Proof Of Courage Essay

1513 words - 6 pages

The problem with the definitions of courage that we covered through the course of this semester is that they are very narrow yet the basic definitions are too broad. As a result of this, each needs to limit the scope of the definition at length. Do we really separate definition of courage for each specific circumstance? Just to name a few, we have battlefield valor, political courage, courage to partake in burdened virtues, religious courage (martyrdom), and fortitude. If a supposed self-evident truth does not hold true in all situations and cannot be aptly summarized in brevity, it is often because of a flaw.
Another reason for the multitude of definitions is that each author defines courage from the individual's perspective. This results in a bias towards defining courageous circumstances rather than courageous action.
Every paper, film, and novel covered during the course, without a doubt, depicted courageous individuals. Yet many of them would only fall under one or two labels of courage. The solution to the conundrum is simple. Courage needs to be defined by way of mathematical proof (regarding the approach, not the content) rather than from the subject's actions. Through an indirect approach it becomes easy to differentiate courage from similar falsities. Courage is a person's ability to knowingly surpass expectations in the process of overcoming an obstacle, to achieve a goal that is greater than one's self.
Aristotle places ample restrictions on what courage meant to him. Subjugated people were not able to demonstrate such a virtue. True courage can only be demonstrated on the battlefield by a fully informed individual. He states that women, children, slaves, and the diseased are unable to express courage as a virtue because either they have not chosen their circumstance or society does not permit them to act in such a way a way (Aristotle 3.chapter 5,6). My issue with this type of definition is that it limits courage to specific social casts. Time period withstanding, would a woman dying for the life of her child not be counted as courage? Or what of a leprous man taking their own life to dissuade social stigma against their family? Even within the social confines of the day, much was overlooked by his definition. Aristotle did name another type of courage which pertains to politicians but while degree of courage may alter, surely a separate definition isn't needed (for this reason, I will not cover Kennedy’s definition).
Thompson did an exemplary job of integrating Aristotle's views with Christian virtues but yet again, he limited his definition to the threat of death. “Moreover it belongs to the notion of virtue that it should regard something extreme: and the most fearful of all bodily evils is death, since it does away all bodily goods(Aquinas OF sub-question A[3]).” While his definition allowed for any social cast to express the virtue, only those faced with imminent death were able fully achieve...

Find Another Essay On Proof of Courage

Symbolism in "The Red Badge of Courage" by Stephen Crane

586 words - 2 pages he truly is. The wound is seen as a symbol of courage and bravery. "At times he regarded the wounded soldiers in an envious way... He wished that he, too, had a wound." He felt almost ostracized army after he runs from battle and has no visible proof of gallantry. Ironically when Henry finally receives his "red badge of courage" it is from arguing with a fellow Union soldier. "He adroitly and fiercely swung his rifle. It crushed the youth's head

Henry Flemming and then Red Badge of Courage

1673 words - 7 pages and learned the real meaning of courage (Mitchell, 104). By the end of the novel he has come to realize that to simultaneously prove himself worthy others, he must abandon his selfish tendencies (Delbanco, 46). In doing so, he will also prove to himself that he is worthy as well (Delbanco, 46). Proof of this development is made at the conclusion of the war when Henry gives realistic self evaluation for the first time (Breslin, 6). &nbsp

Rabbit Proof Fence

877 words - 4 pages the film Rabbit Proof Fence, Phillip Noyce uncovers the trauma, upheaval and journey of the victims of the Stolen Generation had to face and come to terms with, how most suffered poor treatment and mental distress. Noyce takes us on a journey through hardship and bravery, he lets us understand that a journey is not only physical but mental too. We see Aboriginals kinship to the land and how they are psychically and emotionally attached to it. One must have determination and courage to succeed through life’s hardships.

Rabbit Proof Fence Review

915 words - 4 pages transporting wide-angle, low-angle imagery that gives a complete sense of the girls' point of view and the vast expanse they face on their journey - emphasizing in turn their remarkable courage.'Rabbit Proof Fence' avoids preaching about the wrongness of the Aborigine Act but, instead, focuses on showing the various sides of the story - the Australians who believe that they are helping the children by separating them from their heritage, the Australians

A Comparison between two film's portraying aboriginal racism-Rabbit Proof Fence and Yolungu Boy

1313 words - 5 pages and gains courage from it looking over her and picks up her sister and carries on. If the eagle had not have appeared she may have well died in the desert with her sister.Most of the symbols focused on in the film are from the white culture. Symbols include walkman, mars bar, clothes cigarettes and a footy. These symbols bring to the film the acceptance of white culture by the aboriginals. In Rabbit Proof Fence, white culture is not freely

Epic Heroes: Sir Gawain and Beowulf

1733 words - 7 pages Arthur. He took on the game because he believed King Arthur’s life was more valuable than his own and that King Arthur should not risk his own life. As a result, Sir Gawain became a knight because of his loyalty and bravery. Both Sir Gawain and the Green Knight’s and Beowulf’s characters share the same quality of courage, the desire to protect people and the involvement of supernatural beings. Beowulf and Sir Gawain share courage in

To Kill A Mockingbird - Relate three incidents where Atticus teaches his children a valuable lesson and explain the important lesson which is learnt. (focus on moral values)

2582 words - 10 pages that it's a sin to kill a mockingbird, what real courage is, and to consider things from other people's perspectives in order to understand them.One of the greatest lessons Jem and Scout learn from their father is that it's a sin to kill a mockingbird. The mockingbird symbolizes Boo Radley and Tom Robinson, who were both peaceful people who never did any harm. To kill or harm them would be a sin. Atticus tells Jem after getting them air rifles

To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee

1658 words - 7 pages . Because of Jem’s integrity, he strongly relates with Tom. Ironically, Jem, who is inspired and somewhat shaped by the events dealing with Tom, is the only one left with physical proof of the whole ordeal. To drag the irony further, Jem, like Tom, both sustained practically the same kind of visible injury on their left arms, at around the same youthful age. His integrity led to his values, his courage led to personality and bravery, and his bravery led

Coming of Age Rituals

1531 words - 6 pages Coming of Age: The Passage to Adulthood Rituals around the world all teach valuable lessons that help initiates see the value and importance of life. Each culture has different rituals that provide experiences for their youth to learn these valuable lessons of life. Many coming of age rituals are intense procedures. The Amazon's Satere Mawé youth enter adulthood through the bullet-ant glove initiation, teaching courage and endurance, and the

Finding Courage To Die. On Hamlet

532 words - 2 pages him, or to actively destroy, in death, these numerous troubles, and ultimately end his pain. Hamlet is questioning whether it is better to live in a world where he cannot see any goodness or take his own life. Hamlet has a very intense, philosophical personality. For this reason, he cannot take his life because he does not know what happens after one dies. He is not positive of an afterlife, therefore he doesn't have the courage to end his life

Analysis Of Sir Gawain's Character

1111 words - 4 pages , but for Arthur’s blood, is not worth much" (SGGK l. 354-357). He asks to be granted the privilege to claim the Green Knight's challenge because it does not befit a king. Proof of Gawain’s character is substantiated by his noble acceptance of the Green Knight’s beheading game in order to “release the king outright from his obligation”(SGGK l. 365). It shows courage and loyalty that even among famed knights such as Sir Bedevere and Lancelot, both

Similar Essays

Harper Lee's, "To Kill A Mockingbird".

578 words - 2 pages hardly takes it as an insult, because he does not think himself better than those men, or any others for that matter. That ability, is proof of not only his courage and his confidence, but of his humility. It takes a rare sort of bravery and security to stand with even the lowest of men as your brothers.Atticus Finch is fighting an uphill battle from the day the case starts. He relies on his courage to help him when faced with the impossible task of

The Search For Heroism Essay

1009 words - 5 pages What defines a hero? What constitutes courage? What separates heroism in battle from aggression, and courage from sheer ignorance? The Red Badge of Courage, by Stephen Crane, attempts to answer these questions through the perspective of a naïve young soldier, fighting during the civil war. The soldier, Henry Fleming, struggles with his desire to obtain a “red badge of courage” as proof of his heroism and transformation from an adolescent into a

Can Reaction To Fear Be Predicted?

1245 words - 5 pages Brandon Weiss; Is there a way to predict those that will confront their fears? While there has been a significant amount of research performed on fear and phobias, as well as on the idea of courage, there has been very little research performed on the relationship of courage to fear. In their article "The role of courage on behavioral approach in a fear-eliciting situation: A proof-of-concept pilot study" they investigate the theory that "courage, as

Henry Fleming Essay

669 words - 3 pages made to suffer from an act, circumstance, agency or condition. In The Red Badge of Courage, Henry Fleming experiences hardships during the war-both mentally and physically. In chapter 9 page 49 Henry explains how he wants a wound like all the other soldiers-thinking that a wound is like "a red badge of courage.". ("At times he...") Henry's longing for a wound is from the fact that he considers a wound to be undeniable proof of courage in battle