This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Predation Cost Of Conspicuous Male Coloration In Collard Lizards (Crotaphytus Collaris): An Experimental Test Using Clay Covered Model Lizards.

1287 words - 6 pages

The results propose that the balance between natural selection for inconspicuousness and sexual selection for conspicuousness may vary among the lizard populations. At SL, the habitat consists primarily of gray rocks, so the SL collared lizard population has a small chance to hide. Because of this, the male SL lizards are a dull greenish-brown color that is similar to the females and rocks. At GM, the background is more complicated, so the male lizards are more conspicuous compared to the rocks and females (Macedonia et al. 2004). More than double the number of models was preyed upon at SL than at GM, which shows that natural selection restricts sexual selection for colorful males more ...view middle of the document...

However, the results of the study being analyzed expose a direct relationship between conspicuousness and predator detection.
Critique
The research was done very well; however, some changes need to be made. Adequate descriptions of the three populations of the collared lizards were not given in the study. It was difficult to judge their conspicuousness compared to one another without descriptions and photographs of the lizards. The researchers simply stated that the lizards had significant differences in color conspicuousness. They briefly mention that models were painted green or blue-green depending on which lizard they are trying to recreate, but they give no explanation of which colors goes with which lizard population.
The investigators stated in their methods that they used photographs of the three lizard populations to try to match, by eye, the color of the lizards and paint them accordingly. The investigators also stated that they were unable to get spectrophotometric readings of the models until right before the experiment. Because of this, the results of the models’ contrast with the background at each site were inaccessible until after the experiment. This was very disadvantageous because the models’ spectrophotometric readings could have been very different than the live lizards readings. In other words, the models’ contrast with the different backgrounds could have been completely different from the live lizards’ contrast with the backgrounds, causing the study to be to be insignificant. If these readings between the models and the live lizards were different, predators would perceive them differently, causing irrelevant results. The readings were similar between model and live lizards, but not exact. If the researchers knew this beforehand, they may have been able to improve the models, making the results more sound.
Although all other variables were held constant in order to see how color affects predation, this, is not what happens in nature. It is important to note that behavior was not discussed much in the study. According to Forsman and Appelqvist (1998), being preyed upon by a predator depends on conspicuousness and behavior. The predation rates of different colored organisms could be similar if they took part in predator avoidance behaviors.
The methods that the investigators used were well thought out. It was important that the investigators made each lizard model exposed to each natural habitat. Some habitats are more complex than others, so conducting the experiment in each environment was needed to see how each habitat influenced the outcome. Overall, the study was well done.
Future Direction
This study adds further evidence that increased conspicuousness leads to an increase in predation. More research on this subject needs to be done with the same populations of lizards as this study as well as other species to see how conspicuousness influences predation. Other research on how different predators and habitat...

Find Another Essay On Predation cost of conspicuous male coloration in collard lizards (Crotaphytus collaris): an experimental test using clay- covered model lizards.

Isolation of Fungal Strains: An Experimental Study

1160 words - 5 pages remove mycelia. The culture media was then extracted in 5 L ethyl acetate (2 times), followed by filtration and then taken to evaporation. Evaporation of the extract gave a dry extract which was chromatographed over a silica gel column with n-hexane : ethyl acetate as solvent (gradient elution). Based on detection by TLC (SiO gel F254, Merck, Darmstadt, Germany) using n-hexane:EtOAc as a solvent system, collected fractions were combined, and

Best Mates: an exploration of male adolescent friendships in

962 words - 4 pages Michele Gill, Ph.D. the author of this article is currently an associate professor of educational psychology at the University of Central Florida. Her interests are in educational psychology and education reform. Her thesis, published in 2012, focused on the representation of young male adults in contemporary fiction, and appears to be the forerunner of the article, “Best Mates: an exploration of male adolescent friendships in contemporary

Experimental Investigation on Natural Convective Heat Transfer Coefficient of Silver/Water Nanofluid in an Enclosure

1275 words - 6 pages pipe is made up by the glass wool. To add sufficient level and remove the excess amount of the test fluid, a draft tube made of copper is fixed on the piston. The test section is ready for the experimental investigation. Works Cited C.J. Ho*, W.K. Liu, Y.S. Chang, C.C. Lin, Natural convection heat transfer of alumina- water nanofluid in vertical square enclosures: An experimental study, International Journal of thermal Sciences 49 (2010) 1345

Limits of Liberalism as Expressed in Not Either an Experimental Doll

1896 words - 8 pages Not Either an Experimental Doll, is a cluster of letters, narrated by Shula Marks, telling a story between a young South African girl named Lily Moya and a British woman named Mabel Palmer, who tries to help her get an education in the time period when apartheid began developing. The letters reveal many of the complications South African women faced, along with the views of white people on the restraints placed on people of different color. The

An examination of male struggles

1343 words - 6 pages study takes on a quantitative approach as information was obtained and interpreted based on measurements of the waist, chest, and bicep circumference of a collected sample of the most popular American action figures manufactured over the last 30 years. Each male action figure measurements were scaled using classical allometry to the height of an actual man. The overall results obtained demonstrated that the figures have increased in muscularity over

The Character of Clay in Amiri Baraka's The Dutchman

1487 words - 6 pages The Character of Clay in Amiri Baraka's The Dutchman Clay is not naive. He may be misguided, misled, and mistaken, but he is anything but naive. Clay is an individual who has shed the roots of his race, disregarding many of the cultural implications that such a decision could have on him. He is a misguided individual who, because he is human, does the wrong things at the wrong times for the wrong reasons. He continually struggles with his

Using Cost of Production for Decision Making

2169 words - 9 pages . The cost of using this capital is the opportunity cost. A simple way of including the opportunity cost of capital is by using a cost of leasing the land. Alternatively you can apply an interest rate on the value of the land. Finance • Interest on the input costs used to grow the crop. In the cost of production model, this has been calculated as all cash costs at 8% interest. This is an estimate assuming the money is borrowed or could be

An overview of how can the PPF model help to explain the issues of choice, opportunity cost, growth and unemployment

611 words - 2 pages lifestyle.However, the issue of opportunity cost affects the firm, in a slightly different manner. The firm must decide whether or not to invest its resources, in stepping up production of an existing product, or producing a completely new product. This means that the "real" cost of choosing to step up production of a certain product, was not being able to produce an additional product, which may give the company an advantage in the marketplace.Finally

Confessions of Saint Augutine in Contrast With Previously Covered Literature

593 words - 3 pages When reading ancient texts, they are often told through an omniscient point of view, such as The Odyssey or Gilgamesh, or they are written through another person’s perspective, such as The Republic. Confessions differs in that it is told from a first-person point of view, which makes it uniquely fascinating because we get to learn firsthand how Augustine’s actions, thoughts, and beliefs affected him. In comparison with the other, often mythical

The Advantages of Using the Flipped Classroom Model in the EFL Classroom in Nicaragua

922 words - 4 pages The Advantages of Using the Flipped Classroom Model in the EFL Classroom in Nicaragua Quoting Nelson Mandela, ¨Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world¨. Education is a never-ending process that requires constant learning, updating and guidance; much like technology which evolves very quickly trying to adjust to the everyday needs of the individuals all over the world. In the recent years, technology and

Health promotion in a diverse community using the tannahill model of health promotion

2073 words - 8 pages The aim of this case study is to provide a detailed account of a patients holistic health care needs from a health promotion perspective utilising the Tannahill Model which will be described. In promoting the health of the patient maintaining individuality within a diverse community will also be discussed by the application of the model to the patient.Mary, the patient the study focuses on (surname withheld to uphold confidentiality), was chosen

Similar Essays

Predation Cost Of Conspicuous Male Coloration In Collard Lizards (Crotaphytus Collaris)

2447 words - 10 pages more often than the drab females (Stuart-Fox et al. 2003). These studies indicate that more testing needs to be done on this subject. In the Husak et al. (2003) study, the investigators examined the possible cost of male conspicuous coloration in three populations of collared lizards (Crotaphytus collaris) in Oklahoma that varied in color. The male collared lizards are more conspicuously colored than the females (McCoy et al. 1997; Macedonia et

Estimation Of Reshaped Profile In Berm Breakwaters Using Experimental Data

2320 words - 10 pages the experimental results, because of the material compression phenomenon, these two areas are not necessarily equal. Ezabad et al. (2005) [16] presented a computer software named "IB" in which the reshaped profile of a rubble mound structure could be estimated, using some equations based on statistical models. 2. Experimental data A total number of 412 test results are used in the present study, which are obtained from the experiments carried

The Role Of Competition And Predation In Ecology

630 words - 3 pages Competition and predation are two key factors that affect the stability of an ecosystem, such as a lake. There are three theories on the affects of competition. Competition may lead to competitive exclusion, stable coexistence, or niche differentiation. It has been shown that in marine environments, species are strong competitors for both light and nutrients and thus competition leads only to competitive exclusion (Passarge et al. 2006). The

Performance Evaluation Of Pumping Test In Heterogeneous Environment Using Tracer Test

1766 words - 8 pages transmission is done from conduit and matrix routes. In dam site of Salman Farsi with abundant conduit routes, observed tracers following high conductivity conduits and noted that using an average K value from an aquifer pump test to predict solute transport would result in considerable underestimation of transport distances for a given time period.