Problems Of Decentralization What Were The Problems Of Decentralized Power That Existed Under The Articles Of Confederation?

1242 words - 5 pages

After the American Revolution was won and the Treaty of Paris formally recognized the United States of America as a country, there was still much to do . Major parts of the country were in shambles, and there was a strong need for a central government. At the time, many states drafted their own state governments, but soon realized that a national government was needed, so delegates went to the Second Continental Congress to draft the Articles of Confederation. Though it provided a legislative branch of government with one house that had the power to declare war, had the power to make treaties, and could also borrow money to pay debts, it was nothing more than a declaration of friendship between the colonies . The weaknesses of the Articles were apparent after the government showed helplessness after Shay’s Rebellion. The governor of Massachusetts asked Congress to send troops, but they didn’t have the money or the men to send aid . It also exposed the fact that the Articles of Confederation also failed to see that the states would adequately protect the rights and liberties of all their citizens .In the process of writing the Articles of Confederation so that it would not resemble a parliamentary government like Great Britain’s, the authors unintentionally created many problems pertaining to centralized power. The states kept their sovereignty which made it seem like there were thirteen separate countries rather than thirteen states unified together to create a country. There was no executive branch which translated into no follow through on decisions and there was a lack of leadership of the armed forces. No standing army meant that there was constant internal strife and state conflict, as well as making the threat of external invasion very real. There was also no trade regulation, which resulted in numerous trade disputes and also resulted in states taxing one another. State conflict was not only limited to trade disputes; laws in one state weren’t always recognized in others. Bigger states often bullied smaller states because of their smaller population size. And there was not a judicial system to help states settle disputes so states sometimes would even war against each other . Since it was evident that these problems were hindering the growth of the country, a meeting was called to fix and strengthen the existing form of government, the meeting was later known as the Constitutional Convention .At the Constitutional Convention, their main goal was to create a strong central government that had power that would exceed the states, but not so much power that it would resemble a parliamentary government . James Madison, the leader in the convention, also wanted to put a series of checks and balances into effect so that the three branches of government could all control each other and at the same time also govern themselves . After compromising between the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey Plan, which both dealt with state...

Find Another Essay On Problems of Decentralization What were the problems of decentralized power that existed under the Articles of Confederation?

Why the Articles of Confederation were an effective form of government for the U.S

1312 words - 5 pages Confederation provided the United States with an effective government from 1781-1789.The socio-economic functions that the Articles set up were committed to Jeremy Bentham's theory of the greatest good for the greatest number of people. During the revolution, each state had to raise their own militia's forcing them in debt, but instead of it being a federal responsibility, under the articles they are forced to find their own ways to get money, hence

What were the problems caused by Japan because of Manchuria, especially between China and Japan, and what were the influences?

1638 words - 7 pages , the Japanese had a special policy for Chinese. "Kill all! Burn all! Rob all!" Some old people nowadays, who had gone through that part in history, when asked about what happened to the Chinese people during the Japanese occupations, cried so hard that they couldn't even answer the question. Up until 1945, millions of Chinese were killed. In 1930s and 1940s, under the pressure of national crisis, the Chinese started their movement of fighting

Explain the impact of the Articles of the Confederation on the Constitutional Convention of 1787. How were the imperfections of the Articles ‘corrected’ with the new constitution?

1870 words - 7 pages America that the Articles of Confederation should be disregarded, and an adequate government be provided, and the Union preserved; or that an adequate government should be omitted, and the Articles of Confederation preserved." From a charter written at the Annapolis Convention of 1786, providing for the alterations and provisions, 21, to amend the Articles, we were given an illegal, Federalist koan to property and aristocratic civic rights. What

"Prohibition in Early America" Describes Prohibition in America, what people did to get around the problems, and some of the acts that were instated to stop drinking

898 words - 4 pages There once was a time when a person couldn't sit down after a hard day's work,and have a comforting Martini. This was a time in our history in which our governmentfelt as if the root of all evil was alcohol, it was their belief that if alcohol were no longerhere, then there would be no more problems. They had a good idea, but because of lackof being able to enforce the laws brought forth under the Eighteenth amendment, it didnot make a

Describe the Lewis and Clark Expedition. What were the problems encountered? How did Lewis and Clark prepare for it? What were the results of the Expedition?

1741 words - 7 pages to know about 80 new species of plants that were put into collections. Their collections formed the basis for the first major scientific publication that described and illustrated the plants west of the Mississippi River. These collections were the first of what would grow to thousands of collections as later botanical explorers followed in the footsteps of Lewis and Clark.The Lewis and Clark Expedition is one of the greatest and most remembered

Problems That Led to the Wrongful Conviction of David Milgaard

2611 words - 10 pages interchanges the two concepts of crime and deviance, assuming that they are one in the same. "A crime is what the law proclaims it to be, and is an act punishable by law" (Winterdyk 9). Deviance, on the other hand, is a contested concept; it can be defined as differing from a norm or accepted standard of society (dictionary.com). Deviance involves acts that fluctuate from social norms; although such actions can be, they are not necessarily

What were the problems in Weimar Republic from 1919-1923?

1066 words - 4 pages The problems that occurred in Weimar Germany were unavoidable, considering the drastic different changes of the government before and after 1919. Before 1919, the government of Germany was almost a military autocracy under Kaiser Wilhelm II; after 1919, it was a parliamentary democracy. The drastic change from one pole to the other in such a short period did not allow people to adapt the changes and thus create a ground for conflicts. The

Jamestown v. Plymouth: What were the motives and expections of the people in each colony? What different sets of problems did each group face? How did they react to these problems?

991 words - 4 pages Starvation, disease, and Indians; these are just a few of the problems you would have dealt with if you wanted to journey to and live in the New World at the start of the 17th century. Knowing some of the fatal and dangerous problems they would have faced what could have been the motivation to make people go anyway? To give up the comforts they were accustomed to having; to risk getting sick and not having the things they would need to get well

The Merchant of Venice has been condemned as a racist play, what are the problems that a modern production faces

2106 words - 8 pages The context in which William Shakespeare wrote the Merchant of Venice in 1597 was racist and prejudiced against different religions in the society that existed then.At that time England was a protestant country that had recently been under threat from catholic Spain and before that the Jews had been exiled from the country. Therefore Jews, coloured people and Catholics were generally hated and very rarely seen except in ports around the coast

As one reads Confederation: The Use and Abuse of History by D.G. Creighton, it becomes apparent that he exemplifies no secrecy when referring to the present day problems emerging between Quebec and...

1399 words - 6 pages would encompass all of the provinces under the power of a concentrated sovereign legislature. Creighton stresses that at that time, most Canadians and more importantly the Fathers of Confederation themselves were most interested in a form of legislative union under one common parliament. This would allow for little provincial autonomy or sharing of authority with the federal government. It is clear that Creighton believes the Fathers intended

Explanation of the Intellectual Foundation and Methods that Were Used in the Organization Under Benito Mussolini.

2020 words - 8 pages . Preexisting conflicts between north and south Italy were not abandoned with the unification. Italy's government did not represent its people but its government and business officials. Italians did not have a sense of national pride to Italy and that would not change until Mussolini would come into power years later with ideals of fascism. Ideas that were twisted and shaped throughout his entire life. Benito Mussolini was born July 29th, 1883 in

Similar Essays

The Nation Under The Articles Of Confederation

819 words - 3 pages The Nation Under the Articles of Confederation The Articles of Confederation from the period 1781 till 1789 would be a period least effective of a government according to the fully oppositional Constitution that came right after the articles. The effectiveness of a government contains the factors such as economy, political

How Effective Was The Articles Of Confederation And Did The Constituion Solve These Problems

678 words - 3 pages refused to cooperate. The Articles were also virtually impossible to amend, so problems could not be fixed unless all of the states agreed. Other weakness of that the Articles of Confederation encountered were the fact that the enforcement of federal laws and treaties were left to the states. Also, the federal government was not given the sole power to coin money. That right belonged to each individual state. As time passed, it was obvious that

Foreign Policy Problems With The Articles Of Confederation Lehman College, Senior Essay

1449 words - 6 pages declared independence.[footnoteRef:1] The leaders of the colonies feared centralized government because they believed that it put too much power in too few people's hands. After over a year of back and forth, the Articles of Confederation were ready for ratification.[footnoteRef:2] However, the Articles of Confederation did not last long because it made the central government too weak especially in foreign affairs.[footnoteRef:3] Under the

Reasons The Articles Of Confederation Led To The Ratification Of The Constitution: Why Did The Articles Fail? Did The Constitution Solve The Problems?

942 words - 4 pages another state.Also, under the Articles, each state had one vote in Congress, no matter the size of the state. This caused problems because the larger states thought they should have more representation because they had a larger population. The larger states often ignored Congress and did what they wanted, like negotiate with foreign nations. They got away with this because there was no way to punish individuals. The root of this problem was that