This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Read The Corn Sale Dilemma (Cicero, On Duties 3.50 57). How Can This Scenario Help To Understand The Ancient Arguments For Treating Other People Gener

1461 words - 6 pages

The Corn-Sale Dilemma was included in Cicero’s philosophical work De Officiis, aka On Duties. It was written in 44 BC, specifically addressing his son Marcus. It deals with problems of moral behaviour, drawing on the opinions of different sects of ancient philosophy. The Corn-Sale Dilemma exemplifies the main problem of the treatise, namely, finding the right balance between what is “honourable” (honestum) and what is useful. The passage may read like a page from a course on Business Ethics, but in fact Cicero’s focus is primarily moral in the philosophical sense: the emphasis is on the character of the hypothetical seller. This individual is assumed to be a good man1 and, therefore, would not increase the price of his corn if he knew it would be unethical. Cicero goes on to talk about the differences in opinions that the Stoic school of thought had in approaching the problem. Through the exchange between the two Stoics, Diogenes of Babylon and Antipater of Tarsus (both flourished in 2nd century BC),2 it becomes clear that the crux of the argument is centred around the relationship between legitimate self-interest and philanthropic other-concerned obligations. This is a moral dilemma, a probelm that is open; the person has a choice over what to do according to their own morals.
The story reflects a rich spectrum of historical and ideological contexts. Cereals were the staple foods in Greco-Roman antiquity;3 still, food shortages were endemic. Prejudice against profiteering merchants dates back to Homer’s Odyssey (Bk 8.163-4). Generous giving by the affluent elite, on the other hand, was both expected and celebrated. For instance, in the anonymous Latin romance Story of Apollonius King of Tyre4 the hero’s donation rescues a city from famine; the citizens repay his gift of grain with an inscribed statue (ch. 10). Such generous spending in the interests of the community was known as euergetism. Often the elite would give money and/or food generously as a tactic of political advancement – for example, Julius Caesar (Plutach, Life of Caesar ch. 4): his generosity is driven by ambition, rather than by genuine philanthropy.
1 On Duties, 3.50. 2 For critique of Cicero’s account of the two Stoics’ views, see Annas, 1989. 3 Wilkins and Hill, 2008, ch. 4. 4 Kortekaas, 2004.
Page 3 of 9
In Cicero’s scenario political ambition is not even considered as a possible motive, the seller must reach a decision based on a moral rationale, this is a philosophical dilemma first and foremost. Out of two Stoic solutions related by Cicero, Antipater’s argument about “common benefit” dovetails with the Stoic idea of natural solidarity among manking. The mainstream Stoic theory proposed that as rational beings all humans are naturally programmed to respect and support each other. Such an attitude is imagined by the Stoic Hierocules as concentric circles of affection; the smallest circle is our self, next our family and kin, then friends, the wider community, and so forth;...

Find Another Essay On Read the Corn-Sale Dilemma (Cicero, On Duties 3.50-57). How can this scenario help to understand the ancient arguments for treating other people gener

This Is Going To Tell U Lots Of Things About A Book Called "THE GIVER" If U Have A Hard Time To Understand It This Is The Right Essay For You To Read

991 words - 4 pages in order for us to be a real human being. As we read the book, we also learned about the people that lived in Jonas' community. There's no evidence of disease, hunger, poverty, war, or pain. People don't have freedom and the society solve every problem for them. People who lived in the community just act the same way as a robot did, they just follow the rules of their community without knowing anything. They do things for community instead of

"The aim of marketing is to know and understand the customer so well that the product or service fits him or her and sells itself." (Drucker) Produce arguments for and against this statement

924 words - 4 pages reached retailers (Kolter & Keller 2006).Furthermore, by dividing consumers into groups of people that share the same needs, businesses are able to concentrate their efforts contributing to marketing success (Kennedy 2000). In 2003 Starbucks and Pepsi found and exploited the gap in the market for ready-to-drink coffee products. This proved a successful venture for the businesses and they are now market leader in the industry. However, it was

Intertextuality essay choosing one chapter from Foster's HOW TO READ LITERATURE LIKE A PROFESSOR to help illuminate the meaning of Nathaniel Hawthorne's SCARLET LETTER. Analyze the occurrence of this...

1066 words - 4 pages Untitled Anzhelika Sheyko AP Literature Thomas C. Foster's How to Read Literature Like a Professor gives insight on how to notice repeating symbols, patterns, and archetypes throughout literature. One piece of advice was to notice what background and history the author of a book had. Knowing an author's background life may give an idea of what allusions and techniques of writing he/she may use. For example, he says, &quot

Economic Inequalities. "Some people are equal but some are more equal than others," by using this quote by George Orwell, we can understand the inequalities in our society

758 words - 3 pages " brought a nation together in prejudice without trying to understand the ideology of the opposing nation. The same prejudices destroyed many innocent people and families and brought the country close to anarchy and internal social breakdown. (Ref- modern history handouts - 'The cold war lecture sheets')The current phenomenon of social freedom fighters and liberators, riding on the belief dispensing social justice for the groups initially

Alcoholics Anonumous. This essay tells all about AA. It goes into great detail of how it was founded and why it was founded. It even tell about the different ways it can help people

2005 words - 8 pages opendiscussion meetings, but are for alcoholics and prospective A.A. members/ peoplewho may have drinking problems only. There are also step meetings, which arenormally closed. At these meetings one of the Twelve Steps are discussed.Alcoholics Anonymous has expanded its locations to include holding meetings inboth correctional, and treatment facilities. By doing this they are able toextend help to people who are in need, but unable to go to meetings

Regardless of the nature of the disease, 'palliative care' should be available for all dying people. Identify and briefly evaluate some arguments for and against this assertion

1860 words - 7 pages from other diseases other than cancer, and palliative care should be developed for these patients also. There are many arguments on whether specialist palliative should be extended to patients who are dying from non-malignant illnesses such as heart failure, stroke patients or renal failure and the answer to this question, lies not in what diagnoses or diseases patients have, but what needs exist that can be met by and supported through advise

A report on Down Syndrome. this report tells about how people are born with the disorder and what they can do later in life

611 words - 2 pages Down syndrome is a disorder that is caused by an extra number 21 chromosome. This affects one in every 800 births worldwide, and causes birth defects. Also, there is no cure for Down syndrome. Most research says that there have always been people suffering from Down syndrome. Dr Jon Langdon Down was the first person to recognize this. Down syndrome was also known as "mongolism" because the people who had it seemed to resemble Mongolian Asians

Do People Who Are Trafficking Human Organs Help Other People?

1244 words - 5 pages live without for money to the sick people who need this organ to stay alive. Selling organs can help the sick person to stay alive and give the poor person money to help his family from humiliating life. I read something posted on (ALL THINGS PAKISTAN blog, 2007) about a poor Pakistani guy who holds with his hand a paper with a sign that says “Would you buy my kidney please?.” I think that poor guy needs money to stay alive, because he needs to

Do People Who Are Trafficking Human Organs Help Other People?

1236 words - 5 pages organs that they can live without for money to the sick people who need this organ to stay alive. Selling organs can help the sick person to stay alive and give the poor person money to help his family from humiliating life. I read something posted on (ALL THINGS PAKISTAN blog, 2007) about a poor Pakistani guy who holds with his hand a paper with a sign that says “Would you buy my kidney please?.” I think that poor guy needs money to stay alive

How Far Do You Think Observing A Visible Religious Activity, Such As A Festival, Can Help You Understand The Part A Religion Plays In The Life Of An Individual Or A Community?

1282 words - 6 pages To fully understand the part a religion plays in the life of an individual or a community, I would suggest that we need to examine it from several different points of view, only some of which can be addressed by observing a visible religious activity.Using Ninian Smart's 'dimensional model' as a starting point, we can examine the different dimensions of a religion and discover how much insight into each of them the observation of a visible

What lessons can we learn from brain research that help educators and parents understand the complex processes involved in the development of chil

1087 words - 5 pages Brain research has progressed rapidly in recent years, providing a far deeper understanding of the brain and how its development shapes all other aspects of human development. There are several important aspects of brain development which have profoundly changed the way in which brain development should be considered in the context of human development per se. To understand how these developments can provide better guidance for parents and

Similar Essays

Read The Corn Sale Dilemma (Cicero, On Duties 3.50 57). How Can This Scenario Help To Understand The Ancient Arguments For Treating Other People Gener

1472 words - 6 pages passage refers to (51). The Cynics altogether denounce the need for money. Their slogan “deface of the currency” is not in the literal sense of destroying coins but showing society how dependence on money was not in line with nature. Money was of no importance for the Cynics, so the Corn-Sale dilemma would not have been a dilemma for them.10 It is likely that they would simply have given the corn away as they saw it everyone’s entitlement to the

I Need Help With This Essay, Read The End To Understand

1365 words - 5 pages . Perhaps when one feels that to live with oneself, to sleep at night, one needs to do something. Ethics asks, "What is the good or not so good? And how do we know?"[1] Not everything that ethics authorizes or requires can always be called "good," like calling a patient who has already left the Emergency Department to tell him that his radiographs may contain bad news. Therefore, I substitute other words and phrases, so that the whole list looks like

How Can Robotics Help People? Essay

1937 words - 8 pages ”). It can navigate around obstacles when needed which is especially useful when in an urban environment, and is able to run for 20 miles without refueling (“Boston Dynamics”). This would be an incredibly useful unit for the future as it cannot only carry gear reliably, but it could also carry wounded soldiers that cannot walk under their own power. LS3 is scheduled to deploy with US Marines sometime in 2014 (“DARPA’s AlphaDog”). The military

Vocational Rehabilitation For People With Mental Illness In The Uk. How Occupational Therapy Services Can Get Involved And Help

6500 words - 26 pages extent, the sexual desire-dominance example represented growth. It was significant for courts to be familiar with that gender favoritism can take the form of sexual proposal. But the example also foreshadow problems. By highlight sexual abuse, the paradigm endangered to eclipse other, evenly damaging forms of gender-based antagonism. As Parts II and III demonstrate, this concern has appeared. Part II documents the difficulty of disaggregation: Courts