Student Athletes' Opinions Of Ncaa Amateurism Laws

3360 words - 13 pages

Since the National Collegiate Athletic Association’s (NCAA) inception in 1906 there have been laws in place to protect the amateurism status of its student athletes. Over the last 100 years the NCAA has morphed into a multimillion dollar business. The success and revenue that student athletes have brought the NCAA and its member institutions has sparked a debate of whether or not to compensate players for paying. Research in the field has focused on the debate and reasons to pay players and reasons not to. There has been little attempt to assert the thoughts, feelings, and opinions of the student athletes. The purpose of this study is to examine what the thoughts, feelings, and attitudes of the student athletes towards NCAA amateurism laws. Informal face to face interviews with Division 1 student athletes at universities in Indiana will be conducted to get an analysis of the attitudes, opinions, and feelings Division 1 student athletes have towards NCAA Amateurism laws.

The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) formed in 1906. When the NCAA was incepted they created strict bylaws requiring student-athletes maintain amateur status (NCAA Amateurism). The NCAA has remained diligent in enforcing and maintaining those laws. Under NCAA law it is illegal for student athletes to enter into contracts with professional teams, receive a salary for participating in athletics, and receive benefits from an agent or prospective agents (NCAA Amateurism). Presently, the NCAA has justified these regulations to “ensure the students’ priority remains on obtaining a quality educational experience and that all of student-athletes are competing equitably” (NCAA Amateurism). These rules however, have been in place since 1906 and the current times are much different then how they once were. In 1906 the NCAA formed to protect young people from the dangerous and exploitive athletics practices of the time (NCAA History). Now, due in large part to the student athletes the NCAA has morphed into a multi-million dollar business (NCAA Revenue) and a debate has ensued as to whether or not the NCAA is exploiting student athletes in the form of not giving them a stipend or salary. One side is for paying student athletes and the other side is against paying athletes.

Just like any business, the objective is to maximize productivity and profits. More than 1,000 schools fall under the NCAA’s jurisdiction and are bound completely under NCAA law. Under NCAA law universities have agreed not to provide athletically related financial aid in excess of the authorized cost of tuition, room and board, and books and fees. To the outsider this looks like a sweet deal. A student athlete is receiving a free college education along with room and board and books. It is very true that a student athlete is getting his or her education taken care of. However, what many people fail to realize is that tuition, room and board, and books is the only thing a student...

Find Another Essay On Student Athletes' Opinions of NCAA Amateurism Laws

Student or Athlete: The Age Old Question of Paying College Athletes

1613 words - 6 pages keep the self-sustaining program running. ‘TV money’ fuels up the college basketball programs tanks, Sheed gives a reason regarding why colleges do in fact (and have the means) to “pay” their athletes. “And the TV money has also made it that much more difficult to slip any real moral wisdom or spiritual balance in to the student-athlete’s regimen. Since the players tend to have the impression that the school is already making a lot of money off

"The Lost Fight", by William F. Buckley, Jr. and "Only the Force of Law Can Deter Pornographers", by Jim Exon: Opinions over the controversy of pornography and laws.

887 words - 4 pages Pornography is sexually explicit pictures, writing, videos, or other material whose main purpose is to cause sexual arousal. In the readings, "The Lost Fight", by William F. Buckley, Jr. and "Only the Force of Law Can Deter Pornographers", by Jim Exon, both discuss their opinion over the controversy of pornography and possible laws regarding pornographic sites on the internet. Buckley doesn't really have a stand point about the situation of

NCAA Atheltics: Young Money

936 words - 4 pages of the “no pay” rules is that athletes may not accept pay in any form from that sport, accept a promise of future pay or receive any form of future assistance. If the NCAA changes the rules, student athletes would be able to receive money and performance-based bonuses they work hard to earn from their schools, boosters, and other third parties. Consequently, the number of federal laws and NCAA rules broken each year would be radically lowered. A

The current system of collegiate athletics and the NCAA

2615 words - 11 pages seen as the moral compass of college athletics to be morally flawed. Miller, Anthony W. "United States Sports Academy - "America's Sports University"" NCAA Division I Athletics: Amateurism and Exploitation. N.p., n.d. Web. 02 Nov. 2013. Studies show that people are equally divided in their stance of whether a student athlete should be paid or not. College athletes are not paid for their athletic service because the NCAA does not view the

The NCAA and College Athletes: Should College Athletes Be Paid?

1464 words - 6 pages living expenses, and access to a degree at the end of their career, players should be paid because schools, coaching staffs and major corporations are profiting off their free labor. The NCAA prides itself as an organization dedicated to safeguarding the well-being of student-athletes and equipping them with the skills to succeed on the playing field, in the classroom and throughout life. In order to ensure that participants are students first and

Pay College Athletes

1204 words - 5 pages athletes do come from privileged backgrounds and try to make something of themselves through sports. But when that doesn’t work out, they are back to their unprivileged lives with nothing but a dissatisfied taste of generating so much money for the school that ended up dumping them back exactly where they came from. The NCAA, whose job it is to work for the betterment of student athletes just watches this whole process play out and is fine with it

The Sacrifice of College Athletes

1133 words - 5 pages student athletes, but somehow sports come first?FB These athletes aren’t the ones going home at night in big houses, fancy cars, and making millions of dollars, the department heads are, and there using these athletes to make money off them. (SC) All the revenue that these athletes make; they receive nothing. It just doesn’t seem fair when they're the ones doing the hard work here. According to, “Injustice Of Amateurism “ The NCAA has made it so

College Athletes Need Stipends, Not Payments

1390 words - 6 pages many different opinions of what the NCAA should do regarding payment for players. Currently, all the NCAA is doing is nothing. Most people believe that rules need to be changed and updated, however varying opinions exist on what changes should be made. Many assume the only solution is to allow players to be paid by colleges. Contrary to popular belief, allowing colleges to pay athletes will not solve the problem of impermissible benefits; it will

Should College Athletes Make Money

2155 words - 9 pages student athletes want their share of the profits as well. “In 2009, many high-profile former players filed a lawsuit to challenge a contract that the NCAA forces collegiate athletes to sign. The contract in question prohibits the athletes from earning any money during their college athletic careers. Traditionally, the NCAA has said the contract helps it defend the amateurism of college basketball by denying payments of any kind to the players

Should College Athletes be Paid?

1540 words - 6 pages arises primarily in reference to student athletes in the sports of football and basketball at Division I institutions with high-profile, high-income athletics programs” (Should College Student Athletes Be Paid). It is also not fair for the smaller schools who make little or no money at all because they are not as popular or as good as the bigger schools. “Most NCAA athletes do not need to be paid because they compete in sports, and play in

Should Student Athletes Be Paid?

2345 words - 9 pages scholarships, the NCAA introduced the first version of the Student Assistance Fund in 1999 as a way to benefit student athletes directly.(....) In the 2010-2011 academic year alone, the Student Assistance Fund helped over 81,000 athletes by giving student athletes almost 53 million dollars for things such as trips home, insurance, school supplies, tutoring, clothes, or helping an athlete to recover from a natural disaster.(....) In April of 2011, the

Similar Essays

Sexual Harassment Of Student Athletes Essay

2421 words - 10 pages ) The main reasoning behind the background check is to have proof that colleges had prior knowledge of a student with that criminal record. With that being said in the article, “ Proposed Legislation Asks Athletes to Fight Domestic Violence: NCAA, Others Worried About Stigma Associated With Sports Figures” states that, “Dan Boggan, chief executive officer of the NCAA, said, "I think that there is a broader concern in this country about violence, and

A Phenomenological Study Exploring Coping Responses Of Retired Ncaa Athletes

2557 words - 10 pages after those for years? According to a study completed by the NCAA (2013), the odds of being drafted from college football to the National Football League is 1.6%, and from college baseball to Major League Baseball is 9.4%. For those who do not go on to play professional sports, which have no eligibility remaining, what happens to them? Much research has been conducted on the mental health status of current student athletes. The research given

Drug Testing Of Student Athletes Essay

1049 words - 4 pages Drug abuse is a major problem in our society as a whole and increasingly within our youth. In recent years, many school districts have implemented student athlete drug testing programs within their schools. Athletes were targeted because student athletics are voluntary and the "athletes are often held to higher standards than other students, keeping their grades up for example" (Tantillo, Wen & Morgo, 1995, p. A22)."The issue of drug testing

The Student Athlete Association And Subsidized Payment Of College Athletes

1726 words - 7 pages Excellence Without a Soul NCAA, 2011. About the NCAA Smith, Ronald A,1988. Sports & Freedom, The rise of Big-Time College Athletics Powel, Justin. 2009 Should Student Athletes be paid? Coaches discuss Pros and Cons of Paying college athletes at OSU athletes-be-paid-1.99059 Theodore Roosevelt Association, 1988. Kids’ Corner. http