Protestant King And Catholic Sister Essay

1234 words - 5 pages

This is a summary of the Article "Elizabeth I: Exception to the Rule" by Helen Castor in History Today. In the article, Castor analyzes the history of queens and queenship itself in medieval England. In this day and age it is very common to see a woman obtaining complete power, whether it be something as simple as choosing what she wears, to it being something as complex as making the final decisions in a successful corporation, which she happens to own. Woman as a whole have made tremendous leaps towards equality over the centuries and will continue to do so.
Having a female monarch seemed utterly unnatural in the 12th century and there was a harsh civil war due to Matilda's claim to the throne. Until the second half of the 16th century, England had been ruled by kings. The unexpected death of Edward VI in 1553 presented the opportunity for the crown to be passed to two queens, Mary Tudor also known as the infamous bloody Mary and Elizabeth I also known as the virgin queen.
In medieval England the power of the crown was male. A woman was categorized as incompetent to carry out the obligations of a king, such as upholding order within the kingdom and defending the country. A queen was meant to be the wife of a king and to exemplify the feminine aspects of law making and war, not his equivalent. This is the reason for Henry VIII's persistence to father a son to commence a memorable line of Tudor kings. Despite the absence of a law constraining a female from inheriting the crown as there was in France, Henry didn't consider that he may have left his thrown to a woman.
After the abrupt death of Louis X in 1316, it was determined that the king's brother, Phillip should succeed him, instead of his four-year-old daughter Joan. Joan was considered damaged goods due to her mother, Margaret of Burgundy, being imprisoned for adultery. This example of governance was later moved into the Salic Law, by which women were ostracized from either inheriting or passing on a claim to the French throne. In Castile the reign of the 12th-century Queen Urraca encouraged the accession to the throne of Queen Isabella three centuries later. Which aided Henry's rejected wife Catherine of Aragon, and also proving that her own daughter Mary was a deserving successor to the throne.
England's history as a country was not so encouraging. Instead of Matilda's claim to the throne resulting in England's first female monarch, it caused a 18 year civil war. Matilda's prerogative to the throne as the heir of her father, Henry I, were justified in the Treaty of Winchester that ended the war in 1135, but only through her son, who became king as Henry II. At the time male offsprings of royal woman could succeed the throne. Henry VII's claim to the throne depended upon a woman, his grandmother, the Lancastrian heiress, Margaret Beaufort.
Although Henry VIII had no intentions to die while his heir, Edward was still a child, he stood ready to succeed him, thanks to the finest education...

Find Another Essay On Protestant King and Catholic Sister

Protestant Reformation in England Essay

1013 words - 4 pages and silver went to the Crown. By the time of Henry's death in 1547, England was not completely a Protestant nation. Henry's successor, his son Edward VI, would further progress what his father had already started.Edward's reign as king lasted from 1547 to 1553. He had been brought up as a Protestant which differed him from his father who was brought up Catholic. Although he was only 9 years old when he assumed power, he had two advisors who

English Christanity Essay

1080 words - 5 pages , was made guardian and ruled in Edwards place. Somerset together with Archbishop Cranmer began to turn England into a Protestant country (Lambert, 2014). After Edwards’s death in 1553 his half-sister Mary I (1516-58) became Queen. Mary who was a devout Catholic began to undo the changes that Edward and Henry had started and set the nation back to Catholic faith. During her rein (1553-1558) hundreds of Protestants, who refused to turn Catholic

Henry VIII and His Six Wives

1808 words - 7 pages control England. Protestants were happy the young king was on the thrown but feared what would happen if he died. It was common knowledge that Mary, the king's oldest daughter and next heir would turn England back to Roman Catholism. Some began rallying behind Lady Jane Grey, a descendant of Henry VIII's sister, Mary. Lady Jane Grey On July 6,1553 the king died and Lady Jane Grey was proclaimed Queen. Nine days later Mary and her followers

Elizabeth I

2157 words - 9 pages not rule yet. Unfortunately, she would have to rule after her half-sister Mary I, also known as “Bloody Mary” who married Phillip of Spain. Mary I was catholic, of course, which created a catholic-relationship between her and the pope which later caused problems for Elizabeth I. Mary I wanted to undo all that was enforced by her half-brother Edward VI who died in 1553. Mary I changed all that was enforced by her deceased protestant brother. When

The Extent to Which England was a Protestant Country by 1547

976 words - 4 pages supremacy. Henry VIII also made the change between Catholicism and Protestantism extremely confused. After having a protestant influenced wife from Lutheran Germany the king was then married to a religiously conservative catholic. After executing Cromwell for his advanced religious ideas and arresting a religious conservative, Henry VIII also executed his Catholic wife and remarried to Catherine Parr who again had

The causes of the gunpowder plot and the reasons they had

864 words - 3 pages religious differences and direction of England. Though both Puritan's as well as Catholic, demands were rejected, the Catholics were especially upset by the failure of the new King - son of Mary Queen of Scots- to support the Catholic faith. To make matters worse, James I added extra pressure and new laws (under the Protestant parliament) to expel Catholic priests. This infuriated Catholics further. Even after this he tried to appear innocent but

The Thirty Years War

728 words - 3 pages a whole may be considered a struggle of German Protestant princes and foreign powers (France, Sweden, Denmark, England, the United Provinces) against the unity and power of the Holy Roman Empire as represented by the Hapsburgs, allied with the Catholic princes, and against the Hapsburgs themselves.The war began with the resistance and eventual revolt of Protestant nobles in Bohemia, which was under Hapsburg domination, against the Catholic king

Conflict in Northern Ireland

1475 words - 6 pages anything about Catholicism, they were only taught about Protestant history. Children grew up believing that Catholics were evil and the Protestant religion was the way forward. "We knew nothing of the Catholic world. That Catholics were allowed to live in London with our Protestant king seemed impossible" (2) Another significant social problem at the time for Catholic people was that they were placed in

The Reign of Queen Elizabeth I

1768 words - 7 pages queen the country was religiously divided (Hilliam 40). Before her father King Henry VIII died, he left the Catholic Church and started the Church of England also known as the Anglican Church. It was a part of the Protestant movement happening in Europe lead by Martian Luther. When Elizabeth’s half sister Mary I became queen she reconverted England back to Catholicism (Hilliam 40). Elizabeth always wanted to try and please her subjects, so she

The Life of Mary Tudor

1015 words - 5 pages . On July 19, Mary had been proclaimed queen and she finally in position to bring England back to Catholic Church. Mary had every protestant burned at the stake. The total death count of the people Mary had killed was over three hundred. That is how she got the nickname Bloody Mary. At age thirty seven, Mary knew she needed a catholic heir or her half-sister Elizabeth would take the throne as a protestant. Since Mary was queen she could marry

The Legacy of Edward VI as Explained in Tudor Church Militant: Edward VI and the Protestant Reformation

1044 words - 5 pages critical moment in the progress of the Anglican Church and the establishing of England’s Protestant identity. The aim of this book is to recapture King Edward’s reformation of the Church of England from revisionists such as Haigh, Duffy and Pollard. They and others viewed that the reorganisation of the church was indecisive, weak and insignificant. MacCulloch intends to argue that the reformation was essentially consistent, effective and ultimately a

Similar Essays

Protestant And Catholic Conflict In The Elizabethan Era

2616 words - 10 pages Catholic conflict during the Elizabethan era boasted numerous accomplishments in the fields of history, art, philosophy, sconce, and literature with a major contribution to humankind. The decades long battle between the Protestants and Catholics began when the Protestant ruler, Elizabeth I became the Queen of England after her Catholic half-sister, Mary I died. Before Queen Elizabeth I’s reign, Mary’s support of the Roman Catholic Church

Differences Between A Catholic And A Protestant Mass

1277 words - 6 pages I am a nondenominational Christian and I decided to attend a catholic mass. I attended mass at the Conversion of St Paul Parish on April 6, 2014. The preside was Father Senan Glass and the starting time was 10am. The Conversion of St Paul Parish’s location is 4120 Euclid Ave, Cleveland, Ohio 44103. The church was very big and the stain glass windows were beautiful. At first, I felt uncomfortable because I did not know where to sit or what to

Protestant Dbq What Are The Differences Between The Catholic And Protestant Churches During The First Years Of The Break

653 words - 3 pages Francis 1Tara FrancisMrs. BowmanAP European History Period: G2 October 2013Protestant and Catholic DBQAt the eve of the Reformation, the Catholic Church's future was not looking bright. Corruption and money had taken control of the Church and many of its influential leaders. The Protestant Reformation was an attempt to get away from the corruption of the Church, but in essence it is still very similar in beliefs. The Protestants deviated from

King Arthur And The Catholic Church

603 words - 2 pages The Catholic Church has many influences on King Arthur and the rest of his Knights of the Round Table. The knights depended on the church for its teachings and the great power the church held in society. The Knights of the Round Table pledged great loyalty to the church. Also the knights held the teachings of the church in great reverence and were never disloyal to the church. There are many links between the Catholic Church and the way that