This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reaction To Gyekye'ss Concept Of Political Corruption As A Moral Pollution

1540 words - 7 pages

To: Dr. Levine
From: Peter Tierney
Date: March 26, 2014
Re: Reaction to Gyekye’s concept of political corruption as “a moral pollution”

Despite its current popularity among political scientists, Gyekye rejects the theory that institutional reform is a useful anti-corruption strategy. This leads him to conclude that political corruption is fundamentally a moral problem, to which the “most adequate therapeutic response” is a “serious and profound commitment to our moral beliefs and principals” through what he calls a “moral revolution.” This memo disagrees with Gyekye on both of these points, first criticizing Gyekye for failing to provide a clearly defined alternative framework for his “moral revolution” recommendation, and then arguing that institutional reform, while not without its challenges, is still the best available option.

Background
In chapter 7 of Tradition and Modernity, Gyekye argues that political corruption is a moral problem, and that a “moral revolution” is needed for public officials to “steel their moral wills to avoid involving themselves in acts of political corruption.” Gyekye begins by defining political corruption as “the illegal, unethical, and unauthorized exploitation of one’s political or official position for personal gain or advantage,” followed by a review of common acts of political corruption, which includes taking a bribe, graft, fraud, kickbacks, the misappropriation of public funds, favoritism, and nepotism. The discussion then turns to the root causes of political corruption, which is the central point of contention for Gyekye. He acknowledged that weak political leadership, certain types of social structures (he mentions communitarianism in African societies), poor economic circumstances, and the lack of adequate legal and institutional framework are all causal factors “in the incidence of political corruption.” However, he believes that the “moral circumstances” of political corruption, despite being largely overlooked by academics, are the most fundamental factor.

The moral circumstances of political corruption
In a single burst of deductive reasoning, Gyekye rejects institutional reform and asserts his claim that political corruption is a moral problem:

“…if attempts intended to deal with the problem of political corruption by such measures as changes in the political structure, the institution of fraud detection squats within the public service, the tightening and enforcement of legal sanctions against public officials who commit politically corrupt acts mostly fail to reduce the incidence of political corruption in a significant way, then it makes sense to say that a more serious approach to dealing with the problem must lie somewhere else. That ‘somewhere else’ is, in my opinion, the moral character of individual public official and his motives for seeking elected public office.”

As evidence for this claim, he cites a prospective member of parliament for an unnamed African country that he once...

Find Another Essay On Reaction to Gyekye'ss Concept of Political Corruption as a Moral Pollution

"What is Democracy" This is an essay written about democracy. It a reaction of an average person as to what democracy means to them. This is not a step by step definition of the political system

1354 words - 5 pages ironies of these facts is that most citizens of democratic countries do not know what the word democracy means and what it represents. "A citizen of America will cross the ocean to fight for democracy, but wont cross the street to vote in a national election." Bill VaughanThe Oxford dictionary defines democracy as government by the people, direct or representative. In Canada we have a representative democracy that allows us to pick our political

The Gilded Age, it earned a reputation of widespread corruption in government and business, as well as persistent economic, social, and political problems facing the nation

703 words - 3 pages In the years following Reconstruction, America changed from a country of farms into a nation of growing businesses, factories, and cities. Despite these changes, the decades of the Gilded Age earned a reputation of widespread corruption in government and business, as well as the failure of the era's Presidents to resolve the persistent economic, social, and political problems facing the nation.The rise of industry and business defined the period

The issue of race as a concept

1242 words - 5 pages principally derives from their common descent. The discussion of race shows little sign of diminishing, despite efforts to destroy the concept. Even the Census Bureau categorizes people according to the race with which they most closely identify, although the Bureau agrees that race is a socio-political construct and should not be interpreted as being scientific or anthropological in nature.Based on the Census Bureau classification, I would be

modernization as a concept of social change

6079 words - 24 pages profit and productivity ought to be regarded as the ultimate social good. By this account, while traditional societies were characterized by domination of society by the political system, modern societ- ies are dominated by the economic system. The debate about modernization is then defined as a choice between political or economic domination. This common error is exacerbated by the fact that modernizing societies are often termed 'capitalist

The Concept of Moral Panics

2694 words - 11 pages The Concept of Moral Panics A moral panic is said to occur when the media mobilises public opinion around the condemnation of deviance ("Media coverage of deviance: moral panics", lecture handout, 07-10-02). Deviance, in this context, refers to the violation of social norms and values, and the subsequent disruption of social order. This essay will begin with a clarification of the terms 'moral

The Concept of Fideism as a Solution to the problem of Faith/Reason - Question/Answer Format

728 words - 3 pages humanity in a form of freedom of choice and reason. Why would he create us in a way so that the denial of his authority would be an unlienable quality of any concious human being. Fideism does not honestly represent the "thinking" ability and the process of reasoning, it states that one has to have faith in God without even trying to think about it and accept it as it is. Well, why not then if honestly following this concept, not believe in other

The Concept of Political Representation

2773 words - 12 pages In “Political Representation,” Shapiro et al. (2009) say that “political representation lies at the core of modern politics.” Representation is usually linked to the concept of democracy (Shapiro et al. 2009). The concept of representation is explicitly mentioned in the U.S. Constitution (U.S. Const. art. I, § 1, 2). However, the meaning and appropriate form of “representation” have been debated by political theorists and philosophers for

The European Rapid Reaction Force. The EU's move from a political instrument to a European army

1335 words - 5 pages The European Rapid Reaction Force (ERRF) is an idea as old as the EU itself. However until recently the issue of an EU force has been considered a taboo subject and so there has been no need to warrant public discussion about it. The formal decision to create the ERRF was only taken late in December 1999 whereby this agreement the 15 EU Members committed themselves to creating a European force of around 60,000 troops, with supporting aircraft

The Transport sector as a source of Pollution

1851 words - 8 pages Introduction The transport sector influences air pollution. Pollutants like carbon dioxide (CO2) and water vapour (H20) are known to be the most important transport emissions to the atmosphere. The use of vehicles in the roads affects air emission pollution and the combustion of fuel takes place when vehicles are used. As a consequence, this combustion process emits gases that affects the environment. In addition, “road traffic exhaust emissions

The Transport sector as a source of Pollution

728 words - 3 pages lanes with a solid white line. HOV lanes provide several benefits to decrease air pollution because people use less cars to get to their final destination. Some advantages of having these lanes are: 1. Saves Time HOV travelers like bus drivers and carpoolers can avoid areas of congestion, especially during peak hours. 2. Offers Reliable Commute Commuters can get to work in less time and provide an incentive to take the bus, carpool or vanpool

Religion as a Major Organizing Ideology to the Social and Political Reality of the Nineteenth-Century

3995 words - 16 pages Religious scholar, Stephen Prothero, sees religion as a major organizing ideology to the social and political reality of the nineteenth-century. For Prothero, there is a close and intimate ideological relation between theological beliefs and a culture; therefore, they are not separable from characterizing the religious mood of the nineteenth-century. Prothero argues that many Americans were, “inspired by [the] republican rhetoric of liberty

Similar Essays

Description Of Rent Seeking As Applied To Political Corruption

1975 words - 8 pages organisation. This does not, however, mean that every bureaucracy is automatically burdened by rent seeking and that every company is automatically efficient. Rent seeking constitutes a form of political behaviour, which can be described as lobbying superior regulatory bodies.Rent seeking and corruption: Rent seeking is extensively linked with corruption (although politicians' favours to clients or lobbying by interest groups are not in themselves corrupt

Moral Crisis And Corruption As Obstructions To Perfect Justice

1631 words - 7 pages interests. The cause of the corruption is to conserve the structures of society for long time. When people try to conserve the social structure as long as they can, the social structure eventually creates vested interests in some way such as construction of infrastructures. For instance, in Behind the Beautiful Forevers, to achieve slum-free in Mumbai, the government of India tried to get rid of a part of the slum to extend the Mumbai airport

Watergate: A Study Of Political Corruption

2605 words - 10 pages of investigation.” The work was tiresome due to the large numbers of individuals involved and the scope of the corruption. Nevertheless, the pair was determined to bring the facts to light and hold the conspirators accountable. Consistent reporting by the Post of facts as they were uncovered kept public interest in the story alive. Each detail provided a piece of the puzzle and helped make the picture clearer. For example, the large

Romanticism As A Reaction To The Enlightenment

934 words - 4 pages Romanticism as a Reaction to the Enlightenment The epoch known as the Age of Reason, or the Enlightenment, was a secular intellectual movement that looked to reason as an explanation of the world. The Enlightenment began in 1687 with the publishing of Sir Isaac Newton’s Principia and ended in 1789 with the French Revolution (Fiero 134). The epoch of Romanticism was a reaction to the rationalism of the Enlightenment. The movement of Romanticism