This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Qumran: Identity, Spirits, Science And Dualism

2324 words - 9 pages

1. The topic of my research is the coexistence and dualism of determinism and free will or, natural evil and moral evil, within the texts of the Dead Sea Scrolls. I am interested in this subject because I was intrigued by the debate it sparked among scholars and scientists alike. When applied to a religious backdrop it seems to be an especially complicated puzzle which can’t be easily solved rationally or scientifically. As I am determined to know what made ancient people tick, this subject falls near the center of my personal interests.
I noted that the authors of the Biblical texts seem also to make no attempt at harmonizing their implications of the importance of human choice with their unwavering belief that all things were pre-planned by God and therefore unchangeable by any human choice or lack thereof. In my research I discovered a few instances where a given scholar mentions this similarity between the Dead Sea scrolls and the Bible then ends the discussion post haste, as if it cannot be rationalized in the scrolls if it was not rationalized in most other aspects of Judaism or Christianity. Other scholars content themselves with the very obvious overtones of determinism or predestination within the scrolls, specifically The Community Rule (1QS), and fail to see any dualism beyond that point. I was even more interested after I resolved to understand the terms “determinism” and “free will” then discovered that perhaps our understanding of those terms can’t be applied to ancient texts, or the minds that created them, as we would like them to be.

2. Vanderkam, in 1994, Baker, in 2004, Vermes, in 2004, Alexander, in 2006, and Timmer, in 2009, agree that predestination is given the central position in Essene theology. The discourse of the two spirits is considered by these authors to be locus classicus in the Qumranite thought and lifestyle, and locus classicus for the modern study of the Qumran groups’ ideals concerning determinism and free will. In the Community Rule, several passages such as “Before ever they existed He established their whole design, and when, as ordained for them, they came into being, it is in accord with His glorious design that they accomplish their task without change” (1QS 3.15-16), lend themselves to the position of these authors. 1QS allows these authors to place considerable weight in its author(s) belief in divine foreknowledge. It is obvious in the text that they considered themselves to be in the “lot of the Holy Ones” (1QS 11.7-9) and that this was the effect of grace, as having been pre-planned for each of them. They attempted to adhere to the spirit of truth in the ways of light as it is described in the Instruction of the Two Spirits within the Community Rule, while all others were assumed to be doomed to falsehood in the path of darkness.
Noted, but not focused on among these five authors, are the more subtle references to freedom of the will of human agents within the predestined...

Find Another Essay On Qumran: Identity, Spirits, Science and Dualism

Dead Sea Scrolls Essay

988 words - 4 pages accepted theory is Qumran was a Roman fortress rather than the previously thought monastery. (Thompson, 1997) This time when the scrolls were written was the Hellenistic period. An inter-testimonial period, a time between the Old Testament and New Testament. An idea found in the Dead Sea Scrolls is dualism. Dualism defined as evil being ascribed to Satan (Belial), not God. (Cotterell, 1980). About 14 famous scrolls and countless


2308 words - 10 pages Although the identity of the community who occupied the settlement at Qumran has been the object of much debate, most scholars believe that they were most likely members of the Jewish sect called the Essenes. The Essenes were widely known for their rules concerning ritual purity and several known historical authors mentioned them in their writings, including Josephus and Pliny the Elder. Eleazer Sukenik, who purchased three of the


995 words - 4 pages here. The mind in the dualisttheory may use a form of energy transfer not yet discovered by science. Centuries ago, undiscovered forms of science were refuted and called 'magic'. In the future, The mind may become completely understood by science.The third argument against substance dualism is neural dependence. That the mental capacities depend on the brain's neural activities. The materialists show that the mind is altered when the brain is

Metaphysics: Ontology: Dualism Vs. Materialism

2277 words - 10 pages Metaphysics: Ontology: Dualism vs. MaterialismThe original idea of the word 'philosophy' was a 'love of wisdom' (Cowan 2). Philosophy is meant to explore the 'big questions' and try to find answers as best we can in the time we have been given. One of the areas of study in philosophy is metaphysics, which deals in the ideas of the nature of reality. "We look at the world, and we assume that it is the way it appears to be. It is not." (Carreira

A defence of cartesian dualism from the attacks of modern science

1321 words - 5 pages Dualism has been given a rough ride. This theory, ascribed mainly to Descartes that the mind is separate from the body, has been justly rejected for many reasons. Descartes theory required the existence of a substance that was mind, as well as a theater in which the mind could view what it internally perceived. As our scientific understanding of how the brain functions to produce consciousness and hence the mind has increased, these two pictures

Can One Exist Without Seperation?

1085 words - 4 pages objects and whether one knows it or not, dualism is all around them every day (Comer). Denying respect to a contrasting group or idea one does not believe in is also a way to describe dualism. Dualism is presented in many ways throughout everyone’s life; it is a part of our own identity which makes it almost impossible to exist in today’s world without separation from an opponent or an object. Dualism exists through many factors, one in which can be

Women in the Dead Sea Scrolls

2183 words - 9 pages allow the Essenes, who lived in tents, to bury their dead in their holy city. Though the true identity has not been determined, it is known that both these sects held women to some value. Archaeologists and ancient manuscript scholars are currently translating more manuscripts and excavating the site of Qumran. In the near future, more information will soon be revealed to uncover this mystery.

Arguments Against Dualism

1243 words - 5 pages Arguments against Dualism Introduction The debate as to the true nature of human beings, the existence of free will and the validity of science is centered on two philosophical theories; dualism and materialism. Under dualism, the proponents believe that there are two kinds of matter that make up human beings which is the physical presence and the non-physical mind or soul . Materialism on the one hand proposes that man and matter is one

How have dualist tried to explain the apparent two-way causal interaction between mind and body? Which version of dualism is the most plausible theory of mind?

1144 words - 5 pages (Fall 2008 Edition), Edward N. Zalta (ed.). Available at:, Luke, "Mind & Morality Lecture 2: Materialism and Dualism"6.Russell, Luke, "Mind & Morality Lecture 3: Arguments against Dualism"7.Russell, Luke, "Mind & Morality Lecture 4: Materialism & Numerical Identity v. Qualitative Identity"

Dualism: Concerns and Issues

2289 words - 9 pages -identity-disorder-multiple-personality-disorder 4- “Elementary Particles. <> 5- Hofstadter, Douglas R., Daniel Clement. Dennett, and Raymond Smullyan. The Mind's I: Fantasies and Reflections on Self and Soul. New York: Basic, 1981, Chapter 23 “The Unfortunate Dualist”. 6- “On Lockean Dualism” 7- “Problems from Philosophy”. 8- “Rene Descartes”

Exploring the Different Theories Involved in the Mind and Body Problem

2580 words - 10 pages mental and the physical have a fundamentally different nature. Dualism has been the driving force behind the mind-body problem and has been by far the majority view until recently partially due to the influence of Descartes he claimed that the pineal gland was the interface between the mind and the rest of the brain. Whether Dualism is correct one way to explain how the mental interacts with the material is dualistic

Similar Essays

Analyzing Individuation And Identity In Descartes´ Philosophical View Of The Mind Body Dualism

1292 words - 5 pages Every since Plato introduced the idea of dualism thousands of years ago meta-physicians have been faced with the mind-body problem. Even so Plato idea of dualism did not become a major issue of debate in the philosophical world until the seventeenth century when French philosopher Rene Descartes publicized his ideas concerning the mental and physical world. During this paper, I will analyze the issue of individuation and identity in

The Explanation Of Dualism And Why It Is Rejected By Science

711 words - 3 pages Throughout history there has been many different theory’s that have been presented, in numerous fashions. From psychology’s inception there has been attempts to answer many different questions, how much of our animal heritage exists, are humans basically good, is human nature neither good nor bad, do humans possess free will, is psychology really a science? There has been a persistent question throughout the ages, how are the mind and body

The Dead Sea Scrolls And The Gospel Of John

2109 words - 8 pages hearts of individual members of the sect. It follows then that this struggle is reflected in the moral conflicts each person encounters elevating individual ethical dilemmas to a universal struggle between good and evil. The ethical orientation of Dualism, which is obvious in the Qumran writings is also a distinctive feature of John’s Gospel; John chapter 3 verse 16-21 reads: For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son

A History Of How Societies Have Viewed Bodily Functions

1804 words - 8 pages Introduction Ancient societies viewed bodily functions differently from the way we do today. Many cultures also had different views of what was considered pure and impure. However, almost certainly no group seemed as meticulous as the Essenes. Widely known for their rules concerning ritual purity, several known historical authors mentioned them in their writings, including Josephus and Pliny the Elder. Moreover, although the identity of the