This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Prison And The Alternatives: Is Incarceration The Answer To Crime?

2143 words - 9 pages

Prison and the Alternatives: Is Incarceration the Answer to Crime?How well do our prisons reform prisoners? What are the alternatives to prison? What is the best, most cost-effective way of protecting the public? These are some of the questions raised by individuals who are legitimately concerned not only with where their tax dollars are going, but also with what is being done to break the cycle of crime within their representative communities. When prisons were first introduced to our society in 1790, the idea of rehabilitation as an alternative to corporal or spiritual punishment was adopted and the belief that if inmates were forced to examine their conduct in confinement, repentance and religious conversion could occur. David Cayley, a reporter for the CBS show Ideas, summarizes the reasons we jail people today:In theory, we send people to prison for two reasons: first, to teach them to behave peaceably in society; secondly, to keep criminals out of sight and mind. The justice system has moved closer to the second purpose. A difficulty with sending most of those that commit offenses to prison is that it intensifies problems over the long-term because prison "dehabilitates" inmates (qtd. in Lawrence 8).As a society, we expect these bleak, brutal facilities to correct our criminals. In fact, prisons are more likely of doing the opposite. In the words of the United Kingdom's Home Secretary, Douglas Hurd, "Prisons are an expensive way of making bad people worse" (qtd. in Anderson 5). Late 1997 statistics show rates of recidivism of 60% or more for released prisoners (Lawrence10). This statistic clearly proves that incarcerating offenders is an ineffective method of solving today's crime problems. David Cayley comments, "Rates of recidivism everywhere testify to the fact that those who go to prison will often go more than once" (qtd. in Lawrence 10).From 1850 to 1973, the incarceration rate in the United States remained stable at approximately 100 inmates per 100,000 population. Since 1973, the United States' incarceration rate has skyrocketed to 645 inmates per 100,000 population, representing the second highest incarceration rate of any industrialized nation, falling just behind Russia (Lawrence 4). According to the Bureau of Justice Statistics, since 1992, prison population in the United States has grown at an average annual rate of 9 percent. By mid-year 1997, the United States prison and jail population reached 1,725,842 people, more than triple the number of inmates housed in 1980. At the current pace of incarceration, the national inmate population will surpass the two million mark by the year 2000 (Corrections Compendium 22).For the last few years, research conducted by the Department of Justice and the United States Sentencing Commission has shown that over 20% of the inmates in federal prison are low-level offenders who pose no threat to society. Incarcerating these low-level offenders is extremely costly, and it wastes prison space. An...

Find Another Essay On Prison and the Alternatives: Is Incarceration the Answer to Crime?

Alternatives to Prison Essay

1665 words - 7 pages State governments have been searching for successful alternatives to prison because of the severity of overcrowding and costs. The effectiveness of the available alternatives is competitive to incarceration. Many violent and repeat offenders are released early from prison due to the overcrowding problems.(Smolowe 56) It seems more sensible to keep the violent offenders in prison than those criminals convicted for property damage, drugs, and other

Incarceration: History, Purpose, and Relationship to Crime

2778 words - 12 pages operate on the assumption that a certain level of crime is healthy for society and that to eliminate all crime would be detrimental, we cannot then assume that the purpose of the US penitentiary system is to eliminate crime altogether. But does the US system of incarceration effect crime rates? There is little doubt that it does, but it is arguable that whatever effect that it has is incidental to its various other purposes. Theorists have proposed a

Alternatives to Incarceration.This paper is about options available for offenders that do not require jail or prison terms.Raises the question of cost effectiveness

868 words - 3 pages Ever since the first prison opened in the United States in 1790, incarceration has been the center of the nations criminal justice system. Over this 200 year period many creative alternatives to incarceration have been tried, and many at a much lower cost than imprisonment. It wasn't until the late 1980's when our criminal justice systems across the country began experiencing a problem with overcrowding of facilities. This problem forced

The Answer Is No

1150 words - 5 pages The Answer Is No From centuries to centuries the role of women has been predominantly subordinate to the role of men. Men have been known to be superior in both physical and mental levels. They are also most likely to have an "upper hand" in situations based on their gender. An example of such situation is taken place in "The Answer Is No", written by Naguib Mahfouz. This story has a considerable amount of sexual politics. On

Crime and Punishment: Do you agree with the moral "crime does not pay"? Refer to at least two texts in your answer

618 words - 2 pages did a big robbery, made loads of money and spent the rest of your days in Spain. In the 1980s, armed robbery started to get dangerous so you did one or two, went to Spain and invested the money in drugs. Nowadays, thanks to improved security measures, the average armed robbery nets only a few hundred pounds and newcomers to crime have no choice but to start right at the bottom and work their way up.As is often the case in big business, a career

Crime and Punishment: Do you agree with the moral "crime does not pay"? Refer to at least two texts in your answer

1929 words - 8 pages The saying that “crime does not pay” lies at the heart of a great deal of literature and many films. It appears in a large number of fairy tales and children’s story. This is to teach children from an early age that it is wrong to commit a crime, no matter how small, and that every criminal is eventually punished. Of course this is not true, many crimes, especially smaller crimes, are never punished. This can either be because no

The United Nations Is the Answer To The Worlds Problems

626 words - 3 pages The United Nations Is the Answer To The Worlds Problems The issue of whether or not the United Nations should be disbanded is a complex two-sided answer. Some may say that no the United Nations should remain in society because of all the good the organization has done for the world such as UNICEF. Others may argue that the United Nations have done more harm than good, like the fact that your voting rights in the International Monetary Fund

The Answer To Foreclosure

1041 words - 4 pages to fix through various approaches. The ugly problem still remains despite many efforts. Everyone wants answers, congress, people who’ve been forced out of their homes, people who’ve had to see people forced out of their home, and the rest of America. So what is the answer? The answer to foreclosure and many problems that are developing also in the credit unions can be answered two ways. One in which is quite simply, give money back

Gun Control is Not the Answer to High Murder Rates

1740 words - 7 pages on this it is Boozman’s opinion that assault rifle bans, and particularly the ones proposed after the Sandy Hook shooting, would have no effect on crime. Even a more general gun ban though does not appear to be a solution, based on evidence from several of the bans that have already taken place. The two largest shootings in American history, one at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University and the other at Sandy Hook Elementary

Home Confinement is the Solution to Prison Overcrowding

1406 words - 6 pages a safer society. This strategy would sharply reduce the nation's need for prison bed space. Supporters of rehabilitation believe it "represents a real 'get tough' approach to crime, stressing public protection, offender accountability and restitution to the community and to victims of crime" (Tipp 123).   Another approach to the continual controversy of prison overcrowding is a new method developed for offenders: home confinement

Is Gun control the answer?

2016 words - 9 pages not rational and therefore is not the answer for the gun control debate in our nation. What exactly is gun control? This question is where much of the misconception begins. Many people would reply to this question simply by saying taking away guns. They are correct but this is just a small part of what gun control actually is. The authors of the article, "Does Gun Control Reduce Crime or Does Crime Increase Gun Control?” give a good definition

Similar Essays

Incarceration In An Adult Prison Increases Juvenile Crime

2259 words - 9 pages because teen brains are not mature and lack understanding towards the situation, incarceration in an adult facility increases juvenile crime, and children that are sentenced to adult prison are vulnerable to abuse and rape. Society has lost touch with our children, and instead of fixing our children we ignore them. No longer are children slapped on the wrist for criminal behavior. The nation's youth is sent to prison confined in cells for hours

Nonviolent Criminals Is Incarceration The Answer?

1484 words - 6 pages Neil CondonCRJS 600Dr. RichesonNonviolent Offenders - Is Incarceration the Answer?"It's really clear that the most effective way to turn a nonviolent person into a violent one is to send them to prison," says Harvard University criminologist James Gilligan. The American prison system takes nonviolent offenders and makes them live side-by-side with hardened killers. The very nature of prison, no matter people view it, produces an environment that

Alternatives To Incarceration Essay

901 words - 4 pages Alternatives to Incarceration Ever since the first prison opened in the United States in 1790, incarceration has been the center of the nations criminal justice system. Over this 200 year period many creative alternatives to incarceration have been tried, and many at a much lower cost than imprisonment. It wasn’t until the late 1980’s when our criminal justice systems across the country began experiencing a problem with overcrowding of

Alternatives To Incarceration Essay

2722 words - 11 pages female friends. The findings of this study are based on the analysis of the themes that came up during the interviews with each of the 12 individuals. After reviewing these 10 different studies, the facts support the idea that alternatives to incarceration actually work. Not only do these alternative programs reduce the prison population, they also decrease costs to tax payers, and help assist individuals in changing their life course