This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Puerto Rico Shouldn't Become A State

677 words - 3 pages

“To think that the Yankees are going to give us all their freedoms and all their progress for our pretty face is to think blindfolded. We could indeed have an unheard-of-manufacturing and business activity; but all this would be in their hands, monopolized, and exploited by them.” (Puerto Rico::The Flame of Resistance, 34). This statement from a Puerto Rican journalist emphasizes why she believes that Puerto Rico should not be controlled by America. This is a popular belief in Puerto Rico and America because of reasons regarding culture, independence, and the economy. It would not be beneficial to Puerto Ricans or Americans if Puerto Rico was made a state.

A great deal of Puerto Ricans are concerned that becoming a U.S. state will cause them to lose their culture. In the past few years Puerto Rico has managed to become a contender in international competitions, where it competes as a sovereign nation. "Puerto Rico is not a ...view middle of the document...

Puerto Rico would have to undergo this rule as well, and it may compromise the access of future generations of Puerto Ricans to their Hispanic heritage and culture, including it within the overwhelming English-speaking American culture.

Statehood would prevent Puerto Ricans from ever achieving the independence that they desire. Achieving Puerto Rican independence is the only great cause which can unite all Puerto Rican people and allow them to break out of the colonized mind set that they have and reclaim their dignity as a nation. Puerto Ricans do not want to give in to what they have been told time and time again, “Puerto Ricans in America and in Puerto Rico are taught three things: Puerto Rico is small and the US is big, Puerto Rico is poor and the US is rich, Puerto Rico is weak and the US is strong” (n.pag.). For Puerto Rico to accept statehood would be for them to give in to the pervasive American culture.

Puerto Rico becoming a state would not only affect Puerto Ricans negatively but also a great deal of Americans, due to the way it will hurt the economy. If Puerto Rico becomes a state Puerto Ricans will no longer be exempt from Federal Income Tax, that means that the government will have to give more money to more unemployed people. The 2010 Census Bureau data shows that 41% of people in Puerto Rico live in poverty, and their unemployment is at 13%. Many are aware of the economic state that the island is in as a citizen explains, “we do have the poverty we have, and we need to deal with [it], and that’s an issue, that’s going to be an issue as a state, as a territory, regardless” (n.pag.). Statehood would cost the U.S. government an additional $20 billion a year due to the U.S. benefit programs. Making Puerto Rico a state will leave a lasting impact on our country, and it may not be a good impact.
Puerto Rico should not become the 51st U.S. state. Puerto Rico should not obtain statehood because it will lead to the loss of Puerto Rican culture, Puerto Rico will never achieve the independence they desire, and because it will hurt the U.S. economy. Many Puerto Ricans fear that to accept full control by America will cause them lose their identity, that fear may become a reality.

Find Another Essay On Puerto Rico Shouldn't Become a State

The Historical Significance of Puerto Rico

1764 words - 7 pages The Historical Significance of Puerto Rico For most of its history, Puerto Rico has been controlled by an outside power, and its people oppressed. While Puerto Rico is currently a U.S. territory, Spanish colonialism has had a significant impact on the island’s development and identity. The history of the island itself is proof of this fact, demonstrating each step Puerto Rico took to reach its current state. By examining the stages of Spanish

Coca Cola and Coco Frio Essay

1792 words - 7 pages States troops invaded Puerto Rico during the Spanish American War . As Olga Jimenez de Wagenheim and Kal Wagenheim state“ The war marked new eras for both the United States and Puerto Rico. It was America’s first major step as an imperialist power , The Spanish American War was a small war , edging towards immense consequences ” (77) . December 10, 1898 The Treaty of Paris between The United States and Spain was signed, Spain ceded Puerto Rico

Puerto Rico Under American Rule

2021 words - 8 pages 400 years, no one knew what to expect from the United States, but the island hoped for change and for the chance to be self-governing, if not independent, because as a colony of Spain, all Puerto Rico wanted was to be considered a "state" of Spain. Spain, however, did not grant them this. Once overtaken, military forces ruled the island for two years, "undermining one way of life without replacing it with another", while the United States

Societal, Political, and Economical Changes in Puerto Rico

2643 words - 11 pages Commissioner of Puerto Rico, Pedro Pierluisi, in order of them to decide whether or not Puerto Rico would become the 51st state of the United States or not. Puerto Rico, along with many other countries in the world, has had a long history of colonization and violence due to political policies. Some, such as Cuba, Mexico, India, and other African countries were able to achieve independence from their metropolis; however, Puerto Rico had a different

The Future of Puerto Rico

2886 words - 12 pages Whether or not Puerto Rico becomes the 51st state of the United States of America is an important issue that has been pondered for the last fifty years. Puerto Rico is currently a Commonwealth of the United States and has been under U.S. rule for a century. Spain ruled Puerto Rico for about 400 years prior to the U.S. take-over in 1898. The current and pertinent issue, though, is whether Puerto Rico will remain a Commonwealth of the U.S., become

The Future Of Puerto Rico

818 words - 3 pages The Future of Puerto Rico In 1898, the United States assumed control of Puerto Rico and since then has become a Commonwealth. While this particular status allows Puerto Ricans to be drafted into the U.S. army, it does not allow them to vote in the Presidential Elections and does not give Puerto Rico a seat in Congress. Some consider this status to be the only modern day colony left in the world, others consider Commonwealth to be "The best of

Spanish Language's Influence on the Puerto Rican Identity

2345 words - 9 pages because Puerto Ricans heroically held on to their vernacular” (Negrón-Muntaner, 259). Puerto Rico continues to be a mainly Spanish speaking nation. If Puerto Rico were to become the fifty-first state of the United States, where the official language is English, Puerto Rico would surely lose the fight in keeping Spanish as the official, if not the only language. In fact, a Congressional Act H.R. 856, passed March 4, 1998, states that “in the event

The Identity of a Puerto Rican

3158 words - 13 pages ; Majorcans and Catalans began to settle in Puerto Rico. This wave created a second colonization. These immigrants settled in the mountainous central area of the island unlike the first Spanish settlers who settled in the coastal areas. The main crop in the mountainous area was coffee therefore these immigrants became the owners of these plantations allowing them to become rich. Gonzalez writes, "The world of the coffee plantations, in this century

The Impact of Spanish Rule on Puerto Ricans Today

1485 words - 6 pages Spain for the next 400 years. But the interesting fact remains that Puerto Rico was not truly settled by the Spaniards until almost fifteen years later! In 1508, Juan Ponce de Leon came to settle the land of Borinken, and founded the town of Caparra. This was the start of a proud people that would eventually become known as Puerto Ricans. Since there were only the natives on the island known as Tainos (descendents of the Arawaks), the

The Impact of United States Rule on Puerto Rico

2249 words - 9 pages to civilize Puerto Rico and help it become a democratic society, its hypocritical manner of dealing with the island had a great impact on Puerto Rican development. The early years of U.S. colonization affected many aspects of Puerto Rico, including economics, politics, and social relations. When the United States first took Puerto Rico from Spain, its plans concerning what to do with the island appeared to be noble. According to Fernandez

Puerto Rican Music in the United States

1713 words - 7 pages speak or understand Italian. However, the audience is moved by the emotion conveyed through tone, facial expressions, and beat of the music. I believe this is relevant to the situation of Puerto Rican forms of music, and its success when Puerto Rican musicians migrated to the United States. Original forms had to be adopted to become popular in the United States, often assuming a heavier dance beat, but when the songs and musicians did become

Similar Essays

Should Puerto Rico Become America´S 51st State?

2952 words - 12 pages OUTLINE I. Introduction a. Should Puerto Rico become Americas 51st state? b. Many politicians have different views on what Puerto Rico should do. Should the island become a State, stay a Commonwealth, or become independent. Either way, it would benefit the island. II. Body a. Should Puerto Rico become a state? i. How would it benefit the government? ii. How would it benefit the economy? b. Is Puerto Rico better off as a commonwealth

Describes A Trip To Puerto Rico

1019 words - 4 pages My Trip To Puerto RicoI am from a small town of all most all white people and I had never been outside of the United States until 1997. I went to Puerto Rico that year to play baseball. I knew baseball would keep me occupied, but I wanted a chance to experience the island. Puerto Rico was a very different place compared to where I come from and it didn't take me long to realize that.I guess it all started when, I got off the plane. The airport

I Was Required To Writ About A Place That Is Special To Me. This Essay Is About Puerto Rico

1282 words - 5 pages more than five minutes, these symptoms become inane, and so begins the search for our driver. Once he is located, we began our journey through the "real" Puerto Rico to our destination, Palmas Del Mar. The "real" Puerto Rico resembles some third-world countries; however, there are no signs of a weak economy. There are some areas that are undoubtedly high-crime, dirty, and not-so-friendly. The roadways leave much to be desired, and the

To Become Educated Is A State Of Mind

1702 words - 7 pages standards. The use of strategic thinking was one of the major losses in score. Americans weren’t become educated in a deeper capacity. The state of the how we see education is in need of change. My personal philosophy on the subject of education is that of personal dedication. To truly become educated, one must have a desire to learn. To have a yearning passion to learn, instead of just an obligation; the modern society has made it so that we are