Primate Virtues: A Cross Species Study Of Morality

4605 words - 18 pages

Primate Virtues: A Cross-species Study of Morality

In his 1881 book, Daybreak, Friedrich Nietzsche wrote,

We do not regard the animals as moral beings. But do you suppose the animals regard us as moral beings? –An animal which could speak said, ‘Humanity is a prejudice of which we animals at least are free’.[1]

This passage expresses Nietzsche’s belief that animals do not judge human actions as morally good or bad. Only humans think in moral terms, Nietzsche believes –a prejudice of which “animals at least are free”. That is, animals do not believe in morality; and modern philosophers, as well as behavioral biologists, would have to agree. Nobody suspects their dog of trying to maximize utility, follow categorical imperatives, or do penance for his sins. Moral agency is uniquely human in this respect; only we maintain that our actions have some greater—moral—significance.

Ethical theories try to provide us with a coherent and rational account of precisely this moral aspect of human thought and action. But no matter how coherent and rational a given moral system may be, if it becomes too detached from our regular deliberations and actions, we do not consider it a correct account of our normal moral reasoning. But what exactly constitutes this “normal moral reasoning” that humans allegedly possess?

In this paper, I argue that human “moral reasoning” is actually a normal biological phenomenon that we share with the rest of the animal community, most noticeably with our closest primate relatives. I demonstrate this by using the standards provided by a normative moral theory to evaluate the actions of one of our animal relatives –Pan Troglodytes, or the African chimpanzee, illustrating the fact that these animals behave like moral agents. After showing that human moral reasoning and behavior, as we know it, are actually part of the animal kingdom’s normal behavioral repertoire, the second part of this paper examines the implications of this finding on both the moralist’s and the moral skeptic’s conception of morality

Several moral systems try to provide us with an account of human moral reasoning and behavior—systems such as utilitarianism, virtue ethics, and deontological ethics. In trying to make explicit those actions that we deem morally significant, it is best to use the theory that attempts to stay true to our normal behavior—that is, a normative theory that is descriptively strong. Such a theory will provide us with the most rigorous standards for accounting for behavior that we already recognize as moral. This is important for this analysis because we are not trying to find out when animals act morally or immorally (i.e. how often they deviate from one moral standard or another), we are trying to see how their normal behavior compares with what we identify as normal moral behavior in humans. One moral system that is both normative and descriptively strong is virtue ethics. In fact, virtue ethicists pride...

Find Another Essay On Primate Virtues: A Cross-species Study of Morality

Virtues Of A Perfect Bride Essay

909 words - 4 pages Virtues of a Perfect Bride by Chris Mount English 101 Dr. Mary Ann Kohli October 12, 2001 Chris Mount Dr. Mary Ann Kohli Eng 101 October 11, 2001 Virtues of a Perfect Bride In Dandin's "The Perfect Bride," Saktikumara is searching for patience, creativity and a good sense of other virtues in a wife along with her beauty. The definition of virtue is as follows: moral excellence and righteousness; goodness and an example or kind of moral

A Comparison of Primate and Dolphin Intelligence

2321 words - 9 pages has demonstrated a correlation between the size of a home range and the EQ of the species, which would appear to support the gather hypothesis' prediction about furgivores and foliovores. But a more recent study found no relationship between the percentage of fruit in the diet and the EQ of the species. This study did not take into consideration the importance of fruit in the animals diet, so it still possible that the predicted difference may

Stem Cell Research – Developing a Cross between Species

606 words - 2 pages Ethics of Stem Cell Research – Developing a Cross between Species The idea of a chimera, a cross between species, has been around since the mythological creatures of ancient Greece, such as the centaur (a man’s torso with a horses body) and the griffin (the wings, head, and claws of an eagle and the body of a lion). Today, due to our advances in biotechnology, we are seeing this mythology become a reality, but in a different respect. Human

Destruction of a Species

1252 words - 6 pages inflicted upon those who believe their life or custom is superior to those who differentiate and so a division is conceived and a definition desired. The need to be defined has ingrained itself into society’s core throughout generations and it is through these separations that the dominance of religion, social biases, and race have usurped our morality. Although each of these factors have influenced the formation of genocide the most dominant facet is

A comparative study on varied potentials of Aspergillus species in synthesis of silver nanoparticles

702 words - 3 pages Conclusions To conclude, though use of Aspergillus species is common in synthesis of metal nanoparticles, these five species are not well studied. Among them, A. fischeri confirms a good quality production of AgNPs at an incredibly low concentration of salt solution used but with more number of bigger sized particles. However, efforts are underway to optimize the conditions in the process to obtain a good size and shape morphology. Also

A study on interspecific competition: How interaction between two competing populations of species affects their persistence

839 words - 4 pages species with similar requirements occur, since there is a clash in the resources they use (Connell 1961, Tilman 1987). Other factors that influence the distribution of species and interspecific competition are weather, predation, intraspecific competition, disturbances and the characteristics of the competing species themselves (Connell 1983). The aim of this study was to see how the characteristics of competing species affect the outcomes of

Managing human resources in a cross cultural context: A case study of South Africa

4461 words - 18 pages the political background and the socio-legal environment of the country. Though the implementation of 'western' human resources practises and policies in South Africa is possible, there should be a lot more emphasis on the managing of the socio-cultural and political issues. This is built on the divergence - convergence paradigm. Modern cross-cultural management is however built on the concept of crossvergence of cultures. This leads to a hybrid

Vices and Virtues: Ethical Dilemmas of a Fading Man

2387 words - 10 pages Tyler Rutland Dr. Belzer History 2000 April 10, 2014 Vices & Virtues: Ethical Dilemmas of a Fading Man When Sidney Stewart was freed in Manchuria in 1945 after 3 years of imprisonment by the Japanese, the 6’3 American weighed 65 pounds (Goldstein). Stewart was an Army private stationed in Manila in 1942 when they were overpowered by the Japanese. The 21 year-old wasn’t the killing type of soldier. Of course he killed when required, but he

Case Study Analysis of the Red Cross

3293 words - 13 pages :// Board of Governors. American red cross governance for the 21st century. Retrieved from Greenspan, J. (2013, October 29). History. Retrieved from 7 Red Cross Facts: Janis, Irving L. (1972) Victims of groupthink: A psychological study of foreign-policy

A Critique of Confucian Morality

1857 words - 8 pages Isabelle Schymyck Mr. Hobson HZT-4U1 4th May 2014 A Critique of Confucian Morality For many centuries, Confucianism has been widely revered by the Chinese for its emphasis on morality. Confucius, who lived from 551 to 479 BCE, is different to most philosophers in that he showed no interest questioning his existence, the possibility of a God, or the reality that he seemed to live in; instead he focused on the human relations side of

Determinants of Polygyny: A Cross-Cultural Analysis

2106 words - 8 pages Polygyny is a topic that existed in a great amoung of societies that are being investigated by anthropologist. In the Standard Cross-Cultural Sample (SCCS), 83.8% of societies are socially polygynous; 28% are coded as more than 40% of marriages being polygynous. However, the proportion of polygynous marriage could be small, especially in hunter-gatherer or foraging societies where people gather resources or wealth through collecting and

Similar Essays

Primate Behavior A Study Of Orangutans And Mandrills

2022 words - 9 pages During my research of Orangutans and Mandrills I observed them in captivity at the San Diego Zoo. My observations included a 20 minute observation of each primate as it cohabitated with other Primates and with other members of its own species. My findings will support the research of Orangutans and Mandrills through firsthand observations. My observation of the orangutan habitat was on a sunny and hot day with the average temperature being

Primate Behavior A Study Of Orangutans And Mandrills

1060 words - 5 pages Primates are one of the most diverse creatures on earth, they include many species and range various areas of the world. In the American continent we can find Platyrrhines which are of one of the two Infraorder,(the other being Catarrhines) they are distinguished as having a wide nose septum and some have a prehensile tail (Larsen 144) which allows them to suspend from it and use their other limbs for other things. In Africa and Asia we find

From Persistence To Cross Species Emergence Of A Viral Zoonosis

922 words - 4 pages viruses, including severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS), Nipah, Hendra, and Ebola viruses, which often emerge in the context of anthropogenic change with devastating outcomes for humans and animals. From an ecological and evolutionary perspective, the high species diversity of bats also presents a unique and fascinating system to test hypotheses on cross-species emergence in complex host communities.Despite recurrent cross-species transmission

A Study Of Cross Cultural Pragmatic Failure

2122 words - 8 pages alter the communication event. The labels race, ethnic groups, and co-cultural communication are three forms of cross-cultural communication. The learners of foreign languages have to study cross-cultural communication becausea) We are living in a changing world. Changes in technology, travel, economic and politics, immigration patterns are so great that we have to increasingly communicate with people from different cultures. The cross-cultural