Present Day Detention Camps: North Korea Vs. The United States

1144 words - 5 pages

Present Day Detention Camps: North Korea Vs. The United States

Abstract
The purpose of this research was to determine how similar detention facilities run by the
U.S. government are to the gulags of North Korea. The research spanned many different media
sources from online news articles to reports in scholarly journals to an anthology of memoirs
and articles concerning the treatment of prisoners in U.S. detention facilities. Although some
of the specific details of the camps were inconsistent across sources, this can be attributed to
the secret nature of the prison system. However, despite those inconsistencies, an overall
theme present in all the sources was the secret nature of the camps as well as U.S. lack of
cooperation with human rights standards presented by the United Nations. The research also
showed that the U.S. in fact had imprisoned innocent persons. Because of the similarities to
North Korea camps in terms of secrecy, the incarceration of innocent people and the deliberate
avoidance of compliance with human rights laws, it is possible to compare the U.S.
“democratic” government with North Korea’s communist regime.
Review of the Literature
Kang Chol-Hwan’s The Aquariums of Pyongyang, a memoir of life in a North Korean gulag,
presents the stark reality that concentration camps do still exist to this day. However, the existence of
these camps alone is not the only harsh reality. Not only do these detention camps exist under the
communist regime of North Korea, but such camps are also present under the supervision of the
democratic United States government. Therefore I wonder: how do the U.S. detention camps
compare to North Korean gulags? The research of information on U.S. camps included a variety of
sources from scholarly articles to online news to an anthology of essays and analyses of secret
imprisonment by the U.S. government. In the end, the sources of interest on U.S. detention camps
revealed frightening similarities in the structure and nature of the camps to those of North Korean
regime.
There were some inconsistencies among the research sources. Although the existence of a
secret prison system operated by the U.S. throughout the world was acknowledged by most sources
(Grooms; Margolis; Meeropol; Priest; Reuters), the number and locations of these detention centers
varied. ABC’s online news article “US has secret prisons: rights groups” claims, according to a
Human Rights First report, that the U.S. is holding prisoners in more than two dozen facilities spread
throughout the world (Reuters 1). Among these the locations mentioned in the article were Pakistan,
Diego Garcia, and Jordan along with the more famous centers of Guantanamo Bay and Abu Ghraib.
However, in another similar report on the secret prison system, the Washington Post article “CIA
Holds Terror Suspects in Secret Prisons” claims an undetermined amount of “black sites,” as the
White House refers to the secret prisons, to have...

Find Another Essay On Present Day Detention Camps: North Korea Vs. The United States

Legal Business Practices in the United States and Korea

1503 words - 6 pages Introduction The purpose of this paper is to describe business practice in detail and provide a comparison of South Korea with that of the United States in regard to business practices. The researcher will define ethical and legal business practice as well as unethical and illegal business practices. Furthermore, the researcher will identify business practices that are considered illegal and unethical in the United States and address why

My first day in the United States

1196 words - 5 pages Hundreds of various thoughts and dreams crossed my mind, awakened frightened because of wind shears. Still feeling sleepy, the captain started talking about the weather in Houston and how much time left till landing. We would approach Houston in a short time and my first day in the United States was about to begin. My first day in the United States disturbed me too much although it ended well. At this time one of the stewardesses came to me

The developing of North American to United states

1008 words - 4 pages Columbus found America when he landed in the Caribbean looking for a Western route to Asia, but found North America. After that settlers from different parts of the world start to come to America. The United States really begin to develop when Christopher Columbus found the region. From the nation had found to Manifest Destiny, which is the believe of expansion, to the United Sates start to be divided and finally broke in to war. All of these

North and South Korea: One Country, Two States

2259 words - 9 pages stepped in to unbind Korea from its harsh Japanese rule. The country was separated into two halves in which Russia took control over the North and the United States took control over the South. Despite the fact that Koreans were promised that reunification would occur, these foreign governments essentially installed dictators that would further each foreign country’s own political agendas (Korea, 2013). There are a large amount of similarities

The History of he United States from the Viewpoint of the People: 1492-Present

3158 words - 13 pages “What we learn about the past doesn’t give us absolute truth about the present, but it may cause us to look deeper than the glib statements made by political leaders, and the ‘experts’ quoted in the press,” states author Howard Zinn (684). Throughout this book, Zinn portrays to the readers the history of the United States from the viewpoint of the people, not just from the rich, but also from the destitute. As Zinn informed, the book is

How can Republic of Korea foreign policy towards Japan and China affect the United States in the region?

1317 words - 6 pages their ties. Second, the constraining factors in the South Korean-Chinese relations will be analyze. Finally, this section will analyze the extent to which these relations affect the United States in the region. The Ties that Bind Largely, South Korea and China have developed their relationship with an unprecedented speed through expanding bilateral economic cooperation. The development in these areas is the driving force promoting cooperation

Mandatory Vaccination in the United States: A Past and Present Examination of Jacobson v Massachusetts

1350 words - 6 pages by the U.S. Constitution, citing the Preamble and the 14th amendment; namely, Section 1 of the 14th amendment, which states “No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law” (4). The case progressed from the local court to the state supreme court, each time being upheld as

My Past, Present & Future Self in Hyderabad and the United States

1237 words - 5 pages Making my way through the crowded streets of Hyderabad (India), I arrive at the door step of a bakery shop. I have picked up some freshly baked sweet rolls for breakfast. My family really enjoys breakfast the day sweet rolls with jelly and warm milk are on the menu. Over breakfast, my family usually discusses any important events of the day ahead. Most families in India create a strong sense of family bond and aim to instill good values in

The Evolution of the Elite United States Navy SEALs: Vietnam to Modern Day Conflicts

1942 words - 8 pages a variety of tactical and strategic uses. As time went on, the United States Navy SEALs played a role in a variety of conflicts all over the world. Present day conflicts in the Middle East are utilizing the SEALs more than they have ever been used. This is particularly true in the regions of Iraq and Afghanistan where the war on terror still occurs today. Since their creation and evolution during the Vietnam War, the SEALs have basically been completing missions and operating under the same style of warfare. The SEALs presently carry on the legacy that their brothers back in the Vietnam War forged for them with blood, sweat, and pure firepower.

United States Supreme Court in the Case of McCarve v. North Carolina in Accordance with the Eight Amendment

1296 words - 6 pages Brief provided by the APA helps to give assistance in using a set of procedures to follow when dealing with capital crimes of the mentally retarded (APA, 2013). The United States Supreme Court ruled that the execution of those who suffer from mental retardation is cruel and unusual punishment and voted in a 6-3 ruling to use alternate means of punishment for these individuals (APA, 2013). In the case of Atkins V Virginia the court had decided

Better offWhile there are many positive and negative aspects to the North winning the Civil War, the debate of whether the United States is better

845 words - 4 pages While there are many positive and negative aspects to the North winning the Civil War, the debate of whether the United States is better off today is still controversial. The Confederate States wanted to fight off many issues they faced with the North or the Union. While many only are aware of the abolition of slavery, there were also more positive aspects due to this war. With the evidence I have seen, I believe the United States is better off

Similar Essays

Prison Camps In North Korea Essay

1624 words - 6 pages …” ("Political Prison Camps in North Korea Today." Nkdb.com.). Prisoners were expected to work and were punished if they did not fill their quota of work for the day. For Ms. Lee, the work was done “. . . under high temperature, which caused my spine to shrink.” She was forced to work in the ironworks factory ("A Survivor: Soon Ok Lee." Msnbc.com.). The other types of work performed at the prison camps include wood cutting, grass cutting, stone

The Us Rogue States And The Dialogue With North Korea

2388 words - 10 pages to the new unipolar world. The United States of America assumed a responsibility to contain these states and/or transform them into successfully functioning democracies. Currently this is being done by military interventions and sanctions. However, one special state arises – North Korea . It is the most aggressive of the group, but enjoys the most diplomatic approach. This paper’s aim is to understand why North Korea is receiving a different

N Orth Korea And The United Stats Afd Dsf

520 words - 3 pages POUTS Policy Memo Project Rinzing Karsang Sherpa Professor Little GOVT 2302 Fall 2017 Title: Nepal’s Students been brainwashed MEMO To: Donald J Trump, President of the United State From: Rinzing Sherpa Date: October 05, 2017 Subject: Nepal’s Student been brainwashed United State Of America the land of opportunity as they say. They are many international student’s that come to the states to pursue their dreams. Among them students from Nepal

A Cognitivist Explanation To North Korea And United States Relations Polc09 Research Paper

4754 words - 20 pages Hadi Qarizada 1002666037 November 29, 2017 Abdul Hadi Qarizada 1002666037 Decision-Making and the relationship of North Korea and the United States of America: Is a global major war occurring likely? Professor Ahmad POLC09 November 29, 2017 The political relation between the United States (U.S.) and North Korea has been a major international concern. In particular, the nuclear crisis between the U.S. and North Korea has increasingly risen in