Public Defenders Essay

2242 words - 9 pages

In the United States, the adversarial system of justice relies on ensuring a criminal defendant receives a fair trial. The sixth amendment gives defendants the right to legal representation in criminal trials even if they cannot afford one themselves. Each city and county in the United States ensures a defendant the right to counsel. There are different ways cities and counties across the United States provide representation for indigent defendants. One such approach to indigent defense is public defender programs and is a popular system used by many states today. Public defender programs have been around since the 1900’s but gained popularity throughout the years due to the many indigent defense cases.
Historically, the right to counsel was only guaranteed in federal criminal court (Wice, 2005). A person charged with a crime in the state court did not have the right to legal representation. Law scholar Professor Mason Beaney explained this by saying, “only a few states guaranteed the right to appointed counsel…In most jurisdictions counsel was appointed in none but the most serious cases, often only when the crime was punishable by death” (Wice, 2005, p. 3). Many defendants, who were poor, illiterate, and uneducated had to face the justice system without legal assistance (Smith, 2004, p. 579). Los Angeles County started one of the first public defender programs in 1914, spreading slowly to other counties (Neubauer & Fradella, 2011, p. 176). By the 1960’s, less than a dozen states still refused to provide attorneys to defendants unable to afford one (Smith, 2004).
There was a big change in 1963 when the landmark case Gideon v. Wainwright transformed the way state courts applied the right to counsel to indigent defendants. In the Gideon v. Wainwright decision, the Supreme Court held that states were required to ensure a constitutional right to defendants facing felony charges who could not afford a private lawyer (Smith, 2004). Subsequently, in 1972 Argersinger v. Hamlin held that defendants were required legal counsel when faced with incarceration from a misdemeanor or felony conviction (Smith, 2004). Following these Supreme Court decisions, most state and local governments had to develop new systems of indigent defense or modify the old ones to keep up with the number of clients (Wice, 2005). Since Gideon v. Wainwright, other cases have challenged the Supreme Court application of the right to counsel. Currently, all defendants are given the right to counsel at all stages of the criminal justice process, including during trial, appeals, and even during police interrogation.
There are three different methods that states use to provide indigent defense; public defenders, assigned counsel, and contract attorneys. Depending on the size of a city or county usually determines what type of indigent defense is employed. Public defender programs can be public or private nonprofit organizations (Neubauer & Fradella, 2011). Public...

Find Another Essay On Public Defenders

Capitalism in Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged

656 words - 3 pages Ayn Rand’s Atlas Shrugged, displays societal destruction caused by intense government economic intervention. Rand heavily stresses Capitalistic views, however straying from “public good” appeals. On the contrary, Rand views the public good as inconsequential and possibly detrimental when considering capitalism. Ayn Rand varies from Capitalist defenders supporting views disregarding public good and considering competition driven innovation

A Comparison of J. A. Hobson and V. I. Lenin’s Historical Interpretations of Imperialism

848 words - 3 pages behind imperialist expansion. He constructs a "combination of production," witch is co-dominating monopolists and banks, as the investors. Thus this combination created a "Financial Oligarchy" to produce mobile capitals.They both acknowledge the upper class as the beneficiaries of foreign investments and sympathize with the impoverished proletariat class. Both use examples of massive public expenditures on war objects and how expansion collected

Gideon’s Failed Solution for Retributivism’s Justification of Punishment

1820 words - 8 pages judges were forced to deal with more pretrial motions, and the chances a fair trial were undoubtedly increased (Cohen). Unfortunately for the retributivist Gideon did not go far enough to bridge the gap of inequality and bring about fair trials. Gideon failed for a multitude of reasons. First, the allotment of funds to actually pay public defenders was grossly underwhelming. The Federal Government didn’t want to spend the money; State

This essay is an argument agaisnt the Death Penalty

657 words - 3 pages little bit of evidence found, even several years after the case, can possibly prove the persons innocence.Another problem with the death penalty, which is linked to innocent people being murdered, is representation. Almost all defendants in capital cases cannot afford their own lawyers. This means that most of the people on death row have used public defenders. In many cases these public defenders are overworked, underpaid, and lack the

Capital Punishment: Should it be Legal?

1045 words - 4 pages that very few Americans abide by. So putting all ethical reasons aside it wouldn’t make sense to allow our flawed justice system to be able to determine whether a criminal get to live or not. In the United States people that cannot afford lawyers are assigned public defenders. Public defenders are often times young, overworked, and inexperienced. This does not give poor people an equal opportunity to plead their case. Capital trials with

The Beluga Whale

1611 words - 7 pages , this plan is expected to be released to the public some time this year ("What Defenders Is Doing To Help Beluga Whales"). Defenders of Wildlife has also been part of a team of scientist and local citizens that are concerned with the population of the Cook Inlet Beluga Whale ("What Defenders Is Doing To Help Beluga Whales"). Another organization that is educating people on how we can preserve whales is the Save The Whales organization

How mexican american historians tell the history of america from a different perspective from the standard angle historian standpoint

634 words - 3 pages known or for the most part not known at all, is that French troops as well as troops from Bernardo Galvez's (governor of Louisiana) army were major combatants in the battle.In regards to the history of our own state, it is common knowledge that Texas gained its independence by defeating the Mexican army. In addition, we know about the Alamo, that's where the several Mexicans attacked and killed all the defenders in the Alamo such as David

Field Hockey

1749 words - 7 pages sundry from such stone, wood and iron throwing; handball, football, or hockey; coursing and cock-fighting, or other such idle games.” In the early 19th century, the game grew due to English public schools where clubs started to first perform it (the first performance was during 1849, in London.) Middlesex cricket was the first club to produce its rules. However, the sport kept dropping but because of the FIH it kept stable. The Teddington Hockey Club

timed wrote about Annexation on Texas - AP English - Essay

450 words - 2 pages though U.S troops finally can it was a little too late because the defenders of the alamo were captured and killed. If Texas already had the strength of a strong U.S military unit behind its back the end results would have ended differently.​ When they annexed into the Union Texas's military join the U.S and together they created one of the greatest military units in the world going on to win many battles and wars in the future.​ ​“...when admitted

Global Flows Sovereignty Commentary - essay

455 words - 2 pages I think the debate on humanitarian intervention is one of the most powerful and polarized in International Relations, with many defenders and opponents both politically and academically. Based on one of the most important theories of International Relations (Realism) I think that countries that decide to intervene in another country always have a national interest that drives them. As an example the text of Mahmood Mamdani “Responsibility to

Basic Defender Statistics

1032 words - 5 pages attorney is handling possession cases, a particular schedule drug charge or distribution of drugs, whether there were weapons enhancements or if there were multiple co-defendants. Although descriptive statistics can’t provide you with answers as to “why” a variable produces a certain outcome, it can provide a summary that will enable defenders to make comparisons across people or different defender units. Works Cited See Wilbur v. City of Mount Vernon; and Public Defender, Eleventh Judicial Circuit of Florida, et al. v. State of Florida

Similar Essays

Defender Statistics Essay

651 words - 3 pages outcomes for client’s in criminal defense needs to be improved. Although, defenders may not be have the research capacity, or the funding available to hire a researcher, or the ability to partner with universities to assist with the researcher to create evidence based practices, they can collect and use basic data to inform their decision making. Basic descriptive data analyses in public defense, directed by public defenders, will not only allow

Right To Counsel Essay

1286 words - 5 pages in regards to their respective case. However, with such a large and important task, this system has key issues that raise the following questions: Is there a standard for the service provided by the attorney that is met by the public defenders? Do these attorneys receive adequate training and funds in order to represent indigent defendants equally? Should the defendants be appointed attorneys who are equal to the prosecution’s attorney? We will

15th Judical Court Essay

906 words - 4 pages small number of people dressed in business suits and were frantically going from one client to another trying to discuss their case. No matter how swiftly the suited people (later identified as attorneys and public defenders) vaulted between there prospective clients, no one seemed to be satisfied with how the public defenders were handling their case. In one instance a furious defendant told his public defender that he neglected to review her

Plea Bargaining Essay

760 words - 3 pages guilty to committing minor crimes through the system faster so that the courts can concentrate on those criminals who commit major crimes. In this video you can see some of the variables that enter into the plea-bargaining system and how they can be fair and unfair to the parties involved. You can see the quality of legal representation provided by the public defenders office and how they have the discretion to what happens to these criminals. And we