Property Law: Resulting Trusts And Constructive Trusts Problem

2992 words - 12 pages

Throughout this report I will try to discuss and critically examine the facts of the case concerned, while doing this I will observe and identify the points which arise on each of the parties and come to a conclusion in whether any beneficial rights in the houses may be claimed by Rachel and Jane and how the size of their shares will be calculated.

Part A (i) (a): Jane

In order to establish express bargain constructive trust there must be an agreement or understanding between the legal owners and non-legal owners to share the equitable interest; the non-legal owners relied on that agreement and acted to their detriment. This is the Lord Bridge's criteria that Jane will need to satisfy using the case of Lloyds Bank plc v Rosset

Where the common intention is founded on express discussions then the existence of such discussions must be clearly established as Lord Steyn stated in Springette v Defoe 'Our law does not allow property rights to be affected by telepathy'. Therefore Jane will have to establish an express discussion.

Creation of the express trust must comply with s53 (1) (B) Law of Property Act 1925 which requires evidence in writing. It will, however be enforceable because constructive trusts are exempted under s53 (2) .

According to Rosset, if Jane is to establish any interest in the property she must bring herself within one of the following categories. First she must show that the legal owner has made an express promise to her that she should have an interest and that she has relied on that promise to her detriment, as in Eves v Eves , Grant v Edwards and Babick v Thompson . Ahmed's words of assurance "in the near future when we marry the house will be yours" count for this purpose.

The payment of the decoration might have been relevant if the couple had been married. There is every chance that Jane could have relied on s37 of the Matrimonial Proceedings and Property Act 1970 to establish a beneficial interest by way of improvement expenditure. However, this is not the case, and it is doubtful whether contributing to the costs of improving a house that is already purchased can, without any agreement to the contrary, give rise to an equitable interest (Bank of India v Mody ). Ahmed had already purchased the house before she moved in however the most important question to ask is 'Whether knowingly or unknowingly , he has allowed or encouraged another to assume to his detriment'(Tailors Fashion Ltd v Liverpool Trustees Co Ltd ).

Claimant must show that he has changed his position in reliance on the representation made by the owner of the land according to the case of Re Basham . This can be physical labour towards renovation of the home as in Eves v Eves , so Jane redesigning interior can count for this purpose.

There must also be a casual link between the representation and the change of positions. There is no casual link between Jane leaving her career interests and Ahmed's assurance as this was made after she had already...

Find Another Essay On Property Law: Resulting Trusts and Constructive Trusts Problem

Moot speech criminal law and property - Monash Uni Law - Speech

1830 words - 8 pages . Three elements must be made out for theft to be committed: appropriating property belonging to another, doing so dishonestly, and doing so with the intention of permanently depriving the property of another. Establishment of these three elements would therefore makes out the crime of theft as per s.74 . In relating this back to the current case, the applicant respectfully submits that an error in law has occurred due to a mistake in the judge’s

Intellectual Property The state of Intellectual Property Law and the current debate in modern society

1836 words - 7 pages attempt to regulate that concept must be vaguely conceived and applied. Because of the rapid growth of technological innovations, and the rapid spread of that information to spur more growth, the law cannot keep up. Most decisions, like the one in the Microsoft case, are outdated almost as soon as they are written into law. The pace of change, the sharing of information, and the use/misuse of intellectual property can only be guided, it cannot be

Wrongful dismissal and summary dismissal: Law problem style question

3900 words - 16 pages the employer, with or without notice; secondly, when a fixed-term contract ends without being renewed and thirdly, if the employee terminates the contract in circumstances whereby they are entitled to claim constructive dismissal.A 'fundamental' breach of contractual terms by either party at common law or statute, may release the parties to the contract, and may justify a summary dismissal (instant dismissal). If the breach by the employee is

Discuess about Pimmel's Law and how this problem involved in consideration

2607 words - 10 pages helpless when their debtors break the promises they made before. However the implement of promissory estoppel solved this problem. The modern promissory estoppel could be found in the case Central London Property Trust v Hign Trees House Ltd. This case is described as follow:In 1939 the Central London Property Trust had a block of flats to lease; the Hign Tree was to sublet the flats to individual tenants and profit form that exercise. However Hign

The underage Drinking Problem and how to prevent youths from consuming alcohol underage. A perspective view of parents, law enforcement, bar owners, and college students

856 words - 3 pages The ongoing act of underage drinking has been a difficult social problem for parents and community members, bar owners and servers, law enforcement officials, and college students to address. As a college student at Oswego State University, I have noticed underage drinking and the violent actions of students that arise from the consumption of alcohol. The entire situation appalls me.In reading the article entitled, "Taking Aim at Underage

Business Law Defining Concepts and Problem Solving

1156 words - 5 pages relied on it in deciding to buy the motel. After an unprofitable year Mr. Bedard found out the information received about the revenues and profits was false. He comes to you for advice as to his options. What do you advise and why?This problem involves the concept of fraudulent misrepresentation occurring in the course of negotiating a contract.A fraudulent misrepresentation occurs when a party makes a deliberately false statement of fact and that

Take the book 'A Civil Action' by Jonathan Harr and outline this case. Discuss the problem of people whose health is affected by toxic industrial pollution in obtaining compensation under civil law

2643 words - 11 pages that the leukemia was a direct result of drinking contaminated water from two city wells. The children fell ill between 1969 and 1979 with the wells finally being shut down in 1979.The case, labeled an 'orphan', had been passed between many law firms and it was Anne Anderson, mother of Jimmy Anderson who had died from leukemia, who contacted Schlichtmann and his colleagues about undertaking the case. Schlichtmann sat on the case for many years

Laws Regarding the Estate of Those Deceased

2139 words - 9 pages clearly referable to the acquisition of the house and as such should be seen as purchase money. In the absence of any declaration of trust, the parties respective beneficial interests of the property fail to be determined not by reference to any broad concept of justice, but by reference to the principle governing the creation or operation of resulting, implied or constructive trusts which by s. 53(2) of the Law of

Do you think that the courts should have a statutory discretion to determine the effects of illegality in resulting trust cases?

1725 words - 7 pages . [2000] "Illegal transactions: chaos or discretion?" Journal of Legal Studies 20(2).Creighton, P. [1997] "The Recovery of Property Transferred for Illegal Purposes" The Modern Law Review 60 (1)Enonchong, N. [1994] "Illegality: The Fading Flame of Public Policy" Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 14 (1)REPORTSIllegal Transactions: The Effect of Illegality on Contracts and Trusts, Law Commission Consultation Paper NO 154 [1999].

A trust is a relationship formed at the direction of someone, in which one or more persons hold - University - Essay

1716 words - 7 pages Equity and Trusts A trust is a relationship formed at the direction of someone, in which one or more persons hold the individuals’ property subject to certain obligations to use and guard it for the advantage of others. There are two common types of trusts; express and implied. Express trusts are usually created by a person orally or in the form of a written statement and involve all the parties concerned; whereas implied trusts are created by


2054 words - 9 pages . There have been attempts by the courts to address this, resulting in a ‘patchwork’ approach to the jurisdiction. They currently use proprietary estoppel and express or constructive trusts in cases such as Stack v Dowden but these remedies are not comprehensive and sometimes give rise to unsatisfactory financial outcomes for one party , which can ultimately lead to reliance on the state. There is a marked difference in the way cohabitants and

Similar Essays

Remedial Constructive Trusts Essay

2262 words - 9 pages "There is a great fear in our law that recognising a remedial constructive trust will give rise to an indiscriminate or unjustified variation of existing property rights." Graham Moffat: Trusts Law Text and Materials (1999) Discuss.A constructive trust is not the usual kind of trust encountered in Equity. It is a trust which is different from other trusts in that is imposed by a court of law and it cannot be created by an individual. It is

Constitution Of Express Trusts/Uk Law Essay

1606 words - 6 pages PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Property 2Constitution is the last of the formalities that the law requires to create an effective and enforceable trust. Failure to constitute a trust will mean that no gift or trust is applicable; and the law that relates to perfect constituted gifts and trusts will not be appropriate. Moreover, the axiom of equity will intervene: "equity will not perfect an imperfect gift". The state of equity at the start of 21st

"To What Extent Should The Law Recognise Non Charitable Purpose Trusts?"

1460 words - 6 pages perpetuity and will therefore be valid. Trusts for the saying of masses are often also valid because there is a close religious link; Re Hetherington [1990] . Trusts for the maintenance of particular animals (such as in the case of Re Dean (1889)) may also be held valid because there is the ability to establish certainty of object, being the animals.It is a general rule that the law does not recognise non-charitable purpose trusts and they are

Equity And Trusts Sussex University

2751 words - 12 pages Can imperfect gifts or incomplete declaration of trusts can be validated? To form a valid trust, it is a necessary that the gift or the trust property be completely constituted. This requires the conferring of the trust property in the trustees for the benefit of the beneficiaries. This problem question deals with incomplete formalities, imperfect constituted gifts and incomplete declaration gift of trusts. Through case laws, I will identify