This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reader Response To Sydney's Sonnets, Astrophil And Stella

1421 words - 6 pages

Reader Response to Sydney's Sonnets, Astrophil and Stella

As we discussed Astrophil and Stella in class, I felt a familiar knot in my stomach. At first I could not pin-point the reasons for my aversion to these sonnets. However, as we discussed it in class, it became clear to me. I could identify with Penelope Devereux Rich. Although Astrophil and Stella could be interpreted as an innocent set of love sonnets to an ideal woman and not a particular woman, they reminded me of the letters I received last year from a guy, Lee Burt, I had not seen in seven years. He stalked me by mail and phone. I felt small and vulnerable, and in some ways, violated. I do not hold much higher opinions of Sir Philip Sydney. I would argue that Sydney's sonnets were not innocent, but obsessions, and he too could be considered a stalker.

In Sydney's first stanza, he attempts to rationalize and give a reason for writing these sonnets. He hopes that by writing what is in his heart, "might cause her read, reading might make her know, knowledge might pity win, and pity grace obtain." Lee did not write these sentiments out as clearly, but they were often implied. He did state, "I'll send you my thoughts in segments and let you piece them together." He then proceeded to send me a poem a day until I finally began simply stamping them return to sender. These "pieces" reminded me of Sydney's stanzas.

The obsession with idealized beauty is also consistent between Lee's letters and Sydney's poems. In one letter, Lee wrote, "You walked into that room like an angel in all its glory. With a beautiful smile upon your face you introduced yourself to me. My heart, from that moment on, gave itself to you willingly." This is a striking parallel to Sydney's stanza seven in which he writes, "Least if no veil those brave gleams did disguise,/ They sun-like should more dazzle than delight?/...Both so and thus, she, minding Love should be/ Placed ever there, gave him this mourning weed,/ To honor all their deaths, who for her bleed."

Sydney also devotes a number of stanzas arguing with Reason over his obsession. He is sure that if Reason looked at Stella, it would kneel "and offeredst straight to prove/ By reason good, good reason her to love." Lee spends a whole page attempting to convince Reason that his feelings are something more than hormonal. He mentions God often. "I don't understand what God's plan, reason was for our paths to cross. For as long as I can remember I've been praying and praying for God to show me the one - and every other time I think he points one out to me - it is just my hormones speaking."

Sydney often mentions pity as well. Stanza 45 particularly addresses this, ending with the lines, "Then think, my dear, that you in me do read/ Of lover's ruin some sad tragedy./ I am not I; pity the tale of me." With similar sentiments Lee tried to play on my pity. "My life since the very beginning has been strange. Somehow no one had my problems, and frankly...

Find Another Essay On Reader Response to Sydney's Sonnets, Astrophil and Stella

Desire in Chaucers "The Wife of Bath" and Sir Philip Sidney's "Astrophil and Stella"

1040 words - 4 pages When a person is infatuated with something, they can become single-minded and ignorant to reality. If they cannot have the object of their desire, they may be plunged into a state of despair and frustration. Sir Philip Sidney explores the affects of desire in his sonnets, Astrophil and Stella. Geoffrey Chaucer also delves into the topic in “The Wife of Bath’s Prologue and Tale”. These two works present the idea that desire is

Compare and contrast Sir Phillip Sidney's Astrophil and Stella (sonnet # 47) and William Shakespeare's sonnet # 1

2457 words - 10 pages reminds the young man that the only way to counter this peril is through the replication of a parent's beauty within his offspring and therefore continuation of the family line. And according to Kenneth Muir, "to refrain from procreating is to be guilty of narcissism, and of cruelty to future generations" (45).Phillip Sidney's series of sonnets, Astrophil and Stella, are similar to that of Shakespeare's as they incorporate strong imagery and are full

Reader response to an Essay

835 words - 3 pages Is Email the Future of the Family Feud?"In the article "E-mail: The Future of the Family Feud.", the author, Candy Schulman, believes "modern technology is affecting human relationships."(509) She believes that technology, E-mail specifically, is destroying human relation ships. She tries numerous times to convince the reader she is credible, but falls short many times.The author does not use the elements of argument well enough to make her

Reader response theory and the

1194 words - 5 pages movement form. The phenomenological approach represents the notion that the author and reader collaborate to produce the literary work. Phenomenologists credit the reader with having a performative role in the literary experience. Authors such as Jean-Paul Sartre, Wolfgang Iser, and Hans Robert Jauss are associated with the phenomenological approach to literature.Because the reader response movement is built on the foundation that the audience is

Reader Response to Woolf’s To The Lighthouse

1510 words - 6 pages Reader Response to Woolf’s To The Lighthouse      There is a saying that the worth of a man’s life is best measured by the degree to which he has if he has touched the lives of others and not by the quantity of worldly possessions that he has acquired.  It is important to keep this in mind when considering Virginia Woolf’s novel, To The Lighthouse.  Throughout the novel, it seems as though the characters, mainly Mr. And Mrs. Ramsay, are

Reader Response to James Joyce's The Dead

1138 words - 5 pages guidelines through which to examine and express ideas of the meaning of "The Dead."  Joyce himself said that the idea of paralysis was the intended theme of all the stories in The Dubliners of which "The Dead" is the final story.   Of all critical approaches, reader response works best for me.  This approach examines the images, symbols, point-of-view, characterization and setting of "The Dead" in such a way as

Reader Response to Memoirs of a Geisha

888 words - 4 pages Reader Response to Memoirs of a Geisha                Memoirs of a Geisha is Arthur Golden's debut novel, written exquisitely with great detail. It was initially written as a novel that would depict the son borne of a geisha and a Japanese businessman, but once he had learned the true nature of a geisha, he changed his topic. Golden discovered the intrigue of the geisha

A Reader Response to The Lie

610 words - 2 pages A Reader Response to The Lie     Pleasing people and the pressure that comes with it.  This is a major factor in one's everyday life. Eli Remenzel, however, has been caught in the middle of just one of the many lies he will ever tell. It just happens to be that this lie was one that would make a lot of people disappointed. In the short story "The Lie", the parents, and Eli's actions make me angry.  However, I can

Reader Response And A Grain Of Wheat

1274 words - 5 pages together and leaves the readers with not only a great deal of satisfaction, but the main point that Ngugi was trying to get across is very evident to the reader. The readers are finally granted the knowledge of what is happening in each characters head. Mugo finally confesses to betraying Kihika and the readers finally understand that Karanja is innocent in relation to Kihika. Also, the readers are given a look into each other character’s

A Reader-Response Criticism of How I Learned to Drive

1826 words - 7 pages , and formalist critical approaches) and one may not look to an underlying moral message, as the entirety of the text is pervaded by moral ambiguity. It is in the act of interpreting our response by which How I Learned to Drive may be understood. How I Learned to Drive gave me a sense of religious optimism, amusement, anger, and bewilderment. During my reading of How I Learned to Drive, I was surprised by the sexual nature of the play. The

A Reader-Response Criticism of How I Learned to Drive

1504 words - 7 pages , and formalist critical approaches) and one may not look to an underlying moral message, as the entirety of the text is pervaded by moral ambiguity. It is in the act of interpreting our response by which How I Learned to Drive may be understood. How I Learned to Drive gave me a sense of religious optimism, amusement, anger, and bewilderment. During my reading of How I Learned to Drive, I was surprised by the sexual nature of the play. The

Similar Essays

William Shakespeare’s Sonnets And Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella

2635 words - 11 pages unconventional poet. Sonnet 130 is interpreted as a critique against Petrarchan poets, yet some authors argue against the reading Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130 as solely a challenge to Petrarchan clichés. Still, they recognize the sonnet at least in part as a response to Petrarchan standards of beauty. Others argue that Shakespeare’s sonnets directly respond negatively to Sidney’s Astrophil and Stella (Steele 131). Possibly Shakespeare may be paying

Sir Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella

1395 words - 6 pages wrong with early childhood memories because the material is pure--not yet contaminated with the clichÈs of what we are supposed to believe and feel. Astrophil and Stella inspired literally thousands of sonnets and Sidney's admirers thought that he was greater than Spenser or Shakespeare. The idea that Sidney, himself happily married to Frances Walsingham, could be passionately in love with Penelope Rich and jealous of her husband bothered

Sir Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella Sonnet 20 Versus Shakespeare's Sonnet 130

1792 words - 7 pages goddess, the one and only, down to earth mistress from Shakespeare’s sonnet. The differences of the love object give a hit to the resemble nature of love, arbitrariness. Another difference is the treatment of love in the two sonnets. Sidney’s sonnet describes love as a hunt, in a more violence way and Shakespeare’s one is more clam and comforting. In Astrophil and Stella Sonnet 20, cupid controls love and he is illustrated as a predator and

Compare/Contrast The Ways Philip Sidney's Astrophil And Stella And Milton's Comus Explore Gender And Sexuality

1185 words - 5 pages the society. Both Sidney's and Milton's heroines are no longer passive feminine receivers of affections. They determine what happens to them by using reason rather than emotions. Hence, Sidney and Milton exemplify progressive views of their periods, attempting to see gender and sexuality in a new light. Sexuality and desire Philip Sidney: Astrophil and Stella (c. 1591) Sidney's Astrophil and Stella, a compilation of 108 sonnets and 11 songs