This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Psychiatric Advance Directives Versus Recipient Rights

1146 words - 5 pages

Introduction and Scenario Description
When a patient enters the hospital, he or she expects the health care professionals to treat him or her with respect and fairness. The hospitals, clinics, and other healthcare settings should deserve and be reputed with a strong set of ethical principles and respect in the face of the law. To John, a 35 year old schizophrenic who is experiencing a crisis situation, his mental health depends greatly on his health care team. He wrote an advance directive that states which medications he would prefer to receive and that he wants his parents to be involved in his care, but he currently exhibits paranoia against his parents. John’s health care team must decide on what course of action to take. The purpose of this paper is to examine the legal and ethical aspects of John’s advance directive and his recipient rights.
Ethical Principles
The ethical principles that most pertain to John’s situation are those of autonomy and beneficence. John deserves respect to his autonomy and his health care providers should consider beneficence in all of their interventions.

Autonomy is an important ethical principal that should be considered with great attention, especially with the limitation of personal autonomy one finds in hospitals. Burkhardt (2008) and Nathaniel define autonomy as self-governing and describe it as including four elements, the ability to determine personal goals, decide on a plan of action, to be respected, and to have freedom to act on choices. In John’s situation, his vulnerability in contrast to the power that the health care professionals hold over him put all four of these elements into jeopardy. Since his advance directive and his current choices differ, the matter of respect for John’s autonomy becomes difficult for his advocates in the hospital.
Consent, autonomy, and psychiatric advance directives.
Consent is the most important issue in a hospital situation when considering autonomy. John’s ability to consent to treatment could be compromised because of his mental state. Psychiatric advance directives are a tool that informs health care providers of clients’ treatment preferences for during crisis situations, such as the one in which John finds himself (Srebnik & Russo, 2007). This document facilitates autonomy for clients in the hospital and could make care decisions easier for those with psychiatric patients. The physician in John’s situation believes that the best way to respect John’s autonomy is to follow a different prescribed set of medications and to respect his current wish that his parents remain uninformed. John’s advance directive indicates that he knows his paranoia manifests against his parents and that this paranoia is only that, a paranoid delusion.
Stedman’s Medical Dictionary defines beneficence as “the ethical principle of doing good” (Stedman, 2000). This broadly defined principle does not assist in a decision whether to follow John’s advance directive...

Find Another Essay On Psychiatric Advance Directives versus Recipient Rights

Shiawassee County Community Mental Health Essay

2890 words - 12 pages , and support, including therapeutic clinical interactions, socialization and adaptive skill and coping skill training, health and rehabilitative services, and pre-vocational and vocational services. (e) Recipient rights services. (f) Mental health advocacy. (g) Prevention activities that serve to inform and educate with the intent of reducing the risk of severe recipient dysfunction. (h) Any other service approved by the department. (2

Making Decisions Today For Health Care Tomorow

2737 words - 11 pages legislation on this topic confuses it even more. Advance Directives provide, in theory, for self-determination and put the patients mind at ease with the knowledge that they have decided for themselves the extent of health care that they wish to receive. Also, for the family, the process of watching their loved one suffer through unwanted medical treatment is eliminated. In practice, however, there are a lot of inconsistencies and legal barriers that

Case Study

1327 words - 5 pages and the right to complete state-allowed advance directives andb) the provider's written policies concerning implementation of those rights;2) document in the person's medical record whether or not the person has completed an advance directive;3) not discriminate or condition care based on whether or not the person has completed an advance directive;4) ensure compliance with state laws concerning advance directives;5) provide education for staff and

Involuntary Outpatient Commitment

4366 words - 17 pages Accessible Society, 1999). In conclusion, the Olmstead Act provided for the legal groundwork to both provide and enforce IOC. Research has shown IOC to be more effective when combined with additional components. Examples of these components include psychiatric advance directives, Assertive Case Management (ACM), representative payees, conditional release, conservatorship/guardianship, and mental health courts. Psychiatric advance directives are


5151 words - 21 pages above.CONCLUSIONSProvisions of EU law can be invoked by individuals before national courts provided that they are sufficiently clear, precise and unconditional - direct effect. Normally, though not always, this means they are capable of conferring rights on individuals…Legal effect of directives is complex. They have vertical but not horizontal direct effect. ECJ have crafted a growing number of qualifications to the proposition that directives do not

Moral and Legal Lessons from Washington v. Glucksberg

1965 words - 8 pages accept or refuse treatment; (2) the opportunity to write advance directives which allows patients to state in advance the kinds of medical care that he or she considers acceptable or not acceptable; (3) does not discriminate; and (4) educates the staff and community about advance directives. This act defines a legal definition of patient rights. It also explains informed consent with risks and benefits, assent, documentation needed, surrogate

The Erosion of Patient Confidentiality

558 words - 2 pages the right to refuse treatment. The right to formulate advance directives. The right to be provided with information regarding treatment that enables the patient to make treatment decisions that reflect his or her wishes. The right to be provided upon admission to a health care facility with information about the health care provider's policies regarding advance directives, patient rights, and patient complaints. The right to participate in

Why Decisions Should be Made Before Terminal Illness

1096 words - 5 pages condition, then appreciate it and recognize the stages of life. In doing so, the pain suffered is reduced and the patient and the family members can face the condition with courage and hope. Florida State Legislation and legal considerations at end-of-life The Florida state legislation on end-of-life is contained in chapter 765 under the title of civil rights. It includes health care advance directives, health care surrogate, life prolonging

Should the Unthinkable Happen: Are you prepared?

1384 words - 6 pages in Munoz vs. JPS, the case has challenged the existing law and demands further scrutiny for the purpose of dictating lawful action in the future. We believe that Munoz vs JPS will be a case that will be instrumental in better defining the limitations of right to life, abortion, individual rights, and advance directives. Works Cited  Bradley, E. B. (1997). Institutional Efforts to Promote Advance Care Planning in Nursing Homes:  Boni

dignity and dying

638 words - 3 pages nominated adult must not have any material gain in the patient’s death The Euthanasia Act (Belgium) allows for advance directives for euthanasia and legalisation has voided any legal claims of incompetence in advance directives (Black & Lewis, 2013). Oregon An adult who is capable of making their own decisions, must be a resident of Oregon and the patients physician and consulting physician has determined the patient has a terminal disease, has

Should the Unthinkable Happen: Are you prepared?

1407 words - 6 pages her body. (Gregorian Alexis, 2010). Works Cited  Bradley, E. B. (1997). Institutional Efforts to Promote Advance Care Planning in Nursing Homes:  Boni-Saenz, A. A. (2013). Personal Delegations. Brooklyn Law Review, 78(4), 1231-1278.  Casey, D. M. (2011). THE CLINICAL REALITIES OF ADVANCE DIRECTIVES. Widener Law Review, 17(2), 429-442.  Collett, T. S, 2013, Parental Involvement Laws for Abortions for Minors Are Constitutional.  Dena

Similar Essays

Should The Unthinkable Happen: Are You Prepared?

1497 words - 6 pages Crisis: When Pregnant Woman Is Dying. New York Times. p. A19.  Flamm, A. L. (2008). IS THE BABY IN THE BATHWATER? A DEFINING MOMENT FOR THE TEXAS ADVANCE DIRECTIVES ACT REVIEW PROCESS FOR MEDICAL FUTILITY JUDGMENTS. Health Matrix: Journal Of Law-Medicine, 18(2), 229-235.  Gold, R. B., & Nash, E., 2013, Abortion Rights Are Threatened. In T. L. Roleff (Ed.), Are Abortion Rights Threatened? Detroit: Green haven Press.  Gregorian Alexis, 2010, Post

Advance Directives Essay

2314 words - 9 pages PressNational Healthcare Decision Day. (2010). Fact Sheet retrieved November 29, 2010 from, J. B. (2006). Death and dying sourcebook: Basic consumer health information about end-of-life care and related perspectives and ethical issues, including end-of-life symptoms and treatments, pain management, quality-of-life concerns, the use of life support, patients' rights and privacy issues, advance directives

Advance Directive Essay

2314 words - 9 pages PressNational Healthcare Decision Day. (2010). Fact Sheet retrieved November 29, 2010 from, J. B. (2006). Death and dying sourcebook: Basic consumer health information about end-of-life care and related perspectives and ethical issues, including end-of-life symptoms and treatments, pain management, quality-of-life concerns, the use of life support, patients' rights and privacy issues, advance directives

Psychotropic Medicine Essay

1121 words - 4 pages right to refuse treatment, substitute decision making, and advance directives when caring for psychiatric persons ( Many state and federal courts decisiveness have challenged several position of this topic. The moral and lawful matters covering the treatment and administration of psychiatric patients are demanding and complicating. The lawfully knowledgeable psychiatrist is a stronger status to offer good medical care to the