Presumed Innocent Essay

1432 words - 6 pages

Presumed Innocent By:Scott Turow Presumed Innocent Scott Turow writes an engrossing book based on love, obsession, and the legal system. In the beginning the protagonist character, Rusty Sabich, a District Prosecuting Attorney (P.A.) begins the story in first person speaking about what is expected of him as a P.A. His voice gives reason that he is unhappy and lacks faith in the legal system. Rusty has been accused of a horrible crime, rape and murder. Turow's story depicts a typical situation of a person being set up. The ending will ravish your outlook on love and infidelity. Rusty speaks of his sorrow for a peer who has been raped and murdered. Her name is Carolyn Polhemus. She was a Deputy Prosecuting Attorney for Kindle County. She was known to excel in her job of prosecuting rapist and her reputation became that of a slut. Raymond Horgan, the acting P.A. and Rusty Sabichs' boss asks him personally to investigate her murder. Rusty and his co-worker, Lipranzer "Lip", talk over the case and decide that it would be best to start with the men that Carolyn had put behind bars. This inquiry led them to a missing file, dubbed the "B" file, meaning bribery. The "B" file becomes a crucial twist to the plot. Rusty is seeing a psychiatrist. The first session that Turow reveals is that of Rusty talking of his affair with Carolyn Palhemus. He goes back in time as he discusses his compulsive, obsession for her. They began their affair after they won the case of a young boy who was brutally abused by his own mother. The book gives explicit, erotic details of their sexual encounters together. Carolyn ends the affair with Rusty because she can not talk him into pushing Raymond to the side and running for office himself. This change in professional status for Rusty would in turn give Carolyn the chance to move up in the ranks. Rusty does not deal with the break up and continues to persue Carolyn at the office and via telephone. He did not want the affair to end, nor would he have left his wife for her. Rusty confessed to his wife, Barbara that he was having an affair with Carolyn Polyhemus, but that it had ended. The fingerprint report is back and the prints belong to Rusty. There several phone calls from Rusty's home to Carolyn's home. Lip also told him that the pathology results lead to type A blood and type A semen and that the person was sterile. Rusty made the comment that he is type A and Lip said that he thought about that; however, Rusty has a son. The evidence against Rusty is taking a huge toll on the election of Rusty's boss, Raymond Horgan. Raymond Horgan, a knoble man, looses the election to a man who used to work him, Nicco Della Guardia, an unfare, dirty player. Rusty's house is searched and tests are performed on carpet and coat fibers. Rusty's wife is surprisingly very strong and supportive for Rusty. Shortly after the results come in Rusty is arrested for the rape and murder of Carolyn Polhemus. He hires the best and most expensive Defense...


The Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the Rights of Man and the Citizen compared to The U.S. Constitution and the Declaration of Independence

794 words - 3 pages escape religious persecution, but it had existed long before that. This "freedom of religion" allows our country to generally be a safe haven against religious persecution. Another striking similarity is in Article 11 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, "Everyone charged with a penal offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty..." This same idea is implied in Amendments 4-8 of the Constitution: Article XI especially

Revolt of Mother, by Mary E. Wilkins

1098 words - 4 pages stand to change that. Essentially both stories portray the discontent of presumed gender identities, and both women overcome their adversity to rediscover their own identities as well as to change the classic stereotypes regarding gender roles. In “Revolt of Mother,” the story immediately illustrates in the opening sentences how little power Sarah has in making decisions. When Sarah comes outside to question Adonriam about the barn and his

Interrogations Versus INterview

790 words - 4 pages discoveries of the experiment showed that the interrogators with the innocent suspects were exerting more pressure for a confession then those who were guilty. Also, those innocent were found guilty more often than those who had committed the crime. This information is parallel with other data discovered during actual interrogations. Officers often presumed guilt before having enough evidence to prove it and when the interrogation is not going their way, they tend to try to coerce a confession.

wrongful conviction

2186 words - 9 pages In criminal law the principle, presumed innocent until proven guilty is sometimes twisted and altered to presumed guilty until proven innocent in many wrongful conviction cases. Many factors go into the deliberation and reasoning behind an investigators, juries and courts verdict and occasionally their decision is actually wrong and an innocent person is locked up behind bars, to serve a sentence that they do not deserve because they are not a

Terrorist Attacks

550 words - 2 pages terrorists are the culprits behind these heinous actions. Thousands of people are already dead, while others are still unaccounted for, which are presumed dead. The attack surpasses the devastation caused at Pearl Harbor. America is in a state of recovery with many decisions still yet to be made on how to deal with destruction and culprits behind these hatred actions.The United States is undoubtedly the strongest country in the world. Terrorists

Wrongful Conviction: An Injustice Within the Justice System

1644 words - 7 pages suspension of individual fundamental rights and freedom. Before a conviction is made, an individual is presumed innocent until proven guilty. A study done by Garrett, entitled The Substance of False Confessions, explains the substance of wrongful confession and why such a burden occurs. It uncovers the fact of what makes an individual confess and bring themselves into an awful burden. The methodology of the article explains that individuals will

Oedipus Rex Essay

593 words - 2 pages stated, “I shall never be found guilty of the blood,” (126). Oedipus was certain of his innocence at the time, but little did he know that this presumed innocence was based on a rumor told that Laius’ killer was more than one person. Though it seemed solid, Oedipus’ certainty that he was innocent was in fact not certain at all, as it was based on false knowledge, demonstrating how one’s certainty can never be truly certain until the truth and all

Snow Falling on Cedars by David Guterson

1530 words - 6 pages Washington state in the post-world-war-two era. The victim of western United States injustice was nearly anyone with Japanese ancestry. The novel’s story revolves around Kabuo Miyamoto, a Japanese-American man on trial for the death of a white man, Carl Heine. Historic evidence proves that a fair trial would be exceedingly difficult to create: Kabuo was presumed guilty solely on the fact that he was of the Japanese populace. In

Need for Control in Fitzgerald's Tender is the Night Essays

1011 words - 4 pages : 'Afraid I have presumed'(142). He is her connection outside of the clinic and she desperately needs that relationship and his approval. Nicole is repeatedly described through her smile as young and innocent, "She smiled, a moving childish smile that was like the lost youth of the world," and "whenever he turned to her she was smiling a little, her face lighting up like an angel's..."(153). The love she feels for Dick is a very young, worshipful love

"The crucible, by Miller" - 900 wd essay of who initiated the tragedy in Salem?

891 words - 4 pages Mary Warren, hoping profusely to save her own name.Denial in Salem is considered a terrible sin. The narrow mindedness of the court possesses an unwritten law that if your name is brought out within the court, without any questioning, you are presumed guily. Innocence is not taken into consideration, and only until the victim confesses,, is the court convinced they were right. There is no hearing for the victim, and if they are innocent, they have

Virginia DUI Laws and Consequences

886 words - 4 pages accidents. The National Safety Council also set up a study to develop tests that could be used to determine intoxication. The groups found that a driver with a BAC (blood alcohol concentration) of 0.15 percent or higher could be presumed to be inebriated, while a driver with a blood alcohol concentration under 0.15 could not. Groups like, Mothers Against Drunk Driving (MADD) and Students Against Drunk Driving (SADD) during the 1970’s helped to

Similar Essays

A Term Paper On The Comparasson Between Innocent Until Proven Guilty Vs. Guilty Until Proven Innocent, And The Role Of The Prosecutor In The American Judicaial System

1887 words - 8 pages "Everyone charged with a penal offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proved guilty according to law in a public trial at which he has had all the guarantees necessary for his defense. No one shall be held guilty of any penal offense on account of any act or omission which did not constitute a penal offense, under national or international law, at the time it was committed. Nor shall a heavier penalty be imposed than the one that

Oedipus The King By Sophocles Essay

623 words - 2 pages knowledge, his rash actions and judgment, and his unwavering sense for justice. In Knox’s statement, he refers to Oedipus’ “inadequacy of human knowledge [and] certainty” as a cause of his downfall. Oedipus believed he possessed certainty of knowledge; however, his knowledge was based on false assumptions. During the search for Laius’ killer, his certainty led him to believe that he was innocent of the crime. As Teiresius proclaimed, “Alas, how

Civil Liberties After 911 Essay

1262 words - 5 pages terrorist hate crime and propaganda, and labels its use as an outright crime. Freedom of speech allows terrorism to prosper, even in nations where it is condemned. However, the limitation of our freedom of speech impairs our democracy, as it revokes our freedom to criticize the government.To defeat terrorism, governments must also expel the right to be presumed innocent, until proven guilty. Although vital to a democracy, this law aids terrorists

Differences Between Packer's Crime Control And Due Process

546 words - 3 pages suspect more opportunities to prove they are innocent and show that evidence against them is false. The defendant can ask for a trial with due process, and if the defendant does not like the results of the trial, the defendant can appeal the decision. Unlike Packer's crime control where defendants are guilty, due process are presumed innocent until proven guilty.Packer's crime control puts much faith into the police. Packer's crime control did not