This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Rebellion: Noble Or Immature? Essay

1016 words - 4 pages

When one hears the word “rebellion,” he is inclined to imagine a brave, intelligent revolutionary who does not blindly conform to the majority, but does what he deems right and just. A rebel will do whatever it takes to bring into existence the world he wishes to see. This may be an admirable image, but it is not always the case. On many occasions, rebellion results from selfish, unpretentious desires. Rebellion is not only synonymous with independence and brilliance; it is also linked to immaturity and ignorance. This is evident in “Editha” by William Dean Howells, John Updike’s “A&P,” Ovid’s piece, “Metamorphosis,” and “Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night” by Dylan Thomas.
In “Editha,” Howells uses exceptional imagery in order to tell the tale of an ordinary young couple. Editha, a bold, demanding, and stubborn woman, wants her fiancé, George, to fight in the Spanish-American War of 1898. George, an enigmatic pacifist, was brought up to see war as a brutish monster created by man. Editha, a hopeless romantic, wants George to serve his country in order to be “her hero” (Howells 216). After much thought, George decides to rebel against his own beliefs in order to conform to a woman’s standards of something she knows nothing about. George may be going against his family’s mantra, but not for a noble cause. He is merely doing it to please his juvenile fiancé. He blindly states, “When I differ from you I ought to doubt myself” (Howells 216). As a result of his foolishness, George is killed in a war he does not agree with in the first place. In this instance, rebellion is unwise.
It is also unwise for one to quit his job in an attempt to impress a group of beautiful young women. This is the scenario Updike presents in “A&P.” Sammy, an adolescent cashier at the grocery store, A&P, is going through the motions of what seems to be another ordinary day when three barely-clothed young women enter the building. As soon he sees them, Sammy is unable to take his lustful eyes off of them. He stands there with his “…hand on a box of HiHo crackers trying to remember if I rang it up or not. I ring it up again…” (Updike 244). After observing the girls as they venture the store, Sammy develops an attachment to them. Finally, the store manager, Lengel, confronts the beach babes about their inappropriate attire. After making their meager purchase of some herring snacks, the girls readily leave. Before they make it out the door, however, Sammy loudly announces that he quits. His reckless rebellion against A&P goes unnoticed by the ladies. Lengel tries to talk the youth out of his sudden desire to leave, but Sammy feels as though it is too late to back down. Sammy holds the torch of what he feels is righteousness, and carries it out of the grocery store. To his dismay, the girls were not outside. They were gone. Sammy’s revolt...

Find Another Essay On Rebellion: Noble or Immature?

etter Essay

996 words - 4 pages Sai Karan R Uppugalla457 Lincoln BlvdHauppauge 11788 NY, USANovember 5, 2014The Noble FoundationP.O. Box 5232Sturegatan 14, Stockholm, SwedenDear, Noble Prize CommitteeMohandas Karamchand Gandhi or "Mahatma Gandhi" is one of the world's famous leader he is known for his great deeds which lead to Independence of India, and he is also known as peace icon for using nonviolence to fight the British. Every person is cognizant that Gandhi is

This assignment is on Russian Serfdom - Monmouth, Russian History - Essay

1525 words - 7 pages was far outlived, in fact it never needed to happen. “By the time of the Decembrist Rebellion in 1825 Russian serfdom had outlived its usefulness to the state and the village as a form of rural control and a way of peasant life. Indeed, as a vehicle for village stability and social justice, serfdom no longer had any redeeming value as an institution” (Professor Pearson). This statement couldn’t be more right, serfdom had far outlived its purpose in

Women and Maturity in Eschenbach's Parzival

1236 words - 5 pages Women and Maturity in Eschenbach's Parzival Through the course of Wolfram von Eschenbach's epic romance Parzival, it becomes abundantly clear that the main characters, Parzival and Gawan, must attain some level of maturity or growth before they will be able to persevere in their personal quests. While their paths to maturity involve a great deal of combat and contests of knightly skill, it is their encounters with noble women that truly


946 words - 4 pages a natural instinct. You cannot artificially make love where there is none or where it does not belong. Yet, the condition of being in love grows independent of all rationale. It grows places where an observer may not understand its existence. Attempting to fight love in such a situation leaves even powerful and noble families, such as the Capulets and Montagues, suddenly powerless. When love takes control of two souls, it takes the lovers on a

"The Lion in Winter" by John Goldman

1057 words - 4 pages , machine-like person, so it is very easy for him to do this. In fact, he is often described as "more cogs and wheels than a man" because of his android personality. Geoffrey takes a more analytical approach to getting what he wants as opposed to his brother John, who is the youngest of the brothers and is extremely selfish.John really has no noble qualities to him. The third of three boys, he is spoiled, dim-witted, and very immature. Despite these

How Do Choices Test Our Maturity?

1058 words - 5 pages Juliet here, for she is lying to her mother’s face. She has developed feelings for Romeo and reached a new level of emotional maturity. This act of rebellion shows how Juliet’s love for Romeo provokes an increase in maturity: she is more willing to betray her family than to betray her husband. Juliet is more emotionally mature, but is she mature in general? Romeo is immature from Juliet in a different sense. He experiences the naive pain of petrarchan

The Responsiblity The Adults Hold

1513 words - 7 pages Juliet to marry to his desire or she will face disownment from the family, making Juliet feel isolated since being rejected from one’s noble family is worse than death, in some eyes, which obliges Juliet to act upon irrational verdicts. In spite of the rash ruling of her the Capulet, what heighten the whole situation was the neglection of Juliet’s mother, Lady Capulet. When Capulet was abusing Juliet, in a way, in marrying Paris and Juliet was

Confederate Flag in South Carolina

992 words - 4 pages understand that the southern rebellion was against the powers of central government and limited constitutional democracy [Terry, 2003].As I have said the flag symbolizes the history and tradition of south and especially South Carolina, the flags reminds us of the sacrifice our ancestor gave for freedom and should not be associated with baseless racism issues. The southerners honor the noble effort of our ancestors and the Confederate flag honors the

Loss of Innocence in Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck

1284 words - 5 pages and rebel. Therefore, two winners are better than one. Rue’s death and Katniss’s actions leads other people to defy the Capitol, too. A man in District 11 was killed for saluting the District 12 respect sign as the Capitol doesn’t want anyone else to show rebellion (The Hunger Games). In real life, children may lose their innocence by playing violent video games and that will leave children becoming more immature, taking violence as

Feminist Literature

2193 words - 9 pages Victorian period. To put it simply, women in the Victorian period grew up with just one mind set, with only one view. This view pertained to being a good housewife and above all a noble mother. The women of this time period believed that life was sinful to think of their pleasure or emotions above any one else’s. The Victorian Era was the time of the British rule of Queen Victoria, and how during her time period of rule their were sudden uproars

Friar Lawrence is guilty of extreme irresponsibility in taking matters into his own hands - Essay

945 words - 4 pages , hatred and death. However, William Shakespeare reveals that despite noble intentions, the dire consequences of Friar Lawrence’s actions will still hold him accountable for the lamentable deaths of Romeo and Juliet. Friar Lawrence is convicted of extreme irresponsibility for officiating a surreptitious marriage between Romeo and Juliet. Considering both Romeo and Juliet are minors, Friar Lawrence progresses with their wedding in secrecy from both the

Similar Essays

Power In Henry Iv Part One By William Skakespeare

1081 words - 5 pages bold and impulsive language depicts a fierce impression which scares his family and friends away. Hotspur and Hal are greedy and determined to reach the throne, but whereas Hotspur makes his boldness and bitterness open to everyone, Hal attempts to appear his appearance as foolish and immature until he gets the chance to be the king. Furthermore, Hotspur is indiscreet about the rebellious act, which causes the king to know about the rebellion

"Henry Iv" Analysis

1119 words - 4 pages clouds to describe the condition he is in at the moment: "Yet herein will I imitate the sun, Who doth permit the base contagious clouds" (I.ii.150-151) The clouds symbolizes for being a mask that he hides behind. It also shows him for being immature for refusing to accept his noble responsibilities but instead, he joins the lower class to act as thieves. However, later he will emerge in his full glory as the heir to the throne or as the sun or son of

Cry Liberty: The Great Stono River Slave Rebellion Of 1739 By Peter Charles Hoffer

1026 words - 5 pages On September 9, 1739, as many as one hundred African and African American slaves were living within twenty miles of Charleston, South Carolina. This rebellious group of slaves joined forces to strike down white plantation and business owners in an attempt to march in numbers towards St. Augustine, Florida where the Spanish could hopefully grant their freedom. During the violent march toward Florida, the Stono Rebellion took the lives of more

The Development Of Chiasmus' Potential In I Henry Iv By William Shakespeare

1501 words - 6 pages the majority of his time in the tavern, drinking away the money that he "earns" by robbing travelers during the night. He is introduced to the readers as immature, irresponsible, and ignorant to his destiny and potential. But Shakespeare doesn’t let his readers see Hal this way for long: in I.ii, Hal’s intention of transcendence to princedom is evident in his revealing soliloquy: "Yet herein will I imitate the sun, Who doth permit the