Presidential Greatness Essay

1869 words - 7 pages

Ranking presidential greatness is a process, which is largely based upon opinion and personal judgment. With any ranking system, whether based on subjective or objective criteria, judgment and opinion is required to determine which factors best serve as indicators or measurements of greatness. While opinion serves as a major part of the decision-making process, a factual framework is also intrinsic to the process of ranking presidential greatness. This framework serves as the basis on which comparisons are made and can include factors such as those related to historical events, presidential accomplishments, presidential performance, personal characteristics, etc. The central focus of the paper is to discuss presidential greatness. I will begin by examining the American public's general conception of presidential greatness and their apparent views regarding the subject. In the second half of the discussion, I will examine how scholars have attempted attempt to define greatness and rank presidents; I will also include my analysis and criticism their arguments. The subsequent focus of this paper is to present my own definition of presidential greatness and the categorization and ranking processes that I have devised. I will conclude by presenting the president who according to my definition qualifies as the greatest president.
Poll data seems to suggest that in general public's evaluation presidential greatness is shortsighted. When asked to identify whom they considered the greatest president, over 53% voted for a president whose term in office occurred after the latter half of the 20th century. Of the 17 presidents who received votes, 11 had served after 1950 and only four served prior to 1900. At the top of the list was Ronald Reagan, who received 19% of the votes, Abraham Lincoln with 14%, Bill Clinton with 13%, John Kennedy with 11%, and George Washington with 10%. In addition, included in the list was our most recent presidents Barack Obama and George H.W. Bush who received 5% and 1% respectively. In the past 12 years, Gallup has conducted the same poll eight times, and each time the top ranking president has been one of three candidates: Reagan, Kennedy, or Lincoln. The poll also reveals that party affiliation affects the public's opinion regarding presidential greatness. According to Republicans that participated in the poll the top five greatest presidents are Reagan (38%), Washington (14%), Lincoln (13%), Kennedy (7%), and George W. Bush (5%). Clinton leads among Democrats with 22% of the vote followed by Kennedy (18%), Obama (11%), Franklin Roosevelt (10%), and Lincoln (10%).
Michael Genovese examines presidential greatness within the context of presidential usage of power. He points to Franklin Roosevelt as a president whose term lead to the invention of the "modern presidency" and which brought about "a new standard of greatness" that increased the public's expectations for successive presidents (Genovese, Memo 45). Genovese...

Find Another Essay On Presidential Greatness

P-Noy’s Political Peculiarity Essay

843 words - 4 pages As a person who is prominent in various forms of media, Benigno Simeon Cojuanco Aquino III has been popularly called in different names. During the times when he was a representative of the second district of Tarlac, a senator, and a presidential candidate, he is simply known as “Noynoy” or “Noy.” However, on the day of his inauguration as the 15th President of the Republic of the Philippines at the Quirino Grandstand in Manila last 30 June

The Ups and Downs of Richard Nixon´s Life

863 words - 4 pages Whether he ran a failed Orange-Juice business, or lost his high school election for student body president (history.com), Richard Nixon was a good leader, man, husband, and father. Because of the watergate scandal, his reputation was lost, but Richard had the greatness to be the man he is known for. Some of Richard’s achievements “Never let your head hang down. Never give up and sit down and grieve. Find another way. And don't pray when it

This essay is written on the future of history, basically explaining what I think my children will be learning in their history classes

732 words - 3 pages "Few will have the greatness to bend history itself; but each of us can work to change a small portion of events, and in the total, of all those acts will be written the history of this generation." --Robert F. Kennedy What do you believe your children will study regarding the future of the United States as a result of today's decisions and events? a.What mistakes will they believe your generation has made? What impact will they have on the

trumans excellent adventure review

998 words - 4 pages recounts ex-president Harry Truman’s amazing adventure and his enchanting, post-presidential life. Overall, Algeo really zooms in on the extraordinary travels of Truman and his wife, while at the same time helping the reader understand the rapid changes of the mid-20th century in America. Further, the book is able to give the reader an equal blend of history and a slight biography on Harry Truman, the last citizen president. In fact, “Harry Truman was

The Kennedy Administration Fiscal Policy

1416 words - 6 pages aggregate demand. Fiscal expansion raises the demand for products—increases in demands leads to more output without changing process. An investment tax cut, meaning businesses can reduce their income taxes by 10% of their investment in a year, was introduced by JFK. (JFK Presidential Library and Museum, Address to the Economic Club of New York, December 14, 1962; U.S. News, The Myth of JFK as a Supply-Side Tax Cutter, January 26, 2011

Corrupted media in Egypt

1164 words - 5 pages they also give them what the his supporters need, which is making new songs to cheer him, supporting him in his campaign for the next presidential elections, and propagating the greatness of the military and its acts. Corrupted media is surly a big issue, just like what Adolf Hitler said in one his quotes about media and propaganda “It must confine itself to a few points and repeat them over and over. Here, as so often in this world

Herbert Hoover, John F. Kennedy, and Ronald Reagan

2630 words - 11 pages persuade, a professional reputation, and a public prestige. Herbert Hoover, John F. Kennedy, and Ronald Reagan are three presidents who were elected to power at three very different eras of American history. The following research paper will examine how each of these three men succeeded and failed at meeting Neustadt’s criteria of presidential greatness. In addition, this research paper will compare and contrast the successes and failures of

The American Change An analyse of Lyndon B. Johnson's Inaugural Address

2464 words - 10 pages The American ChangeAn analyse of Johnson's Inaugural Address1. Introduction:Lyndon B. Johnson was born on August 27, 1908, in Texas . In the 1960 presidential campaign, Johnson was elected Vice President, as John F. Kennedy's running mate. On November 22, 1963, when Kennedy was assassinated, Johnson was sworn in as President. Using skills of persuasion and calling on the legislators' respect for Kennedy, Johnson succeeded in gaining passage of

Book Report: Noonan, Peggy. "When Character Was King". New York: Penguin Books, 2001. (Following Guidelines assigned by teacher)

1071 words - 4 pages a professor of journalism at New York University. In 1984, Noonan was recruited to the become special assistant to President Ronald Reagan. It was there that Noonan became acquainted with Reagan along with many of the people she quoted throughout the biography. In 1988, Noonan was asked to be chief speech writer for George Bush (Sr.) during his presidential campaign. She left the White house after one year and in 1989, wrote her first

How Great is "The Great Emancipator"?

753 words - 4 pages Abraham Lincoln was born on February 12th, 1809 in a one-room log cabin in Hodgenville, Kentucky, but little did his parents Thomas and Nancy Lincoln know that their new born was going to grow up and change the entire course of United States history. Lincoln beat the 1861 presidential election by a land slide right when the Civil War began. Throughout his presidency, Lincoln moved the United States forward by defeating many of the county’s

Presidents Club by Nancy Gibbs and Michael Duffy

963 words - 4 pages , memoirs and presidential correspondences were used rather more than actual interviews. So the book started with Truman and how he went from being vice president for Roosevelt to forming the Presidents club with former President Hoover. Truman was able to get advice from Hoover for both counsels and political for building better relations abroad. To build better relations abroad Truman needed an ambassador, so he picked Hoover. Hoover was

Similar Essays

Greatness Of Lyndon B. Johnson Essay

1162 words - 5 pages . Johnson was one of the Presidents who stood out by taking the extra step. LBJ showed presidential greatness through passing groundbreaking legislation and improving society. To get a feel for how Lyndon Johnson came to achieve greatness, let us look at how his journey began. In 1908, Lyndon was born on a farm near Stonewall, Texas to his loving parents Samuel and Rebekah. His father was a man who had a love for politics and instilled it into his

Abraham Lincoln, The Only Honest Politician?

1358 words - 5 pages eloquence. Yet he remained a politician sly enough to finagle into the presidency, a job with no room for greatness. Thus a contradiction arose: either politicians could achieve greatness, or Lincoln, too, fell short of it. My solution called for the latter. Douglas Donald's Lincoln altered my solution and convinced me of the greatness of the sixteenth president and, potentially, of his profession. Despite his professional interests, Lincoln's

Dissecting The Animal Of Politics Essay

1829 words - 8 pages presidential candidates in the novel. Barack Obama, the forty-fourth President of the United States, was born on August 4, 1962, in Honolulu, Hawaii, to a Kansas-born, white mother, and a Kenyan father (“Barack” 1). Being of mixed racial background, Barack was already an odd one out among his peers. Even then, no one could have known his destiny for greatness. Obama began his career in politics in the Illinois State Senate, working his way up to

Presidential Ranking Factors Involved In Rating Presidential Approval

2527 words - 10 pages greatest contributor to presidential studies, at least on thespecifics of success analysis, James Barber, puts forward a binary matrixinvolving two baselines. The first, activity-passivity, places the presidentsaccording to the amount of energy invested in day-to-day activities. For examplethe notoriously hard-working Lyndon Johnson, who slept as little as possible inorder to have more time to work, features far higher on this scale than thelethargic