Product Warning Labels And Protection Against Liability Lawsuits

1882 words - 8 pages

Product Warning Labels and Protection Against Liability Lawsuits

We have all purchased a new consumer product with several labels, stickers, and product inserts containing warnings, disclaimers and oversimplified directions. The warnings can actually be humorous at times as illustrated in the following examples:
· On Sears hair dryer: Do not use while sleeping
· On Marks & Spencer Bread Pudding: Product will be hot
after heating.

· On Rowenta Iron: Do not iron clothes on body.

· On Nytol (a sleep aid): Warning: May cause drowsiness.

· On a Swedish chainsaw: Do no attempt to stop chainsaw
with your hands.

Obviously, with a little common sense, your average consumer can avoid the injuries that the above statements are attempting to warn against. One can argue that these warnings provide protection to the manufacturers against lawsuits based upon personal injury.
There are many infamous cases where damages were awarded to consumers due to a personal injury resulting from what is claimed to be negligence, failure to warn or a product defect. According to public opinion, some of these lawsuits are frivolous and are causing the decline of our civil justice system. An examination of cases against tobacco companies will provide us with some conflicting information regarding product warning labels. Do they provide manufacturers with adequate protection against this type of lawsuit?
By law, product manufacturers are responsible to give a reasonable warning when the product they manufacture poses a foreseeable risk of injury or harm. Courts use the following factors to consider a manufacturer's duty to warn: "the magnitude or severity of the likely harm, the ease or difficulty of providing an appropriate warning, and the likely effectiveness of a warning" (Mallor, etal. 377) in addition to the manufacturer's ability to reasonably foresee the risk.
Are people drying their hair while sleeping or ironing clothes while wearing them foreseeable risks? As lawsuits become more outrageous, so do the warnings and there is an outcry for reform in our civil justice system to minimize frivolous lawsuits. According to a poll conducted by Nation's Business magazine (February, 1998) 2/3 of the businesses that responded had been named as defendants in product liability lawsuits. An overwhelming majority felt that frivolous lawsuits are definitely a problem and that "people who file lawsuits (should) pay the defendant's legal fees if they lose". Eighty percent were in favor of a "federal law being enacted to supersede conflicting state laws on the liability of a company if someone using it's product is injured".
Courts use a risk/utility analysis to determine whether the risks associated with certain inherently unsafe products are reasonable. To make the determination, courts weigh the availability of safer alternatives and whether the risks of using the product outweigh that...

Find Another Essay On Product Warning Labels and Protection Against Liability Lawsuits

Lawsuit Against The Tobacco Industry Essay

701 words - 3 pages the product is inherently dangerous and should not have been put into the stream of the commerce. Unfortunately, courts have held that the use of tobacco is voluntary and most of the dangers are known, so the user knew this and chose to use it anyway. The companies also argue that the warning on the package is enough to satisfy the obligation to warn. These are near impossible cases to win.Most of the current lawsuits are from people getting

Frivolous Lawsuits Essay

2348 words - 9 pages large settlement in order to avoid any public media. Congress has pursued several key steps towards protection against frivolous lawsuits. This past month, the Bush administration addressed Congress with several tort reforms, including a $250,000 pain and suffering cap. However, innocent people and institutions are still susceptible to falling victims of ambulance chasing scams, while greedy lawyers reap on the benefits of minute mistakes, like

The War on Tobacco

1704 words - 7 pages of sports and entertainment events (What FDA Regulation of Tobacco Products Really Means 3). Eventually the FTC and Congress banned any radio or television advertising (Congress Requires Cigarette Warning Labels 3). The first viewpoint is all about regulating tobacco and there are different ways to regulate tobacco and this is another one of them, and this will make it so tobacco industries can't persuade people from taking up on smoking. Ban

Lawsuits Gone Wild: Our Out of Control Legal System and the Need for Tort Reform

1195 words - 5 pages increases the cost of financing. Aside from spending and losing more money, immense awards for often ridiculous lawsuits can force businesses into bankruptcy, and cause large and small companies alike to shut down.Another problem caused by frivolous lawsuits is that unnecessary precautions have become necessary. What would be unneeded protections now are needed to guard against litigation. Doctors carry out expensive but otherwise unnecessary tests to

Tobacco Advertisements

1806 words - 7 pages power to regulate tobacco products, is a major step for federal regulation of cigarette manufacturers” (Brief). It gives the FDA more authority over the tobacco companies by “ . . . not only does it grant the FDA the power to dictate product ingredients and overrule new products, it compels tobacco companies to eliminate potentially misleading labels like “light” and “mild”, regulate a product’s ingredients and increase the size of warning

Limited Liability Corportations and Partnerships

861 words - 3 pages for business debts, much like the shareholders of a corporation. This allows each owner's personal assets protection from lawsuits and judgments against the company. This limits each owner's liability to the amount he or she has invested in the business. The LLC also has the option of choosing its own tax status. Additionally, bankruptcy will not affect the owner's personal finances, as in a sole proprietorship.Limited Liability PartnershipsA

Limited Liability Corporation and Limited Liability Partnership

1003 words - 4 pages taxation, and management flexibility.The owner or owners of an LLC have limited liability for business debts, much like the shareholders of a corporation. This allows each owner's personal assets protection from lawsuits and judgments against the company. This limits each owner's liability to the amount he or she has invested in the business. The LLC also has the option of choosing its own tax status. Additionally, bankruptcy will not affect the owner's

Financial Ratio Analysis on Philip Morris

2573 words - 10 pages industry was able to overturn all lawsuits filed up until 1996 (Marshall 78). Warning labels invoked in 1965 on cigarette packaging helped companies to argue the fact that consumers knew the harmful effects associated with smoking, but assumed the consequences and the risks anyway. Coupled with large donations to political parties, these factors helped the tobacco industry to not only win court cases, but also aided in its ability to maintain good

Product Liability

1477 words - 6 pages Product Liability This week's question concerns liability and moral responsibility in consumer products. As the question is multi-part, the answer will be likewise. To begin, the first question addresses who should be liable for the voluntary actions of others. Specifically, if substantial information concerning the hazards of a product or service has been offered to the consumer, who is to blame if someone is injured? Similar to most

Frivolous lawsuits

2872 words - 11 pages Do you remember the lawsuit about the woman who ordered the McDonald’s coffee and spilled it in her lap and sued McDonald’s because it did not have a warning label on it? What about the woman who fell in the fountain at the mall while texting and wants to sue the mall? These lawsuits may seem fairly farfetched. They fall into the category called frivolous. Black’s Law Dictionary defines frivolous as lacking a legal basis or legal merit; not

A Modern Day Hester Prynne; "The Scarlet Letter" by Nathaniel Hawthorne

785 words - 3 pages example of shunning in modern society is recent tobacco litigation and regulations set up against tobacco companies like Philip Morris. Philip Morris and other major tobacco companies have worked hard over the past few decades to cover up evidence that smoking is bad for your health. Tobacco companies conducted their own research that showed smoking their product could cause potentially fatal diseases long before this information was revealed to the

Similar Essays

Liability Causes Of Action Against Law Enforcement Personnel, Supervisors, And Agencies

1850 words - 7 pages forecasting combined with continuous training; we can bolster and mitigate the agencies defense against liability. In essence, we need to be offensive thinkers in order to build a strong defense. This process should be continuous as our policies and procedures are living documents and customs. Recent studies show the most troubling legal problems facing law enforcement agencies today is the impact of criminal and civil liability. The amount of

Consider The Arguments Both For And Against The Contention That Gender Is A Product Of Nurture Rather Than Nature

2014 words - 8 pages Consider the arguments both for and against the contention that gender is a product of nurture rather than natureSociologists use the term sex when referring to biological differences between male and female bodies whereas gender is used to explain the social construction of masculinity and femininity. The distinction between sex and gender is important as many differences between males and females are not just biological. The predominant

"The Aim Of Marketing Is To Know And Understand The Customer So Well That The Product Or Service Fits Him Or Her And Sells Itself." (Drucker) Produce Arguments For And Against This Statement

924 words - 4 pages In 1973, Peter Drucker stated "The aim of marketing is to know and understand the customer so well that the product or service fits him or her and sells itself." Considering that marketing is an exchange process between two parties which results in both customer and organizational satisfaction (Kolter & Keller 2006). It seems logical that, if a business is able to produce a product that is able to sell itself (i.e. does not require the

The Liability Of Tobacco Makers Essay

932 words - 4 pages (We’re Fighting). Is it right that people are allowed to put tobacco companies at fault for illness due to smoking? Each year there are hundreds of court cases in the United States against tobacco companies just like Charles Green’s case. Long term smokers and nonsmokers like Green are suing large tobacco companies for injuries from smoking. They feel that tobacco companies should be punished for making a product that millions of people use