This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rats And Rationality By Joel Marks

983 words - 4 pages

Rats and Rationality by Joel Marks
As the scientists Jonathan Crystal and Allison Foote have found that rats have “high mental power,” the report of the research suggests that rats can be used in future neuroscience experiments. As a result, the usage of rats in the neuroscience experiments will be increased. The author of the article, Rats and Rationality, Joel Marks argues against this proposal and emphasizes that the usage of rats in the experiments should be decreased. Mark argues that the conclusion of the research to use rats in neuroscience experiment is illogical. Even though Marks argues that rats should not be used in neuroscience experiments to benefits humans, his argument is not persuading due to contradiction and lack of evidences.
Marks focuses on two main assumptions as he analyses this study. He states that the experiments of rats are invasive. According to the proposal of the study, rats have to undergo the neuroscience experiments, which are often painful as Marks says, “concerned investigators will lead to the future confinements, perhaps torture, and ultimately killing of rats” (Marks). The other assumption of Marks is that the protection for the animal is fewer as he states, “minimal legal protection to over 90 percent of the animals in laboratories” (Marks). This fewer legal protection for animals results in the uncontrolled experiments that use rats as experimental subjects.
Marks assumption regarding the invasive experiments and the protection of the animals is contradictory. The reason is that the rat experiments might be different what he assumes since there are no proper clarifications given about the invasive experiments in Marks paper. Neither all the rat experiments will be invasive nor all the experiments will let rats to be killed. Hence, Mark should not generalize his opinion only based on this particular research to all the rat experiments. The other assumption of Marks, regarding the protection of animals, lacks evidence since the Animal Welfare Act is not the only protection for the animals. There are many other organizations over the world that care about the protection of the animals and work to improve the animal welfare. Therefore, Marks needs solid evidence to support his argument regarding rat experiments and the protection of rats.
To prove his argument Marks compares the reasoning of human and rats, which is considered as a distinctive characteristic of human. He emphasizes that rats and humans are not alike even though rats have higher cognitive power as humans do. Therefore, humans should not under estimate the reasoning of rats and make use of them to improve the quality of humans’ lives. If human can reason, they should be able to reason that what measurements they can use to determine the similarities of the cognition of humans and the rats. Moreover, humans should have the ability to understand that the animals also have the right to live and can feel the pain as humans do. Therefore,...

Find Another Essay On Rats and Rationality by Joel Marks

Book Review: "The Old Rookie" by Jim Morris and Joel Engel

581 words - 2 pages baseball, football, and basketball. He got many friends and was just getting to his new life when his dad decided to move back to his hometown Brownwood, Texas where all they cared about was football. He was not welcomed in his new school in Texas as only athletes, cowboys, or just plain tough. As he had no way to prove, he was an athlete because there was no baseball. He proved himself by playing for the football team and became the varsity's second

The Clockwork Boy Essay

2527 words - 11 pages he already knows so much about clocks. He picks up things from the market when Joel is busy. He’s kind, as seen by the stay cat he picked up and refused to throw back out into the streets. He’s so easy going that Joel’s little tendencies never stress him out. He’s just always helpful and almost always by Joel’s side. Joel didn’t want Ray to stop working. He wanted to give him a life worth living. A life fulfilling. One day Ray came home with a

The Book of Joel

1065 words - 4 pages visions and prophecies. The third formula is a bit more complex and uses four parts: the first part is introductory, followed by a principle statement, then pertinent details ending with the closing formula.8 This third formula is used mainly in the third chapter telling of God’s future intentions to restore all that was lost to the people of Israel and call all others to judgement. I find the book of Joel very appealing and particularly like

The Effect of Prenatal Stress on Sexual Behavior of Male Rats

1263 words - 6 pages . Frye and Orecki (2002) found that prenatal stress resulted in increased behavioral inhibition of the female rats in mating situations. This study, and the study by Frye and Orecki (2002), both examine the affect of prenatal stress on rats. Each study investigates the sexual behavior of rats that were prenatally stressed, in comparison to rats that were not prenatally stressed. Frye and Orecki (2002) focused on the affect on female rats

Joel's Dream

1425 words - 6 pages discuss the terms of his contract and if all went well he would sign for Milan and fulfill his dream of being a star footballer and also make his wife Sharon very very happy. Sharon was a gold digger and was after Joel for his money, but she did stick by him, they had been married for two years and if Joel got the contract Sharon would be able to move to Milan and have everything and have everything she desired. So obviously she was very

Change Over Time

793 words - 4 pages The Columbian Exchange refers to a historical period of the exchange of animals, plants, diseases, and technology between the Old World (Europe, Asia, and Africa) and the New World (the Americas). It is considered one of the most significant events in the history of culture because it affected almost every society by bringing deadly diseases and expanding the variety of new crops and livestock. Today, rats can be found everywhere in the world

Short and Long Term Regulation of “Leptin” Through Feeding

866 words - 4 pages low level of Leptin? For the result of the online research, I have found an article that was published by M. Flavia Barbano and Martine Cador who are studying at the University Victor Segalen Bordeaux in France. Also, this report has done at the Laboratory of Neuropsychology in the University Victor Segalen Bordeaux. This journal have used thirty two rats and three experiences by investigating the motivation, anticipatory, and consummatory

Traps and Poisons for Eradicating Rats in the Home

652 words - 3 pages ., cage trap) This type of trap uses a repeating style where one or more rodents can be caught at a time. The rodents caught in this trap can be released in a new location, or disposed of using rodenticides. Cage traps are effective for one or two rats, but not for an established colony. 2. Snap Trap (e.g., spring trap and break trap) This trap, which is the most common rat control method, utilises triggers to hold bait, and kills the rodent by

Three Skeleton Key Ending

1116 words - 5 pages . There was barely any food in there. The supply ship hadn’t come for a while, and we were running out of water. I found this ironic, since we were surrounded by the blue ocean, which was filled with more water than all the people on the Earth could drink. We salvaged whatever food and drink we could, but it was just enough to last us for three days. I told Itchoua and Gleo that we should at least try to kill the rats, as a possible food source, but

Salvation in the Old Testament

998 words - 4 pages (Isaiah, 24:2). Here Isaiah employs a kind of antithesis, giving examples of opposing sets of people in order to make it clear that no one will be spared from the desolation that the Lord will cast upon the earth. He goes on to make this even clearer, by stating that “For thus it shall be on earth and among the nations, as when an olive tree is beaten, as at the gleaning when the grape harvest is ended” (Isaiah, 24:13). Like Joel, Isaiah

Chapter one

1943 words - 8 pages she didn’t want him to push the subject by the way that her bushy eyebrows lowered and pulled inwards. “What’d you do to it?” “None of your business,” She said in a low agitated tone. Her eyes always warned him to stop while he was ahead, but sometimes he worried if he never asked, the Rat would never tell him. He couldn’t help it, though, since she was gone so often. Every time she had a break from off-sites, Joel would do his best to crunch

Similar Essays

The Reversal Of Power In Uncle Remus: His Songs And Sayings By Joel Chandler Harris

1358 words - 5 pages The Reversal of Power in Uncle Remus: His Songs and Sayings by Joel Chandler Harris In Joel Chandler Harris' Uncle Remus: His Songs and Sayings, Uncle Remus frames the black folktales as entertainment for the young boy with the similar approach Joel Chandler Harris writes this entertaining novel. Both the author and Uncle Remus employ the format of entertainment to further convey the issues of black and white race relations. One issue

Attenuation Of Insulin Resistance, Metabolic Syndrome And Hepatic Oxidative Stress By Resveratrol In Fructose Fed Rats

592 words - 3 pages SIRT-1 and SIRT-2 could be useful to attenuate diabetic cardiomyopathy by inhibiting NFkB activity. In the present study, we have administered resveratrol a well-known activator of SIRT-1 to fructose fed diabetic rats for 8 weeks to demonstrate if resveratrol can reduce NFkB activation and ameliorate cardiac oxidative stress through deacetylation of NFkB.

The Use Of Tone And Metaphors In Marks By Linda Pastan

581 words - 2 pages The Use of Tone and Metaphors in Marks by Linda Pastan Linda Pastan?s poem ?Marks? is unusual because it addresses the frustrations of a typical housewife. Few people consider being a wife and mother a full-time job in itself, and it is not uncommon for a woman who plays both of these roles to feel overworked and unappreciated. What is unusual about Pastan?s poem is the way she effectively conveys these sentiments by the use of

Critique And Analysis Of "Goodbye Saigon" By Billy Joel

613 words - 2 pages Song:"We met as soul mates"The soldiers were enthusiastic, buddies, and hopeful for a better life."We left as inmates, from an asylum"The soldiers dreams/ideas of heroism, and valour were completely wrong"And we were so gung ho to lay down our lives"The soldiers thought they'd be heroes, that when they came back, they would be revered as fighters for freedom."And WE were sharp; as sharp as knives""And THEY were sharp; As sharp as knives