Proposition 227 California Law Essay

2485 words - 10 pages

The issue of English language learners (ELL) and their rights to an education has been a major topic of debate for many years. Should ELL students be taught in their first language? Will they learn English, or should they be put into English speaking classes? That has been the topic of discussion amongst educators. Which method is better for the student? The arguments continue and many states and school districts have made a decision on what to do. One state in particular had a serious ELL problem, so California took action. In 1998, California implemented a program called Proposition 227.
Proposition 227 was legislation that was put to a vote by the California government. Proposition 227 was passed on June 2, 1998. Proposition 227 changed the way schools were to teach to ELL students. Before proposition 227, ELL students were taught in their first language and English was mixed in. The hope was that eventually the ELL students would be placed in all English classes. The ELL students would be slowly weaned into the all English classes. Wit the passage of Proposition 227, that all had to change. The state of California was taking their education philosophy in a different direction.
Proposition 227 stated that all classes in the state of California were to be taught in all English programs. The ELL students had to be placed in all English classes with the English speaking students. The ELL students were forced to speak English when they were in school, no matter how well they understood English. Proposition 227 was a push for the use of a single language in schools. The goal was to get all students in the California school system to speak and understand English. The new law was a drastic change but the voters of California felt strongly enough to vote Proposition 227 into law.
When Proposition 227 was voted in, it was challenged in the California State Courts almost immediately. "The legislative language of Proposition 227 was sufficiently vague and thus created other problems."1 Torrez. Pg. 208. The legislatures wording of Proposition 227 was unclear and left a great deal of the legislation open to interpretation. The wording was not black and white; there was great deal of gray area. This only helped to cause more confusion amongst the school districts. "The law, itself, spoke to specific changes and mentioned curriculum issues. Yet, there was no money set aside to create the new curricular approach, and no plan to in-service teachers in the new methodology to be utilized". 2 Torrez, 2001, pg. 208. There also was no time line in place for the implementation of the new mandated changes. The proposition had been passed but it had not been thought through. The politicians wanted this piece of legislation passed but they did not thoroughly research their new legislation.
The legislators created Proposition 227 because the people of California wanted such a law enacted. That is why the people of California voted for the...

Find Another Essay On Proposition 227- California Law

The California State Public Education System

2482 words - 10 pages grades, with 33% of students being second-generation or new immigrant children who are learning English as a second English enrolled in kindergarten through Grade 3 (California Department of Education). But when the Proposition 227 (P-227), placed severe restrictions on bilingual education programs implemented under federal and state laws since the 1974 Lau v. Nichols U.S Supreme Court ruling delineating the rights of language minority students

This essay compares the views of booker t washington and DU bois.

542 words - 2 pages Prop 54 is a California constitutional initiative that will come before voters in the next statewide election, currently scheduled for October 7, 2003. The point that will be targeted are health care, school reforms, law enforcement, last but not civil rights. Prop 54 is a Racial Privacy Initiative this is a banning racial preference in state admissions, hiring and public contracting. Being the latest initiative designed to change the way

The Necessity Of Bilingual Education In Our Society

1744 words - 7 pages English (theS.A.D.I.E. method ) when the student reached the intermediate level in English. In 1986 a request for a six year extension of the law was vetoed by the Governor, who found it lacked " methodological and implementation flexibility." Efforts to implement the act failed again in 1987 . Until the passing of Proposition 227 the education of thousands of students that fall into the category of being Limited English , Non English or

California's Proposition 8

943 words - 4 pages LGBT couples were equal to all other couples would lead to a natural change in the education system to reflect that. Even if they were right however, California law states that a parent has the right to withdraw their child from any lesson on health or sexuality that they disagree with. The final and greatest reason why people supported Proposition 8 was simply because of their beliefs in the “traditional” family. Many Americans had a lot of

The Never-Ending Search for Civil Rights

1236 words - 5 pages On November 4, 2008 thousands of California citizens lost their constitutional rights to marriage. With a 52% majority, Proposition 8 passed, changing the words of the constitution to ban same-sex marriage. The Proposition proposed that the California constitution should add the following statement, “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.” These new fourteen words not only eliminate same-sex couples the

The Debate Over Bilingual Education and Immersion Programs

3838 words - 15 pages in his native language – will be equally successful in an English immersion program like ESOL? For that matter, who is to say they won’t? The efficacy of second-language instruction, just like any other kind of instruction, varies with each child, for many reasons. In California, with the passage of Proposition 227 (which eliminated a majority of the state’s bilingual education programs), the number of students enrolled in bilingual

Municipal Budgeting and Revenue

2493 words - 10 pages proposition that has changed the way California cities have been financed for the past fifteen years is Proposition 13. Proposition 13 was passed by the voters in June of 1978 to amend California’s Constitution to incorporate a limit on local governments ability to impose property taxes. The proposition basically states that the maximum amount of tax cannot exceed one percent of the full cash value of the property. After Proposition 13 was enacted

California's Promise

1882 words - 8 pages understand why and how California lost its greatness. Once we analyze the core problems of the state, such as the initiative process, the state legislature, and misrepresentation of the public, we will have a better understanding of how to tackle the issue. First, an obvious problem of the state is the usage of the initiative process. Originally, it gave “Californians the power to propose constitutional amendments and law that fellow citizens

Substance Abuse Treatment and Proposition 36

1258 words - 5 pages incarcerating offenders who have substance abuse related issues instead of providing a way for treatment or rehabilitation outside of incarceration. Through public policies regarding criminal justice interventions that address drug use and crime, an initiative was created to provide treatment services as a diversion to incarceration. The Diversion-to-Treatment Law that was created in California is called Proposition 36 also known as the “Substance


6319 words - 25 pages expectations and he may be right (Schrag 157). Unz argued that the system didn't work, because fewer than 7% of immigrant, migrant, and refugee students became fluent each year. The Silicon Valley entrepreneur developed Proposition 227 in an effort to dismantle the unsuccessful bilingual educational program in the California. All of the evidence early on suggested that Proposition 227 would have desirable effects on California's bilingual

Americans Must Share a Common Language, English

2213 words - 9 pages 1998: A1. [11] "An End to Bilingual Education," BBC News, 3 June 1998, Online, available 3 Dec 1998, [12] Daniel B. Wood, "Vote to Eliminate Bilingual Education in California Resonates Nationwide," Christian Science Monitor 4 June 1998: 10. [13] "First Students Test California's 'English Immersion' Law," CNN Interactive, 3 Aug 1998, Online, available 3 Dec 1998, [14] Nanette Asimov, "Prop. 227 Upheld by U.S. Judge 'No constitutional right to bilingual education'," San Francisco Chronicle, 16 July 1998: A1.  

Similar Essays

Fight To Preserve Latino Heritage Essay

1296 words - 5 pages retention of unity and “American-ness” in California. However, the restriction of foreign languages in response to this may be seen as a form of discrimination. Furthermore, those who do not believe in either the necessity or the efficacy of Proposition 227 argue that the said appendage of the local educational law is discriminatory; if the government can support teachers in the pursuit of proper education using English, then surely it is also

Bilingual Education Essay

1354 words - 5 pages . However, in 1998 California passed the law (Proposition 227) prohibiting bilingual education for the majority of the students. Therefore, in current Brown v. Board of Education 1954 unlocked the progression for individuals to cause uncertainty of identity, intergroup relations, and psychology of unfairness and or partiality to the forefront of discussions that educators and the public have regarding educational policy (Zirkel & Cantor, 2004

Billingul Education And Ron Unz Essay

503 words - 2 pages Newsweek magazine.They are both very successful articles that carry their main idea with details, examples and facts. Their main idea talks about the removal of bilingual education of school programs in California and about Ron Unz, who is the person behind this movement. The titles of these articles are "The Man behind Proposition 227" and the second article is titled "Habla Ingles, Por Favor." Both articles give details and examples about

Family Essay

970 words - 4 pages law. In 1999, the California Legislature enacted a statewide domestic partnership registry. Adding FC sections 297-299.6. Proposition 22 was passed by the California voters in November of 2000. The passing of this initiative added section 308.5 to the Family Code which provides that: “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.” Proposition 22 was one of a number of similar measures that were proposed and