This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Profiling Foreign Students Is Rational And Legitimate

1153 words - 5 pages

Profiling Foreign Students is Rational and Legitimate


Sixty years ago, the United States placed Japanese-, German-, and Italian-Americans in internment camps. Our country has also excluded people of various nationalities simply because we didn't like "their kind." The government's scrutiny of Middle Eastern students in response to September 11 has thus evoked acute suspicions and fears that the Hollywood scenario in "The Siege" will become a reality. Others are concerned that even if internment is a remote possibility, the recent heightened attention toward a group of foreign students amounts to racial profiling. These fears are perfectly reasonable but, thankfully, unsupported by what has happened thus far.


As much as Americans today insist on treating people as individuals, there are some regrettable circumstances in which grouping has legitimate purposes. The Supreme Court has recognized the necessity of grouping by subjecting "inherently suspect" classifications like race to a standard of "strict scrutiny," while letting classifications with a reasonable purpose pass with "intermediate scrutiny."  Fundamentally, the Court asks whether there is a "rational basis" for a government policy that treats a particular group of people differently. In its recent treatment of foreign students, the government has demonstrated a "rational basis" for measures that group people to meet a pressing state interest while minimizing the violation to individuals' dignity. 


Without casting aspersions on the people and the culture of the region, we cannot deny that the Middle East is a hotbed of fanaticism. Thousands of militants have been indoctrinated by calls for the violent destruction of entire groups of people merely out of spite for their way of life. While fanatic terrorists can be found anywhere-even at home-fanaticism in the Middle East is much more intense, virulent, and widespread than it is anywhere else. Accordingly, authorities are trying to learn more about how terrorists from this region operate. After two attacks on the World Trade Center, we know that terrorists have entered and remained in the country by overstaying their student visas. We know that there are "sleeper cells"-groups of terrorists who enter the country and stay incognito for extended periods until they receive their activation order. What we do not know is who and where these individuals are. 


Just as the United States and other countries have banned people who have lived in the United Kingdom from donating blood to protect against the possibility that they came into contact with "Mad Cow Disease," the government is questioning people-many of them students-who have lived and had substantial social contacts in the Middle East, and who might thus well have come into contact with terrorist groups. This analogy is imperfect, however, since the specific people being questioned of course are not suspected of having been...

Find Another Essay On Profiling Foreign Students is Rational and Legitimate

Foreign Aids Affect on Us and Is It Beneficial

855 words - 4 pages Foreign aid is beneficial for other governments, their people, and our selves. Foreign aid is assistance we give to other people. It can help preserve the lives of people facing natural disasters, corrupt governments, and eliminate terrorism. It also can allow us to form alliances with other countries that may help us in later times. The money we get for financial aid comes from the federal budget. According to Shan Carter’s review on Obama’s

This essay is about racial profiling. I am comparing two different essays written by two authors and there views on racial profiling

540 words - 2 pages On September 11, 2001, 19 Arab terrorists killed more than three thousand Americans. If they were checked and singled out by the airline maybe it could have prevented this attack from happening. There wasn't that much racial profiling before September 11 and this is what happened. Everyone blamed the airlines for not enough security and such. But if they were checked this attack might have been prevented, but it would be considered racial

Critical Thinking and Decision Making Critical Thinking is defined as the systematic evaluation of arguments based on explicit rational criteria

626 words - 3 pages Critical Thinking and Decision MakingCritical Thinking is defined as the systematic evaluation of arguments based on explicit rational criteria (Browne and Stuart IX). Deductive reasoning is the first tool that reasonable people can use to improve their critical thinking skills. Critical thinking requires people to be able to find the faulty reasoning and deductions in an argument. Incorrect or inconclusive assumptions must be identified and

Private School is a Better Option for Students and Parents

1043 words - 5 pages a place where they are not bombarded with students in a classroom. “ This smaller class size permits a teacher to spend more time with each student will receive more individualize attention from the teacher which benefits the students academically” (AACS). The student-to-student ratio is also small.“ 86% have fewer then 300 students in the whole school” (CAPE). Which gives the students the best chance to truly understand and know all they need to

Reward is a Reinforcer for Employees and Students

1991 words - 8 pages organization or institution to provide compensation and benefits to employees or students commensurate with a workforce that has been poured . The importance of rewards and benefits are indeed undeniable. If the employee or student is not satisfied with the compensation and benefits provided , then this will result in the existence of such problems as absenteeism , job rotation rate employing high , declining productivity and not serious in doing

Connections between Lewis Lapham's essay, "Who and What is America?" and Christopher Edley, Jr.'s essay "The New American Dilemma: Racial Profiling Post-9/11"

1295 words - 5 pages and the politicians try to categorize Americans and split us into groups turning one against another. Politics turn Democratic Americans against Republican Americans and the media turns white Americans against Americans of color. As a result, the sense of feeling as one nation is lost, causing prejudice, dishonesty, and hate. Christopher Edley, Jr. states in his essay "The New American Dilemma: Racial Profiling Post-9/11" that our diversity is what

Is it important for nursing students to demonstrate academic honesty and integrity?

837 words - 4 pages This essay will be examining why nursing students need to demonstrate a high level of honesty and academic integrity in there work. The discussion for this essay will look at why academic honesty and integrity is so important, what is considered academic dishonesty and how can it be managed; and how this can effect clinical situations. Academic honesty is defined as the use of one's own work, this includes thoughts, materials and workings, in

What is I.D.E.A. and How Does it Effect Students of Color?

2158 words - 9 pages Mid-Term What is I.D.E.A. & How Does It Affect Students of Color? The United States is home to hundreds of different types of peoples and cultures. We have always prided ourselves on our achievements as a nation, but now there is a problem. In the past century we have discovered that it is inhumane to hide away people that are different from us. It is an atrocity to deny one child an education just because he/she can't see

What is meant by the term foreign exchange risk and explain and illustrate those strategies that are available to a multi-national enterprise to deal with such risk

2286 words - 9 pages In this paper I intend to introduce the relevant options available to a multi-national enterprise when dealing with foreign exchange risk. I am going to use Toyota Motor Corporation throughout as an example. Toyota is the world's third largest automaker. It was established in Japan on August 28th 1937 and apart from its 12 plants in Japan, has 54 manufacturing companies in 27 countries, employs 246,700 people and markets vehicles in more than

Knowing your Content Area is Not Enough for Teachers or Students: Do Not Just Memorize Facts and Formulas

1053 words - 4 pages Knowing your Content Area is not enough Traditionally, students have trouble thinking of subjects beyond right and wrong answers. For example, students will see a history class as a set of dates and events that need to be memorized in order to answer questions correctly on an exam. They fall short of seeing the broader picture or the impact that history can play on the present world or their own lives. Similarly, students miss the broader

A Presidential Look: John Adams - The Only Federalist President This is a paper about the presidency of John Adams. It covers his economic, foreign, and domestic policies

1225 words - 5 pages Matthew HelmA Presidential Look:John Adams - The Only Federalist PresidentJohn Adams was the second president of the United States of America. Over his term as president, Adams had to deal with many conflicts centered on the political climate, the economy, and foreign and domestic affairs.During the presidential campaign of 1796, Adams was the presidential candidate of the Federalist Party with Thomas Pinckney as the second most popular

Similar Essays

Racial Profiling By Police Is Ineffective And Reduces Public Safety

1189 words - 5 pages ethnic groups for minor traffic or petty criminal offenses in order to question and or search them for drugs, guns, or other contraband.” After the investigation, the medial exploded with coverage of the problem of racial profiling (Gene & Anderson, 2001). According to Gallop Poll on December 9, 1999, 81 percent of those polled disapproved of the practice. Racial profiling in many cases has altered lives and destroyed families. Racial profiling is

Racial Profiling By Police Is Ineffective And Reduces Public Safety

1082 words - 4 pages Racial Profiling is law enforcement and private security practices that disproportionately target people of color for investigation and enforcement. Racial Profiling occurs across the United States and an overwhelming number of Hispanics and African Americans, including children, are being stopped. Some may say “racial profiling is an ineffective and degrading practice that violates civil rights” while others say that it is

To What Extent Is Faith A Legitimate Basis For Knowledge Claims, In Religion And Different Areas Of Knowledge?

1574 words - 6 pages and there would be no way to construct any sort of knowledge system. My purpose in this essay is to establish the validity of this assertion and to demonstrate that not only is faith a legitimate basis for knowledge claims in religion, but also in all areas of knowledge.To start with, in order to effectively answer a question concerning "religious beliefs", we must first define the term. Obviously, there are many different religions, each with

"Racial Profiling Is Wrong And We Will End It In America"

524 words - 2 pages (ACLU), which defends the bill of rights. ACLU was founded in 1920 after the suppression of World War II. The ACLU is the nations guardian to preserve and protect individual rights and freedom. There were Palmer Raids that were initiated due to terrorist's attacks that are today affecting the way we view terrorism. There are a lot of victims to this nations racial profiling