Rand Ethics Of Altruism Essay

1377 words - 6 pages

Altruism is a concept in which the individual sacrifices regard for themselves in the interest of another. The ethics of altruism state that a person should act in a matter where their self-sacrifice yields the greater well being on the whole. To put that statement in the form of a fundamental principle of rightness, an action is right if and only if (and because) the action brings a net-gain of well being to anyone except the individual performing the action. The altruistic mentality of an individual according to this moral theory means that any action that they undertake should be in the interest of others rather than themselves. The ethics of this concept also state that relationships of ...view middle of the document...

There is another statement within altruistic ethics, which denies the concept that the value that individuals have to a person is based on the value the individual has for themselves. Rand points out the flaw in this logic stating that a person can only have so much respect for another person as they can have for themselves, by disregarding their own value they’re in turn devaluing the other individual, which seems intuitively wrong in the way altruism should regard the individuals involved. To make an example, a grown-up man has a candy-bar, which he can give to a child without, or to give it to his child whom is also without, but has asked for the father to buy him the bar. By the ethics of altruism, the man, in order to act rightly, should give the candy bar to the child he has no relationship with since it will be more sacrificial to his own well-being to do so, but intuitively this seems wrong since a candy-bar seems without meaning and sacrifice in this situation does not appear to be a morally correct decision. From this example, the intensity of the situation appears to play a role in whether or not self-sacrifice should be necessary in making a morally right decision.
The critical nature of a situation should determine the proper response when it comes to altruistic action according to Ayn’s moral theory. The theory she proposes takes into account emergencies that require actions of individuals that are necessary in making sure that the value of an individual is taken into account properly. The example Ayn uses is to consider a man who values life aboard a ship at sea, the ship is then shipwrecked and there are people onboard the ship who need saving. In this situation he is responsible, though not at the expense of his own life, for helping out the individuals in need. Her theory also puts a limitation where the only extent of his duty is to help save lives, once he’s achieved that goal, he has acted morally right, therefore he can not be held responsible for other troubles that might arise for the people he’s saved. The goal that Ayn achieves in her theory is to limit the morally obligatory decisions for emergencies, and ensure that the individual isn’t always at a loss when acting morally right. Ayn’s moral theory can be stated as: An action is morally right if and only if in situations of (metaphysical) emergency the agent of an action acts to preserve human life. The main difference between her proposed theory and the theory of ethical altruism is that the altruistic theory needs constant self-sacrificing when making decisions, while her theory reserves self-sacrifice for situations of emergency.
The ethics of altruism moral theory can be compared to Utilitarianism by the fact that it has issues with being too demanding of people. Much like a Utilitarian would say its better to forego a major surgery for the sake of helping a greater number of people, the ethics of...

Find Another Essay On rand ethics of altruism

Psychological Egoism Essay

1980 words - 8 pages ethics, Rand started at the very beginning: why do you need ethics anyway, she asks, what is it for? Her answer to this question can be analyzed in two parts.First, Rand said that values ought to be objective facts about reality. She noted that life is conditional, and that it requires a specific course of action to maintain. She concluded that something can be good or bad only to a living organism acting to survive: the good furthers life, the

Altruism: The Illusion of Self-Interest Essay

1156 words - 5 pages after it is over, it will always turn into a reciprocal altruism action. Many would argue that moral would influence in it as well as the opposite of altruism, ethics. Another two different main points which have to respect this altruism theory is the universal egoism and the moral. Although altruism and egoism are completely opposites, there is a connection between so-called selfish behavior and altruistic acts. The moral action is based largely

Ayn Rand and Today's Business Ethics

1850 words - 7 pages INTRODUCTIONThis paper is intended to give an overview over what would Ayn Rand think about today's ethics business. In order to understand her I have divided this paper into three parts. The first part is a brief summary of her life to understand the background that leads her to develop her objectivism theory. The second part is a description of what her theory is, what are the essential parts of objectivism, how this theory was developed and

Objectivism and The Fountainhead

2112 words - 8 pages herself and be known. The Individual is what is important, and she stresses this so much in her novel, using the main character, Howard Roark as perhaps a mirror image of herself. (Actually, it has been stated that Ayn Rand used the prominent architect Frank Lloyd Wright as a model for Howard Roark, which Rand denied (Bierut 2), but personally, I think that Howard Roark is a model of herself). She states throughout her novel that altruism is a

Altruism and Egotism Portrayed in Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead

1968 words - 8 pages In the world today, altruism is associated with the “common good” of man while egotism is associated with evil and non-consideration of the fellow man. In contrast to the world’s view, Ayn Rand provides and proves a new definition for egotism through her book, The Fountainhead. She defines egotism in the context of ethics. She states: “Man-every man-is an end in himself, not a means to the ends of others; he must live for his own sake, neither

Analysis of Altruism And Egoism in Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead

1484 words - 6 pages The ultimate motive of both the altruist and egoist is personal gain. Separating the two ideologies is the method by which this is accomplished. For the altruist, addressing the needs of humanity is purportedly the sole purpose of existence. Egoists, on the other hand, refuse to act if an action does not directly benefit themselves. In The Fountainhead, Ayn Rand addresses the function of altruists and egoists within society through character

Peace on the Streets: Analysis of Altruism and Egoism in Ayn Rand's The Fountainhead

1502 words - 6 pages The ultimate motive of both the altruist and egoist is personal gain. Separating the two ideologies is the method by which this is accomplished. For the altruist, addressing the needs of humanity is purportedly the sole purpose of existence. Egoists, on the other hand, refuse to act if an action does not directly benefit themselves. In The Fountainhead, Ayn Rand addresses the function of altruists and egoists within society through character

Ayn Rand

1964 words - 8 pages ). Objectivism is against altruism which "...holds that man has no right to exist for his own sake, that service to others is the only moral justification of his existence..." (Ayn Rand Column). During the height of the Objectivist movement in 1968, Rand had gathered a very devoted group of followers and believers of her philosophy. (Baker pg.22 1987). The motto that these followers lived by was: "I swear--by my life and my love of it--that

Psychological and Ethical Egoism

1877 words - 8 pages Egoism is a teleological theory of ethics that sets the ultimate criterion of morality in some nonmoral value (i.e. happiness or welfare) that results from acts (Pojman 276). It is contrasted with altruism, which is the view that one's actions ought to further the interests or good of other people, ideally to the exclusion of one's own interests (Pojman 272). This essay will explain the relation between psychological egoism and ethical

Importance of Moral Character in Sports

1545 words - 7 pages living. Based on the idea the values are not rooted in some transcendent source but in objective reality and that one can discover these ethics in objective reality, Rand pursued America’s moral, capitalistic system. Fascinated by the respect for the integrity of each individual, Rand who had grown up surrounded by the collectivism of Soviet communism, escaped to the United States to live in a country where everyone must live and work for

Individualism in The Fountainhead

1336 words - 5 pages . "Dominique," says Rand, "is myself in a bad mood." As a foil for Dominique is Catherine Halsey, a tragic, but beautifully drawn figure - a figure of utter altruism of complete submersion in to the lives of others. Society, however applauds her dedication as the perfect social worker, failing to see that until she has a self of her own, she cannot possibly be of any value to others. Rand describes the various groups of writers and artists that

Similar Essays

Philosphy Introductory To Ethics By Ken Burgess The Essay Contains Three Questions That The Professor Asked And We Had To Discuss. Areas Of Interest That I Discussed Were Kant, Ayn Rand, Rawl

1512 words - 6 pages Ethics of Selfishness/Ethics of DutyCompare and contrast Kant and Ayn Rand on the issue of altruismAltruism is an unselfish act wherein one's intention is to benefit another. Within every act, three aspects must be considered: the motivation behind the act; the moral value of the individual carrying out the act; and the selfish consequences of the act itself. Both Kant and Rand agree on using moral values to make decisions on an act, however

Paper

934 words - 4 pages In "The Virtue of Selfishness" Ayn Rand argues that self-interest is the norm of ethics. Perhaps the strongest argument Rand gives for this claim relies on the argument that it is up to every individual to decide what values his or her life needs. Since it is important to know what morals one should have, or if one should even have any. In this paper I will argue that this argument fails because a self-interested person will belittle the

The De Humanization Of America Essay

2082 words - 8 pages thing that people are morally obligated to do. If a person’s self-interest happens to be the same as someone else’s and in helping yourself you also help someone else, your actions are right only if the initial motive was to gain a personal advantage. According to Rand, altruism lessens the value of people and government has no place in society other than to protect the people from criminals and invaders. Despite her contempt for the Bolshevik

Ethical Egoism: The Problem With Ayn Rand

2516 words - 10 pages merely offended by that attitude, but others might take revenge or retaliate against them, thereby nullifying the argument that others don’t matter. The opposite is true – we are treated the way we treat others. If everyone behaves the way Rand advocates, the world would be an evil place without compassion. According to Rand, altruism lessens the value of people. She calls altruism a “basic evil” and refers to those who perpetuate the system of