Private Military Fighting For The Us

2173 words - 9 pages

When asked why private security contractors are important for the U.S. military a former specialist for the United States Army replied, “It’s the extra sense of security. Strength in numbers. The United States Government won’t deploy more troops overseas but they will hire these private companies to help us out” (Ruohenen).
Habib Moody, a student at Yale University, is the author of “Soldiers for Rent”. In this article written for The New Atlantis, Moody argues that the government should not be hiring companies to fight the war for our soldiers. At one point in the article he says by hiring private companies to fight, we are “degrading such a noble calling”. In other words, by having civilians working alongside the military we are degrading a soldier’s work. He generates claims and describes why he thinks there is a lack of oversight and regulation on contractors overseas. Because of this, the contractors are unpunishable and getting away with war crime. While I agree with Moody that there is an excess of government military contracts, having private companies overseas is highly beneficial to our government. Without these contracts, the amount of U.S. military personnel would need to be increased to more than double, leading to a higher government expense than what the contractors charge.
Private military companies or PMCs have been taking part in wars for the United States for a long time now. Deborah Kidwell is the Assistant Professor of Military History and has done a lot of research on PMCs. She says in her book “Public War, Private Fight? The United States and Private Military Companies” that PMCs were used as far back as the American Revolution.
During the revolution companies were hired for means like transportation, engineering, labor, and tech services. World War II is where privatization indubitably began to expand. This is where construction and repair and maintenance operations overseas were starting to get hired out. Also a surge of new technology being created by the private industry was taking place at this time and the government was buying (Kidwell). As shown in figure 1, the ratio of the amount of PMCs to the number of US soldiers increased from 1:20 in World War I to 1:7 in World War II. Operations Desert Storm and Desert Shield both heavily relied on saving money with PMCs because of the steep budget cliff at the time. The draft wasn’t quite enough and PMCs, although non-combatant, proved to be worthy for the US. Privatizing expanded quickly and there are now more private contractors overseas than military personnel (Moody).
Even after being around since the founding of our nation, there are still a couple problems that have come up with PMCs. Frequent critics claim it will be a long run problem for the reason that they are for profit, compared to the US military where their first priority is to protect and serve the nation. Plus relying on a countless number of private companies in...

Find Another Essay On Private Military Fighting For the US

American Strategies for Fighting the Cold War

1424 words - 6 pages received on strategic policy and military programs, known as National Security Council Resolution Number 68 (NSC-68), proposed that the United States take a greater role in containing Communism by an active program of counterforce that required greater military spending. During the next three years, the US would increase their military spending from 13 billion to 15 billion. Japan had occupied Korea during World War II. and with Japan's defeat

Segregation: Fighting for the Same Rights

1334 words - 6 pages Segregation was very hard to endure to those who were colored in the 1960’s. Segregation was basically a white person making cruel remarks to a colored person or about the colored people in general. Segregation wasn’t just making racist remarks but it made people fight about little events that weren’t worth fighting about. White people would even take the colored to court just for having a nice car or even not addressing a white person as “sir

This paper was written about the US Army Special Forces Branch. It was written for a military science class. A-.

1295 words - 5 pages respond to any type of rising threat. Following the 77th was the 1st, selected fight in the Far East, based out of Okinawa. From this point onward, Fort Bragg became the nucleus of the Special Warfare Center, now known as the John F. Kennedy Center for Military Assistance. Special Forces have been involved in every major and minor conflict the world has seen since 1955. U.S. Special Forces troops first entered Vietnam for the first time in 1957

The Marshall Islands and US Military Nuclear Testing

1764 words - 7 pages History, he moved to New York City to make a career as a film maker. Radio Bikini would be Robert Stones first documentary film, produced in 1987 it would premier in the Sundance Film Festival and gains him recognition as the film was nominated for both an Oscar and an Emmy (“Biography”). Kilon Buano and the Bikinians. Kilon Bauno was King of the Bikinians at the time of Radio Bikini. In 1946, Commodore Ben H. Wyatt, acting military governor of the

Jay Gatsby; The White Knight Fighting for the Fair Maiden

1023 words - 5 pages Jay Gatsby; The White Knight Fighting for the Fair Maiden Courtly love is a fundamental metaphor of Fitzgerald’s, The Great Gatsby, and, therefore, the elusive Jay Gatsby plays out his role as a courtly lover throughout the novel. Gatsby’s abnormal situation with Daisy reflects the metaphor of courtly love. Many of the characteristics used to define courtly love are reflected in Gatsby’s actions. Every choice that he makes is an attempt to win

The ACLU of Pennsylvania: Fighting for the Equality of All

1501 words - 6 pages deal with politics, health, etc. (“PhillyPride…”). One of the most involved and passionate organizations in Philadelphia fighting for LGBT rights, including the right to marry, is the American Civil Liberties Union of Pennsylvania. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) is a nonprofit, nonpartisan, membership organization founded in 1920 with organization centers and headquarters throughout the nation. The ALCU is dedicated to defending and

The Differences Between Fighting Communism for American Presidents

1147 words - 5 pages the war indicated the direction that Nixon was heading in the fight against Communism, he took his attention off of Vietnam and moved it to China and the Soviet Union. Whereas Nixon took the passive route, Reagan used powerful anti-Communist rhetoric to set the tone for his approach towards fighting Communists. Of his projected changes "none was more important to Reagan than building up tremendous military strength and then demonstrating that the

Were North American Revolutionaries Fighting For The Rights Of Englishmen ?

2115 words - 8 pages WERE AMERICAN REVOLUTIONARIES FIGHTING FOR THE RIGHTS OF ENGLISHMEN In September 1774 the first Continental Congress met in Philadelphia PA, and after some protracted discussion, issued the Declaration and Resolves of the First Continental Congress. Twelve of the thirteen colonies were present, the exception being Georgia. Discussion centred on the on the perceived infringements of their "rights as Englishmen" as inflicted upon them by the

Building Mentors in the Military. The US Army is recognized around the world for its exceptional leader development programs. In fact, it has no equal.

973 words - 4 pages Building Mentors in the MilitaryThe US Army is recognized around the world for its exceptional leader development programs. In fact, it has no equal. We have made great strides in counseling our subordinates to help them improve their performance. But, turbulence, budget and other policy constraints have created the need for a more personal approach to taking care of our soldiers.The knowledge, skill and experimental requirements thrust on

Outsourcing the War: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly of Using Private Military and Security Firms

1385 words - 6 pages of critical government functions. This paper will also outline in detail how private military companies and private security contractors are a detriment to the military and the government. Most of the information is relative to the last thirteen years that United States and NATO forces have spent fighting the war on terror in Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF) and Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF). What exactly are private military companies and

The Royal Military College as an Instrument for Molding Military Offices

3381 words - 14 pages The Royal Military College as an Instrument for Molding Military Offices To view the Royal Military College (RMC) as an instrument for molding military officers for the nation would be an accurate means of outlining the institutions objective. In the Organizational Behavior Concepts, Controversies, Applications, textbook by Stephen Robbins and Nancy Langton, organizational culture is defined as: "a system of shared meaning and common

Similar Essays

Us Strategy In Fighting Terrorism With Military Force

3257 words - 13 pages With recent operations by the Pakistani military and drone attacks by the US, these safe-havens are being attacked, but they remain a major refuge for the Taliban and other insurgents. Complicating the matter are allegations of Pakistani Intelligence (ISI) support for the Taliban and Pakistani fears of Indian influence in Afghanistan. Recent US strategy in fighting terrorism with military force revolves around three central ideas – a

Fighting For The Common Good Essay

1436 words - 6 pages United States has sent military forces into Afghanistan in order to destroy the Taliban. The goal of the military operation is to allow the Afghan people to live in a safe and secure country. In order for this to occur, United States military personal engage Taliban fighters in combat and kill them. This, however requires a great deal of personal sacrifice as these soldiers spend months away from their homes and families and face death and injury

Technological Advancement In The Us Military

1148 words - 5 pages Technological Advancement in the US Military Since its declaration of independence from Great Britain, the United States has experienced wars of many different sorts. Each war introduced a new kind of warfare. The Revolutionary War introduced for the first time in American history, the idea of naval warfare. Ships were armed with dozens guns and carried several dozens of men. The musket, armed with its bayonet as well as the cannon proved

History Of Women In The Us Military

1600 words - 6 pages Introduction Today in the United States military we are seeing more women become a part of the armed forces and serving our country. For me I believe this to be an accomplishment for women who chose to work in a field that is overly dominated and run by men. As for the world there are only 3% of women that make up the worlds military personnel(Herrmann, I., & Palmieri, D. 2010).There are some aspects of women being in the military and serving