This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Preferences, Barriers And Facilitators For Establishing Comprehensive Stroke Units: A Multidisciplinary Survey

1166 words - 5 pages

Preferences, barriers and facilitators for establishing comprehensive stroke units: a multidisciplinary survey

Question 1: What is your view of the quality of the article?

This article is well written with good general flow of thought and easy for the reader to follow. Survey methodology is employed to capture data for quantitative analysis.1

The question asked pertains to a “comprehensive stroke unit (CSU)” model of care. It stems from 2 Cochrane database reviews (02, 07) by the Stroke Unit Trialists’ Collaboration (SUTC) that showed survival and dependency benefits of “organized inpatient (stroke unit) care”.2, 3 These reviews however did not differentiate between models of ...view middle of the document...

Surveys were distributed within the NSW Stroke Network, and therefore should effectively capture all the operational stroke units in the region. Units that did not see a great throughput of patients were excluded. The approach to data collection is diligent with personal distribution of surveys and data collection by 2 researchers who did not influence respondents by comment or expression. Questionnaires were adequately described, using mainly close-ended questions of type 1) multiple-choice (with option for free-text), and 2) scaled questions.

Data was analysed using standard statistical methods. There was a high response rate which likely reflects the diligent survey distribution method. Data integrity was maintained by checking quality of responses and exclusion of survey responses that violated instructions.

In summary the results showed that most respondents preferred CSU as a model of care (doctors and allied health staff more than nurses). More respondents however felt that establishment of CSUs was not, or was unlikely to be feasible (only from non-CSUs; more from SU-R than SU-A). The most common barriers identified were space, money, staff and time. Perceived disadvantages were: inadequate staff training, bed management issues and work-related stress. Perceived advantages were: reduced patient transfers, earlier commencement of rehabilitation and improved patient satisfaction. There is no reference to individual comments or answers which may have provided a qualitative viewpoint.

The authors reasonably concluded that: 1) doctors and allied health staff favoured CSU more than nurses perhaps due to the formers’ emphasis on early rehabilitation and continuity of care, versus the latters’ concerns about mixing patients of different acuity; 2) reduced length of stay, improved functional outcomes and reduced morbidity and mortality were not perceived as prominent advantages of CSUs, perhaps reflecting respondents’ concerns that the model lacks emphasis on acute stroke care (possibly because of their lack of awareness of the evidence, or the evidence is regarded as inconclusive); 3) cost is a perceived barrier (although there is no published data regarding costs related to CSU establishment or maintenance compared to TSU); 4) rehabilitation appeared to commence earlier in CSUs compared to TSUs. Given this they suggest further research into establishment of CSUs is worthwhile.

Question 2: What is the significance of the article to leadership and management practice in health care organizations?

The key significance of this article to leadership and management practice in health care organizations pertains to the issue of transforming the model of inpatient stroke care for possibly better patient outcomes.

Lukas et al discuss 5 key elements in successful transformation of patient care, i.e. “1) Impetus...

Find Another Essay On Preferences, barriers and facilitators for establishing comprehensive stroke units: a multidisciplinary survey

Establishing a Project Vision for the Recruiting Solutions Project

1467 words - 6 pages to developing a project vision and use that approach to develop and evaluate a vision statement for a recruiting solutions project, which is about to begin. Approach Christensen and Walker’s designed an approach to “engender passion and meaning to a project” (40). In addition to defining certain key characteristics, the authors propose a process for establishing a vision that truly resonates with the project team and its stakeholders by

A Comprehensive Examination of the Turkish Economy with Recommendations and Rationale for Economic Growth

2127 words - 9 pages the road for the Republic of Turkey. History, particularly in Turkey’s case, still informs the modern environment. This paper will address the Ottoman influence on the Turkish economy and will then proceed with a comprehensive examination of the present economy. The paper will conclude with recommendations and rationale for economic improvement. The Ottoman Empire The history of the Ottoman Empire spans over 700 years (1300-1918) and its

The Requirements for Developing and Managing a Comprehensive Management Information System

4238 words - 17 pages The Requirements for Developing and Managing a Comprehensive Management Information System The aim of this assignment is to see the requirements for developing and managing a comprehensive Management Information system for an organisation. In today's business environment it is getting harder and harder for organisation’s to not only survive but to compete against other organisation’s. Information technology plays a big part in helping

Program Balance for Developing and Implementing a Comprehensive Developmental School Counseling Program

1271 words - 6 pages Program Balance The ASCA National Model and the Texas Model both emphasize the importance of program balance when developing and implementing a comprehensive, developmental school counseling program (ASCA, 2012; Texas Counseling Association, 2004). Program balance is important as a counselor should spend 80 percent of his/her day working with and for students either in a direct or indirect capacity. A written program can assist counselors in

Human Resources: Establishing a Business Need for Recruitment

694 words - 3 pages 1. Identification of the vacancy: Managers are responsible for establishing a business need for recruitment and for justifying the need to fill the vacancy or the need to create a new position. A Manpower Requisition Form needs to be filled by the respective regional or functional managers then approved by senior mangers before the recruitment process can be initiated by Human Resources. The recruitment and selection process should not proceed

Essay topic: Shareholder value provides a comprehensive framework for evaluating strategic and tactical marketing decisions

1741 words - 7 pages Essay topic: Shareholder value provides a comprehensive framework for evaluating strategic and tactical marketing decisionsModern enterprise is uninterrupted to ameliorate its own system and constitute accredited standard or criterion on institutional. Today's directorate and top management seem to be more concentrating on shareholder value. Obviously, aim to maximize shareholder value become most enterprises' crucial goal that may affect

Aggression and Violence in a Mental Health Units

1366 words - 5 pages Assaults in the healthcare setting are recognized as a growing problem. In considering the violence and aggression in mental health units, the larger issue of violence and aggression in mainstream culture must not be ignored. It has been observed that physical attack in a mental health unit setting appear to be happening more frequently while the attacks include patient-to patient and patient-to-staff aggressive behavior. Most commonly

Carrying Out a Local Survey for Land

6099 words - 24 pages , with minimum disruption to farmland. [IMAGE] View south 3:- Policies 3.1 Site specific A comprehensive scheme is required, which can allow phased development. Proposals should incorporate mixed housing styles and servicing provision for the prospective new school site, and can include local shopping and community facilities. A landscape scheme designed to enhance nature conservation interests is required

The importance of a comprehensive security policy for modern businesses

2140 words - 9 pages The information age went international in the 1980s. However, the fact is that a series of corresponding security weaknesses also came. For example, electronic mails are widely applied in today's daily life and business, while the virus of one computer connected to many others in a honeycomb arrangement may affect another, as usually how great they are interconnected is unknown (Shain, 1996). Therefore, information security is increasingly

A Framework For Barriers Of Telemedicine Implementation In Iran

1849 words - 8 pages believed that technical barriers are the cause of considerable problems in telemedicine. Iran is not a generator country in the scope of technology and faces with a lot of problems in importing technologies and this leads to a lot of problems in implementing telemedicine. Another problem that became confirmed by both literature review and doctor’s idea, was technical problems with hardware and software equipment in telemedicine. For example the speed

Benefits and Flaws of a Resistivity Survey

1412 words - 6 pages What am I going to research? In this case study, I am going to research what resistivity is and how a resistivity survey works using the physics principles. I am also going to explore what benefits this technique might bring, but also what flaws there could be. Additionally, I am going to explore a famous historical use of this method. What is resistivity? Resistivity is the oppose to conductivity. It's a measure of material's ability to oppose

Similar Essays

Theory And Construction Of A Care Plan For Stroke Rehabilitation

3962 words - 16 pages Theory and Construction of a Care Plan for Stroke RehabilitationFor this assignment I will be looking at the care planning process for an elderly stroke patient. The theory behind care plans how they are constructed and are used in rehabilitation and ongoing care I will also look briefly into my client's condition.For this placement I was based on an elderly female rehabilitation ward. Patients were admitted from a range of places, but mainly

Determinants Of Quality Of Life In Stroke Survivors After 6 Months, From Comprehensive Stroke Unit In Spain. A Longitudinal Study

886 words - 4 pages stroke (Reeves et al., 2008). We observed poorer quality of life in individuals with increased comorbidity, which is supported by the literature (Ellis, Grubaugh, & Egede, 2013; Nichols-Larsen et al. 2005). Similarly, patients with little social support experience a greater impact on their HRQoL than those with comprehensive social network (Carod-Artal et al., 2000). We have located valid predictive models for all SF-12 domains, and as seen in

Mac Versus Pc In Schools: A Future Plan And Direction For A Comprehensive High School

2017 words - 8 pages Anyone who ever uses a computer has probably thought about the question: Mac or PC? While consumers can make their decision based on personal preferences, schools and school districts must carefully weigh the pros and cons before making purchasing decisions. This essay will address the pros and cons of both systems in evaluating their ability to meet educational needs at a comprehensive high school. Regular High School (RHS, not real name) is a

Information System In An Integrated Multidisciplinary Health Care Team: A Strategy For Improving Patient Care

1021 words - 5 pages . It is worth mentioning that when there is integration, a multicomponent approach must come in and clinical records must be shared accross the multiprofessional team. Commentators argue that, technology which supports continuous patient monitoring is a tool for clinical or professional integration while multidisciplinary team work and care co-ordination are tools for service integration. Care co-ordination can be improved by targeting highest