Reaseach Critique Of The Article Shaping Juror Attitudes By Malouff And Schutte

935 words - 4 pages

Amanda Maybaum
Research Critique
After reading the article, Shaping Juror Attitudes: Effects of Requesting Different Damage Amounts in Personal Injury Trials, one might notice the elements of research conducted throughout this study, focusing on the many strengths and weaknesses. The following research critique will discuss the fundamentals of the study, the quality of validity and reliability, strengths and limitations as well as future recommendations.
Malouff and Schutte (1989) conducted their study in order to examine the relationship between the amount of money requested for damages in personal injury trials and the amount of money awarded. After conducting a meta-analysis, they realized that researchers have previously found a relationship with the extremeness of a persuasive message and change in attitude. What had not been researched is whether such a message could be applied to a specific situation such as personal injury trials. Therefore, Malouff and Schutte (1989) hypothesized that,
(a) at least some levels the simplest possible relationship exists between the amount requested and amount awarded, namely, that the more requested by the attorney for the injured person or plaintiff, the more the jurors would be awarded, and (b) this relationship would be found regardless of the specific facts of a case, including the injuries sustained and the sex and ethnic group of the plaintiff.
That is, the amount the jurors would award depends on the amount requested by the attorney for the injured. As a result, the amount requested by the attorney for the injured is the independent variable since it is the amount altered by the researcher and the dependent variable is the amount the jurors would award.
In order to conduct the study, Malouff and Schutte (1989) used a 4x2x2 (Amount Requested x Sex of Plaintiff x Hispanic vs. Non-Hispanic Plaintiff) Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) for each case. They took 151 subjects and randomly assigned them case summaries on a leg injury case as well as a tmj injury case. What the researchers found was that there was one significant main effect for the ANOVA on the leg injury case and three significant effects for the ANOVA on the tmj injury case. In regards to the leg injury case, Malouff and Schutte (1989) found that the amount requested had a significant effect on the amount awarded which resulted in a linear relationship. As previously stated, the tmj injury case had three significant effects with one triple interaction. Through this case, Malouffe and Schutte (1989) saw that: (1) female Hispanic plaintiffs were awarded less in damages when they requested the highest amount, in distinction to the overall patter of receiving more if they asked for more, (2) females were awarded less than male plaintiffs, and (3) plaintiffs generally were awarded more if they asked for more. From these outcomes, their hypothesis was...

Find Another Essay On Reaseach Critique of the Article Shaping Juror Attitudes by Malouff and Schutte

The Shaping of a King in The Once and Future King by T.H. White

703 words - 3 pages . Power is of the individual mind, but the mind’s power is not enough” (52). With this comment, Mr. P is showing Wart the importance of physical power over the minds. Wart is so amazed by what Mr. P has stated that he becomes speechless and motionless. Mr. P continues to teach his theories of life but soon becomes very agitated with Wart and Says, “I think you ought to go away really almost at once in case my disillusioned mouth should suddenly

This is an essay about "12 Angry Men", by Reginald Rose. It describes juror 6 and the cons of the Jury System

942 words - 4 pages Juror 6:In the story "12 angry Men", by Reginald Rose, juror six is described as an honest but slow man, one who finds it difficult to create a positive opinion, and is often listening and slowly trying to understand the opinions of others, rather then forming his own. In the text of the play, we can find examples of many of these characteristics of juror six and even more that were not given to us by the author.The first, and most obvious

Facts and Myths of Suicide in Canada and the U.S. (Article Critique)

968 words - 4 pages leading cause of death among teenagers and young adults, more men commit suicide than women (Gelder et al, 2005).Leenar and Lester article mention important information about the general knowledge about suicide in college students. However relevant information is missing. Euthanasia or The right to die is medically assisted suicide, in which people suffering from terminally ill conditions, extreme pain or have poor quality of life

The Feminization of the Community Corrections Work Force - Critique based upon the conceptual article by Jo G. Holland

699 words - 3 pages Article Critique PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 2 Running head: ARTICLE CRITIQUEArticle Critique: The Feminization of the Community Corrections Work Force January 17, 2012This is a critique of an article that has been written in a historical context by Jo G. Holland and published in Corrections Today titled; "The Feminization of the Community Corrections Work Force". This article discusses issues related to women in the male dominated correctional

Analysis of Article: “Influence of Mass Media on Body Image and Eating Disordered Attitudes and Behaviors in Females” by Jordi Fauquet, et al

846 words - 4 pages . The article lacks specificity on the kinds of disorders that come from the mass media’s negativity. These disorders, specifically eating disorders like bulimia and anorexia, lead to more than needed mental care but also intensive physical care. By solely describing the negative affects the media places on females, the article does not show how deep to the core the problem runs. Thousand of adolescents anticipate the mass media to portray the

The Last Juror, By John Grisham Book Report

591 words - 3 pages Justin MooreThe Last Juror This novel by John Grisham is his seventeenth novel. It is the first time he has returned to the setting of For County Mississippi in his first novel A Time To Kill. The Main character. William Traynor grew up in Memphis and graduated from Syracuse University with a degree in Journalism. He became interested in small weekly newspapers after his friend Nick told him his family was rich from owing a small

Critique of Quantitative Research Article

790 words - 4 pages Dr. Karrie Hendrickson published an article in 2009 analyzing patterns of hospital resource utilization of children with leukemia and CNS tumors. Dr. Hendrickson used quantitative research as her means of analysis. In her article, Dr. Hendrickson specifies the population as children ages 0 to 19 years diagnosed with cancer at a large north-eastern hospital between fiscal years 2000 and 2004. Specifically, she focused on children diagnosed with

Critique of Term Paper Article

856 words - 4 pages Becker, Margraf, Rinck, and Roth wrote one of the articles that I found, the emotional Stroop effect in anxiety disorders: General emotionality or disorder specificity? The main idea of the research study is to understand cognitive attention predispositions by demonstrating Stroop task with anxiety participants. Stroop task were repeatedly uses on patients that have anxiety or other disorders such as panic, obsessive-compulsive, social phobia

The Great War And The Shaping of the 20th Century

1398 words - 6 pages The Great War And The Shaping of the 20th Century Another man is killed; Another family receives a telegram saying that a loved one was killed in battle; The family will never be the same again without the presence of this man. This is an effort to explain some of the impact that World War I had on millions of individuals. This sequence of events was conducted over and over millions of times during WWI. So why were there so many deaths

The Shaping Of Cyber And Offline Identities Through Blogging

1372 words - 5 pages . The readers of the personal blog attach an identity with the blogger by his/her blog posts. But a piece of writing can be interpreted in many ways. Thus, each reader may attach a different identity with the blogger, and thus, even without the blogger’s knowledge, multiple identities are developed for him/her. This brings me back to a question on identities. Would there be an identity at all, if there weren’t multiple identities? I would like to

Confucianism and Taoism: The Shaping Philosophies of China

2489 words - 10 pages PHILOSOPHY IN CHINACONFUCIANISM AND TAOISMEastern society is an enigma to many Westerners. Its cultural and technical traditions vary so greatly from those of western thought. What influences shaped China, the largest eastern civilization? It is said that the basis of western thought stems from the ideas and principles set out by Socrates and Plato and their contemporaries. In a similar vein it can be said that Confucian and Taoist principles

Similar Essays

Critique Of The Article 'myth Of Narcissus: Economic Lifeblood Of The Catwalk' By Lia Darby

1284 words - 5 pages 'Myth of Narcissus: economic lifeblood of the catwalk' by Lia Darby is a poorly constructed and argued article. She uses vague and unreferenced examples, ('recently in a seaside town in France', 'in the many fashion magazines') and the progression of her ideas isn't clear and doesn't lead naturally to the conclusion she obviously wants us to draw.The central premise of 'Myth of Narcissus: economic lifeblood of the catwalks' is that the ideal of

Critique Of A Research Article About Incarceration In The Household By Loper & Nichols (2012)

2528 words - 10 pages . Focusing on the child, allows researchers to access the impact of parental incarceration on the child (Phillips, 2010). The significance of this study is articulated by the authors as giving directions for more specific interventions based on school experiences based on how these children differ from their peers. Loper and Nichols (2012) identify several relevant theories surrounding their hypothesis. The first theory is from a developmental

A Critique Of The Article "Psychosocial Evaluation And Prediction Of Compliance Problems And Morbidity After Heart Transplantation", Written By Shapiro Et Al

1736 words - 7 pages In the journal article "Psychosocial evaluation and prediction of compliance problems and morbidity after heart transplantation", the authors attempt to answer the question of whether preoperative psychosocial evaluations have reliable predictive value for heart transplant outcomes (Shapiro et al., 1995). Organ transplant programs use differing selection criteria and screening procedures to establish which patients are within established risk

Critique Of Article Essay

598 words - 3 pages This article is a literature review of how conceptual and empirical studies have furthered the understanding of the processes of improving parental involvement based model proposed by Hoover-Dempsey and Sandler. The Hoover-Dempsey and Sandler model focused on the construct of parental motivation for involvement. It included: (1) active role construction for involvement and positive self efficacy, (2) perception of invitations for involvement