Preserving Wilderness Against Human Needs Essay

768 words - 3 pages

There are different types of people in the world. There are those who love nature and would do anything to preserve it and there are those who ignore nature and are primarily concerned with human needs and desires. John Muir is one of those who love nature and will do whatever it takes to protect it. He is known as America's most influential naturalist. Muir is a supporter of an ecocentric philosophical prospective. His love for nature helped people to realize that nature is never made beautiful by destroying and changing it. Therefore, I think that Muir would not be in favor of the wind turbines project in Main. There are couple of reasons that would make him disagree with the people who are in charge of the wind turbines project in Maine. As the article states "...there are people that feel that Mars Hill Mountain is a beautiful mountain, and they don't want to see the looks of it spoiled...," Muir would probably agree with them because he cares for the look of nature and does not feel it needs to be changed. Also, I think that he would have the same opinion as Bob Cummings of Phippsburg, who said "I'm not opposed to wind power, I just think that you are messing up one of the most spectacular areas in the state of Maine when you put it on those two mountains," because he was not all against human needs. However, his first interest was to defend the natural habitat.On the other hand, Gifford Pinchot was one of those whose primary concern was human needs and desires. Unlike John Muir who was a proponent of preservation, Gifford Pinchot was a proponent of conservation. His goal was to make the most of the value of resources for human use rather than to preserve wilderness. His idea of conservation meant "...the greatest good to the greatest number for the longest time..." In other words, he did not care for the good of nature but for the good of people even if it meant to destroy nature. When it comes to the debate over wind turbines, I think that Pinchot would be in favor of them. He would be one of those who "...look at the sleek, slow-turning wind turbines that produce wind power and see something fascinating, almost like modern sculpture...the promise...

Find Another Essay On Preserving Wilderness against Human Needs

Adirondacks Park Industry: Struggle Between Classicists and Romantics

3616 words - 14 pages sacred place through which the face of God was revealed. It was a place where humanity could physically connect with the creator. To ravage the landscape was to blaspheme against God himself. (Simpson 1992:557) These concepts would travel along to the New World with our countries first settlers. For them, the New World was complete wilderness. It was a land of vast potential and resources, but also filled with danger and the unknown. The

Debate Essay: End the Grizzly Bear Hunt in Alberta

1163 words - 5 pages again when we have the chance to take control for ourselves? I am against the Grizzly bear hunt, but it's grown to so much more then that. I am against the frivolous destruction of our wilderness and our lack of motivation to make a change. As society it is our responsibility to strive for the ideal balance between nature and economy, there is always room for improvement and we should never be satisfied until that ultimate ideal has been achieved

Freedom of Humanity Depends on the Connection with Nature

916 words - 4 pages documents [available]” (Faulkner 185), meaning that the only way humans can achieve freedom in nature is by connecting with it, not by terminating it. Connecting with nature allows humans to discover the intimate deliverance that nature offers (Vickery 211). Ike seeks this deliverance when he “enters his novitiate to true wilderness” (Faulkner 189). At first Ike’s purpose is to be the human who “hunts [and kills] the bear” (Faulkner 204). However

Giovanni di Paolo' Art: Transitioning from Medieval to Renaissance

1467 words - 6 pages the portrayal of St. John. He is very large, especially in reference to the building he stands next to, and to the mountain that he climbs. Paolo has chosen to show John as a young boy, and because entering the wilderness is such a turning point, I feel the goal of this painting is to show his transition into manhood. A young boy leaving home, and going into the wilderness to fulfill his spiritual needs alone. The more a viewer looks into this

Wallace Stegner's Wilderness Letter

1218 words - 5 pages In Wallace Stegner’s “Wilderness Letter,” he is arguing that the countries wilderness and forests need to be saved. For a person to become whole, Stegner argues that the mere idea of the wild and the forests are to thank. The wilderness needs to be saved for the sake of the idea. He insinuates that anyone in America can just think of Old faithful, Mt. Rainier, or any other spectacular landform, even if they have not visited there, and brought

Analysis of Desert Solitarie: A Season in the Wilderness by Edward Abbey

1330 words - 6 pages could serve as a strategic advantage for a partisan conflict against an authoritarian power. The parallels between the wilderness and freedom were also presented in a spiritual framework. Abbey initially addresses that the “extreme clarity of the desert light is equaled by the extreme individualization of desert life-forms (Abbey, 1968, p. 29).” Abbey witnessed the freedom exerted by wildlife in the chapter “The Moon-Eyed Horse”. Moon-Eye was

The Wilderness in Margaret Atwood’s Surfacing, Mary Austin’s Land of Little Rain, and Gary Snyder’s

2702 words - 11 pages The Wilderness in Margaret Atwood’s Surfacing, Mary Austin’s Land of Little Rain, and Gary Snyder’s The Practice of the Wild Journeys into the wilderness test far more than the physical boundaries of the human traveler. Twentieth century wilderness authors move beyond the traditional travel-tour approach where nature is an external diversion from everyday life. Instead, nature becomes a catalyst for knowing our internal wilderness and our

Evolution of Environmentalism

1454 words - 6 pages . This prospect is a dominant factor in human affairs, and the nation as a whole has done a superb job at keeping the green movement alive. The fact that we are now far more likely to call upon scientific data and experimental research to support arguments in favor of protecting the wilderness or against polluting industries, provides us with more power to properly brainstorm and implement ecologically assisting systems. Politicians record the

Personal Statement

611 words - 3 pages I grew up in a culture of science. My roots lay in rural Oregon with a biologist and geologist for parents and a curiosity for the natural world at my core. However, through college and my professional career, I have learned the importance of melding this ecological understanding of conservation with another vital aspect of preserving nature: the historical, economic and cultural knowledge of a land and its people. My goal for graduate school

Being One with Nature

1630 words - 7 pages communities and housing facilities, land needs to be allotted for the purpose of preservation and recreation. Today's industrialization is the most apparent threat to our wildlife inhabitants. When referring to "the wild," not necessarily does is it imply acres upon acres of rolling hills crawling with sounds and footsteps of animals. The wilderness can be as small a space as your backyard, or even a patch of grass in the middle of downtown's square


2298 words - 10 pages . As global population growth continues to grow, more and more pressure is being placed on wilderness as a result of increased demand for natural resources, along with the land that these resources rest on. In light of these fragmenting habitats and human pressures via development, conservation of wilderness and Native American culture has become increasingly challenging. Amongst scholars, there is much debate about wilderness in the United States

Similar Essays

Preserving America's Wilderness Areas Essay

596 words - 3 pages America’s wilderness areas are vitally important for our nation's health and well-being. Preserving America’s Wilderness areas is necessary for conservation of resources, it is necessary for the survival of Human, and necessary in maintaining biodiversity. Over the years, past resources have quickly dwindling. Since then conservation has broadened beyond the use of natural resources, and has become a movement. Many critics of conservation

Outdoor Recreation: Human Activity Damages The Natural Balance Of An Area

725 words - 3 pages area. Being able to strike a balance between the two is the responsibility of wilderness managers. By taking a realistic approach to stewardship and considering societal beliefs about wilderness, wilderness managers are able to support recreational activities while preserving the surrounding environment as best they can, keeping human impacts within tolerable levels. The wilderness provides tremendous advantages for all people. These benefits

The Themes Of Wilderness And The White Man In William Faulkner's The Bear

1445 words - 6 pages needs to "possess them both." Faulkner uses the theme of wilderness and the virtues man can learn from it to point at southern civilization, its treatment of Negroes, and its part in the Civil War. Chapter four is centered on a long conversation between Ike (now 21) and his cousin, McCaslin. Ike explains his intention to repudiate his inheritance originating from his grandfather, Carothers McCaslin. Cleanth Brooks writes, The course of

Freedom In Into The Wild By Jon Krakauer And Heart Of Darkness By Joseph Conrad

2015 words - 9 pages hearts and when a person is in the wilderness that evil is dominant since there is no civilization. As Kurtz is dying, he realises that evil is within everyone and it just takes the wilderness to bring it out. Kurtz also cherishes civilization since he figures out that is what he needs in order for his darkness within him to be controlled. In both text McCandless and Kurtz appreciate the value of civilization and how important it is. McCandless