and live in peace and serenity according to the commandments of Allah and the directions of his messenger.” On the other hand,“...(Rastafarians) view the position (of) women as a

“‘You Have Chosen A Dead End Road’ (Mama) Said After (Baba)” P.43 Suleiman's Parents Are Engaged In A Battle Between Pragmatism And Idealism. Discuss

823 words - 4 pages Hisham Matar’s novel In the Country of Men , clearly demonstrates the differing attitudes of Suleiman’s parents. Faraj, his father, strives for his country’s democracy, illustrating a man who upholds his ideals neglecting practicalities whereas Najwa the mother of Suleiman, is a practical woman. She sees Faraj’s dream as unreal and that their family may be overpowered by the Guide if they openly defy their leader. The corrupted Libyan society

Man Vs. Environment In To Build A Fire By Jack London

1042 words - 4 pages One can express many different types of themes in Jack London’s, “To Build a Fire”. Though I feel strongly that London’s theme in the story is about that the environment shapes who we are because it shows that the man is not strong enough to live up to his environment. Allowing the environment to kill the man indicates that he is weak both mentally and biologically, while on the other hand the dog is stronger by surviving the same harsh