Present And Discuss The Views Submitted By Socrates And Thrasymachius In The First Book Of Platos Republic

2201 words - 9 pages

In the first book of the Republic Socrates and Thrasymachus argue about the nature of justice. Thrasymachus claims that justice is the advantage of the stronger. He also claims that Socrates’ arguments against that position stem from a naive set of beliefs about the real intentions of rulers, and an uncritical approach to the way words acquire their meaning.
Present the arguments on both sides. Who do you think is right? Justify your position.

In the first book of the Republic Plato orchestrates a dialogue between his teacher Socrates and one of his peers Thrasymachus in order to demonstrate the desirable nature of justice. In this essay I shall present Thrasymachus argument that justice is a tool of oppression wielded by the strong over the weak, whereas injustice provides a happy and fulfilled existence, and Socrates notion that justice is a desirable commodity and characteristic that benefits all individuals and is the only way to achieve any common goal. I believe that both philosophers have elements of truth in their arguments, however in the essay I intend to show that it is not possible to agree entirely with either party because of the underlying premise of their argument. I shall demonstrate that neither party has a correct view because they base their arguments on examples whose essence is incompatible with the concept of justice, and refute their claims due to the obvious fallacy of arguing two extremes when considering human nature.

In the first book of the Republic, Thrasymachus states that justice is not desirable. He describes human behaviour as fundamentally self-interested, and states that justice is
‘an advantage of the stronger’ employed to suppress ‘the weaker’ . He submits the view that injustice is therefore preferable in relation to politics and to common living. Thrasymachus postulates that it is right and just to obey the rules of the state created by the ruling power, but that the ruling power will be making rules that benefit themselves. He supports his claim that the ruling power capitalise upon the weaker party by drawing a parallel between the profession of government and the profession of sheep herding: ‘The shepherd and the herdsman study the good of their flock and herds (for) the good of their masters and themselves’ . He considers that rulers rule with the objective of procuring some profit from them. On a basic level pursuit of self interest is natural, right and serves the individual best. For example, during the crusades King Richard raised the taxes of the people in order to pursue the Holy Grail as it served him best and not because it served the people best. Thrasymachus has inferred that rulers are unjust by default, but strengthens his view by emphasising that these men are submitting to their nature. However, there is also the proposition only unjust men will become rulers because they will compete for the honours and financial gain, whereas the just man is too humble for this kind of contest. The...

Find Another Essay On Present and Discuss the Views submitted by Socrates and Thrasymachius in the First Book of Platos Republic

Concepts and Views Present in the novel, "Brave New World" by Aldous Huxley

1113 words - 4 pages , pure, and perhaps na�ve views of humanity outside the isolation of the Native Indian village formed young, and would hold greater implications later in his life. The adult John comes to civilized society as an experiment by Marx and Mond to see how a "savage" would adapt to civilization. ""How beauteous mankind is!....O Brave New World." First exclaimed by the Savage whilst filled with anticipation for what wonders

The Past and Present Views on the Status of Women in Indian Society

620 words - 2 pages Introduction In India, past and present, the status and freedom that are held by women has and is in a constant decline due to both external and cultural factors that not only causes large panic, but defensive reactions that negatively affect and hinder the women in their culture. Many studies conducted, have shown that the influence of other cultures and religions have made an impression on the ideas of Indian men that have resulted in

How does Austen present the relationship between Lizzie and Darcy in the first twenty chapters of the novel? Essay on Pride and Prejudice novel by Jane Austen

831 words - 3 pages How does Austen present the relationship between Lizzie and Darcy in the first twenty chapters of the novel?The relationship between Elizabeth and Darcy is without doubt an incredibly tempestuous one, but the main problems at the start of their relationship all arise because of their own personal qualities, through the characters’ own faults, though it is ironic as neither character is able to see their own faults. The pride and prejudices

Justice In Book I Of The Republic

883 words - 4 pages what justice is. The rest of the first book is a discussion of the definition of justice, mainly that of Thrasymachus' definition. Socrates takes his normal role as an interrogator of peoples' views. The conversation focuses on justice but actually must be viewed in the context of how each individual can lead the best life possible.      Thrasymachus states that "justice is simply the interest of the stronger&quot

Discuss the status of women in Africa, past and present. Is it getting better or worse

511 words - 2 pages The status of women has changed little in Africa since the adoption of the Universal Deceleration of Human Rights by the United Nations General Assembly in 1948. However gender inequality is still present. An African woman's social and economic status continues to be largely defined by customary rules that are deeply rooted in country-specific historical, economic, and social factors. In modern day Africa, women are still looked at as being

How does Aeneas present himself and his people in Book 2 of the Aeneid?

2954 words - 12 pages that although the ancestors of the Romans lost the war, they remained wholly courageous in spite of their unprecedented defeat; consequently showing that their eventual glory did not come without hardship. The book opens with Aeneas 'shudder[ing] to remember' the 'agony of Troy'. He emphasises the duplicity of the Greeks combined with his own suffering both as an individual and as one of the nation: 'the destruction by the Greeks of the

Discuss the impact of the past upon the present in both "Persuasion" by Jane Austen and "The Magic Toyshop" by Angela Carter, from the point of view of both characterisation and plot

2579 words - 10 pages of this impact is debatable, as an old flame is rekindled in the end. However, a past which links so closely to the present creates new plot opportunities to Austen who carefully constructs new perspectives for both the reader, herself and her characters by the past and present love stories between Anne and the Captain.Melanie, the main character of Carter's novel, is also affected by her own past. She is a silly pubescent girl who's grown up in

Morality and Laws in The Trial and Death of Socrates

1231 words - 5 pages Morality and Laws in The Trial and Death of Socrates Upon reading Plato, The Trial and Death of Socrates, Socrates strongly held views on the relationship between morality and laws become apparent to the reader. Equally, Socrates makes clear why laws should be followed and why disobedience to the law is rarely justified. Finally, he makes clear his views regarding civil disobedience. Socrates’ view on morality is that anyone can do wrong

Examine the different views of love presented in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet and discuss for their inclusion

1393 words - 6 pages Examine the different views of love presented in Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet and discuss for their inclusion.The tragic tale of Romeo and Juliet is one of Shakespeare's great plays it is one of his most popular. The play looks at different types of love. Romeo and Juliet are often seen as a romance play, it also looks at physical love, spiritual love, plutonic love and the love of family.When the audience first meets Romeo he fancies the

The Presentation of Socrates' Arguements in Plato’s Apology and Crito

967 words - 4 pages . During the trial of Socrates, the court addresses issues such as his views on death. Socrates proposed that death was ultimately a good thing. Socrates states that there were two outcomes of death. Either through dying, one has no longer any awareness of anything. In Socrates second outcome of death, one’s soul experiences a transformation and becomes this perfect being. While addressing the jury Socrates states that he has no experience with

Erroneus Assumptions in The Trial and Death of Socrates

2336 words - 9 pages Erroneus Assumptions in The Trial and Death of Socrates In Plato's Crito, Socrates explains to his old friend Crito his reasons for refusing an offer to help him escape execution. One of the tools Socrates uses to convince Crito of the righteousness of his decision is a hypothetical argument concerning the state and laws of Athens. Central to this argument is the congeniality that Socrates had always found in Athens, reflected by the fact

Similar Essays

Discuss How The Poets Present Their Views On Old Age In 'old Man, Old Man' And 'warning'

732 words - 3 pages These two poems present old age in very different ways. Fanthorpe's poem, 'Old Man, Old Man', expresses a daughter's feelings for her father as he becomes old and is diminished by old age. In contrast, Jenny Joseph's poem 'Warning' looks forward to the freedom of pleasing herself in later years.Both poems are modern and conversational, written in the first person.The title 'Old Man, Old Man' sets the tone for Fanthorpe's poem. The repetition

The Role Of Women And Marriage In Socrates' The Republic

1114 words - 4 pages the women will be assigned their roles in the same manner as the men of the city. This agreement eventually will lead the men to the discussion of marriages and procreation in the city and how it is to be regulated in order to maintain the greater good in the city. Socrates begins his explanation of marriages in the city by first establishing that all spouses and children in the city be held in common in order to avoid any factions among the

Justice In The Republic By Socrates

645 words - 3 pages In The Republic, Socrates tries to find the answer to a debatable question. What is justice? Throughout Book 1, he is given a couple of definitions that were at first incoherent to him and so he decided to clear them up by questioning Cephalus’s and his son Polemarchus’s definitions of “justice” . In Book 1, Socrates is about to leave from a religious festival when a group of men stopped him and convinced him to stay for the late night

Socrates And Thrasymachus In Republic Essay

2195 words - 9 pages of what your position affirmed?” (Republic 339e) In giving this line of reasoning, Socrates has not taken into account that Thrasymachus’ claim is based on morality being subjective, created by those in power. The question is then begged of Thrasymachus, whether or not he views the stronger party as being fallible. Thrasymachus replies to both Socrates and the begged question by making his defense in regards to expertise, claiming that