Prophets Facing Backward: Postmodern Critiques Of Science And Hindu Nationalism In India

3403 words - 14 pages

Meera Nanda's book Prophets Facing Backward is an extraordinary and compelling book. Few in the West are aware of the alarming confluence of ideas arising out of the contemporary nationalistic politics of India with its endorsement of 'Vedic science' and the dominant postmodernist, social constructivist and sociological trends in science studies in the West. Nanda's book is an intellectual bombshell dropped on this potent combination. No one interested in the ways in which science and culture can interact should ignore this book and the challenging case it makes against the prevailing orthodoxies of much that passes for Western science 'studies'. It should serve for years to come as a reference point for what can go wrong in science studies when it is allied with fashionable but wrongheaded, and even deeply perverse, manqué 'epistemologies', such as those provided in postmodernism, social constructivism and their ilk.

Nanda describes a phenomenon in India that strongly resembles what Jeffery Herf calls 'reactionary modernism' in his study of the Weimar Republic and the Third Reich. This is an outlook that enabled Germans to accept modern scientific technology while at the same time they adopted politically illiberal and reactionary policies and rejected much of the rationality of the enlightenment that informs science. Her thesis is that contemporary India is in the grip of a version of reactionary modernism in which political nationalism is accompanied by technological advance; but the science that informs it has been stripped of its enlightenment context and relocated within the context of nationalistic religion, 'Vedic Science'. The stripping and relocation fits admirably with doctrines from Western science studies that claim that all knowledge is 'local', that scientific belief is culturally caused, that power and knowledge are one, that there is no universal rationality to science and that all scientific belief and its rationality is relative to its socio-political and cultural context.

It is not as if the advocates of 'Vedic Science' are avid readers of Foucault's writings on 'power/knowledge', or the sociologists' advocacy of the Strong Programme for explaining scientific belief, or Latour's advocacy of might over the possibility of being right in science, and so on for many other such claims in postmodernist and 'social constructivist' writings about science. But Nanda tells us that they do cite some Kuhn and Feyerabend, and they do know that in the West there are those who decry modernity and debunk the enlightenment pretensions of defenders of the rationality of science. For such nationalists this is enough to justify their separation of science from broader aspects of enlightenment rationality and its relocation in a different socio-political and religious setting; in so doing they create a distinctive 'Vedic Science'.

Nanda's (and Herf's) analysis challenges the widespread belief that science with its potential for a...

Find Another Essay On Prophets Facing Backward: Postmodern Critiques of Science and Hindu Nationalism in India

Visions of Utopia in Bellamy's Looking Backward

744 words - 3 pages Visions of Utopia in Looking Backward   Edward Bellamy addressed many of the topics crucial to the development of a civilization in his book, Looking Backward. In the story he addresses several different features of years past utopias. Some being "universal harmony, distribution of occupation according to individual aptitudes, equality of reward, universal ease and comfort, reduction of hours of labor, suppression of idleness, of

Ancient India: Advances in Science Essay

1664 words - 7 pages The Ancient Indian civilization made many signifigent advances in fields of science including mathmatics, astronomy, chemistry and medicine. In India, mathematics has its roots in Vedic literature which is nearly 4000 years old. (Ifrah 52) Indians made many advances in Mathematics and Astronomy but also made more practical advances as in the applied sciences like production technology, architecture and shipbuilding. At it's peak, Indian society

Appliation of Leviatian and looking Backward

2087 words - 9 pages Thomas Hobbes and Edward Bellamy have two different views on how society should be governed. Thomas Hobbes in the Leviathan has outlined how he perceives human nature and the best form of government to control our nature. In Looking Backward by Edward Bellamy he has outlined a future utopia; a look at a government after many years of not being successful. In this paper there is going to a problem and using Looking Backward and the Leviathan the

The importance of Dharma and Karma in Hindu Literature.

1753 words - 7 pages Gita. According to the Gita, Dharma is the purpose of life.Hindu Dharma, popularly called Hinduism, is the religion of over a billion Hindus, who mostly live in India, but have large populations in many other countries. Hindu Dharma is also known as Vaidika Dharma, meaning "religion of the Vedas," the ancient Hindu scriptures. The original name of Hindu Dharma is Sanãtana Dharma, or "universal religion." .Unlike other religions, Hindu

The Power of Karma in Buddhist and Hindu Cultures

691 words - 3 pages “Why are you acting like that? Don’t you want to go to heaven?” Chances are we have all heard something like this at some point in our lives because in Western society the dominant religion is Christianity. This religion brings the promise of heaven and eternal life to its greatest followers. However, this is not the case in the Eastern world particularly in India where Hinduism brings the promise of moksha to its followers and Buddhism brings

Role of seers or prophets in Sophocles' tragedies.

1220 words - 5 pages "We cannot believe, we cannot deny; all is dark."(King Oedipus, pg. 39) Throughout the tragedies of Sophocles there are seers and prophets and the resolution of whether to believe their predictions or to disregard them. This internal struggle of belief causes the prophets to play a major role in the outcome of events in both King Oedipus and Antigone.In the two tragedies by Sophocles there are prophets made and the characters who hear them are

The Microcredit Foundation of India and Poverty in India

1131 words - 5 pages The Microcredit Foundation of India is a non- profit organization, and effective tool for alleviating poverty. The Microcredit Foundation has its base located in southern rural India. Microcredit works with just about everyone who needs their help; however their focus is women. Microcredit presents the women of rural communities with the opportunity to start a business. The services of micro credit are dedicated to creating a better stable

Analysis of a Hindu Reflection and Research

1820 words - 7 pages as a world religion. This has only recently happened with the last couple of centuries. This occurred because “Hindu reformers and Western orientalists came to refer to the diverse beliefs and practices characterizing religious life in South Asia as ‘Hinduism’ (Partridge, 168).” Unlike most other religions, Hinduism has no single founder, no single scripture, and no commonly agreed set of teachings (“Hinduism”). According to Merriam-Webster

Reflections of Peace and Nationalism in Sri Lankan Literature

885 words - 4 pages defining postcolonial national reality? How do these imaginings or reflections of peace, in turn shape ideas of nationalism? Transition sentence here. The doctoral research that I hope to pursue at -------------- intends to analyse these questions more systemically (more thoroughly?). My research archive would cover Anglophone literary production from Sri Lanka between 1983 and 2009 - the time period of the ethnic war between.... Through this archive

Critiques of Ernest Hemingway's Novel, Death in the Afternoon

1481 words - 6 pages Critiques of Ernest Hemingway's Novel, Death in the Afternoon Ernest Hemingway's Death in the Afternoon shows a new side of Hemingway's writing which initially disappointed the critics. Published in 1932, Death in the Afternoon was not the expected fictional novel, but instead was more of a nonfiction description of bullfighting and Spanish culture in the 1920's and 1930's. In Curtis Patterson's words, "It is a tripartite work

David Hume and Karl Marx’s Critiques of Religion

1287 words - 5 pages representing different critiques of religion. There are three principal characters in the Dialogues. A character named Cleanthes defends an a posteriori design argument for God’s existence. Next, a character named Demea defends an a priori casual argument for God’s existence. Philo is a skeptic who argues against both a posteriori and a priori proofs. Hume in the dialogue states “Whatever exists must have a cause or reason of its existence; it being

Similar Essays

Nationalism In Mexico, Japan And India

1246 words - 5 pages history as well as by territory. Nationalism was strongly seen in Europe and Asia during and after World War II. Among the countries in those continents lie Japan, India and Mexico, which is part of the Americas.         In Japan, nationalism was used to make the country unite to invade China and expand its territories. Historians can say that unlike Mexico and India, Japan is one of the countries that used nationalism in a malicious way

Hindu Muslim Antagonism In India Essay

1308 words - 5 pages Qinxin RenANT 324Prof. Van HollenOctober 26, 2013 Hindu-Muslim Antagonism in IndiaOver the past thirty years, the relationship between Hindus and Muslims in India has largely been marked by tensions and turbulence. Since the early 1980s, recurring communal violence between the top two religions of India has taken place in the form of intense public riots. The reason for such violence, as many scholars believe, lies primarily in the fundamentally

Exploring The Hindu Caste System Of India

2803 words - 11 pages and economic differences in the subcontinent of India. In English, castes are defined as a ranking system, however in the Indian culture, castes are two separate but related concepts: Varna and Jati. Varna consists of the main four groups seen as castes: Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vaishyas, and Sudras. The Untouchables are a separate sub-caste assigned jobs that would pollute or shun the other four higher classes. Jati refers to the occupations

The Clash Between Nehruvian Secularism And Hindu Nationalism

2926 words - 12 pages India has a long and very complex history due to its massive diversity of different cultures, traditional, religions and due to the period of British rule. This has collaborated in forming India today. In the birth of India as a nation, Nehruvian secularism and Hindu nationalism were the main ideals of how India should be formed. The following essay shall discuss how these two ideals clash, taking into context of the history and social character