Reality And Illusion In Shakespeare's Hamlet The Deception Of Appearance

2172 words - 9 pages

Appearance versus Reality in Hamlet

 
       Hamlet is organized around various pairs of opposing forces. One of these forces is the difference between that what seems and that which actually is, in other words, appearance versus reality. What is, and what merely appears to be? We can discern two principal angles from which this question is approached in Hamlet. First, we have the angle of inward and outward emotions, and the profound distinction that is drawn between them. In other words, the tranquil face that we all show to the world is never the same as the turmoil of our souls. In Hamlet, Shakespeare explores this both explicitly, through the device of the play within the play, and implicitly, through the ways in which he uses the forms and conventions of theater to explore the aforementioned emotional dichotomy. There is also the dichotomy of knowledge that is essential to the Judeo-Christian religious tradition. God, in this tradition, is considered to be omniscient, and thus knows how all things actually are. Mere human beings, on the other hand, can only, as in Plato's allegory of the cave, know how things seem. They have only flawed knowledge. Over the course of Hamlet, we repeatedly perceive characters who focus on things that seem, as well as those who focus on what actually is. This dichotomy is fundamental to our understanding of the play.

 

Before launching into the body of this exposition, it is necessary that we define a few important terms. By "being", or that which "actually is", I mean those things that exist in the objective reality that might be perceived by some so-called omnipotent being. The flawed knowledge of non-omniscient humans - that which we see every day - is represented by the word "seem" and forms thereof.

 

That which seems, in Hamlet, is in flux. We can think that anything we want to exist exists, regardless of the objective truth. In fact, some philosophers have stated that there is no objective external reality, and our perceptions define the world (Berkeley) - while Shakespeare's view is not so extreme, it comes close. This is best exhibited in the oracular nature of certain characters, namely the couple of Hamlet and Ophelia. We can examine the dialogue between Polonius and Hamlet in Act II, Scene ii (171-219). Hamlet's speech here consists of only loosely connected ideas. His speech is full of non sequiturs and facts that are clearly wrong, as we see here:

 

Polonius. Do you know me, my lord?

Hamlet. Excellent well. You are a fishmonger.

Polonius. Not I, my lord.

Hamlet. Then I would you were so honest a man.

Polonius. Honest, my lord?

Hamlet. Ay, sir. To be honest, as this world goes, is to be one man picked out of ten thousand. (2.2.173-179)

 

Polonius is, of course, not a fishmonger. Hamlet's motivation for speaking about honesty here is at best unclear. And why Hamlet suddenly spits out deep philosophical truths - as he does in the final line...

Find Another Essay On Reality and Illusion in Shakespeare's Hamlet - The Deception of Appearance

Duality and Appearance vs. reality in Hamlet

1378 words - 6 pages Throughout history there has been a general understanding that appearances can be deceiving. A person may go through life without anyone understanding the true reality of there character. William Shakespeare, one of the greatest writers of all time, understood the relationship between appearance and reality and often gave characters two sides to their...

APPEARANCE vs. REALITY IN "THE PRINCE" AND "HAMLET"

1608 words - 6 pages 3. Reality and appearances, or if you prefer, being and acting, are important themes for both Machiavelli and Shakespeare. Why? How do their perspectives on this subject agree or differ?APPEARANCE vs. REALITY IN "THE PRINCE" AND "HAMLET"One of the most fundamental questions in philosophy is the appearance vs. reality. We find ourselves asking the question of what is genuinely "real," and what is viewed merely as just an...

Appearance and Reality in Shakespeare's Macbeth

1198 words - 5 pages Macbeth:  Appearance and Reality The theme of appearance versus reality is very important in William Shakespeare’s Macbeth. The characters of Duncan, Macbeth, and Lady Macbeth are unable to differentiate between appearance and reality, resulting in tragic consequences. Poor judgment is evidenced by Duncan, who trusts Macbeth too much; Lady Macbeth, who is fooled by the witches; and Macbeth, who is tricked repeatedly by others.         ...

Appearance Vs Reality in Hamlet

855 words - 3 pages One of the most famous and popular authors and scriptwriters is William Shakespeare. Shakespeare has always been ableto create interesting characters and one of the reasons they areso interesting might be that they are complex people with theirinner selves differing from their outer selves. Are the

Hamlet - Appearance vs. Reality.

1701 words - 7 pages Hamlet - Appearance vs. Reality- Hamlet one of Shakespeare's greatest plays, where the young prince of Denmark must uncover the truth about his fathers death. Hamlet a play that tells the story of a young prince who's father recently died. Hamlets uncle Claudius marries his mother the queen and takes the throne. As the play is told Hamlet finds out his father was murdered by the recently crowned king. The theme that remains constant throughout...

Hamlet theme of appearance vs. reality

901 words - 4 pages Shakespeare examines the theme of appearance and reality in his book-Hamlet. The dilemma of what is "real" is established at the very beginning of the play. Hamlet doesn’t know what to believe and devises a plan to find out. The old king Hamlet appears to be bitten by a snake, but in reality he was poisoned, the ghost appears as an apparition, but it’s actually real, and the play-with-in-a-play strongly depicts the theme of appearance...

Appearance versus Reality in Shakespeare's Othello

1143 words - 5 pages The play 'Othello' is an epiphany of the ultimate battle between appearance versus reality in the respect that Iago is the complete opposite from what he appears to be. Everyone involved with him separately thinks that he is doing them favors, when actually he is a backstabbing, conniving person who is the essence of evil and is often referred to as half-man, half-devil. Contrary to Iago, Othello is often referred to as a God-like figure,...

Shakespeare's Hamlet - The Reality of Appearances

1321 words - 5 pages The Reality of Appearances in Hamlet      Within Hamlet the notion of appearances (through apparitions and mental afflictions) lies in direct dichotomy of reality.  This becomes evident through both plot and character.  The continual demise in Hamlet’s mental state is an important issue which leads us to question his actions and motives within the play.  In this essay I shall be attempting to elucidate how the reality of appearances is a...

Shakespeare "Hamlet" - Appearance vs. Reality.

1541 words - 6 pages Hamlet - Appearance vs. RealityHamlet one of Shakespeare's greatest plays, where the youngprince of Denmark must uncover the truth about his fathers death.Hamlet a play that tells the story of a young prince who's fatherrecently died. Hamlets uncle Claudius marries his mother the...

Appearence vs. Reality in William Shakespeare's Hamlet

1564 words - 6 pages Appearance vs. Reality       In Shakespeare’s tragedy, Hamlet, there is a dominant and overwhelming theme that is concurrent throughout the play. Throughout the play, all the characters appear as one thing on the outside, yet on the inside they are completely different. The theme of appearance versus reality surrounds Hamlet due to the fact that the characters portray themselves as one person on the outside,...

An essay about the theme of appearances vs reality as it appears in Shakespeare's Hamlet

1482 words - 6 pages Hamlet - Appearances Versus RealityOne of the major themes in Hamlet by William Shakespeare is the concept of things not always being as they appear. This is demonstrated by most of the major characters in this play. Claudius brings up this factor in more than one aspect; his love for Hamlet and Gertrude can be examined in regards to appearances versus...

Similar Essays

Reality and Illusion in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Reality, Appearance and Deception

896 words - 4 pages Reality and Illusion in Hamlet   Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet, begins with the appearance of a ghost, an apparition, possibly a hallucination. Thus, from the beginning, Shakespeare presents the air of uncertainty, of the unnatural, which drives the action of the play and develops in the protagonist as a struggle to clarify what only seems to be absolute and what is actually reality. Hamlet's mind, therefore, becomes the central force of the...

Reality and Illusion in Shakespeare's Hamlet - Appearance and Reality

1323 words - 5 pages Appearance and Reality in Hamlet   In today’s society, appearance is everything. What brand do you wear? What hairstyle do you have? What color is your skin? Are you fat? Are you “cool”? However, appearances are often deceiving, and sometimes first impressions are anything but accurate. The deceptive quality of appearance plays a major role in Shakespeare’s play Hamlet. Throughout the entire play, Shakespeare addresses the theme of...

Appearance vs. Reality in William Shakespeare's Hamlet

1502 words - 6 pages Appearance vs. Reality in William Shakespeare's Hamlet In Hamlet, one of Shakespeare's greatest tragedies, there is a prevailing theme that is concurrent throughout the play. Throughout the play, all the characters appear to be one thing on the outside, yet on the inside they are completely different. The theme of appearance versus reality is prominent in Hamlet because of the fact that the characters portray themselves...

Appearance vs. Reality in Shakespeare's Hamlet

503 words - 2 pages Appearance vs. Reality in Shakespeare's Hamlet In Hamlet deceiving illusions are frequently used to protect truth from being a destructive force. Situations within acts one and two that appear to be true and honest are really contaminated with evil. Various characters within the first two acts hide behind masks of corruption. In the first two acts most characters presented seem to be good and honest making it a complex task for Hamlet to...