Rebuttal To Killing Them Softly Essay

1309 words - 5 pages

Rebuttal to “Killing Them Softly”

“Killing Them Softly,” an essay by Jacob Sullum, addresses the issue of Senator Judd Gregg’s bill to give the Food and Drug Administration control over tobacco products. This bill would allow the FDA to make such decisions as halting tobacco companies’ marketing of safer tobacco products and reducing the nicotine content in cigarettes. Sullum argues that by giving the FDA the power to make such decisions, individual consumers would be disadvantaged and lives could possibly be lost instead of saved. If given control of such decisions, the FDA would not allow the introduction of safer tobacco products as they feel this will increase the number of smokers. They feel more people will begin using these products that are advertised as less harmful substances, whereas Sullum feels it would be better for people to change their habits to these “safer alternatives.” Sullum fails to consider benefits of relinquishing control to the FDA, however. By considering some of the positive results, Sullum might develop a different opinion and support the bill as he should.

One major point that Sullum tries to emphasize is how people’s health will be disadvantaged once the FDA is given control. When making the decision about marketing safer tobacco products, the FDA is concerned about how the introduction of smokeless tobacco will be interpreted by the “population as a whole.” Sullum, on the other hand, believes the concern should be with individual consumers. He believes smokers could be doing something healthier for themselves if the FDA promoted smokeless tobacco. However, the FDA believes advertising smokeless tobacco as a less harmful substitute for cigarette smoking misleads people and encourages nonsmokers to adopt this harmful habit. This is a point that Sullum is missing. Smokeless tobacco, although perhaps not as bad for people as regular cigarettes, is still an unhealthy habit. Smokeless tobacco is more likely to cause certain diseases, such as lip cancer and other cancers of the mouth, that cigarette smoking does not cause as often (1Up Health). If smokers are so concerned about improving their health, they should quit smoking altogether. By quitting, smokers would improve their health much more than if they took up smokeless tobacco.

In his essay, Sullum tries to defend smoking. I agree with him that it is a person’s own choice to decide whether they will smoke or not, but if a person makes the choice to smoke knowing its negative effects, then their health is not their first priority. Someone who has their health as one of their first priorities would not engage in a habit that is at all detrimental to their health. Sullum wants to introduce smokeless tobacco to the public as a safer alternative to smoking, but this would only make this unhealthy habit more appealing to people. Why try to make a bad habit more appealing when those efforts could be put to use more productively by stopping...

Find Another Essay On Rebuttal to Killing Them Softly

Mass Media and Body Image Essay

2339 words - 9 pages , Killing Us Softly 4). These retouched women become the baseline men use to judge women. Kilbourne states “We all grow up in a culture in which woman's bodies are constantly turned into 'things' and 'objects' (Kilbourne, Killing Us Softly 4).Women are morphed into beer bottles- making them into the literal object being sold in the ad. Often women's bodies are “dismembered” and used for a certain feature, so the model is no longer a woman- she is a

Mass Media Essay

2905 words - 12 pages Mass Media The media, which is somewhat reflective of society, has become a powerful tool in shaping our culture. Advertisements are the foundation for mass media; they sell images, values, success, normalcy, and romance. Daily, we are exposed to advertisements whether they are written or commercial. Jean Kilbourne says in her 1979 video Killing Us Softly, "advertisement is part of our air pollution" (1979). Advertisements have

Mass Media is Harmful to Women

1379 words - 6 pages prefer to believe that they are not being affected by advertisements however “advertising’s influence is quick, it’s cumulative, and for the most part, it’s subconscious” (Killing Us Softly). Advertisements are everywhere, found on televisions, buses, on the sides of buildings, on the Internet and in the magazines we read. Mass media affects each member of society even when they don’t realize it. Its reach is vast and its message seeps into the

Beauty and women...in society..the beauty myth

981 words - 4 pages Beauty And WomenThe rights and status of women have improved considerably in the last fifty years. Women gained legal rights, reproductive rights, pursued higher education, entered the military, and the sports arena by overturning the ancient and social beliefs about the women's social role. But there is something still killing them softly, the beauty myth, which implies that women 's greatest goal in life is to look beautiful.Women are all too

The Right to Life Includes the Right to Choose How Your Life Ends

1131 words - 5 pages 2nd challenge that I named above is as follows; with the regulations that Oregon has implemented the margin for involuntary euthanasia and the killing of undesirable people would be extremely narrowed. There will always be selfish people looking to gain off of others and vulnerable people who are pushed into things everyday but these things are bound to any crime. Just because people aren’t allowed to do things does not mean they do not do them

Degradation of Women In Media Today

1028 words - 5 pages people believe that they aren't influenced by the media, but media is almost everywhere. The reason why some people believe this is because “advertising’s influence is quick, it’s cumulative, and for the most part, it’s subconscious” (Killing Us Softly, NP). The way that women are portrayed in advertisements greatly affect women and is almost impossible to ignore. According to Rosalind Gill, “we live in an era of 360 degree branding” (75). There

A Little Song

1171 words - 5 pages They were snuggled together on the couch. Aleks was feeling laid back, his head against the arm rest with his arms wrapped around Kevin, Kevin's head resting on Aleks chest, his thumb trailing slowly over Aleks bare arms. The apartment was nice and warm, and especially quiet. Neither of them speaking. They didn't have to talk, they enjoyed just laying together, cuddling, listening to each other’s heartbeat. The sound of Aleks quickened

The Background, Context, and Re-adaptation of a Famous Quote by Theodore Roosevelt

2227 words - 9 pages also has been adapted into various teachings. One networking company website presents this quote, and shows a comic of A hitting B with a big stick after B disagreed on the statement that “networking is software.” (Herrel) This company is using the big stick phrase to emphasize the importance of networking. Another website provides a career tip called by this quote. According to them, “speak softly” (DeciCoach.com) means not bragging too much in

King To My Queen

883 words - 4 pages a garbage bag. I was alone for seven years..." She broke off. Daryl stared at her lovely, outraged face, his heart aching for the way her life had been. Carol shook her head softly. "So many regrets. .." she began, her eyes filling up with tears. "Sophia...if only I had been a better..." "Don't!" Daryl shouted, interrupting her before she could utter the sentiment. "That sure as hell wasn't yer fault! Ya was a damn good mama! What happened to

Teddy Roosevelt: Brandishing The Big Stick Over Speaking Softly

1227 words - 5 pages U.S would intervene if Latin American nations incurred financial debts so that European powers would stay at a distance while the U.S paid them. This doctrine did to an extent apply to Roosevelt’s “spoken softly” ideology as it suggested a peaceful method of protecting the independence of the Western. Beneath the surface however it was clearly backed by the “big stick” of naval superiority that the U.S maintained. Furthermore, the Corollary was

Ignorance and Greed Leads to a Quick Ending

1044 words - 5 pages serpent rampant whose fangs are imbedded in the heel” with the motto of “Nemo me impune lacessit.” This basically means that anyone who does wrong to us will not get away with it without some form of rebuttal. However, Montresor takes his action a little too far. His greed for revenge becomes a passion. To a point where “Montresor’s obsess[es] with the revenge fifty years after the act” of killing Fortunato. Even before the act, he had to think of

Similar Essays

Killing Them Softly Essay

1378 words - 6 pages Euthanasia is defined in The American Heritage Dictionary as the act of ending the life of a person for reasons of mercy (The American Heritage Dictionary). The Hemlock Society defines it as justifiable suicide, that is rational and planned self-deliverance (Humphrey). According to Dictionary.com the word euthanasia is, "also called mercy killing, the act of putting to death painlessly or allowing to die, as by withholding extreme medical

Of Mice And Men, John Steinbeck : How Does The Killing Of Candy's Dog Relate To The Killing Of Lennie? What Were The Similarities Between Them? What Was The Reason For Killing?

1789 words - 7 pages The killing of Candy's dog was related to when George killed Lennie in several ways. First of all, both the dog and Lennie were weak, and killed as soon as they became useless to the society. Also, the dog was Candy's friend, and Lennie was George's friend. In both cases, Slim viewed the deaths as mercy killings. The last similarity was that both Candy and George felt lonely after the death of their companions. The difference was that Carlson

Cultural Myths And Ideologies Essay

976 words - 4 pages manner a king was able to hide the truth about his ruling to anyone who would later search his history. In Killing Us Softly the standard person is portrayed as skinnier, younger and prettier. Most of them are victims affected by the transformed way they are presented. It gives off the impression that there are many women who are 'flawless' and only those are the ones that should be considered pretty, when in reality ideal people do not

The Impact Of The Media On Body Image

1475 words - 6 pages within the recesses of the brain” (qtd. In Killing Us Softly 4). Kilbourne mentioned that these images replay continually, giving the perception that a person is supposed to look this way. She also mentions that when confronted with the photos that represent the media’s view of “ideal beauty” we are sold “concepts of love and sexuality, success, and perhaps the most important, [the concept] of normalcy” (Killing Us Softly 4). Kilbourne also explained