This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

President Bush's Immigration Plan: Compassionate Or Ridiculous?

809 words - 3 pages

Every year, hundreds of thousands of immigrants, legal and illegal, from around the world, come to the United States. Current INS estimates put the number at 8 to 12 million illegal immigrants, mostly Mexican nationals, within our borders (Seper par.11). These immigrants come because they want a chance at a better life; others are refugees, escaping persecution and civil wars in their home country. Earlier this year, in his State of the Union, President Bush addressed the issue of immigration by proposing a temporary worker program that would grant amnesty for millions of illegal aliens, claiming that our current program is not working. Bush's proposal undermines current US border patrols, labor laws, health and safety protections, and will not end the flow of illegals from entering our country. This plan will not solve our growing immigration problem.Bush outlined a plan that would offer amnesty to undocumented aliens by providing them with temporary work permits. Illegal aliens and prospective immigrants would be eligible for the permits as long as they have secured employment in the United States. The permits would then allow approved employers to hire guest workers for a three-year period (Bush, par.20). The White House argues that the jobs these illegals are doing are jobs that Americans simply will not or cannot do. This reasoning is ridiculous; it allows an influx of 8 million unskilled workers into the current job market where unemployment is on the rise. Granting these permits will hardly solve the problem of companies hiring illegals. If the workers who have permits start getting paid equal wages, and businesses have to comply with labor laws, then there is no incentive to keep these workers. The laborers have no reason to sign up for the program either if they know they will be deported at the end of their three-year permit. Bush's plan does not make sense to employers or illegals, meaning that there will always be a black-market for labor in this country so long as the White House does not factor logic into their policy.Amnesty is not the answer; it is a pardoning of millions of illegal activities. Entering the United States illegally is a felony and Bush's plan does not outline any penalties for breaking this law, rather it encourages others to do the same (Seper). This is a slap in the face to the Border Patrols that round up an estimated one million people a year at our borders trying to cross illegally. It is not in our nations best interest to excuse lawbreaking of any kind,...

Find Another Essay On President Bush's Immigration Plan: Compassionate or Ridiculous?

State of the Union Essay

1044 words - 4 pages The State of the UnionOn February 2, 2005 our president George W. Bush gave the state of the Union address. In Bush's speech he stated that, we must be," good stewards of our economy, immigration, Social Security, free society and terrorism." These were the main highlights that he proposed to do something about.In Bush's speech me state that we as Americans have a healthy growing economy, and a force for good in the world and

Social Security Debate Essay

616 words - 2 pages individuals drawing Social Security benefits, but not enough people working to support them and pay those benefits. Under President Bush's plan, younger workers would have the option of diverting part of their Social Security taxes into stock or bond investments. However, this would be in lieu for a reduction in future guaranteed benefits. The President is adamant that workers can benefit from higher rates of returns from stocks and bonds. Polls

IImigration Reforms and Children

2882 words - 12 pages /citizenship-through-naturalization Cline, S. (2014, January 30). Citizenship or Legalization, GOP Immigration Plan Doesn't Bar Entry. US News. Retrieved April 13, 2014, from http://www.usnews.com/news/articles/2014/01/30/citizenship-or-legalization-gop-immigration-plan-doesnt-bar-entry Dream Act Summary. (n.d.). National Immigration Law Center. Retrieved April 4, 2014, from http://nilc.org/dreamsummary.html Fiflis, C. A. (2013). Deferred Action

The Presidential Candidates Bush and Gore

2337 words - 9 pages . The elections are on Tuesday and a lot of things are at stake the way I see it. There is the issue on whether abortion will remain as a constitutional right for women, there is the issue on how the government will expand health care and education, and there is the issue on whether senior citizens will retire in comfort or in poverty. Even though Both candidates promise to provide prescription drug care for the elderly, Bush's plan would only

Climbing The Fence: Immigration across the US-Mexico Border

1621 words - 6 pages problem for America. There are Americans taking advantage of both sides of the coin.It seems that with all the corruption, even George Bush's new plan to end illegal immigration wouldn't work. In October, Bush put into law a new bill. The bill allows for a seven hundred mile fence to be built along the border. The fence is estimated to cost six billion dollars to build. Bush said, "Unfortunately, the United States has not been in complete

George W. Bush

1845 words - 7 pages November, with the enactment of a measure expanding Medicare to include a prescription-drug benefit program for elderly Americans. With an eye to 2004, Bush began raising campaign funds at a record rate, and assured Vice President Cheney that he was welcome to remain on the ticket for a second term. As of late 2003, although the country appeared sharply split on most aspects of Bush's performance, robust economic growth, a rising stock market, strong support for Bush among Republicans (with no challenge for the nomination) and sharp divisions among the president's Democratic opponents fueled optimism among Bush's advisers about his reelection prospects.

Treatment of President George W. Bush

1168 words - 5 pages George Bush, Jr.George Bush is seen in a more negative light then a positive one. This is due to the constant stream of lies that the media catches him in. Bush's lies about Iraq are only "16 words" -- the administration lied, deceived or committed outright fraud about every single point they used to justify invading Iraq (except to say that Saddam was an evil man). The "16 words" reveal just how shameless their lies are. Short lies don't matter

George Bush: The World's First President

1094 words - 5 pages is a perfect example of how social and directly democratic institutions behave. Hence, instead of “calling the shots,” he united with the American people and other nations of the world such as the United Kingdom, Australia, and Poland to devise a tactic and plan for invasion. President Bush's actions after September eleventh reminded the nation, as well as the world, of the United States resilience, drive, determination, and power. In the center

Make America Great Again: Trump’s Immigration Policy - st johns university - Research Paper

1845 words - 8 pages protect American workers. What trump is offering is an anti-immigrants argument. Immigration is good for the American economy, and for American workers. However, our issue lies in poor education, or occupational licensing. Both of these factors have nothing to do with immigration, but contribute to the nations low labor participation rate. As we know, or should know, the only great wall is in China. If trump is elected president that will no

1988 Presidential election

1198 words - 5 pages , a man not even running for President received an electoral vote; Lloyd Bentsen (Democratic Vice President Nominee) received one electoral vote from the state of West Virginia. Bush's victory was also a victory for the Republican Party, but the Democrats received a similar victory in that they retained control of both the House and the Senate. The presidential election as a whole was a negative race, with an abundance of personal attacks (mainly

Government Under President Bush's Management

1472 words - 6 pages attacks of September 11th Bush's initial reaction was to call this war a crusade with the motto "God Wills It" (Wills, pg. 4).Wills uses examples from past presidents that have used religious representation in their speeches, but not quite like the examples or with the frequency Bush uses them.Bush is shown as a president that believes the United States is God's catalyst for spreading freedom and democracy. And to question that belief is to be an

Similar Essays

Immigration And Emigration Essay

1576 words - 6 pages deported nearly 350,000 immigrants in fiscal year 2008” (p. 2 para 3). Former President Bush may have had great intentions however he did not have a clear and concise plan of action to combat our immigration crisis. President Barack Obama is clearly making changes into the right direction, although he criticized Bush's harsh policies on illegal immigrants, he is relying on programs initiated by his predecessor. “Including expanding a program to verify

Treatment Of President George Bush Jr

1011 words - 4 pages increases in debt".(Lindlaw)President Bush's lies about Iraq can be said in "16 words" -- the administration lied, deceived or committed outright fraud about every single point they used to justify invading Iraq (except to say that Saddam was an evil man). The "16 words" reveal just how shameless the lies are. Short lies don't matter? Well, Clinton got impeached for just 8 words -- "I did not have sex with that woman." Even by that ridiculous

Employment For Illegal Immigrants Essay

1731 words - 7 pages economy and it holds many benefits to the immigrant. A common misconception regarding illegal immigration in the United States is that too many people are being allowed into the country which can jeopardize national security. The truth, however, is that President Bush's proposal actually helps maintain the security of American boarders. Also, in addition to the proposal, vast efforts are being made to secure U.S. boarders from terrorists

Bush's Tax Plan Essay

779 words - 3 pages Bush's Tax Plan Our new President, George W. Bush, has unveiled a new and radical tax plan that has thus far stumped analysts as to its benefits and flaws. No one is quite sure as to how the new plan will affect the different classes of today's economy or weather or not all of it will be passed as law. Thus far neither the Treasury nor Congress has put together distributional tables that clarify the tax plan. According to David E. Rosenbaum of