This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

The Contrasting Views Of Pro Slavery Vs. Abolitionist

1414 words - 6 pages

Throughout the history of mankind, slavery has existed in one form or another. Since the times of ancient civilizations to modern era subjugations, there have forces who feel strongly of its necessity and purpose, while others have devoted themselves to seeing the ideas and acts of slavery abolished. America is not an exception to the concept of slavery and during the nation’s early history, parties from both sides have been made famous for their beliefs in the continuation or the denouncement of slavery in the United States. To understand the contrasting views of pro-slavery advocates versus abolitionists in antebellum America, a comparison of the individual positions must be made to further understand the goals of each party.
A common theme of the pro-slavery advocates in the 1800’s was the continuation of slavery for the wellbeing of the enslaved and country. During this time in American history, it was believed African-Americans were inferior to whites and without bondage, they would reduce themselves to animalistic acts and barbarism. George Fitzhugh, an American social theorist who wrote “The Universal Law of Slavery” said, “He the [African-American] is but a grown up child, and must be governed as a child, not as a lunatic or criminal,” (Fitzhugh). Interpretation of Fitzhugh’s writings reveals his stand on slavery and his belief that through bondage, African Americans have become more civilized and protected from worst fates. To further persuade his position he introduced the quality of life and happiness slaves in the southern states experience. Fitzhugh illustrates that the children and elderly are excluded from work and the women are guarded by overzealous husbands through their master’s protection. He also addresses that the capable men do not work more than what is considered fair and appropriate time is given off during holidays. He concludes the overall existence for the southern slaves is pleasant and they are freer than most men; “The [African-American] slaves of the South are the happiest, and, in some sense, the freest people in the world,” (Fitzhugh).
Dr. Samuel Cartwright was a physician and pro-slavery advocate during the 1800’s and is well known for his diagnosis of drapetomania, a supposed disease that made slaves runaway. He concluded that the reason African slaves sought to escape was because they were treated inadequately by their masters. Delving deeper in his writings it is discovered he too, like George Fitzhugh, approved of enslavement. Both men advocated the issue and have similar analyzes on how slaves are or should be treated. Cartwright expresses to his audience that slaves will most likely run (drapetomania) if they are treated poorly by their master; “according to my experience, the "genu flexit"--the awe and reverence, must be exacted from them, or they will despise their masters, become rude and ungovernable, and run away,” (Cartwright). Dr. Cartwright believed if slaves were managed...

Find Another Essay On The Contrasting Views of Pro-Slavery vs. Abolitionist

The Contrasting Views of Roger Williams and John Winthrop

799 words - 4 pages The Contrasting Views of Roger Williams and John Winthrop People immigrated to America for many reasons, most people shared in the same ideas of going to the New World to start new lives away from England. Roger Williams and John Winthrop both joined in the Puritan dissent to New England, but while they were living in Boston, Massachusetts they did not agree on several matters. These two men had contrasting views when it came to Christianity

The point of views of abortion both pro-life and pro-choice

1610 words - 6 pages for abortion).Pro-life supporters believe that abortion should be illegal. To them abortion is a crime because you kill the fetus, which in their eyes it is a future living human. Christians are a majority of the pro-life supporters. Their point of view is that in God's eyes, a fetus is a living child. Pro-choice supporters believe that abortion should be legal, because it is their choice and no one else's choice. America's given freedom makes them

The Views and Lifestyles of Slaves During Slavery

3344 words - 13 pages The Views and Lifestyles of Slaves During Slavery Throughout the history of world there have been many documented cases of oppression and violence that one country or one race has forces upon another. Although the notion of slavery is thought to be gone from today's world, there are still numerous countries that force

The Good Vs. Evil of Slavery

743 words - 3 pages During the early mid-1800s, the perspective of slavery was altering and became a hostile wedge between the regions of the United States. Abolitionist in the North believed slavery to be morally wrong, but benefited from the cotton produced by slaves in the South. The South was acquiring economic benefits that slavery was supplying them with, but were too blind with power to see the terrible thing they were doing. While during the years of 1830

This is a discursive essay on abortion, describing the views of both pro choice and pro life groups

799 words - 3 pages the foetus is living, it has rights and therefore abortion qualifies as a killing. They say that if the woman did not want to have a child, she should not have had unprotected sex and so it is her own fault and she must bear the brunt of it. If your mother had decided to abort, you would not be here now.But pro-choice groups say that just because the woman got pregnant by mistake or without realising the consequences does not mean that she should

Frederick Douglass: The Life of an Abolitionist

981 words - 4 pages Frederick Douglass is perhaps the most well-known abolitionist from American history. He is responsible for creating a lot of support for the abolitionist movement in the years before the Civil War. He, along with many others, was able to gain support for and attention to the abolitionist movement. People like him are the reason that slavery ended in the United States. Frederick Augustus Washington Bailey was born in February of 1818 in

Examining Contrasting Views in the Field of Normative Ethics and Applied Ethics

1583 words - 6 pages In this paper, I will examine contrasting views in the field of normative ethics and applied ethics. I will first analyze Aristotle in his writings on virtue ethics and W.D. Ross’s arguments for deontological ethics. I will then proceed to the field of applied ethics, and analyze the positions of John Noonan and Mary Warren on the issue of abortion. Aristotle, in his selections from Nicomachean Ethics, argues that eudaimonia is the supreme goal

Huckleberry Finn: The Contrasting Views on Life of Tom and Huck

1030 words - 4 pages Tom and Huck differ in their views of life. Briefly summarize each character's view of life and cite references throughout the book to support it. With whom do you agree? Why? What point of view is most dominant in current society? Cite specific examples to prove your contentions.In this life, people are generalized everyday. They're put into categories; neat little boxes that we can deal with and put into piles accordingly. Without forethought

Abraham Lincoln's views on slavery from the years of 1861-1865

1010 words - 4 pages Even from the time Abraham Lincoln was a twenty-eight year old legislator, his views on slavery were strong--he was completely against it. He felt it was "founded on both injustice and bad policy." Abraham Lincoln was elected president in November of 1860. The issue of slavery divided the nation into two--the North and the South, leaving the President with a tumultuous task at hand. Even though his personal beliefs may have led him in one

Retouching the Truth: Pro-Edited vs. Pro-Unedited

835 words - 4 pages essay I will explore the beliefs and arguments both sides pose on the matter of photo editing and whether or not it is moral or immoral. Photography is one of many ways people choose to express themselves. It is not only a career path but a hobby for many. Photos can be used to express any type of emotion, thing or event, realistic or not. Therefore, those who are pro-editing believe that the invention of photo editing software has simply made

Pro-Life: The Opposite of Pro-Death

998 words - 4 pages Pro-Life: The Opposite of Pro-Death Careful attention to the truth has never been standard operating procedure for pro-abortion advocates. Therefore, it should not be any suprise that half-truths, and misrepresentations, and many outright lies have permeated the pro-abortion propaganda campaign. Pro-choice is just a phrase used by people who know the absurdity of legal abortions and infanticide. Pro-life advocates have a more simple

Similar Essays

Phenomenon Of Slavery In American And Abolitionist

1747 words - 7 pages Britain and Foreign Anti-Slavery Society, which joined together with other pro-slave eradication movements in America and Europe to help combat the illegal traffic of men being transported for the unpaid and cruel labour which had previously been allowed to happen.Why the 19th century observed the downfall of the slave trade has many reasons; presented and bought to the forefront of society's minds by pro-freedom groups such as the Anti-Slavery

The Pro Slavery Constitution Essay

753 words - 4 pages , but up to the adoption of the XIIIth it was mandatory. Also, the text did not legalize the slavery itself. Another issue that for a period of time turned the Constitution to a pro-slavery document is the case-law that followed its adoption. Prigg vs Pennsylvania (1843) case stated that the Pennsylvanian law that prohibited blacks from being taken out of the state into slavery would be precluded by the fugitive slave clause. This precedent made

The Abolitionist Movement Of Slavery From The Early 19th Century To The American Civil War

1557 words - 7 pages enacted in many states to regulate the activity of slaves. These laws also regulated the behavior of former slaves or free African Americans. (http://www.understandingrace.org/history/gov/expan_slavery.html) After gaining a vast amount of land from the Louisiana Purchase, the question of slavery became geographical and political. This provided a period of national debate between pro-slavery and anti-slavery states who craved for political and

Two Views Of Slavery Essay

1342 words - 6 pages Two Views of Slavery During the time prior to the twentieth century our world accepted slavery as a normal part of life. Aphra Behn and Phillis Wheatley, both female authors born about 100 years apart, had their own views of slavery and wrote poems and stories about the subject. These women were physically different, Aphra was a Caucasian, and Phillis was an African American, and their lives were rather different as well. Aphra was a spy and