Psychoanalytical And Feminist Approaches To D. H. Lawrence's Sons And Lovers

1581 words - 6 pages

Psychoanalytical and Feminist approaches to D. H. Lawrence's Sons and Lovers

Psychoanalytical and feminist approaches are two relatively recent critical responses towards literary texts. When applied to D. H. Lawrence's Son's and Lovers, both can be insightful yet problematic at the same time.

The theories of psychoanalysis, primarily identified with Sigmund Freud, can be applied to imaginative literature and art in general, in order to study their manifest and latent content, in the same way as Freud studied dreams. Literature clearly lends itself to such a study, since, like dreams, the most significant meaning often lies below the conscious surface narrative of a text. Feminist approaches towards literature are concerned with the portrayal of female characters. Lawrence's representation of women in his work has been admired by many readers for it's insight, women among them, and has been strongly attacked by others for its prejudiced male perspective.

Classic psychoanalytic criticism applied the theories either to the author, or his or her characters, which were seen as internalised images that have come from the author's unconscious. The high autobiographical content of Sons and Lovers lends itself to this type of study. Also, if works of art are taken to be disguised expressions of an infantile wish driven into the unconscious, as Freud suggests, then Sons and Lovers is doubly of interest. It is about the fundamental infantile wish that all boys have and repress, according to Freud, the wish of Oedipus to kill their father and marry their mother.

Freud's theory of the Oedipus complex and of its frequent effect of psychical impotence, of which Paul is a classic victim, offers a valuable key to a coherent understanding of the novel and the way in which it is structured. The extent of the bond established between mother and son is most vividly dramatised by the episode where Paul's mother cries at the thought of losing him to Miriam:

'I can't bear it. I could let another woman but not her. She'd leave me no
room, not a bit of room '
And immediately he hated Miriam bitterly.
'And I've never you know, Paul I've never had a husband not really '
He stroked his mother's hair, and his mouth was on her throat.
(Lawrence, 1994, p. 212)

Not only does she invite Paul to occupy the place of her husband, but she accuses Miriam of the same possessive love with which she smothers Paul. At the end of the chapter, Paul echoes Hamlet, another exemplary Oedipal victim, when he tries to persuade his mother not to sleep with his father. At this point in the novel, the presence of an Oedipus complex in Paul is so patent that one can hardly consider it as a submerged theme. Looked at another way, a major theme of the book is the gradual awakening of Paul to the deadly effects of his Oedipal fixation on his mother. The penultimate chapter, tellingly called 'The Release,' shows how Paul comes to reverse the Oedipal desire to kill...

Find Another Essay On Psychoanalytical and Feminist approaches to D. H. Lawrence's Sons and Lovers

Sons and Lovers Essay

903 words - 4 pages In the novel, Sons and Lovers, by D.H. Lawrence, the protagonist, Paul Morel, represented the epitome of the phrase “mama’s boy.” Mrs. Morel was very demanding, and smothered Paul to the point where he felt it was wrong to love anyone else but her. Paul’s disturbing infatuation with his mother became an obstacle in what could have blossomed into successful relationships with two very important women in his life, Miriam and Clara. In Chapter 7

Sons and Lovers - D.H. Lawrance

819 words - 3 pages There can be no argument that D. H. Lawrence's Son's and Lover's is a study of human relationships. Gertrude Morel, because of her turbulent and odd relationship with her husband, ends up developing deep emotional relations with her two eldest son's. The second eldest in particular, Paul, is the receiver of most of this deep emotion. Because of these feelings and the deeper-than-usual emotional bond between the two, Paul has difficulty being

Color Symbolism in Sons and Lovers

1316 words - 5 pages Color Symbolism in Sons and Lovers Throughout Sons and Lovers, D.H. Lawrence uses colors to suggest the underlying implications of the events taking place. Three colors in particular - red, black, and white - seem to carry some sort of subtle connotation which reveals more about the characters, their actions, and their motives for those actions, than the plot or the setting alone. Tied to the color images are material images which carry

Town and Country Lovers: A Feminist Criticism

731 words - 3 pages works to expose such ideology and, in the end, to change it so that the creativity of women can be fully realized and appreciated".Nadine Gordimer's "The Town and Country Lovers" can be looked upon by a Feminist critic and they would find numerous things how women are shown to be degraded in this piece. Gordimer born and raised in South Africa, depicts a image of a wealthy white male and a poor black female pursing a relationship that is forbidden

The children in "Sons and lovers" by DH Lawrence and "What massie Knew "by Henry James

809 words - 3 pages The characters in Sons and Lovers by D. H. Lawrenceand the characters in What Maisie Knew each have a specialmeaning. They all seem to be interwoven with one anotherportraying a new cycle in another characters life. Forinstance, in What Maisie Knew Mrs. Wix was introduced, inmy opinion, at a time when Maisie needed a mother figure.Also, Sir Claude is introduced when she seems to need afather figure. On the other hand, in Sons and Lovers thereare

Sons and Lovers by D.H. Lawrence -- Brief analysis of family relationships

516 words - 2 pages When William leaves the house to take a high-paying job in London, he is excited, but Mrs. Morel is grief-stricken over his parting. Being his mother, she should be proud of him, but she is not. Rather, she fears losing him and holds even more tightly onto her other son, Paul. This shows her inability to mother her sons correctly beyond their childhood. Instead of showing her love for William by letting him go proudly, she shows her insecurity

Feminist Approaches to Social Work

1629 words - 7 pages This work is going to set out to investigate the relevance of feminist approaches to social work in today’s society. It will first look at the different types of feminism that are present in society. It will then trace and highlight the emergence of feminism in society. This essay will then delve deeper into the different types of approaches that were taken on by feminists within the field of social work. It will discuss what effect these

Feminist approaches to women's writing

1175 words - 5 pages conflicted faces of feminism?Sure, the feminist lobby group takes a lot of heat for the take a rain check of "Western civilization" (Chambers, 1984). But a society that stayed its chauvinistic route was destined to melt down anyway.Down Among the Women a novel by Fay Weldon begins in the time 1950 and follows the lives of Wanda, her daughter Scarlet, and Scarlet's four friends Sylvia, Jocelyn, Audrey, and Helen. The story follows each of the characters

Oedipus complex in the life of the main character as reflected in D.H. Lawrence sons and lovers

5099 words - 20 pages , David Herbert. 1993. Sons and Lovers. London: reprint in wordsworth classic published.Nye, Robert D. 1986. Three Psycologies: Perspective from Freud, skinner and Rogers. California: Brooks/cole Publishing Company.Nurgiyantoro, Burhan. 2002. Teori Pengkajian Fiksi. Yogyakarta: Gajah Mada Press.Rohberger, Mary, and Samuel h. woods, Jr. 1971. Reading and Writing about Literary. New York: Random House.Subhan, Bustami. 2002. Literary Criticism Book

Oedipus complex in the life of the main character as reflected in D.H. Lawrence sons and lovers

2611 words - 10 pages Psychoanaylsis of Lady Macbeth in Shakespeare's "Macbeth".Absract:This paper research will explore psychoanaylsis of Lady Macbeth.As Sigmund Freud theroized that a human personality had three distinct components, the Id,ego and super ego.Ones impulses,drives and desires are a part of the Id,operating on a pleasure/pain principle(Id).Left unchecked these impulses would attempt to satisfy thier urges immediately with no regards to consequences.On

Three Approaches To Literature -- Archetypical - Feminist - Poststructuralist

2094 words - 8 pages are not civilised. So, the same work seems to contradict itself.BIBLIOGRAPHYGuerin, Wilfred L. et al. "Mythological and Archetypical Approaches." In A Handbook of Critical Approaches to Literature. 3rd ed. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1992Henderson, Greig E., and Christopher Brown. "Archetypical Criticism" Glossary of Literary Theory. n. d. (1 May 2006)Peterson, Linda H., ed. "Wuthering Heights": Emily Brontë. Boston: Bedford Books of St

Similar Essays

Prose Style In D.H. Lawrence's "Sons And Lovers"

1121 words - 4 pages Prose Style in D.H. Lawrence's Sons and Lovers[1]And after such an evening they both were very still, having known the immensity of passion. [2]They felt small, half afraid, childish, and wondering, like Adam and Eve when they lost their innocence and realized the magnificence of the power which drove them out of Paradise and across the great night and the great day of humanity. [3]It was for each of them an initiation and a satisfaction. [4]To

The Oedipus Complex In D.H. Lawrence's Sons And Lovers

2015 words - 8 pages of euthanasia, Lawrence provides the reader with the proof that Paul knew he had to cut himself free from his mother. He had committed the mercy killing with the hopes of taking his life back from his mother. He could see what the relationship with his mother had done to him. Works Cited Bodrogean, Adina Lucia. "The Oedipus Complex Reflected In D. H. Lawrence, Sons And Lovers - A Great Experience For The 8TH

D. H. Lawrence's The Rocking Horse Winner

1530 words - 6 pages D. H. Lawrence's The Rocking-Horse Winner “The Rocking-Horse Winner” is a short story by D. H. Lawrence in which he creates a criticism of the modernized world’s admiration and desire for material objects. It was published in Harper’s Bazaar magazine in 1926 for the first time (E-Notes). The story’s main character, Hester, is a beautiful woman who is completely consumed by the idea of possession, and so she loses out on the love of family

Mysticism In D. H. Lawrence's A Fragment Of Stained Glass

1680 words - 7 pages Mysticism in D. H. Lawrence's A Fragment of Stained Glass Mystical ideas about heaven, hell, angels, and the devil have been present in human lives for most of history. While some people simply take what is given to them without considering what else might be out there, others have faith in higher beings and need that support to survive. "A Fragment of Stained Glass" by D. H. Lawrence delves into the questionable beliefs of a mystical