This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rational Choice Theory In Political Science

4419 words - 18 pages

Rational Choice Theory in Political Science

According to one of rational choice theory’s prominent and more thoughtful contemporary exponents, Peter C. Ordeshook, “four books mark the beginning of modern political theory: Anthony Downs’s An Economic Theory of Democracy (1957), Duncan Black’s Theory of Committees and Elections (1958), William H. Riker’s A Theory of Political Coalitions (1962), and James Buchanan and Gordon Tullock’s The Calculus of Consent (1962). These volumes, along with Kenneth Arrow’s Social Choice and Individual Values (1951), began such a wealth of research that political scientists today have difficulty digesting and synthesizing all but small parts of it. Consequently, the full value of this research often goes unrealized…” (Ordeshook 1986, ix)

In this essay I will argue that, contrary to Ordeshook’s claim, the “full value of this research” has actually been overstated; not for the lack of profundity in the assumptions and certain selected observations contained in the literature mentioned above, but for the failure of rational choice theory in explaining political phenomena empirically. This failure can be understood in terms of the fallacies associated with rational choice theory’s predictive and universalist aspirations, as well as in terms of the methodological misuse of the basic assumptions of rational choice theory when actually used in explanatory frameworks. As Donald Green and Ian Shapiro argue, the weaknesses of rational choice scholarship are rooted in the aspiration of rational choice theorists to come up with universal theories of politics, “which leads many rational choice theorists to pursue even more subtle forms of theory elaboration, with little attention to how these theories might be operationalized and tested—even in principle.” (Green and Shapiro 1994, 6)

The two central questions that I will examine are why and how rational choice theory fails to adequately explain empirical political phenomena. First I will provide an overview of what rational choice theory is and why it has staked such a prominent position in the discipline of political science. In this section I conclude that rational choice theory has indeed developed advanced methodologies at telling us how rational agents should behave. Then in my second section I will show, using the empirical case of the free-rider problem and collective action, as well as the case of suicide terrorism, that rational choice theory cannot adequately account for actual political phenomena. In my third section I will provide some reasons for why this is the case. Finally, in my concluding section I will posit a theoretical framework incorporating some refinements to the assumptions behind rational choice theory that would better aid a predictive (but not universalist) political science.

What is Rational Choice Theory?

Rational choice theory is actually more than one theory per se, but the basic similarities among its variants mean that...

Find Another Essay On Rational Choice Theory in Political Science

Theories of Symbolic Interactionism Exchange Theory and Rational Choice Theory

1073 words - 4 pages Theories of Symbolic Interactionism Exchange Theory and Rational Choice Theory This essay will address actions of individuals and the contribution individual actions make to the social structure, how society flows to the actor via the “Me” and is constructed or reconstructed by the “I,” giving the “I” a place in creating society. I will further analyze the theories and explore the impact of norms and values on the decisions by the actors

The Rational Choice Theory: Criminology by Frank Schmalleger

1885 words - 8 pages Gone are the days of pick-pockets and traditional thieves stealing your money and wrist-watches right off of your body. The deviants of today are turning to a safer and easier alternative to gain access to your possessions – the internet. Rational choice theory as defined by Frank Schmalleger in his text Criminology is “a perspective that holds that criminality is the result of a conscious choice and predicts that individuals choose to commit

Rational Choice Theory and Swordfish A Development of Theory and Character

1785 words - 7 pages then be examined against the rational choice theory to explain why each character engages in their criminal activity. Swordfish starts off in a showdown between Gabriel Shear’s American terrorist group and the entire gambit of the Los Angeles Police Department (LAPD). Gabriel is minutes away from successfully robbing the World Banc. Everything is in place for the heist to be completed. As a bargaining chip Gabriel has all of the civilians in the

The Rational Choice Theory versus The Trait Theory on the Issue of the Reduction or Control of Crime

819 words - 3 pages Theoretical schools have long been used in the study of criminal behavior and as guidelines for determining ways to effectively reduce crimes. Two popular theories used in today's society are the Rational Choice Theory and the Trait Theory. Some argue that the Choice Theory is a more effective way of reducing and controlling crime while others argue in favor of the Trait Theory. After researching both theories, I have come to the conclusion that

are humans rational individuals capable of making their own decisions? - critical ideas of contemporary social and political theory - essay

1348 words - 6 pages Caldonia Keighery-Green S3664098 Critical thinking assessment 1 Adam 11.30 Wednesday Word count: 1028 exc. references People are primarily rational individuals capable of free choices. Discuss with reference to at least one theorist of subjectivity mentioned in week 2. The assertion that most neurotypical humans are rational individuals capable of reason and logic implies we are autonomous, and therefore able to make free choices constrained by

On Theory Change in Science

1383 words - 6 pages both changes in observational interpretation or changes in ideology based on human behavior or the historical background prior to a revolution. When the community embraces a new paradigm, a new normal science is formed. Then, a new crisis may emerge, and the process of theory change continues indefinitely. One key feature of Kuhn’s account of science is that it is the first to acknowledge the contribution of human behavior and political

The Tea Party Movement's Influence on the U.S. party competition in a Rational-Choice Perspective

2873 words - 11 pages The theoretical and methodological framework to be used in this analysis is based on a rational-choice microeconomic theory by Harold Hotelling (1929). In his 'ice cream dealers' model, he assumed a beach strip with fixed boundaries, evenly populated with guests. At that beach, two ice cream dealers have set up their stands and are selling coequal products at the same price in a competitive situation. The guests at the beach always buy their ice

Theories and Methods in Political Science: Sanders

1210 words - 5 pages , I don’t find that to be true. Political action is based on behaviors of certain figures, and there is solid reasoning behind it. Behavioral analysis is rich in substance because of the commitment researchers make to analyze behaviors, and because of this, much of what we know today is because of them. Works Cited Marsh, David, and Gerry Stoker. "Behavioral Analysis." Theory and Methods in Political Science. New York: St. Martin's, 1995. 23

Critically analyse the role of ‘consent’ in Locke’s political theory

1723 words - 7 pages conclusions show that people in a civil society may reluctantly consent to domination and obedience. In his own argument, Locke may be seen therefore to be contradicting himself. This may, ironically, be why many have criticised him as a bourgeois liberal. David Hume further criticises the role of consent in Locke’s political theory on the grounds that consent is merely impossible (Haakonssen 1994). He asks whether consent is even possible, as there

The Relevance of Evolutionary Theory in Biomedical Science

1936 words - 8 pages Evolution has been arguably one of the largely discussed topics in the advanced institution of science. The theory of evaluation, first presented by Charlies Darwin (1990), states that all biotic organisms were developed and advanced from primitive organisms through gradual changes occurring over time. The relevance of this fundamental theory is witnessed throughout the disciplines of the pathology department in the subject area of biomedical

Key Events In Shaping The American Nation - uvm/ political science - Essay

1783 words - 8 pages Sophia Tornabene Political Science Long Essay Throughout time there have been numerous events, both American and non-American that have played roles in shaping the American nation through its settlement history and the form of government that presently exists. There have been events that have had both negative and positive outcomes. Events with negative outcomes have shown us what to avoid in order for these end results to never happen again

Similar Essays

Rational Choice Theory Essay

670 words - 3 pages decision to traded later. She chose profit and her 50/50 probability resulted in the worst-case scenario. Rational Choice Theory is best when used based on situation and not in all circumstances. Works Cited Scott, J. (2000). Rational choice theory. In G. Browning, A. Halcli, & F. Webster (Eds.), Understanding contemporary society: Theories of the present. (pp. 126-139). London: SAGE Publications Ltd. doi: http://dx.doi.org/10.4135/9781446218310.n9 political science. (2014). In Encyclopaedia Britannica. Retrieved from http://0-www.britannica.com.mylibraryus.armybiznet.com/EBchecked/topic/467721/political-science

Rational Choice Theory Essay

1292 words - 5 pages There are three main points that are reinforced in rational choice theory (Cornish and Clarke, 1986). First, it may work better or worse for different types of crime, yet it is thought that there are rational choices in every type of crime even impulsive and pathologic crimes. Second, the theory should be applied on a crime-specific basis. Hence, burglaries can’t be grouped together in among residential and commercial categories. Rather

Routine Activity Theory And Rational Choice Theory

1396 words - 6 pages The study of criminology is why individuals commit crimes and why they behave in certain situations. When you understand why someone might commit a crime, you can come up with ways to prevent or control the crime. There are several different theories in criminology, in this paper I will be discussing Routine Activity Theory and Rational Choice theory. I will be comparing and contrasting as well between the two of these theories. Routine

Rational Choice Theory, Rational Choice Approach To Crime Causation,Rational Choice Theory And Deterrence Theory's Impact On Crime Prevention Strategies

529 words - 2 pages , 2008). These thieves will also specifically choose locations which are close to where they live in order to make a quick escape and to assure they know the area. This is a fine example of how premeditated crimes are products of rational decision making.The rational choice theory states that street-smart offenders (1) calculate the potential success of committing crime; (2) select their targets on the basis of risk assessment; and (3) will choose