This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Psychotherapy Vs. Medication For Depression Essay

1275 words - 5 pages

Emotional fluctuations between happiness and sadness are an inevitable part of everyone’s life. Regardless of what we do or how we act to try to prevent these sloughs, bad times always seem to slither their way back into our lives. For many, these bouts of hopelessness become too unbearable to endure. If nothing is done in time, their depression could lead them eventually to suicide. Depression represents a serious problem in our society today. As life continually gets more competitive, our current society pressures people into seeking an education and finding a profession that will bring about the most success and wealth all in an attempt to gain happiness. It is only human nature to pursue happiness, but are antidepressants such as Prozac the answer to true happiness? Although antidepressants work wonders by lifting users from the depths of depression, people using Prozac do not reach the highest level of happiness because these powerful drugs blunt emotions and misconstrue the true meaning of happiness.
The use of Prozac has become mainstream in today’s society. Kramer (1993) discusses the advent of Prozac, its effects on personality, and its gaining popularity in the public in his book Listening to Prozac through sharing personal case studies he conducted in his career as a psychiatrist. In many of Kramer’s studies, his patients were relieved of their depression when taking Prozac, but many did not feel like themselves once they were taken off of the drug. Prozac has the ability to significantly alter someone’s personality. One of his patients, a shy woman who was apprehensive about dating, changed so drastically she began dating frequently, quickly going through men, and even dating multiple men at a time. Her personality after taking the drug transformed into a mentality far different from her normal personality. Instead of making a person’s life happier, Prozac simply changes his personality, and in the process, clouds his perception of happiness. Being happy is a very subjective idea. To one, being happy could simply mean having a family, while to another it could mean accumulating as much wealth as possible. Prozac’s ability to alter personality blocks the user from attaining happiness because each person has a unique perception of what being happy means. By changing that view of happiness, that person loses the insight of what matters in life and cannot become truly happy. This can be seen in another of Kramer’s case studies in which a man on Prozac felt fake while taking the drug and was ultimately unhappy while taking the antidepressant.
The use of antidepressants and other mind altering drugs have skyrocketed in recent years. Doctors seemingly write out prescriptions for these powerful and sometimes dangerous drugs for nearly any reason. Stix (2009) states many people have begun to use these drugs casually to help improve their performance in everyday life. Drugs like Adderall and Ritalin are used religiously...

Find Another Essay On Psychotherapy vs. Medication for Depression

Treatment Methods for Depression Essay

876 words - 4 pages shown maintenance effects, supporting sessions over time to prevent recurrences after successful medication treatment. All psychotherapy tends to be more effective when used in conjunction with antidepressant medications. Major depression typically is treated with antidepressant medication and psychotherapy. Antidepressants alone just stabilize your mood and psychological treatments just provide opportunities for a person to learn more about

The Effects of Depression Essay

828 words - 3 pages . With proper treatment, nearly 80% of those with depression can make significant improvement in their mood and life adjustment. Psychotherapy and medication are the two primary treatment approaches. Antidepressant medications can make psychotherapy more effective, for some people. Someone who is too depressed to talk, for instance, will not benefit from psychotherapy or counseling; but often, the right medication will improve symptoms so

This essay defines depression, symptoms of depression, causes of depression, and treaments for it

864 words - 3 pages that is done you must determine what type of depression it is. Psychologists ask people with depression when the first time the started feeling depressed, how severe it is, and if you have had signs of depression before in your lifetime. There are two cures for depression, psychotherapy, and anti-depressant medication. Most people do well when treated with psychotherapy, but medication works faster than psychotherapy. Some people require

Grief is Not Depression

830 words - 4 pages cases. There are two major forms of treatment, psychotherapy and pharmacologic therapy. For some people psychotherapy is all that is needed to recover from depression. Psychotherapy has been proven to cause changes in brain function just as the changes that pharmacologic therapy does. In some cases this form of therapy is more affective then medications. However psychotherapy along with exercise and medications can be very effective as well

Diagnosing and Treating Depression

1203 words - 5 pages psychotherapy (IPT) and dynamic psychotherapy or psychoanalysis. As a general rule psychotherapies are about as effective as any medication for the treatment of mild depression. On the other hand, for more severe cases, medication is likely to be needed as a supplement to psychotherapy. Many of the medications prescribed by the doctors are called serotonin reuptake inhibitors. This means that after the serotonin is released, the medication keeps

Treating Depression: A Personal Battle or a Combination of Professional Treatments?

1152 words - 5 pages activities and causes physical symptoms (Emedicinehealth, 2011). These individuals search for coping mechanisms and possible treatments. Seu (2008), a WORLD magazine writer, boldly stated that depression can be overcome by personally clearing your mind, living as though you are not depressed, and relying on spirituality. However, Manber et. al (2008) said that depression must be treated through a combination of psychotherapy and medication. Seu

Depression: Clinical Psychology Nightmare

993 words - 4 pages (TRD). TRD refers to the lack of response shown after antidepressant therapy. (Fava 649) It can be frustrating for patients and psychologists when sufficient psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy doesn’t lead to remission. TRD can be managed with different combinations of medication and counseling. Often TRD patients can find a combination of medication and counseling that works, but it takes a lot of trial and error in treatment (Fava 650

Postpartum Depression

1306 words - 6 pages well tolerated” (Camp, 2013, p. 2). Medications such as Zoloft and Prozac are commonly used SSRI’s to treat postpartum depression in breastfeeding mothers. The transfer of the medication into the breast milk is minimal, but the mother should be on the alert for side effects in the infant, such as colic and impaired weight gain (Camp, 2013). When the treatment of psychotherapy is not enough, antidepressants are a safe addition to overall

Misconceptions About Depression

1162 words - 5 pages that around 60-80% of depressed individuals respond positively to a combination of medication and psychotherapy. An effective solution to depression is Cognitive-Behavioral therapy. Cognitive-Behavioral therapy is a form of psychotherapy that addresses a patient’s dysfunctional thoughts in order for a patient to control their thoughts in ways they couldn’t normally. This form of psychotherapy helps patients to improve the way they function in

Common Types of Depression

1664 words - 7 pages common side effects are: nausea, insomnia, anxiety, restlessness, dizziness, weight gain, weight loss, tremors, sweating, sleepiness or fatigue, dry mouth, diarrhea, constipation, headaches. So when taking medication for depression it can back fire or just help you get out of bed for the day, these medicines aren’t cures they won’t just tell your depression to be gone, that is up to you these medicines give a helpful hand. Psychotherapy (therapy

Depression Treatments

2178 words - 9 pages antidepressants. Antidepressants are usually preferred because they do not cause addiction (Hollon and Sexton, 2012). They also show significant improvement in comparison with placebo treatment in RCT (Blais et al., 2013). The data also suggests that patients with severe depression do better in pharmacotherapy then in CBT (Jacobson & Hollon, 1996). The reason for it is the acute response to the medication. But it should be disregarded because the

Similar Essays

How Medication And Therapy Combats Depression

1912 words - 8 pages depression, a person can be treated with a number of methods, but the most common treatments are medication and psychotherapy. Depression is a highly treatable disorder and as with most illnesses, the earlier treatment begins the more effective it is and the greater the likelihood of recurrence can be prevented. The brain of a person who is suffering from depression has been altered and treatment time needs to be long enough for it to effect

How Medication And Therapy Combats Depression

1692 words - 7 pages medication and psychotherapy. Depression is a highly treatable disorder and as with most illnesses, the earlier treatment begins the more effective it is and the greater the likelihood of recurrence can be prevented. The brain of a person who is suffering from depression has been altered and treatment time needs to be long enough for it to effect. Without extended treatment, relapse becomes very likely. In fact, more than fifty percent of people

Comparing The Efficacy Of Cognitive Therapy And Antidepressant Medication In The Treatment Of Depression

1746 words - 7 pages rates for the single treatment groups were 52% for the therapy and 55% for the medication, while the combination group displayed a response rate of 85%. The results of the study indicate that both antidepressant medication and psychotherapy both lead to roughly equal response rates in the treatment of depression. However, a combination treatment displayed to have significantly higher rate of efficacy than any treatment alone. Further research

Treatments For Depression Essay

1109 words - 4 pages treatment for depression is psychotherapy. In some cases, psychotherapy can be just as effective as medication and antidepressants. There are many types of psychotherapy such as psychiatry, counseling, or cognitive behavior therapy. (2) Counseling is used to help a person understand his or her feelings and to help them deal with these feelings. Counseling can be different depending on each person's needs. There is individual counseling, group therapy