This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Reasons The Articles Of Confederation Led To The Ratification Of The Constitution: Why Did The Articles Fail? Did The Constitution Solve The Problems?

942 words - 4 pages

After America had declared independence from Great Britain in 1776, the next step was to construct a new set of government laws to govern the new nation. This was a task left up to the Confederation Congress, who adopted the Articles of Confederation in 1781. The Articles of Confederation were a good idea in theory, but when put into use by the colonies proved to be weak, and failed.The Articles failed for many reasons. One of the main reasons was that Congress had no control over taxes, and the individual states wouldn't give the federal government the money it needed. This meant the federal government could not pay off the millions of dollars of debt from the revolution. There was also no money to get any type of military force together. This left the American borders vulnerable to attacks or invasions from Spain and Britain. Congress also had no power over foreign or interstate trade. This led to economic problems because each state was making their own laws, own money, and taxing each other. This led to chaos because one state's currency may not be usable in any other state.Another problem was that there were no federal courts. Disagreements between states were hard to settle because, just like with the currency, each state only recognized its own laws. This led to criminals not being penalized because they would just go to another state.Also, under the Articles, each state had one vote in Congress, no matter the size of the state. This caused problems because the larger states thought they should have more representation because they had a larger population. The larger states often ignored Congress and did what they wanted, like negotiate with foreign nations. They got away with this because there was no way to punish individuals. The root of this problem was that there was no judicial system in place.The Americans also had no type of executive power. They had no one to run the country and even the individual states did not like to give any one person too much power. The Americans were still traumatized by the British King and tyranny. The former colonists were afraid to give one person all the power because they had fought so hard to get away from that type of rule.A government set up like this was bound to fail, and, for America's sake, something had to be done. At first it was purposed to amend the Articles, but it was decided that wasn't going to be enough. In the summer of 1787 delegates from all states, excluding Rhode Island, convened in Philadelphia, and elected George Washington to preside. Among them they decided the Articles had to go and that a whole new law was required. For sixteen weeks the fifty-five delegates underwent rocky debates. One of the major debates was over whether larger states should have more representation than smaller states. This was finally solved by Connecticut proposing the Great Compromise, which gave all states equal representation.Another large debate was over economic interests....

Find Another Essay On Reasons the Articles of Confederation led to the ratification of the Constitution: Why did the Articles fail? Did the constitution solve the problems?

Articles of Confederation vs. the Constitution

839 words - 3 pages in the Union ha[d] obstructed every attempt to reform the government; that little member ha[d] repeatedly disobeyed and counteracted the general authority." The changes proposed by the new constitution only strengthened the initial system of government and proved essential to the survival of the nation.The Articles of Confederation did not support a strong federal government. Many antifederalists did not want the government to have so much

Articles of Confederation vs. The Constitution

1063 words - 4 pages carried out the intentions of state legislatures. Any amendments added to the Articles required the unanimous consent of the states. The central principal behind the Articles was the fear of oppressive, centralized power.Ratified in 1781, the Articles of Confederation led to problems. Struggling from financing the Revolutionary War, America was now in debt by 11 million dollars. A nationalist named Robert Morris sought out to enhance financial

Articles of Confederation v.s. The Constitution

1902 words - 8 pages the Articles. Sherman was a well-respected leader by both friend and enemy, and he seems to have saved the Constitution.Another Compromise that we saw take place in the Constitution is the 3/5 Compromise. What happened was that the people in the North did not believe that slaves should count as part of the population because they could not cast a vote or have any type of political sway. If the South viewed slaves solely as property, then why

How effective was the Articles of Confederation and did the Constituion solve these problems

678 words - 3 pages see the differences between the two documents and judge whether the Constitution solved the problems that the Articles faced. First, legislature changed from a unicameral to a bicameral. Secondly, members of Congress were now based on two senators per state with representatives apportioned according to the population of the state. Before, in the Articles of Confederation, each state only held one vote. Now, according to the Constitution, there

How the federalist and anti-federalist papers led to the ratification of the articles of confederation

1358 words - 5 pages federalist believed that there was nothing wrong with our current constitution and the ideals of the federalist would mess up our stable government.In the end the Federalist won the debate between the two. The constitution was ratified in 1788 after New York finally agreed to ratification. The Federalist seemed to have a more persuasive argument. They had many reasons for ratification. They believed the Articles of Confederation had flaws to it that

Foundations Of The Constitution: Articles Of The Confederation

575 words - 2 pages own militia. What some called a weak central government, some viewed as a non-existent federal government. The Articles of Confederation created a government too weak to support itself. Demands on congress had led to a debilitating mistrust between the states, as smaller states nervously approached larger states, fearful of a takeover. An inability to tax or federally regulate trade had thrown the fledgling nation into economic chaos. Left with no

The Articles of Confederation and the US Constitution

1300 words - 5 pages , a failure of the Articles of Confederation and ultimate creation of the Constitution led to a more successful government that safeguarded the rights of the people.   Works Cited Brackemyre, Ted. 2012. America's first failure at government: The Articles of Confederation. July 17. Accessed Jaunary 19, 2014. http://www.ushistoryscene.com/uncategorized/articlesofconfederation/. Feldmeth, Greg. 1998. Articles of Confederation vs. the Constitution

Comparing the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution

1402 words - 6 pages say that what they did in the beginning had had not worked so they came out then with the United States Constitution. I will explain to you what they did differently and show the similarities and the differences between both them. Alright if you were to look at both the Articles of Confederation and the Constitution, together and look at them very closely you come to see that both of them are very much different. Even though they were made by

the Articles of Confederation VS The U.S Constitution

639 words - 3 pages can decide if the law or bill is unconstitutional. Although the Articles of Confederation and the U.S. Constitution were written to accomplish the same thing they were very different. The Articles created a weak central government because they did not want another form of government similar to England. Consequently this made it hard to provide security to the colonies and hard to keep the states unified it was similar to having 13 different

This essays explains about the transition from the articles of Confederation to the Constitution: the reasons, the effects, etc

1191 words - 5 pages From the Articles to the ConstitutionIt is understood that the US Constitution was written to form a more centralized form of government, a federation, which could protect and regulate the rights of the US citizens. While the Articles of Confederation was avoiding this type of government affected by the British experience, the constitution encouraged it. The main difference between these two documents is the balance and centralization of powers

The US constitution: A radical departure from Articles of Confederation

635 words - 3 pages we have the federal tax system. The constitution has done many things, one of the things it did was created the separation of powers.The articles of confederation have no executive branch. There was no independent executive and no veto of legislation. Judicial proceedings in each state were to be honored by all other states. The federal government had no judicial branch, and the only judicial authority Congress had was the power to work out

Similar Essays

Why Did The United States Dump The Articles Of Confederation For The Constitution Of 1787?

870 words - 3 pages Continental Congress, renamed the Confederation Congress after the Articles of Confederation were ratified, was not an ineffectual body. It led the United States through a war against Great Britain, gained independence, negotiated the Treaty of Paris, and set up an unprecedented system of government. Ultimately, however, this government did not solve many of the new nation’s problems. The ruling document of this Congress, the Articles of Confederation

The Articles Of Confederation Verses The Constitution

1310 words - 6 pages a person and direct taxation, even though they did not have any rights and were given no voice in government. Another major conflict between the Constitution and the Articles of Confederation happens to be taxes. Under the Articles of Confederation the government was not given the power to levy taxes: this power was given to the states. William Patterson of New Jersey wanted to reform the Confederation and give it the power to tax, but no state

The Articles Of Confederation And The Constitution

762 words - 4 pages Everyone believes that our Founding Fathers were perfect. They always had the right answer and never made any mistakes. What people don’t know is that our Founding Fathers never would have written our Constitution if they did not make a mistake. The Constitution was actually the second document written that was meant to be the “supreme law of the land”. The first document our Founding Fathers created was called the Articles of Confederation. The

The Constitution And The Articles Of Confederation

950 words - 4 pages Bankrupt, and on her knees for solutions, America was in a state of distress. Politicians alike recognized that The Articles of Confederation, adopted in 1777, desperately needed revision as well as modification. Under the Articles, a Continental Congress had been shaped, which was allocated virtually no authority to collect revenue, handle domestic affairs, or control commercial trade. Shortly after the Revolutionary War, America