This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rational Expectation Theory And Ideological Factor Of National Security

2187 words - 9 pages

Raiffa-Kalai-Smorodinsky Analysis

The Raiffa-Kalai-Smorodinsky (RKS) bargaining solution is defined with respect to a “ideal” outcome in which each player’s utility is maximized (26). Figure 6 demonstrates the two-person situation. There is again a default position and feasible set. The point represents an ideal outcome in which each player’s share is the maximum possible within the feasible set, regardless of the consequences for the other players. The RKS solution is the best feasible point on the line segment from to .

Figure 6. Raiffa-Kalai-Smorodinsky solution.

We can see the RKS solution as the result of making proportional allocations to the players. Each player has a maximum gain . First, allot each player 10% of his or her maximum gain, then 20%, and so on until further allocations are infeasible. It is clear that enlarging the feasible set can never cause a player’s allocation to decrease.

Again, The axiomatic derivation of the RKS solution assumes "cardinal non-comparability", anonymity and a Pareto condition. However, it replaces the independence of irrelevant alternatives with the monotonicity property just mentioned (27). The derivation is problematic for the same reason as the derivation of the Nash solution: cardinal non comparability is a very strong assumption that rules out meaningful comparison of utilities as quantities.

A possible bargaining justification is that the RKS solution achieves the minimax relative concession mentioned earlier. If player accepts offer , the player’s concession (with respect to the ideal) is . The concession if negotiation fails is , which means that the relative concession is . It might be argued that the players will try to minimize their relative concessions and will reach equilibrium when they minimize the maximum relative concession among them. Algebraically , minimizing the maximum relative concession is the same as maximizing the minimum relative gain , which is what the RKS point accomplishes.


Figure 7. Anomalous example for the RKS bargaining solution, which in this case is the default position . The feasible set is the shaded triangular area, and the Rawlsian minimax solution is .

So, in the two-player case, the RKS solution resembles the Rawlsian maximin solution, except that it maximizes the minimum relative gain rather than the minimum utility. It might be seen as having ideological content on that basis. However, it leads to some anomalies when there are three or more players (Figure 7). The line segment from to leaves the feasible set at , which means that is the RKS solution-scarcely a rational outcome. is solution for The Rawlsian maximin.

Ideological Factor in National Security
This part of strategic Ideology consists of assumptions at a more operational level, about what strategic options are the most efficacious for dealing with the threat environment as defined by the central paradigm. It is at this second level that strategic Ideology begins to...

Find Another Essay On Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

1043 words - 5 pages and the above axioms, the national security function must be the maximin function. Curiously, however, these premises imply only that welfare function is maximin or maximax (21). The latter maximizes the utility of the best-off actor; that is, . To infer a minimax principle, one must rule out the maximax principle on some other ground. Again the idea of the argument can be conveyed in the two-actors case (22), where separability does not play a

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

1432 words - 6 pages implications for current and prospective extraction of this decision. Furthermore, rational expectations have been intensively examined in the social choice theory literature, which generally assumes no particular connection between individual self-interest and social welfare. Rather, it carries out a logical analysis of what it means to agree rationally on social policy when individual preferences differ. It then derives structural characteristics

Classical and Rational Theory

962 words - 4 pages , because many people repeatedly commit crimes. So, while this explains a portion of the criminals it did not explain the majority of criminals (career burglars, bank robbers, rapist etc). This led to a paradigm shift which began to focus more on criminal behavior and why people commit crimes.One of the paradigm changes was the rational theory. This paradigm hinged on the fact that human had free will. This paradigm also includes routine theory and

Theories of Symbolic Interactionism Exchange Theory and Rational Choice Theory

1073 words - 4 pages Theories of Symbolic Interactionism Exchange Theory and Rational Choice Theory This essay will address actions of individuals and the contribution individual actions make to the social structure, how society flows to the actor via the “Me” and is constructed or reconstructed by the “I,” giving the “I” a place in creating society. I will further analyze the theories and explore the impact of norms and values on the decisions by the actors

Routine Activity Theory and Rational Choice Theory

1396 words - 6 pages The study of criminology is why individuals commit crimes and why they behave in certain situations. When you understand why someone might commit a crime, you can come up with ways to prevent or control the crime. There are several different theories in criminology, in this paper I will be discussing Routine Activity Theory and Rational Choice theory. I will be comparing and contrasting as well between the two of these theories. Routine

Rational Choice Theory and Swordfish A Development of Theory and Character

1785 words - 7 pages Swordfish is a dark counter-espionage action thriller about power, money, sacrifice and 21st-century breaking and entering. Over the course of this paper characters will be introduced and then systematically compared to the rational choice theory and categorized by their actions. First, a review of the movie must be completed. Second, a thorough examination of the rational choice theory will be conducted. Lastly, the selected characters will

How effective are 'cultural' and 'ideological' perspective in helping us to understand the distinct features of national people management practices

2641 words - 11 pages and therefore are faced with issues on how gaining competitive advantages. Externally, measures such as mergers, acquisitions etc can be taken. Internally, managing the organisation of work and people more effectively could be one way. Organisations are evolving in a competitive and changing environment and other factors can affect the way of managing people.It is then interesting to ask how effective are 'cultural' and 'ideological' perspective

The Catalysts and Images of Terrorism: National Security Threat

3468 words - 14 pages enhancing American national security promoting world peace” (pg. 585). DPT is not only a fallacy, but it does not even begin to understand and contain modern day terrorism. Democratic Peace Theory sounds brilliant on paper, but when closely inspected, its deceptive nature and apparent simplicity becomes evident. One issue that currently divides many experts is the question of defining democracy and liberalism. Furthermore, there is no concise

Rational Choice Theory, rational choice approach to crime causation,rational choice theory and deterrence theory's impact on crime prevention strategies

529 words - 2 pages The rational choice approach to crime causation is composed of several different concepts. According to this theory, criminal behavior is the product of careful thought and planning. Offenders choose crime after considering both personal factors-money, revenge, thrills, entertainment- and situational factors, such as target availability, security measures, and police presence (Siegel, 2008). Once the decision has been made to commit a specific

National Security Policies of Today

797 words - 4 pages state and local governments the Transportation Security Administration. The U.S. National Security policy changed in some obvious ways after the Homeland Security Act of 2002 became the law of the land by President George W. Bush. The Homeland Security Act of 2002 impacted the ways of National Security policy through the federal Department of Homeland Security to recognize and focus on infrastructure in order to protect the U.S. from terrorist

Criminalogical theories: An exploration of social disorganization, differential association, anomie and rational theory

1147 words - 5 pages There are many theories of crime some are similar and some are not. In the case of social disorganization, anomie, differential association, and rational theories, there are many similarities as well as, subtle differences. The first theory to look at is social disorganization theory.The Social Disorganization Theory provides that if relationships in the family and friendship groupings are good, neighborhoods are stable and cohesive, and people

Similar Essays

Rational Expectation Theory And Ideological Factor Of National Security

964 words - 4 pages provide a “reason” to make agreements that are ideological aspect of national security in some sense: the agreements would result from rational bargaining in any case. Nash and RKS solutions do not necessarily satisfy standard ideological criteria, however, and they can be quite counterintuitive. Also there is no consensus on how to specify or justify a reasonable default position from which to start bargaining. We conclude from all this that the

Rational Expectation Theory And Ideological Factor Of National Security 676 Words

676 words - 3 pages development. Provide rational expectations theories explanatory principle in the central neoclassical economic theory much and I was born in the academic literature and wide . Rational expectations theories are theories experimental human behavior , and as such , does not claim to ideology . However , it is often seen as the presence of traces of the ideological factor of national security . In particular, it addressed the question of " Why should I be

Rational Expectation Theory And Ideological Factor Of National Security 936 Words

936 words - 4 pages might say that there is a reason to be ideological: an ideological arrangement is the result of rational bargaining. The best-known bargaining theory is due to Nash (23) and yields the Nash bargaining solution (which should not be confused with the Nash equilibrium of non-cooperative game theory). Figure 5 illustrates the Nash bargaining solution for two persons. The point represents the utility vector of a default position . This is the state

Rational Expectation Theory And Ideological Factor Of National Security 1471 Words

1471 words - 6 pages policies.(95) This brief review suggests a concluding observation about the pattern of theorizing in national security studies. In the case of international relations theorizing, one can discern a dominant arc of research. It starts in the lower-left quadrant with a materialist-rationalist neo-realism, extends to the right along the x-axis in the form of neo-liberal regime theory, which adds more ideological imagery, and moves into the upper-right