This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Radical And The Republican Essay

1020 words - 5 pages

In his book The Radical and the Republican, James Oakes compares and contrasts the positions of Fredrick Douglas and Abraham Lincoln. Oakes argues that while both Douglas and Lincoln opposed slavery, they used dissimilar tactics because their motivations were different. Lincoln focused on promoting national unity through the eradication of slavery ( 217) while Douglas focused on establishing freedom for blacks ( 223). Oakes strongly supports his thesis with examples of their diverging opinions of slavery’s relation to equality, the constitution, and Christianity. Although Oakes’s book includes little personal commentary, his choice of structure congruently connects Lincoln and Douglas’s accounts, enabling readers to clearly understand his point of view.
Oakes first argued that while Douglas and Lincoln both believed,“ Slavery was an affront to American values” (34) and that political action was necessary to end slavery, their motivations were initially different. Lincoln, not wanting to alienate either the North or South, merely stated that slavery was wrong because it deprived, “ …men and women…hard earned fruit of their own labor.”(58-61). While Douglas agreed with Lincoln that slavery, “ …thwarted progress and stifled individual initiative”( 34), he was more free to expand his reasons further because of his position as a reformist, “ …[ slavery] contradicted the great principles of the Declaration of Independence. It violated the sacred purpose of the constitution. It defiled the precepts of a professedly Christian nation.”( 34). Years later, Lincoln came to a very similar conclusion, but it was only after this position suited his own motivations and was presented using his own tactics such as “ strategic racism” and compromise in order to promote national unity. This example strongly supports Oakes thesis in that it demonstrates how position effected Lincoln and Douglas’s opinion. It was also advantageous to the rest of the book because it acted as a loose outline, which added to the book’s congruency and overall effectiveness.
Oakes then smoothly transitioned from Douglas’s general argument that slavery was against the Declaration of Independence, to Douglas’s sub-argument that racial equality and slavery were intertwined in his chapter, “I Cannot Support Lincoln”. While Douglas was motivated by a desire to see all blacks both freed and treated equally, Oakes argued that Lincoln was motivated more by national unity. Douglas and Lincoln’s differing reasons led to differing tactics.
In order to promote national unity, Lincoln initially believed he had to use “strategic racism” (125) which argued that blacks were not equal to whites. Years later, when Lincoln expressed his revised public opinion that both blacks and white were equal, he still utilized other forms of compromise. Doing so, Lincoln believed, would prevent the alienation of Southern slaveholders. Douglas, on the other hand, did not have the responsibility of guiding a...

Find Another Essay On Radical and the Republican

Comparing the Democratic and Republican Platforms

518 words - 2 pages There are many differences between the Republican and Democratic Party Platform. The Republicans are very conservative and the Democrats are more liberal. Not all the people in the party agree with the beliefs of their party though.On the topic of abortion, Democrats stand proudly for a woman's right to choose. They also strongly support family planning and adoption incentives. The Democrats think abortion should be safe, legal, and rare

Rousseau and Marx: The Radical Critics

1507 words - 7 pages . With a movement as such, there exists philosophers and like-minded thinkings of their time who were also Classical Liberals, but much more radical, disputing their influentialists and the like. Rousseau disagreed with key elements of the Classical Liberal Tradition. In The Social Contract, Rousseau pokes fun at other philosophies about the force, slavery, and other points from other popular philosophers at the time. Rousseau’s human nature

The Democratic and Republican parties in the Gilded Age

693 words - 3 pages laborers, debtors, businessmen, and other non-agrarian vocations. However, both Republican and Democratic sentiments were mixed until two competing parties with few varying significant economic issues were the outcome (508). Republicans gradually began to abandon their commitment to black equality, as many votes were already cast and few freedmen would vote Democrat, with the last radical Republican act passed in 1875 (Civil Rights Act). Southerners

The Democratic and Republican parties in the 2000 presidential election

1139 words - 5 pages their meaning and are constantly searching for a firm purpose.Economics is one of the most important political issues Americans face. It is what makes jobs, creates wealth, and largely contributes partially to overall happiness of individuals. The major driving force behind economics is small business. Small business makes up over 80% of all commerce and jobs in the United States. In their 2000 Party Platform, the Republican National Committee

The Environmental Platform of the Republican, Democratic, and Green Parties

2314 words - 9 pages The Environmental Platform of the Republican, Democratic, and Green Parties The Environment has become a hot topic in political platforms as of late. With noticeable changes in weather patterns such as El Nino, La Nina, and the steady increase in the average daily temperatures, environmentalist group's views and values have become the views and values of more of the general public. This topic has even resulted in more support of the

Infant Mortality Rates versus the Democratic and Republican issues

649 words - 3 pages increase social welfare, and promotes protection as related to the economic well being, which has social influences on infant mortality rates. Other health issues rises as part of the decision on which the legislation passed which more findings are in the works. Infant Mortality Rates versus the Democratic and Republican issues Infant mortality rates are linked to the comparison of having Democratic presidents in office. This spans from the

Federalist Republican debate; which policies were better for the US in that time period and why?

1282 words - 6 pages the future. In opposition to the Federalist, the Republicans had an aversion to ratifying the Constitution. Thomas Jefferson and James Madison merged together forming the Republican Party believing that the Federalist Party, “had become just such an “interested and overbearing majority”. The Republican Party believed they represented the best interest of the people. Unlike the Federalist, the Republicans favored the Articles of Confederation and

The Liberal, Radical, and Conservative Stages in the French and Russian Revolutions

1020 words - 4 pages The Liberal, Radical, and Conservative Stages in the French and Russian Revolutions First I want to say that both beginnings of the French and Russian Revolutions have two major similarities, Economic crisis and Constitutional Monarch governments. Second I think that all revolutions have three stages. I think the French Revolution did go through the three stages but I don’t think that the Russian Revolution had the same three stages. I

The Significance of Radical Thought and Attitudes in the Civil War Period

2092 words - 8 pages The Significance of Radical Thought and Attitudes in the Civil War Period The Civil War caused turmoil and upheaval that affected every strand of life in England. It challenged and upturned the deeply ingrained feudal system with a Monarch as the head of all moral, spiritual and governmental life, and moved thought and order towards new democratic ideas and systems of rule. This period saw a new experimentation in ideas

The Fourth Revolution (An Analysis of the more radical idea between Jane Austen and Mary Wollstonecraft)

1075 words - 5 pages situation of equality for women so they may encourage others to take up arms with them and fight for equality. From the two different texts written by Mary Wollstonecraft and Jane Austen, Mary Wollstonecraft’s “A Vindication of the Rights of Women” is the more radical of the two texts of the day due to Wollstonecraft covering a broader range of subject that women dealt with in her day. Wollstonecraft first begins will addressing education in her

Q1. What are the strengths and limitations of contemporary crime fiction as a vehicle for radical social and political critique?

2591 words - 11 pages raises about this 'War on Drugs' and whether we can wage a War against a thing? Or is it merely just American propaganda used by politicians to group people together and pretend like they care. I will use HBO's television series The Wire and Stephen Soderbergh's film Traffic to portray how crime fiction can be used as a vehicle to critique for radical social and political critique. Such as America's capitalist society, the aspiration of the

Similar Essays

The Radical Republican Party Of The Reconstruction Era

1457 words - 6 pages During the Reconstruction Era of the Civil War, a two new political groups began to form. The Radical Republican Party gained some of its greatest members, two groups of people from opposite sides of the country (Hodges 1). The carpetbaggers and scalawags joined forces to reconstruct the South, but they were met with controversy and criticism because of their radical worldview (Hodges 1). The carpetbaggers and scalawags’ goals were met with

Rousseau And The Republican Party Essay

1441 words - 6 pages Rousseau and The Republican Party     The Republican Party, since its first convention in Michigan in 1854, has had a philosophy that has remained relatively unchanged. Its oath entices Americans to believe that "good government is based on the individual and that each person's ability, dignity, freedom and responsibility must be honored and recognized"   In this essay, I will examine the Republican's main philosophies and will

New York Times And The Republican Party

1303 words - 6 pages In 1884, the New York Times was under the direction of a new publisher, George Jones, Jones was disgusted with the way the Grant administration was governed and allowed for constant scandal to plague its effectiveness. Previously the paper had a strong connection to the Republican party, under their new direction the paper choose to endorse the Democratic party. Those who were running on the Republican ticket were not qualified to fix the issues

Comparing The Democratic And Republican Parties

2731 words - 11 pages Comparing the Democratic and Republican Parties Ralph Nader campaigned for the 2001 Presidency by arguing that there are no real differences between the two major parties. In a broad sense, that statement might seem true. Major political parties play a majoritarian role in an otherwise pluralistic democracy in the United States. They are both majoritarian institutions trying to win control of the government. The differences between the