"Private Property Rights Protect The Freedom Of Some People By Denying Freedom To Others." Do You Agree?

2003 words - 8 pages

Capitalism is defined by the Collins English Dictionary as an "economic system based on private ownership of industry". It has come to be viewed widely by the democratic western world as a system based on individuality and freedom of rights. Or more specifically, that everyone has a right to own private property regardless of his or her background or social situation. The division of labour created by capitalism is claimed by the capitalists to be beneficial to all of society; the freedom of competition allows for products on the market to be sold to the consumer at the lowest price and at the best quality. However, Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels argue otherwise, claiming that bourgeois private property is the 'final and most complete expression of the system of producing and appropriating products, that is based on class antagonisms, on the exploitation of the many by the few' . For them capitalism, which is based on the right to own private property, is beneficial only to the select few capitalists - or the bourgeoisie - who reap their benefits from the exploitation of the wage earners, the proletariat. For Marx and Engels, at least, private property rights protect the freedom of some but not only deny the freedom, but results in the exploitation, of many others.To understand this argument we must first look at the basis of Marx's theory. Marx strongly believed that capitalist society consisted of two classes, the bourgeoisie, or the ruling class, and the proletariat, who are the exploited class:"To maintain its own existence private property must also maintain the existence of the property - less working class needed to run the factories. The proletariat is compelled, however, to abolish itself on account of its miserable condition. This will require the abolition of private property - both disappear in a new synthesis that will resolve the contradiction."The employers, or the bourgeoisie, build up their wealth through the exploitation of their workers. Under capitalism workers essentially 'own' their own labour which in one respect makes them 'free'. However, although the workers are in charge of their own labour power, in the sense that it is not owned by a master or land owner, they are not free as they are forced to sell it out in order to survive. Instead of owning the product of their own labour, this instead goes to the capitalists who in turn retain a certain amount of the value of the product for themselves and their investment. Thus capital can be defined as accumulated labour. The more Capital grows the more small businesses are put out of production. In turn they are then forced to sell their labour on the market and "all these sink gradually into the proletariat". So the underclass grows as more people are forced to sell their labour on the market and as a consequence the average wage is lowered, as there is more demand for less work. Marx, in justifying his position in the communist manifesto, claims that it is each persons...

Find Another Essay On "Private Property rights protect the freedom of some people by denying freedom to others." Do you agree?

Should Freedom of the Press be Limited to Protect National Security?

1597 words - 6 pages , the right to petition, and the right to assemble. Over the years to present day, these rights have been shifted to meet current standards. Although they are meant to benefit citizens, some of these freedoms bring up controversy. For example, many people consistently debate whether Freedom of the Press should be limited to protect National security. The First Amendment, where U.S. citizen freedoms are written, states that, “Congress shall make no

While some people find reading poetry challenging, others find it inspiring and enjoyable. What to you is the 'appeal' of poetry?

1313 words - 5 pages yourself when all men doubt you,But make allowance for their doubting too;...If you can fill the unforgiving minuteWith sixty seconds' worth of distance run -Yours is the Earth and everything that's in it,And - which is more - you'll be a Man my son!""Poetry is the spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings", said William Wordsworth, and indeed it is. Poetry is an art form approachable by all to release and express all of the human emotions

"To Joy My Freedom" by Tera Hunter: Does the public/private dichotomy pertains to the lives of newly freed slave women?

1562 words - 6 pages created stating "separate but equal" status for African Americans. One of the biggest obstacles that held African American women back from their rights was the private/public dichotomy model. This model stated that public and private lives were separate and do not involve one another. At the time, the issues that women went through were seen having to deal with only private life, like their family and living conditions. Men were the ones that were

To What extent did the spread of Christianity violate Human Rights and Freedom in Africa? By Walubo Jude Tadeo

1919 words - 8 pages categorized with others as 'Christian'. This breaches article 18 of the Universal Declarion of Human Rights which states that, Everyone has the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion. As Daneel (1971:455) points out,"The older generation of mission Church officials - European and African - tended to view the Separatists as their opponents, 'sheep-stealers' who rob members of their flock, and as 'twisters of the truth'. The Separatist

Do you agree that the failure of the 1886 Home Rule Bill was due to ‘tactical mistakes’ made by Gladstone?

718 words - 3 pages Do you agree that the failure of the 1886 Home Rule Bill was due to ‘tactical mistakes’ made by Gladstone? The failure of the home rule bill in 1886 was due, to a large extent, to the tactical mistakes made by gladstone, such as the failure to unite his party and his underestimation of conservative opposition towards the bill. However, it could also be argued that other factors, such as the sectarian nature of Irish society and subsequent

'Intellectual property rights represent one of the most valuable commercial assets in modern society. But also one of the most problematic for a company to protect.' Discuss.

2723 words - 11 pages Intellectual property is an area of law, "which allows people to own their creativity and innovation in the same way that they can own physical property." Intellectual property rights provide people with control over ideas or information embodied in a valuable form of protection. It plays a major part in our modern business environment and becomes an increasingly valuable asset for establishing competitive advantage in all types of business

How can we protect our private information from others?

1726 words - 7 pages . Summary of Communication Privacy Management Theory Petronio asserts the ideas that people are inherently pressured to conceal and reveal certain private information to others while still feeling as if we are in complete control of our information. She addresses the “complexities of privacy regulation [and the need] for a systematic way to grasp how privacy management operates” (Petronio, 2010). Through Communication Privacy Management Theory

What is your own understanding of freedom? Do you believe freedom is an individual or communal ideal? What is true freedom?

669 words - 3 pages Freedom has been discussed and debated for a while now and no one can completely agree that it exists. Does it really exist? Can one do what they feel because they have the want to? And how far does freedom exist without restraints, if it does exist?Freedom for Mills speaks of the rights of an individual. Mills concept is focused more on individual liberty and not as much as community-based as King Jr. For Mills, freedom is personal liberty

There is nothing to admire in any member of the Simms. Do you agree?

1132 words - 5 pages There is nothing to admire in any member of the Simms. Do you agree?I think that this statement is too blunt. There are characteristics of everyone that we should admire. There is one obvious member of the Simms family that we can admire, Jeremy. While other members of the family we dislike due to them being racist. We seem to forget that these people were living in an unjust and unequal community. It was normal for white people to think that

Some critics believe that the visual and musical effects used in 'The glass Menagerie' by Tennesse Williams are what make it such an effective play. Do you agree?

1847 words - 7 pages Some critics believe thatthe visual and musical effects used in'The glass Menagerie' are whatmake it such an effective play.Do you agree?The visual and musical effects Tennessee Williams incorporates into 'The Glass Menagerie' are extremely thorough and detailed. They perform an important part in the play as they help the audience to interpret it in the specific and unique way the playwright intended. These visual and musical effects aid in

Freedom Singers from the Civil Rights Movement

1146 words - 5 pages about what I'm going to do. You see, when I discover what I'm going to do, then I can figure out what kind of sound I want. I'd probably use . . . I'd want the best band around, you know?” (Rolling Stone music) Mahalia Jackson was a gospel singer, who was part of the Freedom Singers, during the March on Washington, for the Civil Rights Movement. She was born on October 1911, and she grew up in a strict and religious household. When she was born

Similar Essays

Napoleon Established Order, &Acute;But At The Cost Of Individual Freedom. Do You Agree?

1076 words - 4 pages ME 20 October 2004 Napoleon established order, but at the cost of individual freedom. Do you agree with this statement? There was so much chaos in France due to the Revolution. The laws were not clear, and to some, unfair, therefore Napoleon had to restore order in France. In result Napoleon came up with various laws, in which he put forward to France. Napoleon was a determined leader meant to have crowned the Revolution and his policies

Some People Believe That University Students Should Be Required To Attend Classes. Others Believe That Going To Classes Should Be Optional For Students. Do You Agree?

551 words - 2 pages that the great majority of college students are young and single, and have few responsibilities, and that they need the discipline and structure of a system that requires attendance. Young people who have just gone off to college are notorious for the excesses to which they enjoy their freedom.There are many negative situations caused by the free-attendance system. The most harmful one is the economic waste for both universities and students. Many

[The Oxford Book Of English Short Stories] It's Ironic To See Adult Characters Behaving Childishly In Some Stories And Children In Others Being Worldly Adults. Do You Agree With This Statement?

1380 words - 6 pages I agree that it's ironic to see adult characters being childish and children being worldly adults and it's based on the statements below. In some stories, adults are illustrated in childish character so as to reveal some phenomenon and in the society, such as the idleness of the upper class and man's pride. Archibald and Aurelia in 'The reverent wooing of Archibald' and Johnson from the 'Dream Cargoes' are the examples. On the contrary, the

The Right To Property: An Essential To Freedom

1176 words - 5 pages social need for property ownership and how they should not be denied the ability to fulfill that need. The inadequacy of government to allow for the rights of property ownership, as well as protect those rights, limits the freedom and happiness of those governed. People should have the right to be able to own property because it raises financial security and success, as well as supports individual freedom and happiness. First of all, property