This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Raymond Carver With Cathedral And John Updike With A&P

1201 words - 5 pages

Raymond Carver with “Cathedral” and John Updike with “A&P”
“Cathedral” and A&P both short stories written during the same century. But even though they both introduce stereotypical characters that somehow change their view of the world, they have many more different aspects. The stories differ in atmosphere and the quantity of people involve in each story.
The story “Cathedral” only took place in a family house with only the husband, wife who can be qualified as a static character tried to kill herself in the past, and finally the blind man. Unlike in the short story “A&P” the event took place in a grocery store with Sammy, the three girls and finally the manager who is also a static character, nothing special with him, just the typical manager the “man”. The short story “Cathedral” is protagonist is a married man who have difficulties making connections with people and even his wife, and he seems to have problems maybe a little jealous of the connection his wife is able to make with other people. “A&P” is protagonist is Sammy, an eighteen years old boy who works in a grocery store, and he hates his job. The two stories do not express the same stereotype values, the husband in “Cathedral” is being stereotype against the blinds, and he seems to have his mind made about how all blind people are, so in the short story “Cathedral” the blinds represent the stereotype. In “A&P”, for Sammy it is the young girls. The catalyst change in both stories is unexpected and it is a disturbance of the characters everyday routine. When the girls in bathing suits entered in the store, Sammy was really surprised at the girls’ careless dresscode or behavior: “You know, it’s one thing to have a girl in a bathing suit down on the beach . . . but another thing in the cool of the A & P” (John Updike 14). Sammy then describes the usual patrons of the A&P as “women with six children and varicose veins mapping their legs” (John Updike 14). Sammy has become kind of used to the same “run-of-the-mill”, decent-business dressed patrons who enter the store. This draw the parallel to the husband in “Cathedral” is also taken away from his daily routine when Robert, the blind man comes to visit. He is bothered about the out-of-towner coming because he is only familiar with pleasing himself, and the fact that Robert is blind will most likely complicate his everyday life.
In each stories the people responsible for the change are introduced differently, for instance in “Cathedral” the wife brought the blind man, who was expected by the husband but not wanted, but in “A&P” the girls showed up out of nowhere, they were totally unexpected by Sammy or even the manager, the arrival of these unusual people made Sammy and the husband to take a step back and look at their lives to see what these guests meant to them. Both protagonists lead very ordinary lives, but these unusual visitors open up a pathway to extraordinary or even miracle changes one might say. For Sammy, the girls’ way of...

Find Another Essay On Raymond Carver with Cathedral and John Updike with A&P

“A&P” by John Updike Essay

797 words - 4 pages In some point of our life, we have experienced that sensation where we are between what we think is correct and what we know is correct, but when we are teenagers that line is almost unrecognizable and it is when we make most of our mistakes that, at some point, cost us more than we believe. John Updike, born in the 20th century, was an American author and a winner of two Pulitzer Prizes for Fiction. He consumed popular fiction especially from

A & P, by John Updike

2288 words - 9 pages The short story “A & P” by John Updike is about a young man’s decision to stand up for others or, in the other characters’ opinions, make a foolish decision by abandoning his responsibility. At first he believes his decision is the right thing, quitting his job for how the girls were being treated. Then when he gets outside of the store, he realizes the world he just left behind, regrets his decision, and begins to question his actions. He

Risky Attire: A&P by John Updike

1245 words - 5 pages In “A & P”, John Updike conveys the reaction of bystanders to three young women when they enter a grocery store, dressed in swim wear during a day at the beach. The ladies begin touring the store in search of Kingfish Fancy Herring Snacks for Queeie’s mother. Lengel, the store manager, takes notice of the girl’s attire as they navigate to the cashier to pay for their snack and disapprovingly confronts them. During Lengel’s conversation at the

Summary of A&P by John Updike

861 words - 4 pages him quitting, he says, "You didn't have to embarrass them" (152), which let us know, he felt the girls were embarrassed. Sammy's main point for quitting his job at A&P, in his and my opinion, is to be an "unsuspected hero" (152). In a interview with Donald M. Murray, John Updike himself, states his opinions on the story A & P. He gives his opinion on Sammy's attraction toward Queenie, and also Sammy's decision on quitting his job. As he talked on

Prejudices in Cathedral by Raymond Carver

1498 words - 6 pages and thus becomes jealous of his wife who has a strong emotional connection with a blind man. “Cathedral” presents life in a subtle yet harsh manner and teaches us to open our eyes to better ourselves; as a result, reflection of reality lends to the literary strength of the short story. Carver demonstrates the inevitable controversy when society is confronted with abnormality but also what happens if we learn to reject our prejudices through the

Cathedral by Raymond Carver - Book Report

815 words - 4 pages Hellen Keller once said “It is tragic to have sight but lack vision.” This quote illuminates “Cathedral” by Raymond Carver which is about a narrator who displays a lack of insight and self-awareness, and a blind man who has profound spiritual insight. By the end of the story, the narrator achieves his own vision through the help of the blind man. The narrator is very neurotic. For one thing, he is extremely isolated as we know because his wife

Short story summary of "The A&P" by John Updike

651 words - 3 pages "The A&P"In the short story, " The A&P," by John Updike, the author seeks to make his point using an unlikely setting and scenario. Using a supermarket as a metaphor for a society, Updike illustrates how breaking the norms of society evokes fear and brings about intolerance in people. When a society is accustomed to only one way of doing things it will not be accept anything different. Members of a society fear change, and only behavior

"The Cathedral" by Raymond Carver is full of both imagery and symbolism

926 words - 4 pages Contrasting Imagery with SymbolismThe story The Cathedral by Raymond Carver is a story of transformation of a human character's life from depression and carelessness to belief and diversity. A cathedral is a symbol of faith, conversion, creativity and strength and is therefore a substantial component of Carver's story. The process of drawing it becomes the climax of the story when the author uses intense imagery to describe the workings of the

Comparing A&P by John Updike and Porphyria's Lover by Robert Browning

1565 words - 6 pages Comparing A&P by John Updike and Porphyria's Lover by Robert Browning In John Updike's short story, "The A&P", he writes of an eighteen-year-old cashier who is infatuated with three girls that enter the store and in Robert Browning's poem, Porphyria's Lover, He writes of a man's intense passion for his lover. Even thought these two works are different in context, they have very striking similarities. Updike's narrating main character

The blind man from Cathedral by Raymond Carver

834 words - 4 pages The blind man from Cathedral by Raymond Carver Raymond Carver wrote a short story called ‘‘The cathedral’’, it is about a woman who has a long time friend and he is blind. He comes at her house to see her and then realize that she as a husband. At the beginning, the husband has a good vision but he is the one who seems "blind." The husband is speaks and do signs when he is talking to Robert, the blind man, the husband is kind of ‘‘blind

An Analysis of A&P by John Updike - English Com 2 - Essay

528 words - 3 pages now. Even Lengel feels Sammy is acting impulsively and gives Sammy the option to think it through more clearly yet Sammy sticks to his guns. While Sammy would paint himself as a fearless defender of the innocent it seems to me his motives have more to do with his own sensibilities and carnal desires and less to do with the innocence of the girls he is defending. Although I’m not sure that Sammy is aware of this I believe the writer of the story was. Then again, I might be just as imaginative as Sammy. Word Count: 525 Work Cited Updike, John. “A&P” Literature, edited by Janet E. Gardner, 4th ed., Bedford/St. Martian’s, 2017, pp. 268-71.

Similar Essays

"Cathedral" By Raymond Carver Essay

1031 words - 5 pages “Cathedral” by Raymond Carver is a story narrorated by a man whose wife invites an old friend (Robert) over for a visit after recently losing his wife of eight years. This old friend is blind, which greatly troubles the nameless man. This is because he already has a preconceived idea of what blind people are like without ever having met one. As the story progresses and soon ends, this unnamed man learns of his misconceptions and the true meaning

Cathedral By Raymond Carver Essay

846 words - 3 pages Cathedral by Raymond Carver In Raymond Carver?s ?Cathedral?, the conventional ideas often associated with blindness and sight are challenged. By juxtaposing his two male characters, Carver is able to effectively explore sight and its seemingly simplistic relationship with learning and knowledge. As well, he addresses the barriers imposed by the human tendency to rely on vision as the sole means of experiencing the world. At the

Cathedral By Raymond Carver Essay

1213 words - 5 pages What would one expect from a loving husband who has to share his home with a complete stranger? Would one expect to be welcomed with open arms or be met with a blinding cloud of jealousy? In Raymond Carver’s short story “Cathedral” a distraught and confounded husband has an ignorant and envious view of his wife’s timeless friend. According to the narrator, he “wasn’t enthusiastic about his visit” (32) and “being blind bothered him” (32). The

Cathedral By Raymond Carver Essay

1282 words - 5 pages The story of Cathedral, by Raymond Carver, shows that you do not have to see someone or something in order to appreciate them for who or what they are. It is about a husband, the narrator, and his wife who live in a house. The wife, whose name they do not mention, has a very close friend who is blind. His name is Robert. Robert's wife dies, and comes to their house to spend a couple of days with the narrator and his wife. The narrator, whose