Reciprocity Among Cherokees And Apaches Essay

1847 words - 8 pages

The Apache and Cherokee Indians, at face value, may seem as different as Native American tribes can be. They both had radically different methods of dealing with colonists and settlers in their territories, were located on opposite sides of the continent, and had vastly different ways of running their societies. Despite their differences, they were also alike in many ways, and among these likenesses was the idea of reciprocity, a chief similarity that the two groups shared.
For the purpose of this essay, this writer will define reciprocity as the expectation or ‘norm’ that people will respond to another party in the same manner in which the other party has treated them. So, for practical purposes, this means rewarding a good deed with another good deed, and punishing a bad deed with another bad deed. Of course, in order for a system like this to produce a favorable outcome, both groups must start out with good deeds, otherwise the system will only lead to relatively permanent hostilities.
Among the Apaches and the Cherokees, reciprocity was an important behavioral norm both within the tribe and toward outsiders of each tribe’s respective culture. However, this essay will mostly examine the two tribes’ behavior of reciprocity toward outsiders, with internal reciprocal acts taking the backstage. The majority of the most notable examples were indeed concerning the two tribes’ relationships with the Americans, and it is from these interactions that we can see the way the two tribes differed in their attitudes toward the Americans, yet were very similar in demonstrating a firm belief in reciprocity.
Far from the Apache, on the opposite side of the continent, the Cherokee nation was a southeastern tribe that, at their peak, spanned multiple states, including North Carolina, Tennessee, South Carolina, and, most notably, Georgia. During the time of George Washington, the Cherokee had begun relinquishing their traditional ways and had already begun “civilizing” in the western way. Around the turn of the century, the Cherokee had organized a national government. By 1827, when the Cherokee drafted their own constitution, they had lost most of their land outside of Georgia. The Cherokee were ultimately forced off their land by the Georgia Guard in 1838 during the infamous Trail of Tears.
The Cherokee went to great lengths to appease the American demands, in order to keep their land and live in harmony with the Americans. Reciprocity was certainly understood as a way for the Cherokee to reach that goal: by doing as the Americans had required, they would in turn be rewarded equitably. However, this trust in reciprocity worked both ways; in return for this appeasement, the Americans grudgingly dealt with the Cherokees longer than most any other tribe. John Ridge, the son of Major Ridge—one of the members of the tribal council—was sent with his father’s blessing to the Foreign Mission School in Cornwall, Connecticut. His education at an American institution...

Find Another Essay On Reciprocity among Cherokees and Apaches

Land, Growth and Justice Essay

1276 words - 6 pages where they received a proper education in English. Gospel Worship would then be adopted among the natives defusing the clouds of ignorance that once surrounded them. Slowly but steady the Cherokees were trying to integrate into the American society leaving behind their old religion and Native American identities. In other words the Cherokees were establishing a nation modeled after the one of the United States altering their society, government

The Cherokee and a Complex Predicament

1276 words - 6 pages boundaries. In the Georgia’s defense, Andrew Jackson stats that relocating will ensure the Cherokees success in their potential of proper civilization and government, “There the benevolent may endeavor to teach them the arts of civilization; and, by promoting union and harmony among them, to [rise] up an interesting commonwealth”. Andrew Jackson’s statements contradict Georgia’s act to remove the Cherokee since many Cherokees already have

Plains Indians Summaries

1583 words - 7 pages among tribes, and unique histories, that all depend on the tribes’ latitudinal --rather than longitudinal-- differences. Additionally, this “comparative approach” reveals that Plains horse cultures reflected a tribes’ relationships with Europeans: for example, the Lakotas were more successful than the Comanches in holding off encroaching whites. This revelation also proves that the success of the Lakota tribe is an outlier in regards to the

Trail of Tears: Andrew Jackson's Removal Treaties

1265 words - 6 pages Migration starting the original Cherokee Nation arose in the early 1800’s. The Cherokee’s were one of the richest tribes in the United States. Many Cherokees owned small farms and had a few large plantations where Africans were imprisoned. More or less Cherokees were cautious of white infringement and moved west on their own to settle down in other areas of the nation. Previously the Old Settlers had willingly relocated in 1817 to Arkansas where

San Antonio de Bexar

2018 words - 8 pages when both parties agreed to try and live a harmonic life among everyone. Afterwards, the Apaches started introducing themselves to the life of the new community at San Antonio de Bexar. After this, there were many other incidents were settlers of San Antonio de Bexar and other Indian tribes, including Apaches and Comanches, held raids and were constantly fighting. Because of this, there was military presence at these colonies. The military presence

Avatar and Chapter 12

1443 words - 6 pages There are countless similarities as well as differences between chapter 12 of “Creating America: A History of the United States” by McDougal Littell and the movie “Avatar”. Among the topics of “Avatar” and chapter 12 that share similarities and differences is why the whites wanted the Native American’s land, and why the humans wanted the land of the Na’vi people. Also, how the Natives tried to adjust. Furthermore, how the natives resisted. These

The Faults of the Age of Jackson

911 words - 4 pages procurers of democracy and equality, they promoted segregation in society, took almost totalitarian hold of the government, and set the country up for an economic depression. Jackson elevated the plight of the working man without creating equality. Instead, he heightened the separation of the classes and cruelly discriminated against those not seen as true Americans. This is first proven by the Trail of Tears. The Cherokees of Georgia were

Stagecoach Overview

1039 words - 5 pages In 1880 a group of strangers board a stagecoach. The stagecoach is heading eastward from Tonto, Arizona to Lordsburg, New Mexico. Among these strangers is Doc Boone an alcoholic doctor, Dallas a prostitute, Mrs. Mallory a pregnant lady and Samuel Peacock a whiskey salesman. Marshal Curly Wilcox tells the stagecoach driver, Buck that his regular ride along guard went hunting for Ringo Kid. Wilcox decides to ride in place of the regular

Trail Of Tears

1644 words - 7 pages fathers and seek a home in a foreign land (Ehle 224). When the Indian Removal Act of 1830 was signed on May, 28, 1830, the Cherokee Indians did not leave their homeland. This lead to rising tension between the Indians and Americans, and would evolve into a long-lasting struggle for the Cherokees to keep their land. Even though Jackson was on the Indians’ side, he was having trouble supporting them. After Congress passed the Indian Removal Act

trail of tears

2180 words - 9 pages some of their land. During the nineteenth century as many as one hundred thousand Indians were moved westward. The Indians from five different tribes were removed. The removed tribes were the Cherokee, Chickasaw, Choctaw, Creek, and the Seminoles. The removal of these Indians mostly occurred during the decade of the Indian Removal Act if 1830. The one Indian tribe that was most devastated by this relocation was the Cherokees. This group of people

Gisaro Ceremony Among Kaluli

926 words - 4 pages Gisaro ceremony The Sorrow of the Lonely and the Burning of the Dancers. The shared cultural value of reciprocity among the Kaluli people permits actions that, under normal circumstances, would be considered violent and cruel. In this way, the actions involved in the Gisaro ceremony demonstrate the importance of reciprocity to the Kaluli people. Food is also an important symbol for the Kaluli people, especially within the context of this

Similar Essays

The Impact Of Westward Expansion On The Cherokee Nation

1661 words - 7 pages Osages, Wichitas, Apaches, Comanches, Cherokees, Choctaws, Chickasaws, Creeks, and Seminoles had all lived on the land east of the Mississippi. All of these tribes were eventually forcefully removed from their land. Imagine the government coming into one's house, telling them to leave, and that they can only bring what they can carry. All else must be left behind. This is most likely how the Indians felt when Americans told them to leave their land

The Apache: Where They Come From, Their Way Of Life, And All Their History

1351 words - 5 pages The Apache The word "Apache" comes from two places. It is a Yuma word for "fighting men" and a Zuni word for "enemy". The Apaches are famous for their warfare skills and incredible endurance, meaning they can run fast and far without getting tired. The reason for such a violent reputation is that they were frequently attacked by other tribes and invaders from Mexico. Inside the Apache community, though, they are actually surprisingly kind

Reciprocity In All Its Forms Essay

1252 words - 5 pages without the expectation of a quick and equivalent return should also occur between certain other kinds of social relations, such as wives and husbands, siblings, and sometimes close friends. Among certain groups of people more goods are exchanged using this form than any other. For example, most members of small hunting and gathering groups are expected to share food and be generous with their possessions. Generalized reciprocity happens in all

Reciprocity Essay

735 words - 3 pages , but also with childbirth, funerals, and even puberty (Mauss 1963:8). In another society, the Japanese in Honolulu, Hawaii, generalized reciprocity had a different meaning depending on the recipients and givers. At a general level, gifts were given had meanings such as giving from the heart, think of others and they will think of you (Johnson 1974: 296). Among empirical level, usually formal functions such as weddings, funerals, births, and even