Protecting Human Rights Essay

1019 words - 4 pages

19. When, if ever, should states intervene in the domestic affairs of other states to protect human rights? Are there certain rights that are more vital than others? What are the costs and benefits to the great powers for intervening on behalf of human rights?

These questions are difficult to answer. Nobody wants to see any human rights violations. However, defining what human rights are varies by country and even by individuals. What one nation believes to be a human right, another may not. Then there is the dilemma of a nation’s sovereignty. If another nation decides which human rights are being violated and decides that it needs to intervene, then will another nation determine that the intervening nation needs intervention because of their human rights violations? Finally, there is the question of the intervention itself. The levels of intervention may vary and depend on the human rights violations. Violations that are more serious require tougher interventions.
The first question to answer is should states ever intervene in the domestic affairs of other states. The simple answer is that they should. The United States is founded on principles, many of which can be attributed to John Locke. In defining human rights, the Declaration of Independence, which Thomas Jefferson wrote and who was inspired by Locke, states, “that all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness-that to secure these Rights, Governments are instituted among Men.” Locke used similar wording and added the simple answer to the question of intervention. The foremost responsibility, which each individual has, is self-preservation. After which Locke stated, “By like reason, when his own preservation comes not in competition, ought he, as much as he can, to preserve the rest of mankind” (Locke 1690). As much as one state can assist other individuals within another state to preserve these same rights, ought to be done as much as possible.
The rights that ought to be preserved are the rights that Locke described. Life is the first priority. It is also the most serious violation of human rights known. Therefore, if a state chooses to intervene it must be the most severe form of intervention. However, as Locke stated, when one’s own preservation is in jeopardy, then it is not required. If the violation was one individual, it may not be prudent to start a war. Other means should be used. However, when genocide or any other form of mass murder is occurring, then there is little question that intervention ought to be chosen. For example, between February and September of 1988, Saddam Hussein murdered between 50,000 and 100,000 Kurds (Human Rights Watch 2006). This is one of many examples of a case of intervention.
The cost of American lives or a coalition of nations’ lives would be serious. However, the lives saved would likely have...

Find Another Essay On Protecting Human Rights

Human Resource Management Essay

830 words - 3 pages improve their skills and knowledge as well as treat and respect them. Organizations however want to keep and attract talented and valuable employees. Human Resource managers have a direct responsibility to respect human rights within their organization or company. Government according to the universal declaration is responsible for promoting and protecting rights within organizations and businesses. Human rights principles within an

The United Nations and Human Rights: Has the United Nations failed in its determination to support and advocate for human rights?

3896 words - 16 pages that these methods be analyzed in their approach, impact, and effectiveness at shedding light on human rights violations, thus improving the status of human rights, and protecting the rights and fundamental freedoms from any further attack. This, in turn, helps to advance the freedoms of all persons, generating improvements in the overall quality of life that each person may receive as a result from having these international rights and freedoms

Kant vs. Mill: Human Rights and Utilitarianism

2106 words - 8 pages safeguard these important conditions that form the basis of human rights (Denise, Peterfreund & White, 1999). According to Kant, human beings have the capacity to exercise reason, and this is what forms the basis for protecting human dignity. This exercise of reason must meet the standards of universality, in that the laws formulated must be capable of being accepted universally by all equally rational individuals (Doyle, 1983). Various accounts

Women to Lead the Human Rights Revolution

2309 words - 9 pages all. Men must realize that they are narrowing the agenda and inhibiting true social change toward peace and democratization when they keep women out of leadership positions. On the way to assuming leadership, human rights education is one of the imperatives that women must adopt. To learning about human rights, men must join women in promoting and protecting women's human rights as part of the larger agenda of social change. As leaders, women need

How effectively does Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms protect Individual Rights?

1323 words - 5 pages was guilty, the court had to drop the charge because it was violating the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” (Issues for Canadians, 2008, pp. 93-96) The Charter did an effective job in protecting the student’s legal rights even though the student was guilty. Even as a convicted criminal, you are still guaranteed rights that protect you in the Charter. You cannot be subject to beating, abuse or any type of assault. “ A couple of years ago, in the

The Importance of Human Development in Terms of Living Conditions in Different Countries

986 words - 4 pages The Importance of Human Development in Terms of Living Conditions in Different Countries Human development is very important in terms of living conditions in different countries. The statement “any society committed to improving the lives of its people must also be committed to full and equal rights for all” is true. The UN considers three factors to calculate human development in a country. These factors cover many aspects of a

Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms

1294 words - 5 pages court had to drop the charge because it was violating the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.” (Nelson Education, 2008) The Charter did an effective job in protecting the student’s legal rights even though the student was guilty. Even as a convicted criminal, you are still guaranteed rights that protect you in the Charter. You cannot be subject to beating, abuse or any type of assault. “Recently in the Edmonton Institution, which is a federal

International Human Rights and Humanitarian Law

1077 words - 5 pages Introduction While there exist distinct points of difference, principles of international human rights laws and international humanitarian law overlap on multiple occasions. It is both interesting and informative to understand the differences and similarities in these principles between the two. Differences include underlying intention behind formulation, range of application and effect on different parties while similari underlying enactment

Inaccurate View of the Legal System

1638 words - 7 pages Although often interpreted differently by individuals, legal rights, human rights and the jury system are essential features of the legal system. Nielsen believes that the main purpose of rights is to protect individuals, while Hajjar portrays the objective of the legal system as recognizing and respecting certain inherent human rights. Further, Dooley understands the jury system as essential for ensuring a democratic and fair trial

Human Rights

1540 words - 6 pages one day. To even make a dent in preventing human rights violationsthe international community needs to come together and work as one. The new millennium isan opportunity for the world to come together and uphold the rights that the people weregiven by their founding fathers. Within the next few years great strides will be taken toprotect the people of all nations in this world. Protecting ones inalienable rights islife long conquest. The

Convention of Human Rights

1547 words - 6 pages Steiner,H(2000) the African Charter of Human Rights provides for the right to life, and made mention of this right in four article of the Charter. Building on what is stated in the Charter, all human beings should have this right and no one can take away this right. In addition, this right and other rights which are mentioned in the Charter are protecting by law . However, there are some aspects still unclear, because the Charter doses not

Similar Essays

Fundamentals Of Law Essay

1007 words - 4 pages of RightsHuman rights involve the inherent dignity and security of all human beings. Human right laws are about defining and outlining human rights and providing legal protections for the rights. These legal protections of basic human rights is often found in a 'Bill of Rights' or a 'Charter of Rights' which refers to type of laws that protect an individual's human rights For Against A Bill of Rights would recognise and protect universal

Human Rights Issues Essay

1660 words - 7 pages support of human rights is essentially connected to its mission to proclaim the Gospel" (Hollenbach 4). Promoting and protecting the rights of all God's people is viewed as a moral act and anything done to counteract the progress of human rights is seen as an act against God in the eyes of the Catholic Church. Human rights is directly linked to the vocation of every Christian and the Church's mission. (Council for the Family, 32). It is every

Human Rights And Human Rights Organisations

2596 words - 10 pages rights are inherently irreconcilable. Increasingly it is accepted that individual and collective rights are concerned with conceptually distinct claims and can exist concurrently. Collective rights can be interpreted and applied in a manner consistent with individual human rights."2. Outline the major international declarations/ agreements conceived with the aim of protecting human rightsThere are many treaties, declarations and agreements that

Violation Of Human Rights Essay

1142 words - 5 pages ://twocircles.net/2012jul18/torture_one Definition of Human Rights Video | What Are Human Rights? : United for Human Rights. Definition of Human Rights Video | What Are Human Rights? : United for Human Rights. Web. 21 Nov. 2013. Retrieved from . Djafar, Wahyudi . "Protecting privacy rights from wiretapping." Home.Web.21 Feb 2013 . 22 Nov. 2013. Retrieved from :