This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Privacy Vs Security Essay

875 words - 4 pages

What's more important, privacy or security? There's an ongoing debate going on between two different groups of people, surveillance supporters and privacy advocates, over privacy. In Bruce Schneier's article, " The External Value Of Privacy", he talks about how privacy is better but in Chris Cillizza's article, " In The Battle Between Security And Privacy, Privacy Always Wins" he talks how security is more important. While Cillizza's article is more specific, it is weaker because he uses a lot of emotional appeals.
One of the greatest strengths of Schneier's article is a based on logic. In paragraph 4, he states, "privacy is important because without it, surveillance information will be abused: to peep, to sell to marketers and to spy on political enemies. " What makes this such a strong piece of evidence is that everybody has secrets to hide. This is important because everybody has a secret to hide and without privacy your secrets and personal information could go to the wrong hands. Another piece of evidence that showcases the strengths of Schneier's writing is in paragraph 7 where he comments, "a Constitution that it never occurred to them to call out privacy as an explicit right. This makes Schneier's the clear winner between these two articles because he uses logical reasoning to the readers that privacy is a basic inherited need in life and without it peoples' personal information could be abused. Opponents might point out that one of the weaknesses of his articles is based on emotions. For example, in paragraph 2, he writes, "privacy is an inherent human right, and a requirement for maintaining the human condition with dignity and respect." Here he attempts to express that privacy is a basic human need, that everyone inherits. This is not as strong as the as the other pieces of evidence because everybody was born with that right. Though this is not his strongest argument, his other pieces of evidence create such a solid foundation for his beliefs, that this one small imperfection falls into the background, scarcely diminishing the strength of his arguments. Cillizza's article, on the other hands, fails to live up to this standard.
Cillizza's articles relies heavily on quotes and emotional appeals to persuade his audience that security is more important than privacy. For example, in the 11th paragraph, he writes, "and because most Americans, while they value their privacy , tend to view themselves as people with little to hide. The general attribute is I'm not breaking any laws so why should I worry...

Find Another Essay On Privacy Vs Security

National Security vs. the Right to Privacy

3061 words - 12 pages sweat. Security is not something that can be compromised; however, it does not have to come at the expense of our privacy. It is possible to maintain our own identities, while guaranteeing the security of our nation. As Bruce Schneier argues in his commentary, Protecting privacy and liberty, security and privacy are not two sides of an equation. (773) In an article for an Internet security company, Schneier addresses the issue of security

Privacy Security Essay

1662 words - 7 pages one or, in some extreme cases, none of the two. However, there are some good examples of how government can, by having just enough power, and by creating a system which provides for checks and balances, give its citizens the freedoms they are entitled to, while making them feel secure at the same time. The paper will deal with two aspects of the privacy-vs-security issue. The first one is concerned with general civil liberties, where privacy is

Internet Privacy and Security

1113 words - 5 pages the same in many ways. Browser security is protection against personal information or data being stolen from oneself to commit fraud, browser security helps us determine secure sites online vs unsafe sites. They are also the same because they share the responsibility along with us, to know how to use the internet appropriately, and safe guard us from viruses, internet stockers, hackers, etc. Privacy and Security are both equally important, to

Security Versus Privacy

2327 words - 9 pages Security Versus Privacy As a result of 9/11, our country has been faced with a new issue: electronic privacy. The terrorists that attacked us used our own technology against us to protect their activities from our view. Because of this, we are now forced to make a decision between two desirable things: privacy and national security. On the one hand, our right to privacy will ensure that our personal rights are not violated, whereas, on the

Sacraficing Privacy for Security

1497 words - 6 pages Security versus privacy is becoming a major issue in today’s society. Recently, the National Security Agency has been the victim of scrutiny due to allegations of espionage. Similar claims not only stem from the authority, but also come from the public as well. For example, one is enjoying a night out in a restaurant when a group of teenagers arrives. Before it is noticed, some of the teenagers take photos with a cell phone. The picture

Security over Privacy

583 words - 3 pages and dealt with, again preventing many of the violent attacks on citizens. In a world where all these assumptions are fact, the sacrifice of our privacy for security would reap incredible benefits. However, history has proven multiple times that governments have not shown themselves to be benign; they are full of fallible humans, thus the constitution was written to help protect citizens from the abuses of government. The very act of violating our liberty to provide more security is a breach of security in and of itself.

Privacy V.S Security

819 words - 4 pages Privacy V.S. Security Many people can’t seem to agree on whether or not they should have more privacy or loses some privacy, and be more supervised. In both articles, each author is trying to inform the readers and state the possible consequences of having too much privacy or not enough supervision. In the article “The Eternal Value of Privacy” by Bruce Schneier and the article “In the battle between privacy and security, security always

Security or Privacy

760 words - 4 pages surveillance, protecting the citizens of the United States? Is it worth giving up privacy for security that may not protect anyone after all? Recently Edward Snowden a former National Security Agent (NSA) said that the reason he leaked government information was to warn the United State citizen of the danger they are facing from the government surveillance programs. According to Snowden, the NSA is gathering phone calls context and internet

E-commerce: Security and Privacy

2129 words - 9 pages E-commerce: Security and Privacy As the evolution of the internet and purchasing online becomes popular, so do the security factors that contribute to the ways of eliminating fraud, theft, and acquiring personal information. E-commerce has created many new ways for customers to make payments including e-cash, e-cheques, and e-wallets. In the 21st century, many organizations worked hard at securing communications and payments made through

Encryption: Privacy versus National Security

2531 words - 10 pages key values.[1]  Although triple DES is widely used, it has not been adopted as an official standard, and eventually computing power will be sufficient to crack it as well.  So, the search for a new standard of encryption is currently underway.  The government is looking for a standard that will allow it to provide national security, and researchers as well as the computing public want the highest-level possible of privacy and security

Privacy: Security, Confidentiality, or Convenience?

3398 words - 14 pages Privacy: Security, Confidentiality, or Convenience? INTRODUCTION The evolution of the Internet started from the department of defense's project, and rapidly distributed to world wide. With the rise of the Internet age comes with the benefits and the concerns. Because of the easeness to communicate information and displaying data, the first amendment needs to be applied to this communication channel. How are we using and

Similar Essays

Security Vs Privacy Essay

771 words - 4 pages evidence strengthen the article there is still not enough evidence to make the whole article much stronger. This quote also weakens his article as well. That is because in the quote Obama only talks about security and protecting the soldier and spies. It has nothing to do about security beating privacy in terms of privacy vs security. Another evidence that weakens this paragraph is “So, why do majorities of the country express support for the

Privacy Vs. Security Essay

2632 words - 11 pages Privacy vs. Security Introduction Pictures seen in homes across America and throughout the world of American symbols in flames and crashing a quarter mile to the ground changed the world forever. The world's last and only superpower had been attacked in a way only conceivable in a Hollywood script. However, the physical destruction that resulted was not necessarily the biggest loss that the United States faced. The emotional destruction

Indiviual Privacy Vs National Security Essay

1499 words - 6 pages day without knowing they are being watched. Yet, how can this be possible of allowing this type of surveillance in today’s society? Due to this hidden surveillance, many people find this as an act of violation of one’s privacy while others declare it is for the benefit of a nation’s security against rivalry countries. “The degree to which a government is repressive does not turn on the methods by which it acquires information about its citizens, or

National Security Vs. The Right To Privacy

790 words - 3 pages rethinking will concern law-how we will balance understandable demands for improved security with our right to privacy, our freedom to travel, our free speech, our policy of welcoming immigrants, and our commitment to a tolerant society. Once we learn how the terrorists learned to fly these Boeing planes, should we place new restrictions on pilot training? Access to flight simulators? First Amendment experts may rightly be concerned about such