Race Should Not Be A Consideration In College Admission: Views Shared Between Egoists, Utilitarians And Egalitarians

828 words - 3 pages

Affirmative action is one of the most recent and popular civil rights policies that is affecting today's society. Affirmative action is an attempt by the United States to amend a long history of racial and sexual discrimination. But these days it seems to incite, not ease, the nation's internal divisions. Affirmative action can be described as nothing more than a lower educational standard for minorities. It has become quite clear that affirmative action is unfair and discriminatory for a number of reasons. One very recent and heated debate is that of using race as a consideration in college admission. Although the government may think that by using affirmative action in this form they are helping out underrepresented minorities, they are actually causing more concern than they may realize.There are several reasons why race should not be a consideration in college admission. A utilitarianist, or someone who believes in doing what will maximize social utility, like John Stuart Mills, would say that affirmative action in colleges lowers the educational standard. When an underrepresented minority comes to college from a high school lacking many educational tools, college can seem like a slap in the face. From a purely statistical point of view, the races that benefit from racial preferences in admissions, generally have lower standardized test scores and secondary school grades--two factors that typically weigh highly in both in undergraduate and graduate admissions, and for which there is no simple remedy. Unfortunately this lowers the standard for others to be admitted and it is a continuously downgrading cycle. A utilitarianist would say this because they would want what is best for the community as a whole, and a lower educational standard is not going to benefit students in any way (besides making college easier for those who are prepared), or better our society. A utilitarianist would also say that affirmative action (based on race) could easily be solved by helping out pre-college level schools that are lacking educational tools to better their students' educations. By doing this, we would be bettering society and actually raising the educational standard.The next issue is one that an egoist, or someone who believes that is their duty to pursue their own interests, would take. Based on statistics, the fact is that education does not actually help underrepresented races, because of their lacking educational background. Admitting academically unqualified students, admitted under racial preference, into a highly competitive...

Find Another Essay On Race Should Not Be a Consideration in College Admission: Views shared between Egoists, Utilitarians and Egalitarians

Minorities in College: Sports Should NOT Be the Only Avenue to Success

3432 words - 14 pages because I could no longer afford to go to school without working. Throughout these articles we see that many times minority athletes have the sole intent to go to the pros and therefore give a passing grade “C” effort in college. Although, my idea is not fully developed, I think it’s worth stating that I believe minority athletes should have the option to try out for these farm teams because it would be a more efficient use and free up some of the

Service Learning Should NOT be Mandatory For College Students

1339 words - 5 pages learning will not have the desired effect, and should not be forced upon students. It is perhaps intuitive to think that by making students help others there will be a net positive; there could be no downside to volunteering time and effort to help the community. However, a more detailed inspection reveals there are many negatives, and any positive effects are just wishful thinking. To begin with, service learning wouldn’t benefit the

Differing Views on Whether or Not English Should be the Primary Language of Africa

815 words - 3 pages different areas. English, in most nations, is only a second language and is not considered as the main tongue. Additionally, Frank does not support Africa to absorb English because of ethnic division. According to her, English should not be regarded as a “primary” language even in academic purpose. These two arguments are contradictory to each other, but DiReck provides information more persuasively. He emphasizes the points of economy and

Exemplification Essay: Greek Organizations Should NOT be Part of the College Experience

1025 words - 4 pages benefits campus life has to offer, including fraternities and sororities. They do not expect a phone call in the early hours of the morning notifying them of their child's death. Since March of 2000, over 60 people have died in events associated with fraternities, alcohol and/or hazing (Marklein p. A3). Greek life and all its implications should be examined more closely before anyone commits to join such an organization. Thousands of college

College Athletes Should Not Be Exempt from Regular Class Attendance Policies

1035 words - 4 pages demanding schedule that requires some to miss class time. In reality, it is unjust that the critics suggest those athletes be exempt from attending classes. College athletes should not be exempt from the regular class attendance policies. Moreover, athletes who slack and skip classes do not learn how to balance their time between class and sporting activities. Additionally, those athletes fail because of low attendance, missed lectures as well as

College Athletes Should Not Be Exempt from Regular Class Attendance Policies

825 words - 4 pages no and here is why. First, the education of athletes takes priority over recreational activities. Second, it is unfair for athletes to receive preferential treatment. Third, exempting athletes from the policies does not allow them to develop time management skills. For these reasons the college athletes must attend classes and not be exempt from regular class attendance policies. In the first place, educating the college athletes is a

College Athletes Should Not Get Paid for Play

929 words - 4 pages The argument whether a student-athlete should be paid to play or not be paid is one that spans the ages. College sports are considered to be of amateur status by the NCAA. Therefore they believe student-athletes should not receive a pay check to participate in a sport. However on the other end of the spectrum, many critics believe that student-athletes should receive pay for play because not only are they participating in a sport, they are

What Should Be Taken in Consideration When Naming a Baby?

1340 words - 5 pages name, you and your partner both like and agree on it. So the real questions are how would you go about naming your baby? What should you take in consideration when naming your baby? The name that will be given to your baby will be something that he/she will walk this Earth with and will reflect himself/herself a person. As I said in my introduction, your children must live with the name that you give them for the rest of their life or until they

Racial Bias in College Admission

1031 words - 4 pages university admissions...may not adopt rigid formulas to help one minority group or another, but they may consider race as one factor in admissions as part of an effort to create a diverse student body.” Chapman argues that diversity on the campus creates a more comfortable and accepting environment for students, allowing scholars to be at ease in a racially diverse environment. However, diversity disregards students who are worthy of their merit. For

Should There be a Playoff in College Football ?

1226 words - 5 pages every year because the BCS is belleved not to be a fair way in determining the number one team at the end of the football season.When I first started this paper my original topic was, what if Rutgers was one of two teams that went undefeated this college season; should they play for the National Championship game in January? This did not happen and they ended up falling to Cincinnati on November 18th. For this topic I had already made a K&W

What is in Consideration to be a Typical Catholic

2184 words - 9 pages . It is not necessarily adoration but more of venerating her, which is not considered idolatry or a sin. Dulia is more of a reverence as well, but to the saint and the angels of our church. These differences were brought into consideration by the Second Council in Nicaea in 787 AD because of ones who had complained it was idolatry, which were then punished.(Nairaland.com) Catholics pray to Mary and the saints as a way of interceding ones prayers

Similar Essays

Capital Punishment Should Be Abolished: Views Shared Between Utilitarians, Egalitarians, Altruists And Supporters Of The Divine Command Theory

852 words - 3 pages killed is not there to feel like justice has been served. In essence, nobody wins, the killing is a continuous, worthless cycle. It is not maximizing social utility because money, time and effort are wasted on something that is not contributing positively to society in any way. Lastly, a view that is shared between Egalitarians and Utilitarians is that capital punishment is unfair. Statistics show that the mentally ill, males, the poor, and racial

How Alcochol Should Not Be Used In College.

1120 words - 4 pages terrible statistics. Two for instance are MADD andSADD. These such organizations help to raise awareness about alcohol and all it's dangers. Colleges have even devised plans to reduce the amount of alcohol consumed on their campus's. A college should provide students with alternate activities, in order to prevent then from drinking. Campus facilities should remain open, and college's should expand their recreational activities on nights and

Should College Athletes Be Payed Or Not?

1526 words - 6 pages athletes shouldn't get paid. They need to focus on getting an education which is what college is for. Also, the pay they are getting, aka scholarships, should be plenty. Though they get paid more, and its not equal at all. Between the players and the teams, its not fair pay. They could get paid though for their playing time since they do dedicate their college lives to the sport, but they don’t go to class. Should we really be paying 18-22 year old to

Why College Athletes Should Not Be Paid

1997 words - 8 pages themselves in a position to achieve one. I do not want them [the National Labor Relations Board] to change a part of that” (Mixed Reviews). Education of athletes is just as important as the education of any student at a university. The focus should stay in the core, in school, and should not be destroyed by payment of athletes. College athletes are way more than the value of their jersey; they are valuable from the knowledge they learn. In addition